13 ms·
We believe that employees should come together and clearly define the values and policies they'd like to see their companies uphold. A tech union isn't the perf
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
We believe that employees should come together and clearly define the values and policies they'd like to see their companies uphold. A tech union isn't the perfect metaphor for this, but it's not far off.
If it's going to do anything but be window dressing then it needs to have the teeth of union - so just call it what it is.
I've argued for a while that tech workers need a union, but the chorus on HN and other places is "we're too special for a union." Which is bogus on it's face - otherwise SAG for example wouldn't exist.
If this moves the needle on a union then great, but I'm wary of the source being a pure power move (which all unions are - rightfully). I think whomever leads this needs to be above reproach in every sense as an advocate for the tiny introverted developer.
edit: I should note that the reason SAG worked is because some of the highest profile actors joined in the early days and arranged to collectively bargain for the rest of the group. It will probably work best if you get the top 50 most high profile developers (Eg. Carmack) to join and then advocate for the small guy. Sadly, in reality, a union is only as good as it's most high profile members.
- djsumdog 10y agoIt's interesting because it would need to have the teeth of a union yes, but unlike unions of the past that lobbied for better wages and working conditions, what is being proposed is a union to ensure their company does what the workers feel is morally right for the world (not necessarily their customers, but the greater community of people affected by each companies goals and purposes).
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI understand that's the thrust of the post, but practically those things aren't really that much different if done effectively. You make a good point though and if the intention is that it will result in some kind of engineering code of conduct or Hippocratic oath - then my guess is that it will have too many hurdles. The military code of conduct is immensely difficult to arbitrate and the Hippocratic oath isn't anything without governing boards for certification and licensure. So there needs to be a power structure somewhere that holds the power of the members if it's going to be worthwhile and that would have to be linked to the other tangibles like pay and time. It comes down to how and what is measured. Time and Pay are easy to measure, if your MongoDB is being implemented "morally" or not is much muddier.
- Kalium 10y agoWhat you're describing isn't a union. What you're describing in a professional association that helps protect workers who make ethical decisions that land somewhere awkward. You don't get the power of a union without the self-interest that makes a union.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoWell personally, I feel that what's morally right for the world is that tech workers should get better wages and working conditions, while standing in solidarity with the non-technical employees at tech companies to help them get the same.
- paulddraper 10y agoWe're not special. We're just like the other engineering disciplines.
- sidlls 10y agoNo, this industry is far from being like the other engineering disciplines. It should be like them, but it is still far too immature to be put at that level.
- intrasight 10y agoFor starters, we are not licensed. And I suspect that a non-citizen couldn't get an engineering license.
- cyphar 10y agoIn Australia, non-citizens can get engineering licenses. The process is basically the same as a citizen (just more complicated because of visa requirements, as you would expect).
- lazyasciiart 10y agoWhat? Of course non-citizens can get an engineering license. It can be trickier if your education is from outside the US, but citizenship is not an issue.
- intrasight 10y agoI stand corrected
- sidlls 10y agoLicensing would require settling on actually understanding that software development is an engineering activity and not an extended CS 401/501 project. The industry isn't even mature enough to consider licensing either.
- paulddraper 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- amorphid 10y agoWhat benefits would a strong Tech Workers' union to provide? And what percentage of one's income would be membership dues be?
- alphonsegaston 10y agoFloors for wages, combatting H1-B abuse, fighting against toxic cultures driven by an untouchable management class. In terms of dues, unions are democratic, so you can debate, decide, and vote on what you think is appropriate.
- aanm1988 10y agoReturn to 40 hour work weeks, eliminate unpaid oncall, paid overtime.
- cb21 10y agoSusan Fowler should've had a union to complain to, instead of Uber's hostile HR department.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Susan Fowler should've had a union to complain to, instead of Uber's hostile HR department. As a minority, you can't assume that a union rep is on your side. Especially if the complaint is against someone else at your company who is represented by the same union, if that person is more politically important (within the union) than you are, you're risking a lot - up to and including retaliatory termination of union membership[0] by speaking out. It's your word against theirs, and you're not the one hiring your representative, so you can't be sure that their incentive is to advocate your case to the bitter end, instead of to brush things under the rug. If you want someone who has no conflict of interest to advocate your case, you need a lawyer, not HR or a union representative. At best, the latter will refer you to a lawyer (at which point they're not doing anything for you you couldn't do yourself). At worst, they will cost you your job, and possibly your career[1]. [0] Which, incidentally, is not protected by the same laws that protect retaliatory termination by employers. [1] If you're in an industry that's represented by one single union, having your membership terminated means you should probably start looking for other career options.
- xienze 10y ago> If it's going to do anything but be window dressing then it needs to have the teeth of union - so just call it what it is. This sounds like it's going to have exactly zero to do with what a labor union would normally be concerned with -- pay, working conditions, etc. Instead, I have a strong suspicion this is going to be some sort of enumeration of the progressive ideals that all tech workers "should" be concerned with, as dictated by a group of Bay Area tech workers. Namely, LGBT stuff, female and minority representation, immigrant's rights, etc.
- badloginagain 10y agoI don't see what that would really accomplish, though. All companies already publicly advertise the 'moral' beliefs you mentioned, yet continue hiring white male whiteboard challenge mavericks.
- xienze 10y agoNo, not all companies. Many still follow the age-old wisdom of staying out of the social commentary business. I think the goal of this endeavor is to change that by convincing the tech workers to create a culture of doing so where it didn't exist before.
- matt4077 10y agoThe only age-old wisdom I remember from my great-grandfather is "never trust the British, and kill every French on sight". Regarding this issue, I'll stop demanding that corporations act morally above and beyond what the law requires when they seize to influence those laws.
- humanrebar 10y ago> yet continue hiring white male whiteboard challenge mavericks. Is that even true? Are you counting Asians and light-complexioned immigrants the same as American white people in this context?
- wtvanhest 10y ago
- x0x0 10y agoI have to wonder if this isn't an attempt to co-opt the movement started by @TechSolidarity / Maciej. I also think -- particularly if the HN audience is in any way representative -- that engineering in particular is far too deeply bought into the narrative of the rights of capital owners to unionize. Much like America, we think we're all temporarily embarrassed millionaires. I'm well aware unions aren't perfect. But they are a countervailing center of power who work for employees. The relationship between the employeed and the employers is a fundamentally contentious relationship: sometimes your incentives align, but often they don't. See eg things like the option trap vs 10 year exercise periods, or even founders getting millions of cash off the table while employees get $0. Much like how VCs can whine all they want, founders get better deals because of economic forces such as decreased engineering costs from open source software and better tooling, more capital seeking investment, etc; employee unions are a way to better the outcome of the employees themselves.
- ThrowawayR2 10y ago> Much like America, we think we're all temporarily embarrassed millionaires. The reason that old canard doesn't carry a lot of weight around SV and the other tech hubs is that a lot of rank-and file, non-manager techies actually _are_ millionaires.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alphonsegaston 10y agoWhile the capital class makes billions off their backs, colludes with each other to restrict wages and labor mobility, and exploits H1-B subcontractors to do more of the same. Why settle for this?
- diyorgasms 10y agoRight. Even at the top of the shit pile you're still standing in shit.
- 10y ago
- civilian 10y agoMy main objection to unions is that, once they're in a company, employees lose the right to negotiate their own compensation. I want to be able to skip my union dues and deal directly with the company. OR I want to be able to make a union of my own, especially for a functional or values-based subset of coworkers, and have us negotiate separately. This is not just a tech-unions-related complaint, this is a critique of unions as a whole. But yeah. I think that tech workers are in a special place because we have a lot of disposable income. I've gotten over my college-era "can't pay for anything" attitude, and I'm willing to pay for content that could be gotten for free. Entertainment was the first one, but now I'm also supporting some people on patreon and donating to causes. We don't need a union to drive that-- we can just remind tech workers that if we all donate a little, we can make big changes.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoYou can create a union to reflect whatever values (e.g. negotiating compensation) you see fit. Don't believe the narratives proffered by anti-union forces for their own benefit. Actors are all in unions and employ an entire sub-class of workers (agents) to negotiate compensation for them.
- stale2002 10y agoCool. How about we base this union on the values of not forcing people to join it? I'd be OK with that. Please keep these efforts focused on voluntary interactions.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoA union can't force you to join it so in that regard it's completely voluntary. It does however pressure companies to only hire union workers, or pressure the government to give preference to union workers. That's the whole point of a union, to check and co-opt the monopoly/oligopolic power of corporations and the government and giving it to the collective workers. You might philosophically disagree with that approach and think that a more anarchic market is better, but a union is not a violent coercive group.
- debt 10y agoit's odd the tech community in sv wouldn't want a union. i mean the tech alone is already attracting top talent imagine what a decent union would do. people from all over would be like omg they work normal hours and have decent benefits and they get to work at these huge companies and they're protected by a union damn but the execs are waiting for most of us to be replaced by the algos we're writing before that happens so who knows
- fragmede 10y agoWhat's in a name? Lawyers and doctors have unions, but they're called associations, but there's a test, with the full force of the law, for doctoring or lawyering without having passed their respective tests. Github's 'like' button has proved that we developers are just as vain (and lazy) as the next human, so I feel this has more of a chance to succeeded if we recognize that. Some of us take pride in thinking that we are better than plumbers, despite most of us merely being the digital equivalent. The G in SAG doesn't stand for union.
- cholantesh 10y agoAnd Carmack is unlikely to ever join such a group, being as he is a staunch libertarian.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYou'd be surprised how thin the line is between a libertarian and a mutualist.
- bigtimeidiot 10y ago>If this moves the needle on a union then great I'm trying to figure out why a tech worker union would want to sidle up to, say, YC. As someone who spent a few years as part of the Canadian Autoworkers Union, management were adversaries, not partners. Are the bourgeoisie trying to get out in front of this thing?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI'm trying to figure out why a tech worker union would want to sidle up to, say, YC. Well they shouldn't, actually - which was the whole point of my last sentence.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago> Are the bourgeoisie trying to get out in front of this thing? Yes. This sounds like techno-Fordism. Given that Fordism was invented to stabilize and rejuvenate a crisis-ridden form of capitalism, this is a very good sign. The union would also want to work with VCs, since they're the real managers in the industry. Startup companies come and go, but VCs and giant firms (Google, Apple, Microsoft) last.
- spangry 10y agoI agree with the what (I think) the parent post is getting at: if you're going to form a union, form a union. As in, a labour monopoly. This might sound radical, but I think there is good reason for developers and tech workers to consider this. There are strong network effects and nearly unlimited economies of scale in most tech markets. In these cases, given enough time, the end result will be a monopsonist employer.[0] This results in lower employment, lower wages and, ultimately, the replacement of labour with additional accumulated capital (e.g. ML algos) and/or cheaper substitute labour (e.g. imported foreign workers). Even in cases where there are a few large firms in competition (e.g. Google and Apple), they will have incentive to collude and make illegal agreements on hiring practices, wage ceilings etc (and there have been documented instances of this).[1][2] The logical way for software developers to avoid exploitation is to form a labour monopoly (i.e. a union or a guild). I've noticed some interesting features of the software development labour market: quite a lot of the work is creative in nature, you produce non-rivalrous products (i.e. my consumption of 'software x' does not block someone else's consumption), and the workforce is supposedly peppered with unusually talented individuals who produce 50-100x the value that the average worker does. There are two other industries that have similar features: traditional screen entertainment (TV & Movie), and professional sports leagues. In both of these industries, the content producing workers (baseball players, actors) are invariably a member of an industry guild or union, and they operate more like independent contractors than employees. Food for thought. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony#Welfare_implications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony#Welfare_implications [1] https://www.cnet.com/au/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-poaching-lawsuit-for-415-million/ https://www.cnet.com/au/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYes, despite a lot of tech workers insistence of unique professional distinction, there is plenty of well worn ground for the exact kind of labor we provide being unionized.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> In these cases, given enough time, the end result will be a monopsonist employer.[0] This results in lower employment, lower wages and, ultimately, the replacement of labour with additional accumulated capital (e.g. ML algos) and/or cheaper substitute labour (e.g. imported foreign workers). Unions that have closed-shop contracts with employers are, by definition, monopsonies on labor. Employees are required to be union members in order to be employed, and the union is the sole purchaser of the employee's labor (before reselling it to the employer). Some of the earliest and most successful unions formed in industries in which there already was a single, monopsony employer for an unionized market (think: "company towns" in the Rust Belt). But that's a very different situation from taking a competitive market and turning it into a monopsony.