7 ms·
I'm not asking this to troll, I'm genuinely confused...why are drivers ever proprietary? Aren't drivers inherently a loss-leader so that a company can sell har
by tombert 10y ago
I'm not asking this to troll, I'm genuinely confused...why are drivers ever proprietary?
Aren't drivers inherently a loss-leader so that a company can sell hardware? Why not always open up the drivers?
- saosebastiao 10y agoA big (but not singular) answer to that question is that proprietary drivers are what allows companies like NVidia to price-discriminate, by selling the same hardware but disabling features for lower priced models.
- Tuna-Fish 10y agoNo, this was a thing long ago but these days this is done by burning fuses on the GPU, which makes some areas of the chip completely inaccessible.
- 542458 10y agoSpitballing here: - Driver source code may contain info that would give hints to upcoming or in-development products and innovations from the company that they'd prefer to keep secret. - Drivers may have features disabled in software, but not in hardware - if you could compile your own, it would effectively overrule this. - Open-sourcing drivers may make it easier for the competition to "copy" innovations and features - "Security" via obfuscation
- jjoonathan 10y ago- Open-sourcing drivers increases surface area for patent-liability (both troll and non-troll)
- kyrra 10y agoMy guesses: 1) Nvidia and AMD both do per-game optimizations in the drivers themselves. Though my understand is that Nvidia has more resources dedicated to this. They will send 1 or 2 people to the studios of AAA game devs nearer release to help the company optimize their game plus to add "hacks" into their own drivers to work around inefficiencies in those games. If they opened sourced their drivers, that work would be made free to AMD and other drivers. 2) "Benchmark Cheating". Graphics Drivers do lots of optimizations depending on the specific application. I'd wager that this includes popular benchmark apps. 3) Patent lawsuits. There are a massive number of patents around the graphics word. Obscuring how a driver works probably helps protect them somewhat from potential patent litigation.
- orik 10y agoHere's a quote from another hn user robert_foss from the discussion on the Apple / Imagination Technologies thread. 'In the GPU space it is impossible to not infringe on the IP of other vendors. In fact it is the major reason GPU vendors give for not having an open source driver. I have spoken to the CTO (Jem Davies) of ARM about the GPU drivers and open sourcing them more than once. And every time I've gotten the reply: "No, we can't, it opens us up to IP infringement suits."' https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14021299 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14021299
- xorcist 10y agoIntel GPU drivers are completely open source, are they not? That clearly makes it not impossible, if they cared enough.
- true_religion 10y agoIntel is #1 in the chip technology field though. They are in a special position where it would be suicidal to sue them.
- thomastjeffery 10y agoAbsolutely. AMD is moving strongly in that direction too. This is just one of many sad excuses to continue a moronic, and frankly harmful practice.
- kimixa 10y agoBoth AMD's and Intel's OSS drivers are 'clean room' separate codebases to their internal closed drivers. It may be that they are specifically avoiding some features/rewriting possibly infringing code in these cases. As far as I know, we have yet to have an open driver to get the same performance as their closed windows ones in all cases. There may be reasons behind that.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> They will send 1 or 2 people to the studios of AAA game devs nearer release to help the company optimize their game plus to add "hacks" into their own drivers to work around inefficiencies in those games. Depending on the nature of the hacks, there's not necessarily anything wrong with that. It's common for drivers, even Open Source drivers, to detect common patterns of API misuse that would otherwise hurt performance, and transform them into patterns that achieve the same effect more efficiently. But that only applies if you can detect the inefficiency by pattern, rather than by application name. If the driver does the latter, then yeah, it'd be hard to Open Source that.
- Merad 10y agoDrivers contain details about how the GPU (or whatever) hardware is structured and works internally. Some companies want to keep that info proprietary.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoIn addition to the reasons others have mentioned: cross-licensing of code, such that the vendor doesn't directly have the rights to release it without rewriting portions of it.
- AstralStorm 10y agoEven a partial driver with a blob or two is much better than a fully closed driver. AMD drivers ship important blobs...
- MaulingMonkey 10y agoThe only thing worse than having to maintain drivers for your product, is having to maintain drivers for your competitor's product!
- 5ilv3r 10y agoIsn't that how ad-hoc standards are brought into existence?
- infodroid 10y agoTell that to Broadcom, Intel, Marvell, Qualcomm Atheros, and Realtek. All of them released open source Linux drivers for their wireless network products and they're still doing good business. So I don't buy this line of argument.
- MikusR 10y agoMost of those drivers are shims for huge binary blobs.
- infodroid 10y agoThat might be true, but the general point is that most drivers in the Linux kernel don't need blobs, and they are in many cases written by manufacturers of the hardware. Competing manufacturers have not suffered as a result of releasing free Linux drivers, and arguably are profiting from it.
- mangix 10y agoThey aren't. There's firmware in there but it's usually not very big. Look up softmac vs. fullmac
- Tuna-Fish 10y agoGPU drivers are not just simple pieces of code that are used to access hardware. They contain very fast implementations of extremely complex libraries, and optimizing compilers for complex programming languages. Just to give you an idea of the ballpark, the nVidia GPU drivers are a more complex system with more code than the entire Linux kernel. As the performance of this system is absolutely critical, a large part of the value proposition of a GPU is its driver package. Since nVidia clearly leads the pack in the quality of their drivers, they have no intention of opening them up.
- mangix 10y agoMore code than the entire Linux kernel? Please provide a reference. There's no way that's even remotely true.
- sherincall 10y ago(NVIDIA Engineer) If you compare the whole driver stack, KMD+UMDs (OGL,DX,CUDA,Vulkan) to just the kernel part of Linux, sounds about right. The KMD alone is definitely smaller than Linux kernel.
- surrealize 10y agoJust open-sourcing and upstreaming the KMD would resolve the biggest pain-point in linux. The "very fast implementations of extremely complex libraries, and optimizing compilers for complex programming languages" can be separate.
- amelius 10y agoAnother legitimate question could be: Why care whether the driver is open source? Just consider the driver as part of the black box that is the product. The vendor will provide you with a blob of binary code that you can invoke. This binary code can be the same on Windows and Linux. Of course, a driver has to interact with the kernel, but the required glue logic can be maintained separately. Edit: Of course, the driver should be run inside a controlled environment (e.g. a sandbox), but this arguably holds for all drivers, even open-source ones.
- dandelion_lover 10y agoClosed source means you do not know what your computer is doing. It means you are not the one who rules your computer. https://web.archive.org/web/20160930051146/http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/09/23/capcom_street_fighter_v/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160930051146/http://www.thereg... "Capcom's Street Fighter V update installed a driver that can be used as a backdoor by any application installed on a Windows computer." (via https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/proprietary-back-doors.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/proprietary-back-doors.html)
- khedoros1 10y agoI think their point is that you can say the same about closed hardware. And since you're already putting a black-box hardware component into the system (with its own black-box firmware, as well), how much more harmful is it to have a closed driver?
- dandelion_lover 10y agoSecurity is not a boolean: secure/insecure. It is the price to own you. It is higher with free drivers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_in_depth_%28computing%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_in_depth_%28computing%...
- amelius 10y agoSecurity is why drivers should run inside a sandbox, even if they are open-source.