15 ms·
Cancer Isn’t a Logic Problem
- esahione 10y agoErm. This is a terrible argument. The universe is logical. Each cell in the human body is at its core just a very complex state machine. What we call cancer is just a particular state for a cell, and its descendents. Find a way to change the cell state, we end cancer. And we know we can change a cell state-we can transform skin cells into stem cells, so what would make it impossible to turn cancerous cells into non-cancerous cells? We just haven't found out the proper way to do so. It takes data, and simulation, and lots of time. At some point we'll figure it out. I think the only misguided attempts are chemotherapy-based - damaging cells indiscriminately, just because cancer cells multiply faster and thus accumulate dna damage faster and thus die faster than normal cells. This means that unless you kill all the cancerous cells your cancer will come back. The problem is chemotherapy drugs will also be damaging your body in other ways, depressing your immune system, and thus making it easier for any remaining cancerous cell to start it all over again. I believe it's much easier to simply figure out the right cocktail that would change cancerous cells into normal cells again, and then find the delivery mechanism for that. I can see a future where we can transform cancerous cells into cancer-killing cells (let's say T/B Cells) that would just cascade into the complete eradication of cancerous cells within an organism. This guy's argument boils down to lack of imagination.
- hprotagonist 10y agoEver done any wet lab research?
- Palomides 10y agocancer isn't a particular state, except in the vaguest sense of 'continually multiplying, but like, in a bad way'. any person's cancer is millions/billions of semi-independent, extremely complicated, poorly understood state machines, with a variety of mutations, constantly interacting and evolving against any treatments applied and immune reactions. imho, cancer is a fundamental disease/property of multicellular life, and trivial reductionist perspectives completely out of touch.
- abecedarius 10y agoIn principle it shouldn't matter that cancer is not well defined, if health is well defined. "Just" visit every single cell and repair its gene sequence to your body's consensus sequence, and similarly for the epigenetic state to the extent necessary -- the latter requires more knowledge to do correctly, but otoh seems less crucial. This is of course ridiculously ambitious compared to the current state of the art, but I think it's a reasonable start to countering the claim that a general cure for cancer is impossible in principle.
- Palomides 10y agoA cell /is/ epigenetic state, and the effect of any piece of DNA is profoundly controlled by other pieces of DNA, RNA, proteins, RNAs interacting with RNAs, RNAs interacting with proteins, proteins interacting with proteins, etc. Scrubbing the proteins, RNA, and so forth from a cell without killing it is inconceivable. That said, I don't want to say that cancer is fundamentally beyond us. I think cheap sequencing and emerging highly targeted DNA editing systems, along with better understanding of the immune response to cancer, will get us most of the way there in a practical sense.
- abecedarius 10y agoRepairs of all these things are performed by the cell itself without killing itself, so they're surely physically possible. But they're limited by a lack of outside information -- e.g. if the DNA is too corrupt, the repair processes can't check the uncorrupted DNA of other cells. That could be fixed with advanced enough technology.
- Palomides 10y agokilling the cell is actually not a big deal, any given cell is generally replaceable. What you suggest is more or less what I mention; you could, say, try to add back some genetic machinery for the cancer cells to recognize that they're defective, and then they kill themselves. Or help the higher level repair mechanism (the immune system) target cancer cells. To my understanding, trying to fix anything at the level between whole cell and DNA mutation is much harder.
- idlewords 10y agoYou just solved cancer from first principles on a message board. Congratulations!
- maxerickson 10y agoWhy is it misguided to do things that are known to be effective? I think for people with cancer right now, waiting for magic would be a lot more misguided than chemotherapy.
- tyingq 10y agoHe does spell out why he doesn't subscribe to that approach: "Cancer cells are not simply a disorder or breakdown in a mechanism, but an organism going on a full-tilt offensive, using multiple, often shifting strategies to produce and use molecular fuel, win resources, and evade the immune system. If so, then the rules of the game may change—these insights suggest that the war on cancer may be endless." I don't have any expertise here, so I'm not saying he's right or wrong. But it doesn't seem to be a lack of imagination.
- atomicthumbs 10y agothank you for warning me in advance about your terrible argument
- nabla9 10y agoI don't think you understood his cancer is ecologic, not systemic argument correctly.
- goatlover 10y ago>> The universe is logical. Each cell in the human body is at its core just a very complex state machine. So the universe is just math, basically? Or maybe a computer program?
- ue_ 10y ago>The universe is logical. How so? >at its core just a very complex state machine Why do you say that?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- prashnts 10y agoChaotic, unpredictable behaviours can emerge when simpler, predictable elements are brought together. A double pendulum is a good example of this. Agreed that we don't yet know how to regulate the apoptosis, or understand how metastasis works. DNA Methylation, small RNA regulation, and purpose of non-coding RNA isn't very well understood yet, too. > I believe it's much easier to simply figure out the right cocktail that would change cancerous cells into normal cells again, and then find the delivery mechanism for that. I reckon much of this has to do with small RNA and miRNA based regulation of transcription. Essentially the specific portions of the RNA/DNA are "silenced" by several regulatory factors. If a growth regulator gene, say CDKNA is accidentally silenced then the cell would undergo an uncontrolled growth, _with_ mutations. This in turn will grow "diseased" cells, eventually causing cancer. Trouble is, we just do not understand this properly, yet.
- obstinate 10y agoDouble and triple pendulums have been solved: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyN-CRNrb3E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyN-CRNrb3E I have little doubt cancer will be someday as well. It might not -- probably won't -- happen in my lifetime. But if humanity hasn't collapsed, I find it very unlikely that we're still dealing with cancer in a thousand years.
- mrestko 10y agoThe author does not lack imagination. You may, however, lack knowledge of biology. What you're boiling down to a "cell state" represents dysregulation of the most complex object in the known universe. A single human cell is vastly more complicated than anything made by mankind.
- JabavuAdams 10y agoI agree with your point, but am always a bit put off by these "most complex ... in the known universe." It's something that people say that doesn't really hold up to cursory scrutiny. E.g. we think of stars as big balls of fusing matter. But that's an idealisation. Is a star really less complex than a human body? It all depends on which questions we want to answer. So there's an asymmetry in this argument. Take a thing that we're trying to understand down to the finest detail, and compare it to a caricature of some other thing that we're not trying to understand at such a fine resolution.
- dwaltrip 10y agoA common measure of complexity is the amount of information required to fully describe or recreate some system. If you simply gather a very large number of hydrogen atoms into a region of space at a certain density, you will create star. From this angle, it isn't terribly complex. The instructions for creating a cell from scratch are... immensely more complicated. The star's behavior, .e.g. the movement and changes of the convection zones, fusion dynamics, how the magnetic fields change over time, coronal mass ejections, sunspots, etc. may be extremely complex. I think few people who know much about stars would disagree on that. But I would wager there are many more orders of magnitude of complexity going on in a human cell, from an information theory perspective. Even just describing individual proteins themselves and how they fold is phenomenally difficult. Of course, I may be wrong about the cell's behavior having higher complexity. The important take away is that it is possible to make such comparisons in a meaningful way.
- JabavuAdams 10y agoGood points, but there's still something missing in the comparison. It's the difference between the initial information content, and the dynamics. Suppose we had to fix some problem in a star such that we need to precisely manipulate the magnetic fields, and perhaps things at a quantum scale. At that point, we are concerned with the fine-scale configuration of that particular star. Your proposed star creation algorithm only gives an ensemble over all stars of that particular mass and initial composition. It has less information content, because it doesn't create a particular star. I.e. we are willing to accept a huge class of individuals that we call "stars". So, we're back to comparing thing A that we need to understand at the finest scale, to thing B where we ignore its individual complexity in favour of the stereotypical version. It's easy to estimate the gravitational attraction or mass of a cell. It's this fine-scale manipulation that causes these severe requirements for deep understanding. EDIT> :) The instructions for creating life are even simpler. 1) Have a Big Bang. 2) Wait.
- mannykannot 10y agoI suppose that by 'just', you mean 'can be reduced to', but 'just' also implies there is not much to it, which is definitely not the case here. More concretely, the combinatorial complexity of the state-machine approach makes it infeasible.
- hprotagonist 10y ago>The universe is logical. Each cell in the human body is at its core just a very complex state machine. Even if determinism holds (and, spoiler alert from about 1927, it doesn't), you can't avoid chaos. Lorenz found that out and defined Chaos: where the present determines the future, but the approximate present does not approximately determine the future. I assure you, biological systems exhibit all the hallmarks of (possibly) deterministic mathematical chaos.
- greenhatman 10y agoEverything is a logic problem.
- goatlover 10y agoThen there is no need for science. The Greeks should had this figured out millennia ago.
- dwaltrip 10y agoIs science not a logical endeavor?
- goatlover 10y agoScience an empirical endeavor. The world determines what is, not logic, or math. Logic and math are great tools for making sense of observations, but they do not determine what will be observed. Otherwise, there would have been no need to carry out experiments. People, armed with only logic, could have deduced any truths about the world from their arm chairs. Some, like Aristotle, did try to do that. To be fair, it was a mix of observation and first principles, but it was lacking adequate experimentation, as humans later found out.
- dwaltrip 10y ago> People, armed with only logic, could have deduced any truths about the world from their arm chairs. Fair enough. I'm probably giving too much of my own spin to the word "logic". I'm thinking of logic as being somewhat grounded in empirical observations. I agree that armchair logic completely removed from reality is of questionable value. At this stage of my understanding, I would argue that our notion of logic and math largely stems from us creating models about the world that lead to abstract deductions, which often are eventually used in new models about the world... and so on. This cycle probably got started as early humans acquired better mental models for categorizing objects of different types and their apparent boundaries, and then began to "count" like entities. If math wasn't useful for describing the world, I doubt we would have done much with it.
- hprotagonist 10y agoThis is a special case of the "Andy Grove Fallacy": http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2007/11/06/andy_grove_rich_famous_smart_and_wrong http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2007/11/06/and... > Andy Grove has had prostate cancer, and now suffers from Parkinson’s, so it’s no wonder that he’s taken aback at how poorly we understand each of those diseases – not to mention all the rest of them. But his experience in the technology world has warped his worldview. We are not suffering from a lack of urgency over here – talk to anyone who’s working for a small company shoveling its cash into the furnace quarter by quarter, or for a large one watching its most lucrative patents inexorably melt away. And we don’t suffer from a lack of hard-charging modern management techniques, that’s for sure. What we suffer from is working on some of the hardest scientific problems in the history of the species.
- kumarski 10y agoI love Derek Lowe's writing.
- nabla9 10y agoGene Regulatory Network resembles (stochastic) recurrent neural network and is sometimes modeled as such. Each cell has it's own GRN and then there is signaling between the cells. Its understandably very hard problem to nudge network states back to the normal or to kill itself once it's gone haywire and causes other networks go haywire too. The "error state" cells are changing and those who survive the last nudge continue to reproduce. If I understand Kozubek's argument correctly, cancer is ecologic, not systemic because of this evolution of cancer cell populations. If the cancer is ecologic problem, solving cancer means that it's not enough to figure out cell's state and fix it. You must figure out how the cancer cell ecology works and find a way to drive it into extinction without survivals. Just setting more mousetraps is not working solution if the mouse population is evolving hour by hour and branching.
- dwaltrip 10y agoThis doesn't mean the problem can't be solved by "logic". If true, then research groups that are operating within such misguided frameworks will need to update their understanding of how cancer works. I think a common trope is to point out some system that humans are currently unable to model in a robust or effective manner, and then throw up one's hands and declare "science and logic can't be used to solve this problem!" The current lack of an effective model for some system in no way implies that one will not eventually be found. To be fair, this article isn't quite doing that, and makes some very important points. I only bring this up as it is a misleading line of argument to watch out for that I run into from time to time, and a few lines in the article were slightly reminiscent of such reasoning. Ecology is a scientific endeavor, and perhaps it will prove to be a more powerful paradigm for looking at a cancer. I hope we can make the most of any tools at our disposal to significantly reduce the harm caused by cancer.
- nabla9 10y ago>This doesn't mean the problem can't be solved by "logic". That's not what the author was saying. It's useless to judge articles based on their title or headline because they are either selected by editor or there are multiple titles and A/B testing is used to find one that gets most clicks. It seems that most comments are just comments based on the headline.
- xherberta 10y agoThe author's last word: we need to consider that the system of cancer goes far beyond the biochemistry of cancer cells. Cancer relates to our fundamental constitution as multicellular organisms, our limited lifespan, the epidemiology of the aging population, socioeconomics and the future of society. Those who believe that the problem of cancer can be solved by killing or reprogramming cancer cells need to take a step back from the molecular technicalities and take a look at the bigger picture.
- jessriedel 10y agoHow cancer fits into the evolutionary context is obviously important to understand, but the author's conclusion is unfounded. Cancer rates in the ancestral environment is set by a balance between costs and benefits of anti-cancer mechanism. But we are not in the ancestral environment, and there's no a priori reason (Darwinian, thermodynamic, or otherwise) to think that cancer rates couldn't be driven down to negligible rates given our much greater resources.
- glbrew 10y agoI strongly disagree with this essay.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kumarski 10y agoThere’s ~ 15K-20K diseases that we’ve classified. There’s 3.2Bn genetic base pairs. There’s just over 7Bn people. Maybe like 7M-20M people suffer from a disease or even well below or above that. Finding someone at a given time in the exact modality that would be testable by a given trial is really hard. Genes are sets of base pairs. A lot of drug discovery is a situation where you have to test compounds empirically against a notion of a theory of a viable drug target. Some drugs may be efficacious, but they may kill you. Some genes may work in coalition with other genes, not at all, or against some genes. There's also the fundamental notion about the druggability of a disease. This article does a great job in outlining it: http://omicsomics.blogspot.com/2017/03/targets-drugability-revisited.html http://omicsomics.blogspot.com/2017/03/targets-drugability-r... There are no monstrously hard computational power problems in drug development that are waiting for mathematical brains to pursue. There are hard Empirical problems. Empirical problems are problems which require actual experiments to show resultant data.
- letitgo12345 10y ago> There are no monstrously hard computational power problems in drug development that are waiting for mathematical brains to pursue Not sure if I would put it that way. For ex, in principle, you could use molecular dynamics and search to find protein sequences that form other proteins/antibodies that can hit targets you want or operate in a more complex fashion. So hard computational power can most definitely help out (and depending on level of advance, help out a great deal). Ofc that doesn't mean you don't need experiments at all.
- bobdole1234 10y agoOnce you build a system that builds treatments for specific problems, you treat the problem and repeat as they come up. Not dying of the first cancer is better than dying of the first. Just because there are N cancers in the series doesn't mean the problem is impossible, it just means we haven't ever gotten past the first levels to figure out how it works. The secret to winning pacman isn't 256 separate strategies, it's a small set of strategies that fit together once you know how the game changes level to level. The author is just fixated on the fact they finished the first level AND THE WAS ANOTHER!
- reasonattlm 10y agoCancer, like aging, is an example where much of the research community is undertaking very challenging and expensive work with marginal expectation value because that dovetails well with the types of fundamental research that can be funded, not because of any expectation that it is the best approach with the highest expectation value. This is an age of genetics, genetics is popular, and so people are getting funded for personalized medicine and ever more intricate mapping of cellular biology. But there are hundreds of types of cancer, and taking the genetics/drug discovery approach for each of them is its own distinct and massively expensive undertaking. It'll never get done: the research community and its funding sources are not large enough to make significant progress on the whole of the problem in the next few decades. This isn't hacking cancer, this is hacking the cancer funding institutions in order to obtain funding to get on with the fundamental life science research goal of mapping all of cellular metabolism. Cancer is the excuse, but not the goal. This is a cultural problem. Hacking cancer would be to sit down and say, ok, the economics of this are not working, we need to find common points to target, a way to produce a universal cancer therapy at no greater expense than one of these single cancer therapies. Some immunotherapies, like CAR-T approaches, are a small step in this direction, something that can be applied to multiple cancers with a lower cost of customization per cancer type. The best target, however, is to block telomere lengthening; disabling both telomerase and alternative lengthening of telomere (ALT) mechanisms. This is a small area of biochemistry in comparison to the scope of most single cancer explorations. All cancers depend on telomerase or ALT or both. All of them. No exceptions. No cancer can evolve its way around a suppression of these mechanisms. It will simply die, losing its ability to replicate uncontrollably. Some noted research groups are making early inroads into disabling telomerase in a targeted way. ALT remains to be dealt with, but is easier to work with than telomerase interdiction by virtue of the fact that ALT doesn't happen in normal cells. A telomere lengthening interdiction treatment would be applicable to all cancers, and it doesn't appear to be more expensive to develop than any other approach to a specific cancer. That is what hacking cancer research looks like; identifying a way to completely change the economics of the situation, and redirect the primary effort back to producing an effective cures as soon as possible. Lastly, I have to fundamentally disagree with the final lines of this article; cancer can absolutely be dealt with robustly by killing cancer cells. You just need to be selective enough, early enough, and comprehensive enough, and raising the bar on these items is the whole point of the field.
- dkarapetyan 10y ago> Cancer relates to our fundamental constitution as multicellular organisms, our limited lifespan, the epidemiology of the aging population, socioeconomics and the future of society. This is the most important part. Life is cancerous. When people claim to cure cancer it's sort of an oxymoron. There are indeed no such things as cancer genes but more like a breakdown in the cooperative biochemical networks that make multi-cellular life possible. It's actually a great wonder how all those cells in your body manage to cooperate at all without stepping on each others' toes all the time. In a way the delicate balance is a constant fight against entropy and entropy always wins. Enough breakdowns and misunderstandings in the biochemical networks and the multi-cellular ecology and you have cancer.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> When people claim to cure cancer it's sort of an oxymoron. There are indeed no such things as cancer genes but more like a breakdown in the cooperative biochemical networks that make multi-cellular life possible. This description fits scurvy fairly precisely. But no one would say it's nonsense to talk about "curing" scurvy. Give someone some vitamin C, and their scurvy will be cured. Would you also say it's an oxymoron to talk about "fixing" software bugs because the terminology assumed they were designed in?
- dkarapetyan 10y agoIf you look at how cells work on the micro-scale it looks a lot like cancer. They constantly divide and try to proliferate by allocating and using resources. The only thing keeping them in check is basically the "cellular honor code". You can certainly try to make it less likely any given set of cells breaks the honor code but you can't "cure" cancer. It's an inherent property of multi-cellular life. Not unlike bee and ant colonies. There is always one queen (or several) but sometimes there will be a rogue queen born that bifurcates the colony. Bees and ants go to great lengths to avoid these situations but the way colonies are set up and structured rogue queens are an unavoidable part of the colony given a long enough timeline. I characterize scurvy as a sub-optimal stable operating state where optimality can be restored. Cancer does not have similar characterization. It's more like an unstable runaway loop. But I'm neither a biologist nor a doctor. My understanding is basically a bunch of analogies between game theory and general systems in the context of biology and maybe that's not the proper set of analogies for the problem at hand. In that context cancer is the breakdown of feedback loops that keep the system stable.
- JabavuAdams 10y agoI think I understand the author's point, but just as people here are making sweeping statements about biology, he seems to have some minor misconceptions about technology. Let's take a step back ... my understanding of what the author's saying is that "solving" cancer is no easier in some sense than "solving" biology. Yes, we have to think of cancer as some kind of adversarial game -- it's not enough to solve a snap-shot of that game. But ... that doesn't mean that we can't have active defences that work for the vast majority of people. It's just that maybe we need to know how to build people from molecules, first. I think we'll solve biology in the sense of being able to engineer life from first-principles. I make no predictions on time-frame.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- elihu 10y agoI'm not sure what the point of this essay is supposed to be. Should we ignore promising avenues of cancer treatment research just because they won't work in all cases or for all cancers, or because the person cured is just going to die of something else later?
- dmritard96 10y agoMy understanding of this argument is that because of cancers many and possibly infinite forms there is no 'cure for cancer'. While I can appreciate the mathematical correctness of this point (sure did take a long article to get this across), it seems largely to miss the point. If cancer rates become low enough that they only kick in at 120 and that people begin dying of other things, whether a small group of people continue to die of cancer vs the rates today is effectively curing cancer, even if its not entirely complete. Another example of why this sort of thinking is missing the bigger picture - many people today die not because we don't know how to treat something, but instead because they can't afford the treatment.
- Ericson2314 10y agoThis is a fine argument articulated quite poorly. A) cancer cells constitute a separate species, or at least evolutionary "actor". B) the tech naivity is not that things can't be deeply understood, but that it's a moving target, and less than complete erradication of the parasite just increases evolutionary pressure leading to decreased understanding of the foe.
- Eric_WVGG 10y agothis bit from PhD Comics, on the same topic, is a classic http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1162 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1162