4 ms·
One huge problem is that September never ended... (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September) What I mean
by carapace 10y ago
One huge problem is that September never ended... (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September)
What I mean is, there are lots of people who are not as smart as they think they are, and they won't STFU and RTFM, etc...
Send not to know at whom the Torvalds curses, he curses at thee.
Frankly, I think the author's original position was correct: Emphasize credit for authors of RFCs and you'll get fools authoring RFCs for the credit. Sheesh!
- kibwen 10y agoI agree that perverse incentives are possible, but I think that stance is a bit pessimistic. Being the author of an RFC grants you no social capital unless that RFC is good enough to get accepted (and if it's good enough to get accepted, then it's a good thing someone took the time to write it!). Additionally, the amount of social capital one receives from being known as the author of an RFC is very minor (especially since Rust RFCs only represent the beginning of the conversation, not the end, and the features any given RFC describes can change drastically between RFC and eventual stabilization, and god only knows how many people are responsible for the end result by that point). (There's only one accepted Rust RFC whose author I can name from memory, and that's only because it's an RFC that I didn't like. :P The knife cuts both ways!)
- carapace 10y agoI agree with you. I'm erring on the side of exaggeration. The thing is there's a large, quiet, ad hoc network of people and it "computes": Who's paying attention? Who's doing the work? Keeping the normals from gumming up that network is very important, and calling [the wrong kind of] attention to it won't help... Cf. Tao Te Ching, chp. 3
- joe_the_user 10y agoMaybe I could put it another way. September 1993 ended, just not the way some people would have wanted it to. The net has become a medium for everyone, not just a small enough group that this group could become acclimatized to a dominant discourse style (whatever the virtues might be of the Linus Torvalds "I will call you a fucking moron when you fail" school of discussion for a rarefied group). And given that, it is now necessary to have the standards of discourse for the net be the standards of discussion for society as a whole. And sure, maybe being nice can produce a series of problems of its own. But it's now necessary to solves those problems while being nice.
- ori_b 10y agoWhy? For the sake of playing devil's advocate: If I am not nice, maybe the people I don't want to interact with will go away and leave me alone.
- chipotle_coyote 10y agoThat's true. However, maybe the people you do want to interact with--or the people you should interact with in order to advance your project, whether or not you particularly "want" to interact with them--will also go away and leave you alone.
- ori_b 10y agoWith one side project, I've had people almost leave the project because I was being accomodating to someone who clearly had no idea what they were doing. They were getting frustrated with the constant low quality discussion, and one ended up private messaging me to say that either $IDIOT left or they were going to go. Another probably just dropped of without saying anything. Just showed up less frequently in chat, until one day they were gone. Being nicer doesn't always help attract people that you want to interact with.
- jancsika 10y agoA lot of times when I start getting frustrated about low quality discussion, I try to reimagine the noisy participant as a kind of "human fuzzer". They have randomly wedged themselves into a corner with some of the unspoken rules of the community. Then it's (usually) sufficient to explicitly and (politely) articulate the expectations for participation and collaboration.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat's quite anecdotal. It might be true and work for you. I'd then ask if it's the general rule that maintainers being helpful to people who have more to learn is causing lots of problems. I doubt it given the huge ecosystems with beneficial results that came from software catering to such people. Now, it might be quite different for those focusing on extra-high quality, reliability, or security. These seem to take a certain minimum amount of skill or determination. People being too nice might bring in people that are purely a drag. You and I both seem to be in that boat a bit. So far, the best path has been filtering out the chaff plus inviting skilled people or mentoring those with aptitude plus desire to learn. I'm sure I could learn more on people side to increase my effectiveness quite a bit. Like you, though, I need a certain baseline to be effective at the levels of success I want with the kinds of people that follow my work. Even if I was nice, the others would tell them off just to prevent damage from being done. Maybe nicely and with tips but the effect is still the same. The problem when it affects communities with higher focus on narrow tech or high quality is worth further research by people interested in this stuff.
- fwilkins 10y agoYou cannot mention Eternal September here. It's a sore spot for HN. No one wants to know how or by whom the software is produced that makes them rich.