4 ms·
> None of these publications ever run with a solution to the problem. How about increased funding for employee retraining programs? I could see high ROI from th
by bsder 10y ago
> None of these publications ever run with a solution to the problem. How about increased funding for employee retraining programs? I could see high ROI from that.
This is a good thing, and I agree with it. But, you are assuming an axiom that is breaking down:
There are enough jobs for everyone at a wage capable of supporting a family.
That is no longer true.
Watching the current kerfuffle in the Central Valley of California has been constructive. "We can't get people to do back breaking labor at $12 an hour now that they got rid of the illegal immigrants! WAH!" Well, at $12 an hour, which is below the official poverty level for a family of four, you are probably better to work at a fast food restaurant which is less work and not seasonal. So, nobody will work those farms.
Funny how shortage always seems to go hand in hand with below average pay. Funny how if the wage rises enough, there isn't any shortage anymore.
I guarantee that $20 an hour will find people to pick those fields.
> they shift the vitriol from foreigners who took our jobs to machines who took our jobs.
Your rhetoric is exactly the same as 100 years ago. I prescribe a trip to the Johnstown Heritage Center:
http://www.jaha.org/attractions/heritage-discovery-center/ http://www.jaha.org/attractions/heritage-discovery-center/
http://www.jaha.org/attractions/heritage-discovery-center/hdc-features/america-through-immigrant-eyes/ http://www.jaha.org/attractions/heritage-discovery-center/hd...
The real problem is that the gains from automation have flowed to a very small number of people. If we don't figure out how to reverse that, we're going to be in very big trouble.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoThe real problem is that the gains from automation have flowed to a very small number of people. If we don't figure out how to reverse that, we're going to be in very big trouble. On the other hand, if we survive the worst effects, the world might come closer to a post-scarcity society. Once we escape the notion that working is necessary to be a member of what is now called working-class society, we'll be better off. Those who want to live on little can live on little. Those who want more can learn a trade to get more. And those who have the most will support those who have nothing, because the alternative is worse.
- Neliquat 10y agoAt current population growth, 'post-scarcity' will never come.
- giggles_giggles 10y agoEven if it does come, there's no sense in designing policy as though it's here or will definitely be here soon. In the modern day it's a utopian pipe dream and history is replete with societies taken from bad or okay to positively dystopic via utopian thinking.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoThe difference is that this time, there is no alternative. We'll be dragged there, kicking and screaming. Normally, it's easy to dismiss statements that are all-or-nothing propositions. Usually the person making the statement lacks imagination. Isn't there some alternative? Unfortunately, there seems to be a >90% likelihood that the answer in this case is no: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU Once you accept that there is no choice other than giving people money to survive, the focus can shift to accomplishing that goal rather than dwelling on whether it might lead to economic collapse. http://blog.samaltman.com/technology-and-wealth-inequality http://blog.samaltman.com/technology-and-wealth-inequality > However, if we cannot find a new kind of work for billions of people, we’ll be faced with a new idle class. The obvious conclusion is that the government will just have to give these people money, and there’s been increasing talk about a “basic income”—i.e, any adult who wanted it could have, say, $15,000 a year. > You can run the numbers in a way that sort of makes sense—if we did this for every adult in the US, it’d be about $3.5 trillion a year, or a little more than 20% of our GDP. However, we’d knock out a lot of existing entitlement spending, maybe 10% of GDP. And we’d probably phase it out for people making over a certain threshold, which could cut it substantially.
- eru 10y ago> The real problem is that the gains from automation have flowed to a very small number of people. [...] What makes you say so? Consumer surplus has been enormous, hasn't it?