13 ms·
I've really turned on Wikileaks. Itd be one thing if all the major powers had equivalent leaks publishing, but focusing on the US basically serves Chinese and R
by azinman2 10y ago
I've really turned on Wikileaks. Itd be one thing if all the major powers had equivalent leaks publishing, but focusing on the US basically serves Chinese and Russian interests far more than it does the citizens of the US. String obfuscation isn't stemming from some corrupt deal that needs sunlight... this is just doing a disservice to their original mission.
- tehlike 10y agohonest question: does wikileaks not have necessary connections in China to collect the intel and stuff?
- cavanasm 10y agoWikileaks doesn't collect intel whatsoever. They pretty much put up anything sent to them that they think is real (and that admittedly fits whatever editorial narrative is driving Assange at the moment). No one at Wikileaks is doing the hacks, or infiltrating government organizations.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> They pretty much put up anything sent to them that they think is real. Maybe, maybe not. How would we know they do that?
- jlft 10y agoIf someone sends real leaks to Wikileaks and they don't publish, then the leakers can use alternative channels to distribute the leaks (for example, sending directly to journalists), and then accuse Wikileaks of not publishing. Has anyone already accused Wikileaks of not publishing real leaks?
- ceejayoz 10y agoYes, they've been accused of that. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/01/world/europe/wikileaks-julian-assange-russia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/01/world/europe/wikileaks-ju... > WikiLeaks, he told a Moscow newspaper, had obtained compromising materials “about Russia, about your government and your businessmen.” > Mr. Assange, asked soon after by Time magazine whether he still planned to expose the secret dealings of the Kremlin, reiterated his earlier vow. “Yes indeed,” he said. > But that promised assault would not materialize. Instead, with Mr. Assange’s legal troubles mounting, Mr. Putin would come to his defense. There's also the fun time they came out against leaks that hurt Trump on the baffling assertion that Trump deserved to get to read them before release: https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/817322050297745408 https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/817322050297745408 > The Obama admin/CIA is illegally funneling TOP SECRET//COMINT information to NBC for political reasons before PEOTUS even gets to read it. Odd stance for the organization to take.
- FireBeyond 10y agoFor added irony, at the time the Pres. Elect was "bragging" about how he didn't feel the need to even read such intelligence, as he was "smart enough to know what was going on" and got other information from the "shows he watched".
- tedunangst 10y agoOne accusation: http://www.cnbc.com/id/42762811 http://www.cnbc.com/id/42762811
- stevenwoo 10y agoAssange had an AMA on reddit, and he said they received Trump intel pre election and judged it was not worthy of releasing compared to the Clinton data dump.
- sleepybrett 10y agoThat's a lot of editorial bias for an organization that's goals, at least initially, revolved around transparency.
- self-diversity 10y agoWhenever this comes up, I like to ask what people would expect could be revealed about Trump that would materially change anything. The Clinton campaign raked him over the coals to the point that deluded people now think wearing a vagina-shaped hat is some manner of effective protest. It seems pretty likely that any leaks about Trump would be boring in comparison to how he appears in the public eye in the first place.
- mmcwilliams 10y agoI see the claim that "no one at Wikileaks performs any kind of attacks" said quite often, but it seems to go against the account of Assange made by his ghostwriter, Andrew O'Hagan, who claims that much of what Assange does or did was hacking and then rejecting credit[0]. It's often lead me to the belief that Wikileaks was formed as a way for him to launder the goods of his infiltrations. Take that along with Assange's history of arrest in the 90's[1], I find it hard to take at face value that he just stopped hacking systems. The relevant section of the essay: > One of the things Julian found it hardest to admit to was the amount of hacking he did himself. He had worked out that being an ‘editor’ was somehow a necessary front for much that he did. He objected to the idea that WikiLeaks ‘stole’ secrets: according to him they simply understood, at a deeply sophisticated level, how the flow of information in society could be altered. [0] https://www.lrb.co.uk/v36/n05/andrew-ohagan/ghosting https://www.lrb.co.uk/v36/n05/andrew-ohagan/ghosting [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_Assange#Hacking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_Assange#Hacking
- tehlike 10y agoSorry, i meant gather cables, leaks etc. That is what i meant by intel.
- devy 10y agoMy guess is that those leakers would prefer leaking to CIA and get a good deal (monetary or protection) than leaking to WikiLeaks for free.
- contingencies 10y agoHonest answer AFAIK: I met Julian back in 1997 in Australia at the security conference that launched his and Suelette Dreyfus' book about the history of the Melbourne hacker scene, Underground. I met him again at HAR2009 in the Netherlands. He was very interested in the fact that I had been living in China for nearly 10 years and confided that he was really surprised after Wikileaks launched not to have received Chinese materials. I hope to meet him again as a free man... or the next time I'm in London. In my opinion he's a fantastic person, an internationalist and a pragmatist who shares knowledge and resources, has truly excelled in multiple fields and genuinely embodies the triple ideals of curiosity, intelligence and social concern. The world needs more Julians, but I think he would agree it would be better if an organization like Wikileaks wasn't required to keep the bastards honest. Shame on those working in defense and surveillance industries. PS. Everyone here should play the 4 hour game Orwell which does a great job of communicating the social ethics at play in surveillance abuse of technology: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13549725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13549725
- teddyh 10y agohttp://www.surpriseattackgames.com/portfolio-items/orwell/ http://www.surpriseattackgames.com/portfolio-items/orwell/
- salesguy222 10y agoyou either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villian...
- matt4077 10y agoTrue. Or, you know, you spend a decade hiding in some embassy indulging your prosecution complex and thinking up elaborate revenge scenarios for everyone who ever dared to question your genius.
- elif 10y agoThe truth isn't responsible for serving anyone's interests, and especially not the interests of the biggest secret keeper. The truth is not political, except that it is the natural enemy of politics which rely upon secrecy. If your perspective is that more secrets are being kept by more egregious actors than the US, the truth welcomes your contribution...
- azinman2 10y agoWhy shouldn't there be secrets?
- elif 10y agoThere should be secrets. there should not be secret attacks on every computer on the planet.
- azinman2 10y agoI dont think there are, but who can say. But you realize the US isn't the only one hacking systems, right?
- chronicx0 10y agoOnce people find out their beloved Sweeden and Norway are also doing it, they will start scratching their heads.
- externalities88 10y agoSo you're being uptight about getting sources from others. Care to back up the assertion that "secret attacks on every computer on the planet" are literally taking place?
- 01000001 10y agoWhy shouldn't they be told?
- deleted 10y ago
- 794CD01 10y agoIsn't the name supposed to reflect the general wiki concept of "anyone can contribute content"? If more people submit US leaks then that's what their coverage will consist of. It's just like how wikipedia covers obscure comic book characters much more thoroughly than it covers the history of Uzbek domination under the Persians.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt's largely a historical accident now, somewhat like "National Biscuit Co." (Nabisco) or "American Telephone and Telegraph". "WikiLeaks was originally established with a "wiki" communal publication method, which was terminated by May 2010.[34] Original volunteers and founders were once described as a mixture of Asian dissidents, journalists, mathematicians, and start-up company technologists from the United States, Taiwan, Europe, Australia, and South Africa.[35] As of June 2009, the website had more than 1,200 registered volunteers.[35][36][37]" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiLeaks https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiLeaks
- brilliantcode 10y agoI don't think so. I think it will make the US stronger. Sure, they can't do the stuff that got leaked but it's far better to live in a reality where you won't get your organs harvested by the state for offending them.
- convivialdingo 10y agoThe US is easily the biggest target. I would think Wiki's justification is that the US has far more culpability in world affairs than most other countries. They get involved in disputes that most other countries can't touch. In terms of risk, the US has a massive intelligence and political footprint that simply leaks more. The opportunity and impetus to leak are simply greater in all regards. In comparison, China and Russia run much more despotic regimes. They have fewer qualms routing out political opposition, and simply have less open and democratic societies. There is a vastly smaller opportunity due to size as well.
- cortic 10y agoFocusing on the US, serves the US.. But i guess it depends what kind of country you want to live in.
- darkmarmot 10y agoI don't think Australian citizens need to care that much. Also, Chinese and Russian are much higher-hanging fruit if your group primarily speaks English.
- SirensOfTitan 10y agoDoes any evidence exist that suggests Wikileaks is withholding information on China or Russia? If not, I don't see how you could conclude they're 'focusing on the US'. They publish what they receive.
- dredmorbius 10y agoTo what extent are Wikileaks actively soliciting inputs from Russia or China? Why, for example, was the Panama Papers leak (or other major financial disclosure leaks) not handled through Wikileaks? (Edward Snowden's disclosures would be another example, though that did target the US.)
- toufka 10y agoI believe most if not all of thier staff is English-speaking (and not Chinese/Russian-speaking). They'd have to find different staff to work in yhose other languages, or to even inderstand the documents' importance.
- dredmorbius 10y agoHiring staff capable of handling such materials would be another material step Wikileaks could take in addressing its glaring bias problems.
- nebabyte 10y ago> To what extent are Wikileaks actively soliciting inputs from Russia or China? And how would that go, exactly? "Excuse me China/Russia, do you have any secrets you'd like to share? Please upload to us..." Lol. Soliciting spies sounds like a good way to get killed. If you're so eager, you go ahead and do it - but good luck trying to convince others they some 'obligation' to lest you brand them 'partisan'.
- dredmorbius 10y agoHow's this for size? "WikiLeaks offers award for #LabourLeaks "23 September 2016 "Wikileaks offers £20,000 reward for #LabourLeaks with information on how the Labour Party’s top officials have attempted to stop Jeremy Corbyn becoming and staying on as leader. "With our #DNCleaks, Wikileaks exposed how those at the top of the US Democratic Party had worked tirelessly to tilt the scales in favour of Hillary Clinton as she faced off against Bernie Sanders in the race to be the Democrat presidential candidate. Our revelations eventually prompted the resignation of five of the most senior members of the Democratic Party in the aftermath of the Democratic Convention, including DNC Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz...." https://wikileaks.org/WikiLeaks-offers-award-for-LabourLeaks.html https://wikileaks.org/WikiLeaks-offers-award-for-LabourLeaks...
- bingomad123 10y agoI totally support Wikileaks. Both China and Russia are oppressive regimes. They don't pretend to be "land of free" while oppressing their people. USA does! Secondly there is element of "outcome". Exposing US government has clear benefit of keeping people informed and hence help them make better voting decisions. Telling Chinese people that their government is systematically harvesting organs of Tibetian people has no new information or benefit.
- cavanasm 10y agoI'm a young person with other young people friends. One such friend grew up in Shanghai. He had never heard of the Tiananmen Square student protests (and the resulting military intervention) until he came to the US for college and someone asked him about it. Anecdotally, it seems China does a very, very, good job of controlling information through their extensive government controls. Telling Chinese people about something like that would probably surprise them greatly.
- azrazalea 10y agoOnly if you could tell them though. As you said, China is good at controlling information. I think the point is good overall.
- chj 10y agoYour young friend was uninformed but that doesn't mean that most people in China don't know about the incident. You have to get something much further than that.
- nebabyte 10y agoMeanwhile, if you went to China, I doubt anyone there could tell you what your government was keeping from you. That's how good they are at regulating their information, and is precisely the reason why we need Wikileaks. There's plenty that WL doesn't know that you might die never having known, and your great-grandchildren might ever only hear about in history books (and maybe not even then, depending on who the victors are).
- 10y ago
- jgrowl 10y agoYou can't leak what you don't have.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoSo what's the solution? Stop publishing until they've caught up on Russian and Chinese leaks? Why just Russia and China? Should each country get a leak until we get back to the start of the cycle again? Why should Wikileaks care who's interests any leaks serve? They should leak interesting material they are given - that's their purpose.
- dredmorbius 10y agoOne action that's been at least partially effective for combatting clear bias in the past and other contexts has to make clear that you are openly inviting contributions (or applications, involvement, etc.) from previously under-served or unaddressed quarters. A current example would be STEM outreach to underrepresented groups: disadvantaged minorities and women in particular. Housing, employment, and educational opportunity efforts would be other examples that come to mind. Can you point to any active solicitation Wikileaks have made, say, for materials specifically addressing political oppression within Russia or concerning its foreign policy? Sincere question. I'm not, though I've not particularly looked.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoI understand your point. Mine is bias does not matter when it comes to this stuff. As long as the leak is factually accurate (and it seems like Wikileaks mostly jump dump the data they get) I want to know if a government is doing something shady and I don't care whether information is also getting leaked at the same rate about another government. Maybe they're not doing anything shady, or maybe they're just doing a better job with information security. Either way it doesn't take away from the fact I should know the information I can as long as it's factual. As an analogy when the US/UK/other western gov criticises Assad or Kim Jong Un over human rights abuses we don't generally complain that it's unfair because the US/UK also have plenty of human rights abuses under their belt. Yes that's a problem but it doesn't take away from the original complaint which is still valid.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIf Wikileaks tells me the sky is blue, I'd be inclined to believe them. But I'd wonder who wants me to know that, and why. Wikileaks is a spotlight. It shines brightly, and exposes much, but only where it shines. And if I notice that it's shining only in specific places ... well, that's a curious fact in itself. And I absolutely disagree with you that bias doesn't matter. Ultimately it's the only thing that matters. Much as, say, US print and broadcast news was conspicuously silent on matters concerning advertiser interests, or government interests in contexts in which the government had leverage over the press. Wikileaks themselves are no different in that regard, though the business model and relationships are slighly rearranged.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chj 10y agoWell, if you ask rest of the world, they are quite happy to know what's really going on. It would be great that we can see the bottom of things in China or Russia, but that's not up to them. How do you know that WL got something real but didn't release deliberately?
- nebabyte 10y agoAnonymously fulfilling a role doesn't morally obligate them to then do something else in the name of "fairness". What, do you want people to receive spy training and move to russia? In that case - why not do it yourself? If there's a moral obligation there, isn't it yours as much as theirs (if not more, as you're the one who feels it is 'unfair' otherwise)?
- throwaway91111 10y agoIt is in the interests of the American public to understand the actions of the government. Including/especially the CIA. Most people know the CIA; few know someone you also know. They carry more reputation that most government organizations. It's a public service to leak this. Besides, most of what the leak has shown is that there is an economic investment in remote code execution, but nothing that new or unknown.