22 ms·
Things that happen at a lock-picking convention (2013)
- mirimir 10y ago_/|_/|_/|_/|_/|_ ;)
- sealub 10y agoI remember when I learned how to open up high school locker room lockers...quite the rush when the first one opened. good times.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI, on the other hand, got kicked out of algebra class because someone stole my book from my locker. The school tried to tell me that it was obviously my fault because the locker wouldn't have been able to be opened had I only closed it correctly.
- jsolson 10y agoMy natural reaction to that would've been to leave the school and every locker in it unlocked over the course of a weekend. Not claiming any responsibility for it, naturally, simply observing that it had happened.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoMy father was the business manager for the school system - stuff like that was a bit difficult for me to get away with without weird consequences.
- sealub 10y agoI was able to stay late after school, as I was close friends with one of my teachers. He would stay until 19:00 most days grading work and talking... now that I think of it, I could have pulled some great stunts. Maybe randomizing the contents of a selection of not so random lockers... (purely for educational purposes, of course)
- dom0 10y agoThere was no need to pick locker locks in my school, since you could just stick a screwdriver in the small gap between locker door and frame and leverage the door over the frame (with no damage done). After I lost my locker key I used a screw driver for some years to open it; not even the paint was scratched :)
- jlgaddis 10y ago(2013)
- aaron695 10y agoI did wonder why Slate had a interesting article like this. They really lost the plot in the last few years.
- bike4beer 10y agoRead Feynman's book "Surely your joking Dr. Feynman", he's got an entire chapter on safe cracking. Yep, I remember in high school, in fact it was in Pasadena not far from Cal Tech, I don't remember who, but somehow I learned from somebody how to open the high-school lockers by 'feel', in a fairly short-time I could open any locker quicker than my own knowing the combo. Locks are fairly amazing when you think about it the locksmiths and the criminals all know how to crack any lock, yet the people in the middle think they're secure. Years later as a landlord I got to know my locksmith fairly well, one day by offhand he told me that the master-key ( So I could have one key to rule them all ) I was using could open 1/2 the units in the city.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- matt4077 10y agoYour telling comes across as an indictment of the security industry. I think it's a testament to human progress. We've never been as safe as we are today. Maybe time to just leave the lock away then. It's pretty common in Scandinavia, and, at least for me as a tourist, had quite an impact on the societies' mood.
- eru 10y agoOh, but we are not safe because of better locks. We are safe because most societies your typical HN readers lives in are fairly safe. (I know lots of people in Germany who don't bother to lock their doors.)
- vincentbarr 10y ago(1) I love your book recommendation; however, it dedicates maybe one or two pages to safe-cracking, so I would not recommend it for this purpose. Instead, I would read the material that Deviant Ollam has published (http://deviating.net/lockpicking/resources.html http://deviating.net/lockpicking/resources.html) or look for an upcoming TOOOL meetup (http://toool.us/ http://toool.us/). (2) I don't intend to be pedantic – and perhaps I'm mistaking hyperbole for fact – but how could you are opening a combination lock with an secret unbeknownst to you more quickly than your a combination lock with a secret known to you? Unless, you're shimming the new lock and avoiding dialing the correct combination altogether, in which case you would solve them all locks in the same span of time, this is unlikely. However, you said you're opening the lock by 'feel,' so I assume that's not the case.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eps 10y agoSo what were these strange things promised in the title? Looked like a perfectly normal lock-picking convention to me.
- tajen 10y agoYes. It's just lock-picking art. I was expecting stories like the organizers finding the party "reversed" (=while organizers are in the main room, most attendants found their way into the backstage) or the parking emptied of all its cars after the first hour of the conference. Defcon seems funnier ;) https://www.reddit.com/r/Defcon/comments/4x47ss/share_your_funny_defcon_stories/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Defcon/comments/4x47ss/share_your_f...
- eps 10y agoDisregard. Mods fixed the title.
- MrQuincle 10y agoWhat makes a lock strong? I think if it's the amount of metal that is inaccessible to the outside. Something like the Haven lock that is bolted to the floor, makes a lot of sense. That of course requires a way of opening that is digital. I'll think of the pros of digital locks: + The proliferation of protocols makes master keys almost impossible. + Faster update cycles when encryption gets cracked. + Keys that are handed out to household members or visitors with potential losses can be easily retracted. + The above separation of concerns. The way to keep someone out should be separate from the way to ask for permission to enter. + The easier integration with other security layers such as face recognition, voice recognition, etc.
- jwilk 10y agoI wouldn't put too much faith in competence of digital lock manufacturers. https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8019-lockpicking_in_the_iot https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8019-lockpicking_in_the_iot
- MrQuincle 10y agoSure, but we've heard all the arguments against digital locks many times. I've never encountered a list with arguments in favor of them. Sorry, if the above was off-topic. Downvotes humbly accepted.
- Animats 10y agoWhat makes a lock strong? Against forced entry, standard cylinder locks are inherently weak, because they're just not big enough. It's often possible to force the cylinder to turn, shearing off the pins. Especially if the pins are brass. Locks need to be much larger than usual to resist forced entry. Here's a classic mechanical prison door lock.[1] It's a straightforward lever lock, but it's far larger. There used to be a thing for "detector" lever locks; if you push a lever too far, it trips the detector, and you have to put in a key and turn it the wrong way to reset before you can try again. Those were once claimed to be unpickable. They're not, but it slows things down a lot. [1] http://www.lockpicking101.com/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=52798 http://www.lockpicking101.com/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=52798
- chayesfss 10y agoIf you see these guys at security conferences, buy cash, don't have it linked to your personal cc, I'm probably overly sensitive but whatever...
- wonderous 10y agoOn the same note, even having picks in some locations may legally be an issue; for example, here's info on laws on a state by state basis in the US: http://toool.us/laws.html http://toool.us/laws.html If you're that concerned though, likely best not even to attend conferences that would be selling picks, since it's easy to track where people go and use network analysis to ID the likely intent of that cluster of people, use public info, info leaked by someone else there, etc.
- pmoriarty 10y agoWhat are you afraid of?
- yjftsjthsd-h 10y agoStandard answer to "if you have nothing to hide..."; someone, somewhere, can assume the worst from that information, and sometimes that person is legally empowered to make your life miserable based on their conclusion. So the logical choice is often to take measures to protect your privacy even when it shouldn't be necessary.
- praptak 10y agoI've spoken to a private investigator in 2015 who told me that bump keys made lockpicking disappointingly easy. Their downside for a criminal is that the application is rather loud, compared to the classic pin-by-pin lockpicking. That was the state for 2015, things might have changed.
- lucideer 10y agoBump keys make lockpicking disappointingly easy for locks that are easy to pick. They take something that's a nice challenge for a beginner and make it easy for anyone. However, a good lock that's difficult to pick for anyone, with or without bump keys or comprehensive experience, is pretty easy to come by. That said, the hard thing is often knowing the difference: expensive and heavy are not necessarily good hints.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThis is not actually true. From around the 35 minute mark in the "What The Bump" talk, security researcher, TOOOL founder and President Barry Wels said: "It [bumping] also works on these high security locks: multiple rows with dimples, keys that look really dangerous thinking if I have these on my door I'm really safe. The thing is, they open just as easy as the other locks, as far as we've seen. The only problem is getting bump keys. We really had some help from some of the state of the art Dutch locksmiths, with very advanced tools to make these keys. But once you have these keys, they're just as easy to open as the other locks. One of the statements which is my favorite is: I think you can teach this to a monkey to open locks like this. I'm still looking for somebody with a monkey to actually shoot some video. If you know somebody with a monkey that we could train to do this, that would be fun. "It also works with locks with moving parts in it. The ball offers no protection because you take the original key, it has all the information already in it. The ball is always in the same position or there are two different spacings of the ball. It all works the same, because there are a lot of locks with protective measurements that are standard for all the locks. So once you have a key that is cut to the deepest, these mechanisms are still in place. The ball is still there, for instance, and it will still open. "We opened some some pin-in-pin locks. The brand name is Mul-T-Lock. They were not happy that we opened them, and they were not happy that they were being mentioned in a white paper, and they more or less demanded a public test to show that it wouldn't work. So when the guy was at our place I explained to him how the technique actually worked, because he had no clue. So then he demanded a closed test where the results were kept secret. I said I'm willing to do that. He also put a time limit of four days or something ridiculous like that. So I said I'm willing to do that but it will be on a commercial basis because I can not use the information for my website, you want to keep it private. When I told him my price just to keep it friendly -- I wasn't asking a lot of money -- he ran away and never seen again. I do hear he's still very angry. But if Mul-T-Lock wants a serious test, they can always contact me directly, but not through this Dutch sub-dealer of them. "We opened some impossible locks. By impossible, I mean I opened some locks, and you can see it on the other video, it's available online if you go to the toool.nl website. I opened some locks that I would never open without damaging it ever, because the mechanism is so well designed. There's only one flaw, which is that the part that makes it secure stays the same in all the keys, and only the variation pins change. I'm talking now about the Assa Twin lock. It's a lock with two rows of pins, and the secure row of pins is always the same in a certain region, which makes it very vulnerable for this attack. Talking about the Assa Twin, another reason that I thought I would never be able to open a lock like that is that it was so well engineered, the tolerances are so small, if the pin is half of a millimeter or a tenth of a millimeter too high or two low, the whole lock does not work any more. "This is also something that we found, that the tighter the lock is made, the more engineering is put in to the lock, the better this technique works. If the key that slides in to the lock wiggles too much because the key has got a lot of space in between, the energy transferred is a little bit lost. If the pins in the chamber have a lot of tolerance and are not straight in the house, but a little angled or a little bit left-right, the energy is not transferred ideally. So the more expensive and the more engineering is put in to a lock, we found most of our favorite locks opened within a few blows because they are so well designed that they are perfect impact energy transmitters that allow smooth transmission of this energy."[1] That said, since the technique of bumping made a big splash in the mainstream media, lock manufacturers have experimented with and released locks with "anti-bump" features. Those locks might not be as susceptible as the locks that were the subject of Wels' talk. On the other hand, there are and will continue to be plenty of locks in use that don't have any anti-bump features at all. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lRv_JN5oedE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lRv_JN5oedE
- bbcbasic 10y agoFree hotel accommodation, for one.
- ransom1538 10y agoI came to work early once and forgot my keys. I decided to just sit on the ground and go through commits [pathetic]. A newer dev, recently hired came by next. I explained the situation. He then grabbed a weird small set of tools out of his bag. After about 3 minutes he opened the door. I was totally horrified. I am not sure if i was more upset he had the tools on him, the tools WERE LEGAL, or how easy it was to steal all our cool hipster monitors. He went on to explain how he couldn't get into various types of locks and which locks he was training on -- like some type of club or sport.
- trome 10y agoWhy should a toolkit be illegal, and why should you not carry your tools with you? Picking a lock is usually the slowest way in, if you are trying to increase security, paying a premium for a better lock while retaining windows and unreinforced walls is a poor decision.
- ransom1538 10y agoLock picking sets should be legal. It was me NOT KNOWING.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoGiven all the FUD around picks in the US, I like to refer people to the toool page, they've done a great job of distilling down what's legal and where. http://toool.us/laws.html http://toool.us/laws.html
- gambiting 10y agoIn the UK posession of a lockpicking kit in public is very much illegal, unless you have a professional reason to carry one. Same with a knife - unless you are literally bringing one back from the store to your home, you can be arrested for having one.
- jnicholasp 10y ago
- wonderous 10y agoFavorite lock currently is the Bowley. Demo animation: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jgekjfwphGc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jgekjfwphGc Here's great analysis of the lock with an attempt to pick it and an breakdown of the design after taking it apart: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=b96pmWSArr4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=b96pmWSArr4 ---- EDIT: In case you want buy a Bowley Lock, they're now available for sale to the public here: http://www.bowleylockcompany.com/store/c1/Featured_Products.html http://www.bowleylockcompany.com/store/c1/Featured_Products....
- falcolas 10y agoI keep seeing mention of how great this lock is, but all mentions go back to this same couple of videos. Makes me really suspicious of astroturfing, frankly. IIRC, also wondered how this particular design prevents against bumping; none of its protections really seem aimed at that usecase. Not to mention the relative frailty of the key, and the general problem of an easily visible (and thus reproducible) secret.
- thinkloop 10y agoThe second video spends most of it's time trying to bump and shows how the key is extremely strong even though it looks frail.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wonderous 10y agoThink if you believe you're able to pick it, then buy one, pick it, post the video to YouTube with ADs enabled - and you'll easily make back the cost of buying the lock. As for bumping and the key strength, given those topics are covered in the second video, you're comment to me at best feels naive. Lastly, no system is prefect. Even if the metal the lock is made of was unbreakable and as a result you could 't destroy the lock to bypass it, you could still build a robot that inserts a metal key to turn the lock and dynamically assembles and inserts every possible bidding for each pin. Feel free to post a lock you like, locks to me are more about simplicity vs security - not some overly complex system will never be used in mass production.
- amelius 10y agoSo do any automated lock picking devices exist?
- wonderous 10y agoAll automation requires some action. Bump keys are a simple "automated" way to pick a lock: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lock_bumping https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lock_bumping If you feel like tapping a bump key with a hammer is to much effort, you could attach the bump key to a vibrating toothbrush; aka a "SonicBump": https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rDlZbQ20aLI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rDlZbQ20aLI
- jonesetc 10y agoWell, there are things like snapguns and lock bumping, which don't work like normal lock picking, but serve the same purpose.
- huxleypig 10y agoYes. More and more all the time too.
- ceautery 10y agoI never learned "real" lockpicking, but I'm puzzled at how trivial it is to bypass some lock systems. For instance, the Kensington laptop lock, which was purchased in bulk for all the laptops of a large utility I worked for some years back. I once misplaced my key, and managed to pick the lock with a small strip of plastic used to bind boxes of printer paper. The longest part of the endeavor was finding a pair of scissors to cut the plastic to the right size. The lock/cable in question retails for about $40. Assuming we paid half that, we still dumped thousands of dollars on presenting only an image of security.
- AtheistOfFail 10y agoThose things aren't designed for the dedicated guy who can pick it, they're designed for someone who breaks in and just grabs laptops as they go.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoThis expands to the general case purpose of locks. They're not to guarantee security, but rather to raise the threshold. Much like DRM, they're all about preventing easy mass theft.
- arkades 10y agoI think his point is: it takes little skill (because I figured out how to do it on the fly) and little equipment (ziptie). Implicitly: anyone with any interest in grabbing laptops could spend 5 minutes on youtube and 5 minutes prepping a ziptie, and maybe 20 minutes practicing, and be as capable of walking around grabbing laptops as he was before the security locks were purchased.
- ohyes 10y agoAnd you'd just use some wire cutters for that.
- ghaff 10y agoI don't know how useful they are in a typical restricted access company environment. They make more sense at places like tradeshows where they may not stop a serious thief but probably are good enough to deter sticky fingers while someone's back is turned.
- thenewwazoo 10y agoGiven the tenor of this response and the fact that you're a green account, I can't say you've done anything but increase my suspicion of astroturfing. At the very least, combative comments like yours don't improve the discourse here.
- dang 10y agoWe appreciate your concern for quality of discussion on HN, but accusing other users of astroturfing without evidence is not allowed. You're welcome to send concerns to hn@ycombinator.com if you want us to investigate, but not to bring this up in the threads. It poisons the discourse and that cost exceeds any benefit by a long shot. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14017364 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14017364 and marked it off-topic.
- Veratyr 10y agoFor anyone interested in this, I recommend the Bosnian Bill YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/bosnianbill https://www.youtube.com/user/bosnianbill He picks a ton of locks and has a few recommendation videos if you're looking to buy.