7 ms·
No, that's a completely non-substantiative quote from an attorney for one side that contains the implicit assumption that Uber really does have the documents an
by jerf 10y ago
No, that's a completely non-substantiative quote from an attorney for one side that contains the implicit assumption that Uber really does have the documents and is actively committing crimes in discovery to prevent the discovery from working. Not only is it not an unbiased source, it's basically a source being paid to be biased. Which is fine; I am generally down with the philosophy of adversarial justice. But you shouldn't read much of anything at all into that quote.
For those of us on the outside, while we are justified in considering that a possible hypothesis, we are also justified in looking at the facts and considering that it may indeed be the case that these documents were never given to Uber. I for one have no trouble believing that the documents were downloaded by an individual but that they were never given to Uber, as I rather suspect "keeping more than one really ought from one's previous job but never raising to the level of actually giving that stuff to one's next employer" is really quite common.
- M_Grey 10y ago>...it may indeed be the case that these documents were never given to Uber. Then they should have their legal team pilloried and set ablaze for advising them to be this cagey.
- jerf 10y agoI'm not particularly committing to either hypothesis right now. If Uber is indeed screwing around with discovery I would imagine they're going to end up in very big trouble. I for one would pretty much consider that prima facie evidence every executive even remotely involved in that decision, including simply being aware of it, should be immediately fired by the shareholders and everything possible clawed back from them. I don't consider that out of the question, but it's a pretty serious accusation on its own. Uber's kinda big to get away with that sort of shenanigan.
- nikanj 10y agoThen again, a large part of Uber's success has been built upon shenanigans. It seems likely that they might develop an arrogance towards the legal system, after years of playing chicken with it.
- __jal 10y agoYou can generally predict Uber's behavior by assuming it behaves like a stereotypical frat house. The behavior is: - Go for it and see if anyone complains - See if ignoring the complainers makes them go away - See if bullying the complainers makes them go away - Can it be solved with money? - Last resort: cheat. - If you get caught, call the lawyers; in public, whine about the raw deal you're getting.
- M_Grey 10y agoUnfortunately for them, the combination of Google alleging massive theft, the issues around Applebaum, and the high profile exit of some of their execs, none of that is likely to work.
- praneshp 10y agoHey, what issues around Applebaum? Some googling didn't help me, the most prominent result is a journalist called Anne Applebaum.
- M_Grey 10y agoWell, in hindsight I can see that's my fault... Jacob Appelbaum. My bad! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13891513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13891513
- dullgiulio 10y agoI have missed the connection between Appelbaum and Uber. Does he work for them now?
- M_Grey 10y agoGood lord... I was so tired I mixed up Uber and Tor. I'm going to bed.
- MegaButts 10y agoI certainly don't know the details, but it's hard for me to see a resolution to this where Uber isn't in trouble. Travis Kalanick has publicly stated that self-driving cars are necessary for the future of Uber, and anything that even puts a damper on that (in addition to all the talent they've already lost) is enough to likely kill them as - according to leaked financials - they are already hemorrhaging money. I've never been bullish on Uber, but this is really bad.
- throwaway4job 10y agoIt's worth remembering a few other things: 1) If the suit is true, then it will almost certainly zero out the investors, and destroy the careers and fortunes of the executives. 2) Uber has a long history of keeping and promoting executives who lack integrity and show a willingness to break the law. As such, it is reasonable to assume that Google is making a good faith effort to argue the strongest possible case on their side; and that Uber is likely to lie, cheat, and steal to make the strongest possible case on their side.
- gsnedders 10y ago> 2) Uber has a long history of keeping and promoting executives who lack integrity and show a willingness to break the law. Knowing almost nothing about US Federal civil law, can inferences be drawn from that (and other previous behaviour of Uber)?
- neom 10y agoBecause it's civil it would need to be presented or entered with relevance.
- throwaway4job 10y agoA judge and jury would struggle to use this unless it was very well-sourced, but as external observers who are attempting to make a best estimate, we certainly can.
- CalChris 10y ago> No, that's a completely non-substantiative quote from an attorney for one side that contains the implicit assumption that Uber really does have the documents Implicit assumption? The first paragraph of the TechCrunch article says: Uber admitted today that it had found one of the documents Waymo alleges was stolen by a former employee — who left its self-driving car effort to join Uber’s — on the employee’s personal computer.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoHow can they access an employee's personal computer?
- maxerickson 10y agoBy asking.
- rhino369 10y agoThey don't even have to access it. They just have to ask for the documents.
- dragonwriter 10y ago"You will provide us this, or you will be an ex-employee."
- komali2 10y agoUntil the facts of the case come out, don't fall into the dangerous dark hole of fully buying into either story. The other day I booted my old galaxy s3 to put a new ROM on it and turn it into a dashcam. I found on it that google drive had offline backed-up some documents from a company I had worked at several years ago, and no longer did. Should I be sued for trade secret theft?
- CalChris 10y agoUber admitted today
- bradleyjg 10y ago"that contains the implicit assumption that Uber really does have the documents and is actively committing crimes in discovery to prevent the discovery from working" I don't think the paragraph implies that at all. Rather it says that Uber has not threatened Levandowski with employment sanctions in order to get him to cooperate with its discovery obligations. Uber could do so without running afoul of the 5th amendment as that only binds the government. Google's lawyer is arguing that the court ought to treat that as constructive non-compliance. There's no implied allegation of perjury or other criminal behavior.
- Natsu 10y agoHe invoked the fifth. Uber could fire him, but I don't seriously expect them to be able to get more out of him than the court itself can. Would you rather lose your job or go to prison isn't a hard question to answer, after all.
- kmonsen 10y agoAlso, if you already have virtually unlimited money loosing the job doesn't seem so bad.
- bradleyjg 10y agoIf this case goes very badly for Uber they may well decide to turn around and sue Levandowski. He may not have virtually unlimited money after that.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vkou 10y agoIf Uber fires him, they run the risk of him throwing them under the bus, in exchange for legal leniency. That's a problem with criminal conspiracies - you either have to stand by your partners, or hold a threat worse then jail time over their heads. Easy for a mob boss, less easy for a unicorn.
- ABCLAW 10y agoJudge Alsup's comments on pages 14 and 15 of the transcript mirror the statement you're attempting to discredit. Perhaps it is a bit more concerning when the argument is made by the trier-of-fact himself.
- themgt 10y agoYeah, reading through pages 14 -> 20 Uber sounds like they're in some shit. Essentially Levandowski wants to keep his criminal 5th amendment protections at the same time Uber is keeping him as head of the division and the judge thinks it already looks likely he stole 14,000 documents. Uber's almost trying to launder his criminal protections into their civil case while he's still running the department they accused him of stealing the IP for? IANAL but this does not sound good: Judge: "And if [Levandowski] doesn't testify to that at the deposition, well, I guess Uber -- you know, Uber is -- if you think this is going to help you, my preliminary view of it is it's not going to help you; and that if there's not a clear-cut path to showing that those 14,000 documents weren't used, then you're looking at a preliminary injunction."
- bonzini 10y ago> launder his criminal protections into their civil case Which they just can't do right? Fifth amendment can be used against you in civil cases.
- ABCLAW 10y agoUber isn't claiming the fifth amendment. A senior executive of theirs is. Their argument is that his choices aren't theirs. Judge Alsup doesn't seem very sympathetic to that line of reasoning. He did not, however, decide upon that point at this stage, given that these matters were not properly in front of the court.
- bonzini 10y agoNot talking about claiming it, but about "laundering it" as the parent comment put it. And in fact as you say, it's being interpreted as making excuses more than respecting the choice of their executive.
- woodandsteel 10y agoSeems to me that Alsup is saying he is trying to remain open to the possibility that Uber is not guilty, but that Uber's behavior so far is making it really hard to do that, and it better do something better real soon or he is might well exercise the nuclear option, namely shut down its self-driving program.