8 ms·
Good. Not enough people realize the best way to answer this question is with a straight-up lie.
by paulcole 10y ago
Good. Not enough people realize the best way to answer this question is with a straight-up lie.
- tlrobinson 10y agoCould that be considered fraud?
- paulcole 10y agoIf lying during a job interview is fraud then lock me up.
- maxxxxx 10y agoEmployers lie about salaries all the time. I Know plenty of people who were told their salary was one of the highest of their coworkers where in reality they made less than most. Is that fraud?
- wbl 10y agoNo more than "my wife thinks we need to take the children out of school, so I'll need the money to make that possible" is.
- sidlls 10y agoNo more than: * We hire only the best * We value your career progress * We are transparent about the company's strategies and financials * We value taking the time to think through the design of features and products And so on. Most of which are, to be charitable, only very loosely applicable when they aren't outright lies.
- antisthenes 10y ago* We think of you as family!
- Arizhel 10y agoYep, take the true answer and inflate it 20% or more. Make them think they're getting a bargain.
- eru 10y agoIf you are going to lie, just pick the number that's best for you. No need to have any relation with any true number.
- dajohnson89 10y agoThe problem is, recruiters/hiring managers will sometimes call your former employer to verify your actual salary.
- eric_the_read 10y agoDo any employers actually provide that information? The most I've ever had any previous employer ever say about my time there is, "Eric worked here from $start_date to $end_date." I understand there to be liability involved if they say anything more.
- X86BSD 10y agoYeah that has always been my understanding as well. Past employers are only allowed to say yes or no to you working there if asked. Where this comes from I don't know. I'm sure there is a law that this common belief comes from.
- dpark 10y agoPast employers can say whatever they want. They open themselves up to legal liability in doing so, though, with basically no value to themselves. Theoretically as long as they're telling the truth, there is no legal liability. In reality it's more nuanced. e.g. An employer who reveals that a former employee was absent a lot might be sued successfully if the absence was within the company's sick day policy, or the reason was a disability. Saying nothing is the safest choice. Most employers only confirm employment as a courtesy to their former employees.
- brianwawok 10y ago> Most employers only confirm employment as a courtesy to their former employees. Lie. It's to cover their arse from lawsuits.
- dpark 10y agoNot sure what you mean. Employers would prefer to give no information about previous employees, specifically "to cover their arse from lawsuits". They confirm employment dates as a courtesy because it can be difficult to get a job without confirmation of previous employment. Tangentially, it's really abrasive and generally unnecessary to start a comment by calling someone a liar. You can disagree with me here, and that's totally fine. To call me a liar for holding a different opinion than you makes you seem really petty. Arguing about the reason companies will disclose employment history doesn't seem to be the time to break out this sort of accusation.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoCareful!! There's quite a few ways to verify past salary. Specially some employers report employment information to private databases and your potential employer runs a "employment report," like banks run a credit report, as part of a mandatory background check. To see if you lied. Of course, they can't do that without your permission but agreeing to a background check is a condition of employment. The database i am thinking of is, IIRC, owned by Lexis Nexis and they claim to have employment data for the majority of Fortune 500 companies. EDIT: The database I am thinking of is called The Work Number and is owned by Equifax. http://www.businessinsider.com/salary-information-not-private-anymore-2013-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/salary-information-not-privat... >One woman interviewed by CNBC had a Work Number report that was a whopping 22 pages long, complete with a copy of all of her paychecks over the years. They claim to have employment information for over 1/3rd of American adults.
- paulcole 10y agoIt's a risk I'm willing to take for the potential upside.
- nashashmi 10y agoAlso to add, if you work for a public institution, your salary for the past three years is in public records.
- matwood 10y agoThat's why you just say "around" and add 20% to your current salary. And even if a company does find out, who cares? What I made at a prior job has zero bearing on my next job. If the new company thinks I bring in enough value to be paid X, then they paying X should be fine.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWho cares? There's a -huge- difference between dodging the question with a vague answer, defecting, or refusing to answer and -outright lying- about your previous salary! These reports are run to catch lying. Do the former, don't outright lie. Similarly, I know part of my job when I do an interview is to sell the company and the position. So I'll put a positive spin on things but I won't outright lie.
- comicjk 10y agoThis points to an interesting method of poverty reduction - identify the little tricks which knowledgeable people use to get ahead in the system, and tweak the system to make the tricks less necessary.
- karrotwaltz 10y agoAlso, I think salary negotiation is partially responsible for the man / woman wage gap. I think men are more inclined to agressive negotiate their salaries, and women might be less prone to lie or hide their current salary too.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoYes, there's a whole book about this, Women Don't Ask: The High Cost of Avoiding Negotiation. https://www.amazon.com/Women-Dont-Ask-Negotiation-Strategies/dp/0553383876 https://www.amazon.com/Women-Dont-Ask-Negotiation-Strategies... > Yet, as research reveals, men are four times more likely to ask for higher pay than are women with the same qualifications. From career promotions to help with child care, studies show time and again that women don’t ask–and frequently don’t even realize that they can.
- BearGoesChirp 10y agoOne thing I never see studied on this topic is the differing impacts of social expectations on gender roles related to how much someone is willing to work extra for extra salary. At least for the part of society where I live, a man's income influences his perceived value as a partner more than a woman's, and in general there is an expectation that a man is the provider who pays for dates. (I'm not defending this double standard at all, only say it is what I observe.) Wouldn't this create a stronger force for men to do more to increase their salary than for women?
- comicjk 10y agoPossibly yes, but it's too easy to create narratives like this. For example, women are more likely to become the caretakers of children and elderly parents, so they have a stronger force to ask for a higher salary now. You can't say how the factors balance out without serious research.
- phil21 10y agoIt took me a while to understand that most people don't realize you can lie on this with almost zero downside. Very few employers are checking, and very few times is that information legally available to them. The most they can typically get is the "typical" salary for a given position at a large company. There are exceptions of course, and the good ole' boys network can sometimes run deep. But in the end, if you are let go or not hired because you lied about a salary they were otherwise willing to pay you? You dodged a bullet. Who would want to work in such an environment to begin with? The correct answer is to say with what you think the current position is worth and what you want to get paid. There is no upside to being truthful here. This is legitimately hard for a lot of folks to understand, the same type of folks who equate violating corporate policy as being "illegal". I'd even go so far to say it's close to immoral not to lie on this question given the power imbalance when it comes to hiring.
- josh_fyi 10y agoYou have some leeway. If you say "My compensation was $70K" and your salary was $50K, you may well be telling the truth.
- vwcx 10y agoExactly! My company's internal benefits page tells me my compensation is "salary + employer side of medical, dental, vision + employer 401k match". I always chuckle at how high that number is compared to my actual paycheck...
- southphillyman 10y agoGoing forward I'm including calculations for free lunch, the relatively excessive amount of PTO days I get every year (30+), and the relatively affordable insurance I have ($140 per monthly for a family). Locally I think it will be hard to get a similar benefit package so I'm going to quantify those benefits and bake them into my "salary".
- eric_h 10y agoThere was a post on hacker news a few months ago that explained exactly this. I believe it's a fair way of calculating it (if you feel that you must disclose something for whatever reason).
- solotronics 10y agoa good way to find out is call your previous employers saying you are a recruiter for "Big Company X" and see if they divulge your previous salary. I would bet most (all?) would not.
- emh68 10y agoRather than lie about your salary, which can be verified, lie about something that can't be verified. Just say that your current employer is awesome, amazing, has a great culture, coworkers you consider close friends, and you're sad to leave, but you realize that you can't afford to keep living in $bigCity on your current salary...
- komali2 10y agoWhy lie? Just say you don't provide that information. If they don't like it, move on to another company. Why are people so blase about lying? I don't get it. It's arguably far more helpful to just wait for the company to state their number first - bearing in mind the fact that there's tens of thousands of other companies out there. Eventually one will budge. In my experience, they all do.
- socalnate1 10y agoIt's depressing to me how many responses there are on this, without anyone simply saying: "Lying is wrong" I know there are a lot of purely utilitarian thinkers around here, but is there no moral compass at all?
- antisthenes 10y agoNo. There isn't. Unless it makes you feel good. Then there is.
- paulcole 10y ago> is there no moral compass at all? Yes but potential employers don't get the benefit of the doubt. I'm looking out for myself first.
- chrisbennet 10y agoI am also surprised at how many responses are "Well, just lie". Maybe having integrity is old fashioned? I never lied about my salary - it wouldn't have even crossed my mind to do so.