5 ms·
Rather than handwringing over what meat it is OK to eat, just don't eat meat.
by paulcole 10y ago
Rather than handwringing over what meat it is OK to eat, just don't eat meat.
- dawnerd 10y agoWhat's wrong with refusing to eat one type of meat? I don't eat fish for the same reasons.
- alsetmusic 10y agoI'm not taking a side here. I eat all meats. That said, Jews had a lower susception to plague because they avoided pork. Of course, this was inferred as evidence that they caused plague.
- ori_b 10y agoFrom what I'm aware, that was largely attributed to regular bathing in the mikveh (ritual bath), rather than diet.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoThat undoubtedly had something to do it, but it's also a fact that pigs, in particular, are prone to many diseases that can be transmitted to humans (there are some with cows too, of course, but not nearly as many). Same thing with shellfish (also forbidden by Kosher rules). Not only do they tend to collect nasty bugs from any human sewage in the water, but they have some truly scary toxins in their own right. None of those are an issue with modern farming and aquaculture, though. What probably happened was that a whole village got wiped out with (say) Paralytic Shellfish Poisoning, and the priest from the next village decided that God really, really didn't want people eating oysters any more.
- houst0n_ 10y agoDiversity is good, seems our digestions evolved with the ability and perhaps even requirement to eat a lot of different things.. Mix it up a bit? Venison is a far superior meat to beef in my book however Ive never tried panda or zebra but I would. Why don't you eat fish? I can't work it out :)
- dualogy 10y agoRather than handwringing over what meat it is OK to eat, just eat meat, emphasizing fresh over processed. Done.
- Dylan16807 10y agoRather than handwringing over what water-living foods it is OK to eat, just don't eat water-living foods. No fish, no rice, no cranberries. Fish is very different from something like mammal meat. They shouldn't be lumped together when talking about major nutritional tradeoffs.
- ajross 10y agoFish is a whole lot closer to "mammal meat" than grasses are, and only a little farther away than "dinosaur meat", which we eat an awful lot of too. We routinely lump these things all together in the nutritional hopscotch grids or ziggurats or whatever is en vogue. Basically I don't see what you're getting at. Fish is food. It can be analyzed as such.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThey're similar in terms of protein percent. Not in terms of mislabeling and storage and plastic feed and mercury. > Fish is food. At a high enough level they are both foods. But I'm talking about a lower level, where you are choosing between types of food. When looking at the types of concerns the article has, there is no justification at all for lumping all meats and only meats together.
- paulddraper 10y agoMeat has all essential amino acids, has Vitamin B12, can be minimally processed, is the only food source of creatine. Plus, we've been omnivores for millions of years. The empirical health benefits of vegetarianism vanish once you control for health-consciousness. Trying to paint some bleak health picture on all meats is plain FUD.
- mrob 10y agoAll the health benefits of meat can be obtained from eating salt-water mussels. Their sensory and motor abilities are extremely similar to that of plants, and they can be farmed on ropes with no environmental damage. This isn't true of bivalves in general (eg. scallops have primitive eyes and can swim). https://sentientist.org/2013/05/20/the-ethical-case-for-eating-oysters-and-mussels/ https://sentientist.org/2013/05/20/the-ethical-case-for-eati...
- paulddraper 10y agoInteresting. And to clarity my earlier statement, there are plausible reasons to not eat meat: animal suffering, cost, environmental impact. Avoiding absolutely all meat on the basis of health reasons (the original context of the discussion) is bogus.
- fredsir 10y agoWhy do you figure that since it's established that it's less healthy than the alternatives?
- matt4077 10y agoIt's really not that clear. Vegetarians live longer, but that probably means we should all live like them, not eat like them: they tend to smoke less, get more exercise, and (because they tend to be better educated and wealthier) have better healthcare and even social lives. Smoking is pretty easy to correct for, but then these vegetarians all run off, work in soup kitchens, and get flooded with endorphins from the joy of altruism, and physical exertion. Try measuring that! If I had to summarise what I remember from when I studied something related, I'd say your best bet is to eat (a) small amounts of (b) mostly white meat. (a) is pretty obvious: a bit of meat on occasion is enough to ward off any possible malnutrition. If you don't go fully vegan the risk isn't high, but neither is any negative effect the meat may have. (b) is probably more controversial, but contrary to what a certain crowd has been hyping, it seems like the evidence against red meat is still ahead. More in regards to cancer, a little less for cardiovascular diseases. The mechanisms aren't clear: Harald zur Hausen (Nobel for HPV) thinks it's viruses from undercooked red meat and only eats it well-done. Cholesterol is more of a symptom than a cause...etc.