3 ms·
All of the first part of the things you said is a part of the accusation. >Waymo says he took 14,000 documents, while Kshirsagar and Radu Raduta took only a fe
by komali2 10y ago
All of the first part of the things you said is a part of the accusation.
>Waymo says he took 14,000 documents, while Kshirsagar and Radu Raduta took only a few. Waymo is now asking for Uber to turn over those stolen documents as part of the discovery process
My understanding is that part of the case is deciding if it is true that 14,000 documents were taken.
So again, the only known truth is that a single document was found on a guy's device.
What I am concerned with is that we all fall into the "Uber BAD, Waymo GOOD" trap simply because Waymo is kicking up a big shitstorm. Let the process of law happen, let the facts of the case arise, before we pass judgement.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> My understanding is that part of the case is deciding if it is true that 14,000 documents were taken. It is, but that's a much later part of the case. The present part of the case is complying with discovery orders and considering preliminary injunctions, which does weigh what the parties are claiming and able to offer to support those claims, but does not involvethe kind of formal, detailed presentation and weighing of evidence that will happen at trial.
- matt4077 10y agoThe taking of 14,000 documents is actually assumed to be true currently for the purposes of this case. That's because Uber is in no position to deny it, only Lewandowsky could. And he can't deny it, because then he could no longer invoke his right to remain silent. Of course, the documentation from Waymo/Google is also pretty strong apparently. Simply saying "I didn't do that" would be insufficient.
- komali2 10y ago> Uber is in no position to deny it, only Lewandowsky could. And he can't deny it, because then he could no longer invoke his right to remain silent. So he should give up his 5th amendment right to fend off an accusation? I don't think so, that doesn't sound like justice to me. >documentation from Waymo/Google is also pretty strong apparently. pretty apparently Come on man, you know what angle I'll go for here. Why are you letting that slip? The documentation aka evidence hasn't been seen yet because this case hasn't gone to court. None of the most relevant facts of the case have come to light. I'm happy to hop on the "Uber is evil" train after the case, but it is painful to watch the normally quite rational people on HN fall for such a typical fallacy of justice.
- nl 10y ago>> Uber is in no position to deny it, only Lewandowsky could. And he can't deny it, because then he could no longer invoke his right to remain silent. > So he should give up his 5th amendment right to fend off an accusation? I don't think so, that doesn't sound like justice to me. That's how the 5th amendment works. It gives you the right to avoid self-incrimination, but if you invoke that right and there is other evidence against you then you'd better have some other way of refuting that evidence.
- life_on_mars 10y agoHas this other evidence even been presented yet? edit: given that even a simple question was downvoted, I can only conclude that there are likely a lot of Google employees downvoting anything that doesn't support Google's side in this dispute.
- matt4077 10y agoI downvoted you because–considering your strong opinions–it seems unlikely that this is a question asked in good faith. And even if, it is answered both in the article, as well as pretty much implied in the headline. GOOG-ACCOUNTING-REF:3FX/ASTRO/15/TURFWAR/PROJECTSOROS
- life_on_mars 10y agoThe document in question was found on the personal laptop of a different former Waymo engineer. This neither supports nor refutes the original evidence Google claims to have regarding 14,000 files they claim that Lewandowsky downloaded. They should have to present that evidence publicly first before discovery, otherwise this looks like just a fishing expedition. In 2017, it's not uncommon to do work on your personal machine and handle personal issues on your work machine. In 2017, interfaces encourage archiving documents instead of deleting them, so it's not uncommon for people to still have documents they've long since forgotten about. I wouldn't be surprised if searches of the personal machines of most people in the world would turn up documents that belonged to that person's previous employers. Here's an experiment: If you acquired your current personal laptop prior to leaving one or more past employers, try searching your personal machine and personal email for documents or information that belong to any of your former employers. I suspect that many people would find at least one document showing up accidentally.
- life_on_mars 10y agoThey claim that they knew this happened more than a year ago. The veracity of their logs, or at the very least the chain of custody of those logs, should seriously be called into question at this point. They should have litigated against Mr. Lewandowsky after he founded Otto using documents they claim to know he stole more than a year ago.