16 ms·
IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service after bad review
- bhhaskin 10y agoThat's a real the danger of IoT devices. What happens if the company goes out of business, Or the company decides to terminate support? Cloud services should be additives not necessities.
- tlow 10y agoSeems like a real problem. On one hand legacy devices -- keeping them supported and updating their vulnerabilities for exploitative uses as we saw from Anna Senpai.
- Cerium 10y agoWhat happens when your nuclear reactor supplier goes out of business? What happens to your handle when your razor blade supplier goes out of business?
- mikeash 10y agoThe former likely involves long-term support contracts, and the latter is often solved with third parties manufacturing replaceable items.
- hkmurakami 10y agoSometimes you also buy large stakes in critical suppliers.
- cornellwright 10y agoWe'll get to find out soon with Westinghouse... https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2017/03/31/westinghouse-bankruptcy-shakes-the-nuclear-world/#48f17bc72688 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2017/03/31/westingho...
- fnordfnordfnord 10y agoWestinghouse is going bankrupt, not going out of business.
- dredmorbius 10y agoWhich means a shedding of liabilities. The question is: which ones.
- djrogers 10y agoNot sure about the nuclear reactor non-sequitur, but with a physical device like a razor blade you can buy spares, buy 3rd party, or move on. When an IoT maker adds 'cloud' to their product and makes it inextricably tied to the product's functionality, you have to be able to rely on their ability and willingness to maintain the cloud services for as long as you use the product.
- jlarocco 10y ago> What happens to your handle when your razor blade supplier goes out of business? This is an utterly stupid comparison. Razorblades cost less than 10 cents and are disposable by design. You don't spend $100 on a garage door monitor, or $1000+ on an appliance or TV expecting to use it once and throw it away.
- parenthephobia 10y agoYes, I can get electricity from a different provider, or buy a new handle, or indeed get a new garage door opener fitted. The problem is that a cloud-controlled garage door opener creates an unnecessary dependency on the continued existence - and good behaviour - of the vendor, unless one thinks that being able to open it from anywhere in the world is an essential feature of a garage door opener.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThere's more to it? Being a cloud service means there's a simple API to open the garage door, using vanilla networking standards. The IoT is maybe more about just using IP for communications instead of special signaling devices (garage-door-opener radios etc). Even if I just wanted to control the door from my desk at home, I'd still benefit from it being IoT-based.
- Ericson2314 10y agoFor the latter buy old school razors with single metal blade. Simple commodity with competitive markete.
- jessaustin 10y agoIt's amazing how much cheaper this (i.e. the double-edge "safety" razor) is, and it's amazing how many people don't know it. Over three years ago, I spent $11 on a pack of 100 blades. I'm not even halfway through the package.
- CaptainZapp 10y agoAs soon my razor, which works with blades, needs to connect to the internet I'll find a different brand.
- droithomme 10y ago> What happens if the company goes out of business, Or the company decides to terminate support? I agree with you completely. Devices that rely on external servers are not OK. My house's automation uses IoT devices that host their own servers, and/or communicate with those locally that do. I had to build them myself since no company I could find offered anything like this. I'm not a snowflake either, other engineers have done the same. Currently, IMO, the only reasonable solution to home automation is to do everything yourself, from absolute scratch. Commercial solutions are a combination of insidious spyware and stuff that will become useless when the company becomes acquired, dies, or gets mad at you and shuts down a server.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoServers are necessary because many users have a dynamic IP address. If your product doesn't need to offer remote control, this isn't a problem. But for many products remote control is a significant USP. I've built my own IoT systems, and this is one of the first problems that has to be solved. In an IPv4 world, with domestic networks connected through NAT and a dynamic IP, external servers are going to remain a thing, because the problem cannot be solved without an external server. If IPv6 ever really takes off every device will have its own address, and then all we'll have to worry about is building bullet proof top tier security into an SoC running some version of Linux that was last patched a few years ago.
- tokenizerrr 10y agoJust run a dynamic dns server and have the client update that. Then in the client software default to using your dns infrastructure but let the user override, so when you go out of business they could set up their own dyndns and use that. There is still the security problem of course.
- ryandrake 10y ago> In an IPv4 world, with domestic networks connected through NAT and a dynamic IP, external servers are going to remain a thing, because the problem cannot be solved without an external server. It can be solved, but the setup UX might not be great. Wouldn't you just have an "Advanced" UI that allows you to input the public IP address of your home network? The IoT device itself could take it from there and set up the correct firewall and forwarding rules over UPnP, or you can do it yourself. It's a one-time setup. Despite it being dynamic, how often does your ISP-provided IPV4 address actually change?
- pasbesoin 10y agoThere's also data leakage, even within the context of "working as expected." Recently, a clerk with the local/county municipality showed be a circa 4 am toilet flush and hand washing at my place-- based upon the single spike and amount of water used. Me slightly creeped out. The new remote-read water meters break down usage to at least the hour level -- that's what the interface she was in provided. I can't go to the can without someone "watching". Do I start "obscuring" or "polluting" my toiletries with random flushes and runs out to the backyard bushes? Maybe I need to roboticize this with a Raspberry Pi (overkill?) or Arduino. (But what random number generator/source do I use?) If I had money to burn, I could install a cistern that I would draw into only periodically in large bursts. My water meter is, via a local 433 MHz uplink, on "the Internet of Things". My friend's dog now has more privacy with regard to his bowel movements.
- tcoff91 10y agoWhat was the context around you being shown that information by the clerk?
- pasbesoin 10y agoI asked about recent increases in my billed amounts and whether my account might be connected to the wrong meter -- something I've read is happening as these systems are deployed. The clerks have a system at the counter that is already signed in at some degree of administrator level. They can pull up any record they wish, on the spot. There appears to be no concern about logging or auditing of access. The clerk just took my account number from the bill I brought with me and pulled up my usage for the last couple of days. Swung the screen around and asked whether it looked familiar (it did). I have access to the same system -- supposedly only for my own account, after I go through an initial sign-up/on process. I wonder how secure that external access to accounts is, but I can't speak to this at this point. My understanding from reading is also that a lot of these systems transmit unencrypted on the 433 MHz band as they communicate up to local aggregators. I didn't bring that up with the clerk. By the way, I was given no choice to opt-out of this deployment.
- 10y ago
- naniid 10y agoThat is exactly why we need more open standards.
- syshum 10y agoOne of the problems with these devices is they almost always come with "free" cloud management solutions, meaning you pay a one time fee for the hardware, and get access to "the cloud" for life for no additional fee So the cloud services must be continually supported by selling new devices at an exponentially increasing rate to support both old and new customers.. In other markets this is called a pyramid scheme where new investors pay off old investors... I will not buy a IoT product that does not some with a Self Hosted management option, preferably open source, but at minimum installable binaries to run on my own server. If they want to provide their own service for the less technical clients more power to them, but for me self hosted or no buy
- ams6110 10y ago100% agree, though personally I make it a bit simpler and just stop with "I will not buy an IoT product."
- rycfan 10y agoWhy an exponentially increasing rate? A device like this doesn't use much storage, any logs it keeps can be rotated out after a certain duration, and the cost of storage goes down over time, not up. So storing the same amount of data 5 years from now will be less expensive, not more expensive, than today. In addition, there are things called annuities, where the purchase price today can have enough set aside to be self-sustaining. Not saying they've done that in this case, but it's not outside the realm of possibility.
- CaptainZapp 10y agoYou know what really bugs me about the whole affair? And granted. I didn't look into this specific product, but Why the hell do I need cloud storage at all for a fucking garage door opener?
- tezza 10y ago"Cloud" is now what they used to call "centralised control via https callbacks and polling"
- 10y ago
- 839083 10y agoThere was the whole Nest thermostat debacle recently, but no legal precedent as far as I know.
- Arwill 10y agoThe point is more that this "company" is most probably run and operated by a single person. Hence he is being upset with not being able to answer support questions at night and being forced to deal with every customer professionally, while being busy with a bunch of other things. But this is probably also calculated into the price of the product, and the fact that its just a garage door device. If it were some medical device, you would expect that its supported by a large company, the device has gone trough mandatory certifications, etc. But that would also show in the price of the product, or the volume at which those products are produced and sold. The mistake is expecting that every gadget maker provides service such a multi-billion dollars corporation can. It simply can't, its a single-person company and that person has its limits. So you either have to deal with some roughness, or you dismiss everything not backed by a large enough company. Not that big companies can't be assholes, they just know how to be assholes less personally.
- dawnerd 10y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14029572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14029572
- mnglkhn2 10y agoThe customer gets to get a refund for the product. This way it is not bricking per-se but refusal of service. My understanding of bricking is that you have a dead device and no recourse in getting a replacement or a refund. The interesting question to me is what exactly you buy for $99: just the device ? Is the cloud-based service included in the price also? Especially since the developer can only make an assumption as to how long (in years) a customer will be using the service.
- ouid 10y agoSurely whether a customer has a right to review a product and some recourse in the event of retaliation qualifies as an interesting question, as well though, right?
- protomyth 10y agoas pointed out on Amazon this might run afoul of https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/hr5111 https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/hr5111 H.R. 5111 (114th): Consumer Review Fairness Act of 2016
- mnglkhn2 10y agoYou seem to imply that I approve of the manner the seller reacted. Not the case. My comment was on the use of the word "bricking", which I found improper in this case, as well as on the nature of the product, the question being what is the product, just the device or access to the remote servers? Aside from a snide remark, nothing was added by your comment. I suppose you were just triggered and felt the need to do some virtue signaling.
- jsjohnst 10y agoWas the last part really needed? Let's keep things civil!
- ouid 10y agoWell now I'm triggered. I was really only offering you an opportunity to clarify. There is a difference between offering a refund and forcing a refund. This was clearly a retaliatory action and you either didn't understand that, or disagree with the premise.
- protomyth 10y agoGrisak'a response in the article is fairly arrogant particularly with the Musk tweet thrown in. If you sell B2B then, by all means, fire customers, but if you sell on Amazon to consumers then you need to deal with them civilly regardless if you feel insulted. I get the feeling a lawyer told him to explicitly state it wasn't about the review because there is a new federal law that protects reviewers. That statement doesn't jive with his previous posts.
- obstinate 10y agoTo be fair to Grisak, Musk's "firing" of a customer was also a B2C situation. That being said, there are a number of factors that differ: - Musk had not already sold the individual a car. - Musk was (possibly) responding not to the critical blog post, but to the content of the phone conversation. - It has not been decided yet, but I doubt Garadget will ultimately have the popularity and cachet of Tesla's cars. This, for better or worse, does have an impact on what you can get away with. - All of the above notwithstanding, maybe this was not Elon Musk's finest moment. Not ever word out of his mouth is useful for all purposes. Citing the fact he said something, even if he was in a situation that is perfectly analogous to one's own, does not justify one's comparable action.
- protomyth 10y agoI should of separated out those two sentences since just the presence of that tweet was my problem, and I wanted B2B to be a separate point. I've noticed if some CEO quotes Jobs it is generally suspect too. That being said, I do agree with all your points. I tend to think no garage door company is going to have the cachet of any Elon Musk company. Frankly, only Elon Musk could send out that tweet and not get hammered.
- mizzao 10y agoCan someone link to the original thing that Musk did?
- arvin 10y agoElon Musk personally cancels blogger's Tesla order after 'rude' post - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/03/elon-musk-blogger-tesla-motors-model-x https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/03/elon-musk...
- lazaroclapp 10y agoI guess it is a good thing this is not a 'smart pacemaker' manufacturer or similar... But in all seriousness, I wonder at which point the decision to rescind an IoT 'service' becomes unacceptable. Obviously doing so with a medical device or a moving vehicle during operation would be criminal. But how about a smart home lock? A security camera / alarm system?
- bigbugbag 10y agoThere's a few million cars around with remote kill switch technology on board. "We can disable the ignition but not while you're driving," Melanie Boudreau, a spokesperson at IMETRIK, a Canadian maker of starter interrupt devices that run around $100 each, told Fortune. "We don't want to kill you." Maybe in a not so distant future or political regime, this stance on not killing people may change. Remote kill switch are not limited to ignition, there's a moving vehicle version intended for police use to stop a car chase[1] so there's that, we can expect this[2] to be done on moving vehicle in the wild at some point[3]. [1]: http://abcnews.go.com/Business/Autos/story?id=3706113&page=1 http://abcnews.go.com/Business/Autos/story?id=3706113&page=1 [2]: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/03/disabling_cars.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/03/disabling_car... [3]: https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/ https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig...
- jessaustin 10y agoWith "self-driving" cars, the next logical customer termination technique will be speeding up to 100mph and then steering into a bridge abutment. I think I'll keep my bicycle.
- adrianN 10y agoNearby auto-cars will start chasing you.
- ddalex 10y agoWelcome to real life: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/putin-driver-chauffeur-moscow-car-crash-killed-kremlin-bmw-mercedes-a7230211.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/putin-driver... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmJPncqoPvE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmJPncqoPvE
- walrus01 10y agoIt's almost as if people are intentionally expending additional effort to prove that https://twitter.com/internetofshit https://twitter.com/internetofshit is correct.
- terminado 10y agoIt's the right idea to consider the concept of IoT as an Internet of Shit because, even if the devices function flawlessly, device functionality is not always crafted in the best interests of the end-user. Even if the device is well-designed and doesn't malfunction, a device might function all-too-well, and act against the consumer who owns the object. When you have a smart device that's smart enough to be too smart to let you freely benefit from it, everything becomes a rental at best. If we let this happen, it could very well be a step backward from the status quo of planned obsolescence. (planned obsolescence is also a bad thing, just in case anyone needs that spelled out)
- donkeyd 10y ago> When you have a smart device that's smart enough to be too smart to let you freely benefit from it What does this mean?
- Houshalter 10y agoAn internet connected device can spy on you and sell your data. It can show you ads. It can have much more sophisticated DRM. It can stop functioning at a random time while it goes through an unnecessary update. It can be bricked remotely if you try to hack it. Consider game consoles. The original xbox would just boot up the game that was in the drive and that was it. The newer ones will go to a home screen full of ads. You have to create a microsoft account to start playing. The game will take several hours to update before you can start (and because of this games are now released in an unfinished state because they count on customers updating.) And it was going to be so that you have to have the internet on all the time so it can check if your game is used or not (fortunately they disabled that after overwhelming protest.)
- 10y ago
- voycey 10y agoHe could at least have gone for the "It was for security purposes to ensure that no-one could intercept your return and get into your garage" Amateur
- WalterBright 10y agoI can't imagine why I'd want to connect my garage door opener up to the hackers on the internet.
- bigbugbag 10y agoSo how did the developer knew it was a toxic individual ? his account has exactly 1 post on the forum which is the one that got him banned.
- kikimaru 10y ago"Toxic" is the new safe-word for millenials. Don't like a person? Must be "toxic"! Best keep away.
- slfnflctd 10y agoI've heard the term used at least as far back as the 90s. The phrase "cut the toxic people out of your life" comes up a lot. I suspect it originated with either 12-step programs or psychologists. Seems like good advice, except for the part where it's basically running from interpersonal conflict instead of dealing with it. In some situations with really unbalanced people it's the best option, though.
- wccrawford 10y agoHe's not saying it's a new term. He's saying that it's being applied when it doesn't really apply in order to just brush people under the rug.
- coldpie 10y agoSounds like a certain cranky old man got kicked out of his niece's birthday party. Time for your nap!
- anjc 10y agoWhen people with no social skills run companies.
- basicplus2 10y agoThe rule of thumb that I have found.. you spend 90% of your time on less than 10% of your clients... so just price yourself out of their market.
- GavinMcG 10y agoWhy would you think the 10% that's a pain to deal with is the 10% at the bottom economically?
- basicplus2 10y agoI don't think they are at the bottom economically, I am saying I will charge a rediculously large fee.
- bichiliad 10y agoI think you'll find people like that, regardless. At the end of the day, people get frustrated when they pay money for something that doesn't work. Plus, posting in a forum can feel like shouting at a wall rather than talking to a person, especially if you're not used to posting in forums. If you're patient enough with angry customers, they can become some of the most adamant supporters of your product.
- miloshadzic 10y agoIf only someone warned us about shit like this... Some guy was jabbering about it all the time but I don't remember his name. I think he wrote a text editor or something...
- justin66 10y agoThe interesting thing to me is that the level of anger involved in the customer interaction here barely even moved the meter and the support person - who is apparently also the owner and developer - went nuclear. Support professionals are used to dealing with people who are angry at them personally and in this case, the guy was only expressing anger at the product. This should have been a low-stress response addressing the problem itself. This story brought back memories. I supported software shortly after graduation and the lead developer once joked with me about how we ought to just give people their money back if they couldn't make it work after a certain period of time. Nobody ever let him near customers without supervision. But even he, when confronted with customers disparaging his work, could cope by hand-holding the customer or asking them how they thought the program ought to work instead. Garadget will fail.
- linsomniac 10y agoA lot of responses seem to be along the lines of: When doing support you need to put up with being abused. Seriously? I think the support guy/founder should have taken the high road, for reasons that are all too obvious based on the number of HN stories I've seen about this. But, if my kids ever spoke to a stranger like this, I'd make them go clean up dog poop in this person's yard and apologize. "C'mon, we're getting on a plane!" And further, if your opinion of a product is that it is a "piece of shit", why would you get mad when the product is disabled and you are offered a refund? Are you expecting them to turn a piece of shit into a unicorn? If it's a piece of shit, a refund is exactly what you wan't, isn't it?