21 ms·
Why Were Economists as a Group as Useless Over 2010-2014 as Over 1929-1935?
- Retric 10y agoGreat Depression: industrial production in the United States declined 47 percent and real gross domestic product (GDP) fell 30 percent. In comparison 2010-2014 was a minor blip, with less than 3% GDP drop, that barely qualifies as a correction. I fear central banks have actually gotten to good at minimizing these issues as we could easily do the same thing in another 10 years, where the great depression created far more systemic change in both organizations and peoples attitude to investing and credit. PS: People want the post correction economy to match up with the pre-recession economy. However, in the case of irrational behavior the rational economy should have a lower GDP and that's not actually a problem.
- astrodust 10y agoYeah, well, hold on to your hat.
- Retric 10y agoJapan style stagnation seems like the most likely outcome to me, what's your prediction?
- alphonsegaston 10y agoNot the parent, but if I had to guess, the current administration is creating the context for a massive wealth transfer using deregulation following a financial collapse of similar magnitude to Russia in the 90s. The end aim is to create a economically and politically entrenched kleptocrat class and a corresponding "managed democracy." Funnily enough, Abe Shinzo and his political allies have suggested doing this explicitly through constitutional reform, Japan being so steeped in corruption at this point that such talk is par for the course [0]. I'm not sure what will be the trigger, they seem to be pushing at several angles - war, knock-on effects from environmental collapse, another financial implosion. Because of the systemic corruption of the Democratic Party, the collapse could emerge organically. Obama really only papered over the root causes of the financial crises (not to mention paying off the culprits). But it's a unlikely you're going to see Japanese style stagnation. Their economic circumstances are a result of the U.S. propping up their economy through an export regime for the sake of regional national security, as well as an economic approach that (generally) pursues a more stable state than dramatic rises and falls. The U.S has neither of those preconditions. Contemporary Russia is probably more instructive generally, with perhaps Central American style inequality being exemplary for the coastal regions. [0] https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.ft.com/content/06d6bf9e-fabd-11e2-a7aa-00144feabdc0 https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.ft.com/content/06d6bf9e-fab...
- gozur88 10y agoI think you're right. The government can keep things in sort of a gentle downward glide slope by printing money as long as they don't overdo it.
- astrodust 10y agoIt's always a gentle glide until a mountain shows up and then you crater into it.
- astrodust 10y agoDid Japan elect a lunatic that wanted to roll back all the institutions put in place in the last sixty years?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoWhich, arguably, shows that economists were not as useless as a group over 2008-2018 as they were over 1929-1935.
- jbmorgado 10y agoWhy not? Minimising these impacts it's about finances, not economics. I.E Economics is about predicting these things (which they absolutely didn't), finances is about putting mechanisms in place so that if they happen they will be minimised.
- ecnal 10y agoThe vast majority of economics is not macroeconomic forecasting. That's somewhat akin to saying that computer science is about making email work.
- lowbloodsugar 10y agoSure. But the ones that were about macroeconomic forecasting totally fucked up. That's somewhat akin to saying that the IT department responsible for managing email is about making email work. Not such an unreasonable complaint any more. Particularly galling that we had "crazy" economists claiming that we were in a massive housing bubble which we should expect to burst back in 2006, while at the same time the economists at the Fed were saying, "Look at interest rates! Now is a great time to buy a house!" and coincidentally their mates from college were selling mortgage backed securities. So really its more akin to the IT department responsible for managing the email deliberately sending Nigerian fishing scams to their fellow employees along with the public message of "No, outlook is fine, just click on anything in your inbox!"
- VHRanger 10y agoEconomics is not about predicting, it's about understanding things. It's basically impossible to do the former at scale for time periods over 6 months, we're slowly getting better at the latter. One big reason economic forecasting is so hard is that agents in the system you are forecasting are taking your present period forecast into account when acting in future periods.
- drak0n1c 10y agoThat's true for correction against irrational exuberance in a static environment. This may explain Japan. But the world is usually dynamic. Technological progress, non-monetary fiscal/regulatory reform, new business innovations (of the non-subprime-mortgage flavor), world events, and population growth are rational factors that can simultaneously push up GDP during or following a correction of previous irrationality.
- hl5 10y agoA minor blip where millions lost their jobs, houses, and businesses... The hard part about economic analysis is you can never know all the variables in a dynamic system. It's a common error to summarize based on variables convenient to the theme you choose to present only to later realize your analysis should have included some fairly obvious factors.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoYes millions lost their jobs, houses, and business. And yes it was a minor blip. If you think otherwise, you don't grasp how bad the Great Depression was. Think about 35% unemployment for years. The majority of mainstream economists didn't see it coming. That's a totally valid criticism. But they did a much better job of handling it than in 1929, and the damage, while major, was still nothing like the Great Depression.
- ThomPete 10y agoI think you owe it to yourself to look up how the US defines a job. Most jobs created since 2008 are trmp jobs not actuallu structurally solid jobs so sure there is less unemployment but the employment there is is way more fragile.
- matt4077 10y agoThe actual criticism is the US not counting people not actively looking for a job as unemployed, thus dismissing those who have given up/gone back to school/retired early/found their calling as a stay-at-home dad. Still: if you believe today's troubles are in any way comparable to the 20s, you owe it to yourself to read up on that period. Check for "starvation" in the index.
- ThomPete 10y agoWe are talking jobs not the consequence of not having jobs. Point is there are a lot more who have jobs which arent actually jobs on any way comparable to back then.
- PravlageTiem 10y agoSlap children often.
- carsongross 10y agoBecause they don't take debt, in particular private debt, seriously, including Krugman and Delong. Steve Keen explains how wrong this is.
- naravara 10y agoNobody thinks national debt doesn't matter. They think the long term costs of endemic poverty or economic stagnation outweigh the long term costs of carrying a deficit.
- akinalci 10y agoWe have this big problem. We'll just patch over it with this other problem and call that a reasonable strategy.
- Gibbon1 10y agoThe elephant in the room is we don't have enough inflation to re-balance the ratio of income to debt. As a result the ratio of debt to income keeps growing.
- tcbawo 10y agoI think what he's suggesting is that paying down debt through austerity can be more costly than growth, since austerity hurts growth. The trick is, where does growth come from?
- gozur88 10y agoThe mistake there is thinking printing money brings you growth. Where has this worked?
- josephlord 10y agoFirstly there are two ways that money is printed. 1) Government/central bank spend more than they take in taxes. 2) Private banks make loans to private sector (biz or individuals). Money is destroyed by government running a surplus or by loans being repaid. Note also that for the government to run a surplus the private sector must run a deficit (decrease savings or increase borrowing) in most circumstances. The question is where money should be created and how it should be managed and controlled.
- hkmurakami 10y ago"Economics is a highly sophisticated field of thought that is superb at explaining to policymakers precisely why the choices they made in the past were wrong. About the future, not so much." -- Ben Bernanke, 2013 (the quote is from an unexpectedly funny and thoughtful commencement speech) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ww6guPQsKQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ww6guPQsKQo http://money.cnn.com/2013/06/02/news/economy/bernanke-princeton-speech/ http://money.cnn.com/2013/06/02/news/economy/bernanke-prince...
- socmag 10y agoHey, there is a great cartoon about that here! https://rwer.wordpress.com/2013/11/09/the-scientific-illusion-of-modern-macroeconomics/ https://rwer.wordpress.com/2013/11/09/the-scientific-illusio...
- fiatjaf 10y agoIt's great there isn't a "consensus" between economists, otherwise if that consensus was wrong we would never be able to leave it, like what happens in other sciences.
- AndrewOMartin 10y agoBecause due to random luck they happened to be vaguely accurate over 1936-2009?
- Gibbon1 10y agoEconomics went down a rathole in the 1960's. Happens to a lot of fields.
- api 10y agoThere was another article on academic incentives today that referenced a wonderful quote: "When a measure is used as a target, it ceases to be a good measure." My impression is that economics as a whole does not understand this. When you target GDP for example, GDP ceases to be a good measure of anything. The trouble with economics as a science is that its results are used to guide the economy. This creates a feedback loop, making it essentially a self-invalidating discipline.
- matt4077 10y agoThat's true if what you measure is only a proxy for some other reality that you actually want to affect, but that is harder to measure. Cholesterol, for example, has long been targeted because it had shown a high correlation to cardiovascular health and life expectancy. The result was a long series of medications that successfully lowered cholesterol, with occasional death as a side effect. GDP is pretty close to what you actually want to change. There are some other measures, such as social mobility, Gini, or poverty–but rising GDP has almost always been good for people.
- api 10y agoI'm not convinced GDP is what we want per se. It's a secondary indicator of what we want, but it's also possible to boost GDP by inflating asset, debt, and investment bubbles, and otherwise moving money around un-productively or even counter-productively. This is particularly true in the short term. What we want is productivity, development, and innovation. Those are primary things that like "good science" in the academic case are not easily distilled into simple measures that can be set as targets.
- thinkling 10y agoIf economists did come to a broad consensus, many politicians would still ignore that consensus if it didn't happen to fit their worldview or the interests of their major donors. See: climate science.
- Fordrus 10y agoMy Gosh, that is an extremely salient and DEEPLY DEPRESSING point. I've been drawn to question what to do about that quite often, but I havent happened across an acceptable answer as yet.
- zoomzoom 10y agoMy hope would be that the problem isn't "major donors" but rather uneducated and misrepresented citizens. The question about donors or deep states or any other conspiracy type scheme is both how they might affect the purpose of the education system and the integrity of the democratic machinery. These should be questioned, but fixing them might be more achievable than eliminating "major donors" which is certainly tied to income inequality in general, some level of which is most likely desirable.
- cassowary 10y agoMajor donors have better access to the media than me. I can't educate them if the major donors are spinning opinions. My HN post will reach a negligible proportion of the voters; their prime time ad will reach a huge number.
- flukus 10y agoVote for better politicians.
- zaphar 10y agoStep 1 is to get better politicians to run. Only then can you vote for them.
- thinkling 10y agoIf economists did come to a broad consensus, many politicians would still ignore that consensus if it didn't happen to fit their worldview or the interests of their major donors. See: climate science.
- TSiege 10y agoFrom what it looks in these comments, almost no one read this article nor know who Bradford Delong is. He's a New Keynesian, arguing no one listened to Keynesians...
- lollerbot817 10y agoBecause economics has always been utterly useless in any practical sense. It makes no testable predictions and is no more scientific than any theology. Only because it clothes its dogmas in symbolic notation is it accorded even the slightest bit of respect. The sooner we jettison it from our epistenic frames, the more quickly we will return to something that at least partially resembles sanity.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoI believe that Economics should be a subset of Psychology. It mystifies me how Psych or Sociology classes arent required for a major. One would think that practitioners of a field essentially about human behavior would have insight into actual human behavior. And you would be wrong. Humans are replace by the mythical rational agent You are correct though. Economists are so proud of their elegant equations that they won't let questions like "Does this model accurately measure reality" stop them.
- cassowary 10y agoPsychology students aren't required to study physics, despite most psychologists believing that psychology is basically just physics at an abstraction
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoA deeper knowledge of physics wouldn't offer much new insight into psychology. A deeper knowledge of psychology and/or sociology can help you predict someone's behavior. Instead of assuming utility maximizing "rational" agents, you may be able to more accurately model human behavior.
- matt4077 10y ago> It makes no testable predictions That's not true. There are, for example, GDP growth forecasts published by almost all central banks and many other institutions. They are pretty wrong, most of the time. But they are made, and falsifying them has been pretty easy in the past. There are many more theories in economics that are, in principle, testable and falsifiable. The problem is that it's difficult to run controlled "experiments" on interventions. You never have a control group in the strict sense, and everything is connected to everything else.
- crimsonalucard 10y agoTwo things in our universe that are impossible: Modeling chaos and knowing the future. Economists model chaos and use that model to predict the future.
- matt4077 10y agoThe weather forecast is pretty close–it's where chaos theory originated after all, and it's got "forecast" in its name. And forecasts in that realm have improved tremendously over the last years.
- forkLding 10y agoA lot of economics aside from the first year undergrad basics are being contested, I've discussed this issue with several economics professors and their consensus is to use the basics but ignore the more senior stuff.
- SubiculumCode 10y agoIt is hard to characterize as diverse a field as economics. However, there are some influential sectors of the field of economics that 1) avoids rigorous empirical research, and/or 2) identifies economic policies that benefit their benefactors, and then produce economic theory that support those policies. Which is backwards, or at least distorted.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoThere is also a troubling cult of personality that plagues the field, where Nobel Prize winners and other luminaries' research is accepted as truth without peer review. Example: Greenspan
- ThomPete 10y agoEconomists are mostly to be considered historians and even as historians they have very little actual data about the things that make an economy. This is most visible in the fact that they treat technology as an externality even though its probably the most important factor in understanding our current economy. These economists with their models still assume production as primarily an output of labour are advicing our politicians. Its going to be seen as an era of great ignorance to the factors that really matter to an economy today.
- nabla9 10y agoIt seems that people are too hurried to read the article and are commenting the title and economics on general level. Basic macroeconomics did fine. Austerity side Alesina/Ardagna/Reinhart/Rogoff camp was utterly wrong. Spreadsheet errors in their studies that became basis for political action etc. Even after the austerity approach has been shown to be baseless in academia it continues to live in politics. Politicians have little or no ability to evaluate what they hear or read. Backgrounder: How the Case for Austerity Has Crumbled http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2013/06/06/how-case-austerity-has-crumbled/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2013/06/06/how-case-austerit...
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y ago> Even after the austerity approach has been shown to be baseless in academia it continues to live in politics. Politicians nearly no ability to evaluate what they hear or read. Unfortunately, politicians and the general public often inject philosophy and morality into their view of finances and Economics. Beyond austerity, another example is drug testing and work requirements for entitlements. This is particularly problematic if automation permanently reduces the demand for actual human labour.
- empath75 10y agoThe problem is that politicians don't give a solitary shit about economics except when it gives them cover for doing what they wanted to do anyway. I hope no one genuinely believe that politicians wanted to enact austerity measures or shrink government because of economics. They do it because huge corporations and billionaires want less taxes and lower regulation so they can accumulate more wealth personally. Whether the economy as a whole or even a a majority of the people benefits is irrelevant to them. See also climate change.
- ksk 10y agoAs you probably might also agree, its a bit of both. Politicians don't go into politics thinking they're just going to accept donations and do whatever. They believe the stuff at some level and then get corrupted by the marketing/lobbying. The greater problem is that politicians are lay people, and even if they wanted to listen to economists they would first have to navigate the topology of the topic at large, and then understand the minutia of what each side represents. Now apply that for 10 different varied fields including foreign policy/medicine/science/defense/social issues/etc and you quickly realize that its just impossible for any one person to make accurate decisions across such a wide swath of issues. Maybe the answer is more decentralization, but then you cant do the moonshots where you need to pool in the resources/talents/labor across a large populace. Its all a shitshow to some extent. But then again, the world hasn't gone to shit just yet so at-least somethings working .. :)
- nickik 10y agoIts interesting how DeLong who got so many things wrong is so convinced he is totally correct. He talks about Skidelsky, who is a convicted old Keynesian who somehow survived the 70s to hunt economics. Many monetarist (and others) have correctly point to these the drop-off in demand in 2008/2009 and said if it continued it would be bad. The large error that happened, was actually the professions believe in the liquidity trap. Those like Krugman and DeLong who wrongly believed that 'the central bank was out of ammo' and the central bankers who ran around like headless chickens when their New Keynesian models failed at the ZLB. It took smart central bankers like those in Switzerland and others (and eventually the US) to overcome that and simply go back to what is now called 'unconventional monetary policy'. It is of course only called that because New Keynesian labeled it that (its not in their models so it can't possibly be a normal thing to do). The Fed for example was so convinced that they needed to control the interest rate (because of New Keynesian thinking), they sterilized (selling bonds to prevent the balance sheet from growing) all their bad asset purchases and once they were unable to sustain that and started growing the balance sheet (labeled QE1 after the fact), they switched to paying interest on reserves with the express purpose to not allow the new money to 'get out'. At the same time they are doing this, NGDP is falling of a cliff. Its economic madness and the reason is a false believe in New Keynesian models and specifically the liquidity trap. It is insane to use a model that practically fails when the crisis hits.