6 ms·
> This is part of the problem of having to rely on hype of general public with short attention span The nuke industry could hire some of the big tobacco lobbis
by petre 10y ago
> This is part of the problem of having to rely on hype of general public with short attention span
The nuke industry could hire some of the big tobacco lobbists to educate (as oppssed to misleading) the public. Compared to oil and coal, nuclear power is orders of magnitude cleaner. Closing nuclear power stations means burning coal most of the time, because the coal power stations are already there. The only renewable resources capable of providing base load that can replace some of the nuclear power are geothermal, but to use that you need a suitable site and solar thermal with molten salt storage. Aging coal power stations could be probably converted to biomass as well. But none of these are going to fully replace nuclear power.
- mohawk 10y agoSolar, wind & batteries will power the future. It is a question of when not if. All others will fade into oblivion. So long, and thanks for all the Joules.
- flukus 10y agoThe fact that they've made so many gains despite governments often building barriers to help non-renewables is quite telling.
- ams6110 10y agoNonsense. They won't scale.
- mohawk 10y agoThey will. I'm an investor, i like to make money, and i hate losing it. So i'm happy there's still someone else on the other side of the trade :-)
- thedailymail 10y agoThe person on the other side of the trade also likes to make money and hates losing it.
- mohawk 10y agoSo may the best one of us win. My most profitable investments have been based on other people's myopia, and it is a far sweeter victory than scoring points in an online discussion forum.
- philipkglass 10y agoNuclear power presently produces ~11% of world electricity. Wind + solar can scale to that penetration level even without battery storage and in much of the world wind or solar will already deliver LCOE lower than new-build nuclear. Reaching really high penetration levels depends on presently-unknown economics of large scale storage. (Much how the success or failure of molten salt reactors and every other next-generation nuclear dream is dependent far more on delivered costs than physics.) EDIT: I see that you were responding to someone who is already sure that storage-backed wind and solar will become the only electricity sources. That's certainly a bolder claim than scaling up to match present-day nuclear penetration levels.
- nindalf 10y agoCertainly Wind and Solar can scale to 11%. The question is about the other 89%. A significant chunk of it could be nuclear instead of coal and we would definitely be better off. And make no mistake, you need to choose between coal and nuclear because it'll be a long while before batteries have sufficient capacity to power the grid for days at a time.
- flukus 10y ago> Certainly Wind and Solar can scale to 11%. The question is about the other 89%. Is it still in question? If you can get to 11% then you can get to 100% with enough geographic distribution and batteries. Wind and solar are now cheaper than coal, even old unsafe nuclear never got to that point.
- Houshalter 10y agoThis comment adds nothing and presents no argument. And I find this sentiment really hard to understand. Why bet everything on solar? Nuclear technology already exists now. In fact it's existed for quite awhile. We could have gotten rid of coal decades ago, if not for irrational fear. It may already be too late to stop climate change. Why wait another decade or two (or three...) until the kinks in solar are worked out (if they ever are...)? It's also a bit ridiculous to point out the improvement in solar technology, and ignore everything else. Sure solar technology is improving over time. So is nuclear. And it could probably be improving a lot faster if it got the same level of interest. The major accidents everyone thinks of were all by decades old reactors. We know of much safer ways to do things, and we've learned a lot from those events. Even coal will improve over time. All that discussion of the coming robot revolution surely applies to coal mining.
- flukus 10y ago> It's also a bit ridiculous to point out the improvement in solar technology, and ignore everything else. Sure solar technology is improving over time. So is nuclear. The solar improvements are a lot more demonstrable, the nuclear ones are usually more theoretical due to the time and cost of building new reactors. >In fact it's existed for quite awhile. We could have gotten rid of coal decades ago, if not for irrational fear. Unsafe nuclear has existed for quite a while. Safe nuclear has yet to prove it's practical, which includes being cost effective against wind and solar. > And I find this sentiment really hard to understand. Why bet everything on solar? Parent mentioned wind and solar, and they didn't exclude others like hydro and tidal where appropriate. That's not betting everything on solar. >All that discussion of the coming robot revolution surely applies to coal mining. To a large extent it already has. New mines are human intensive to create, but largely automated after they're online.
- mohawk 10y agoOk, let's find some common ground: we agree current nuclear reactors "could be a lot better". With very finite uranium, coal, and oil deposits on earth these forms of energy generation are only a short-term solution. As an aside, it would also be great to save those energy supplies for a dark and rainy day. My prediction is based on Econ 101: the cheapest solution will win. Nuclear reactors (and coal plants) are long-term investment projects with payback over decades. If you're close to the equator, it doesn't even make sense today. And the increasing cost differential between solar and nuclear/coal will mean that zone is expanding towards the poles. I'm sorry if you're financially or intellectually invested in nuclear, but that's what i think will happen.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoFusion has and always will be the power of the future. Joking aside, people often seem to ignore what we could do with a true energy breakthrough.
- anticodon 10y agoThis is wishful thinking. Solar, wind and batteries has tons of unsolved problems. And I have serious doubts they will be solved in the next 15-20 years. I hear news about new "revolutionary" batteries every months for at least 20 years. But still, every device uses the same old batteries.
- llukas 10y agoName some of those problems please? Meanwhile LCOE of wind/solar is challenging that of coal power and closing to nuclear. In 15-20 years it would be way lower.
- adrianN 10y agoBatteries suck? They are quite expensive, have low capacity and age too quickly. They are also difficult to recycle.
- Eerie 10y ago>Name some of those problems please? A windless week in the winter will leave you without power.
- anticodon 10y agoThe biggest problem is that no system can withstand such huge alternations in amounts of generated power. Solar and wind energy isn't available 24/7 and generation can't be rapidly changed to compensate for changes in consumption.
- cmarschner 10y agoOf course it is cleaner. Until you need to deal with nuclear waste. And until the accident. Afterwards, it is not. How many Fukushimas and Chernobyls are we supposed to experience? Do we first need to have a plant like Tricastin blow up, wiping out Rhône valley wines and all of Provence for thousands of years? No thanks.
- flukus 10y ago"Chernobyl was just soviet mismanagement, the west is safe", "fukishima was an unexpected tsunami, everyone else is safe", "newer reactor designs are safe". The nuclear industry move the goal posts after every disaster.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoFukushima was not an unavoidable "act of God" as you seem to imply. Fukushima was a galloping series of well-documented fuckups and ignored warnings going back to its construction in 1967. There are no moving goalposts. And coal plants put more radiation into the atmosphere than nuclear, even accounting for the historical odds of catastrophic failure. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-radioactive-than-nuclear-waste/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-...
- flukus 10y ago> Fukushima was a galloping series of well-documented fuckups and ignored warnings going back to its construction in 1967. Exactly. Let me know when you fix humans, companies and governments, then I'll trust nuclear.
- aperrien 10y agoHave fun with global warming then. I think that humanity needs to come to terms with renewables and nuclear power (with fusion being the best case scenario) for the future of everyone on this planet.