5 ms·
I suspect most contracts are gibberish - the only ones anyone really looks at in detail are the ones where there is a dispute and that's a tiny percentage. Ask
by arethuza 10y ago
I suspect most contracts are gibberish - the only ones anyone really looks at in detail are the ones where there is a dispute and that's a tiny percentage.
Ask a litigator what they think about the people who drafted the contracts and they generally aren't particularly kind.
Edit: I wasn't meaning employment contracts which are special cases, like consumer contracts.
- reallydontask 10y agoNot sure where you are based nor what your line of business is so it's hard to say whether your speaking in general terms or based on experience. I've never signed a gibberish contract of employment. This is not to say that I was happy with all the clauses but they all were sensible and, to my limited knowledge, legal.
- mattmanser 10y agoI've read all my past employment contracts and all of them have been readable and understandable (UK). I've even gone back and challenged points before and got some removed or, for example, been given a waiver allowing me to run a company in my spare time (as the contract said you couldn't unless you had asked). I realise I have much higher reading comprehension than most people, and have more bargaining power than a Deliveroo rider, but I find it crazy someone wouldn't read their own employment contract from start to end.
- arethuza 10y agoActually, on the subject of employment contracts (which I wasn't talking about originally) I've had to resort to multiple lawyers who gave conflicting advice on seemingly innocent and clearly written parts of a contract I had. The experienced lawyer who realised what trick a particular clause was trying to pull saved me quite a chunk of cash!
- biot 10y agoWhat was the trick?
- arethuza 10y agoI can't remember the details - was over 2 years ago. But I was on 6 months notice and I was leaving for my current job and I (i.e. my lawyer) negotiated getting 3 months pay out of them and it was something to do with the tax on that lump sum - either they would have had to pay or I would. They wanted me to sign a severance agreement under pressure and I handed it across to the lawyer and he did a splendid job of negotiating away all the silly terms and got them to pay his legal fee (which is actually pretty common in the UK).
- scaryclam 10y agoI'm in the same boat here. Heck, I make it clear that I won't even hand in my notice until I'm happy with the contract and it's signed. If a prospective employer won't allow contractual changes or clarify parts of the contract that are too broad, run away.
- Ensorceled 10y ago.. and if they say something like "oh, don't worry, our VC lawyers just wanted that clause, we would NEVER enforce that", run very fast.
- kasey_junk 10y agoFor employment contracts? I was under the impression it was in everybody's best interest to make those very clear (at least in the US) as their enforceability depended on it. I've certainly read every employment agreement I've ever signed & never encountered an unclear one.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWhat sort of things do employment contracts say in the US? I live in the US and I've had 9 jobs in my life (none startups) and the only thing I've ever signed or been asked to sign was a note saying I'm employed "at will" and NDAs.
- Symbiote 10y agoThis is from mine in the UK, but I'd guess the non "at will" states would be similar? "You will normally be required to work a five-day week of 41 hours gross, Monday to Friday, including meal breaks." "The annual leave entitlement for full time staff is as follows: on appointment: 30 days ... You are encouraged to take the full annual leave allowance to which you are entitled." "You may be allowed sick absence on full pay, less any social security benefit received for up to six months in any 12 months and after that, on half pay, up to a maximum of 12 months sick absence in any period of 4 years or less." "Should you wish to leave the organisation you will be expected to give 4 weeks notice in writing to your line manager." "Travel, Subsistence and Other Expense: If you are required to be absent from your normal place of work on the business of [company], travelling expenses and subsistence allowances will be paid in accordance with the regulations set out in Travel Manual." The contract is 7 pages long, but with big line spacing and only 1 or 2 sentences in each clause. It covers salary, benefits (leave, sick pay etc), notice periods, the pension scheme, expected conduct, the complaints procedure, and lists the trade unions that had representation (it's from a public sector organisation). In comparison, the Uber one is 16 pages of dense text with lots of legal terms and a glossary.
- arethuza 10y agoMy first job contract ~30 years ago was from a UK university and was less than 1 page, basically said that I would get paid X, report to Prof Y and I'd have <huge number> of holidays and that it would be nice if I turned up occasionally.
- pluma 10y agoI'm confused by the responses about employment contracts because I literally can't think of Uber's contracts as employment contracts. The entire purpose of those contracts is to identify drivers as _not employees_. It's much more like an EULA or TOS, which are almost always complete gibberish that doesn't hold up in court indeed (at least in EU courts that is).