24 ms·
Why do people find it surprising that companies who exist mainly on the premise of ignoring laws/regulations they find inconvenient, won't eventually ignore la
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
Why do people find it surprising that companies who exist mainly on the premise of ignoring laws/regulations they find inconvenient, won't eventually ignore laws/regulations that you think worthwhile (ie Uber and sexual harassment and AirBnb and paying for damages).
In addition, I find it interesting that the host is only sending a bill for $8000. It seems as if he is only trying to get paid for his damages and not even considering the damage and disruption to his neighbors (who unlike the host are wholly blameless in this manner). It seems AirBnb attracts the jerks and freeloaders.
- gambiting 10y agoIn the UK it's nearly unheard of to be suing for anything other than material/health damages. An unspecified "disruption to neighbours" is worth exactly zero in court.
- stordoff 10y agoThis is not the case. Disruption to neighbours could result in a claim of nuisance (things such as physical invasion of the land, noise, and smells all potentially give rise to nuisance). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuisance_in_English_law#Private_nuisance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuisance_in_English_law#Privat...
- dvdhnt 10y ago> It seems as if he is only trying to get paid for his damages and not even considering the damage and disruption to his neighbors (who unlike the host are wholly blameless in this manner). I don't agree with this. Obviously, if a bystander's property was damaged, this would be true, however, the idea of being paid for a "disruption" is silly. It's called life and it's full of annoyances. I'd argue the people angling for compensation because they're annoyed probably fall into the jerk and freeloader category more than someone who is willing to forgo reimbursement for his damaged property in order to warn the public about a potential pitfall.
- Marazan 10y agoHey, if some chooses to live next to a hotel then that's there choice. If a unlicensed hotel opens next to them (i.e. an airbnb rental) then they have been impinged on.
- zipppy 10y agoThat's a slippery slope; if my neighbors plant tulips and I HATE tulips, I don't get to sue for damages, even if the tulips weren't there when I moved in.
- nradov 10y agoThere is no slippery slope. The legal doctrine of quiet enjoyment is well established with clear limits based on centuries of precedents. http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/quiet+enjoyment http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/quiet+enjoymen...
- st3v3r 10y agoYeah, no. That's not a slippery slope. That you just being obstinate.
- gamblor956 10y agoLegally, that isn't even remotely a slippery slope. There is a vast difference between a decorative object located solely within one's property which has no effect on neighboring properties, and an for-profit unlicensed/illegal activity which affects the neighbor's safety and use of their abode.
- dvdhnt 10y agoI'm not talking about hotels, I'm talking about the fact that you nor anyone else can tell the future. Your neighbor could start woodworking as a hobby, put in a pool, get a motorcycle, etc. You have no idea what may come, that's my point, and shouldn't expect compensation for inconveniences especially in the case of leasing. Your property value isn't affected, and in fact, it could lead to a decrease in your rent. For you, or whoever is disturbed, your option (as shown in the article) is to call the police. Furthermore, there are plenty of instances of zoning changes leading to hotels or other commercial operations popping up next to someone who did exactly what you suggest i/e living away from a hotel. If you (or whoever) want to be left alone and never be bothered, by a few acres of land, otherwise expect that at any point in time, you may end up being bothered. Look, I get what you're saying and where you're coming from, and in theory, it sounds reasonable, but in practice (real life) it just doesn't happen that way.
- terms 10y ago>It seems AirBnb attracts the jerks and freeloaders. It is up to the person that wants to Airbnb her/his place to make sure the people who are taking residence in her/his property are decent. It is not Airbnb who attracts the jerks and freeloaders. With that said, their handling of this scenario (assuming everything that has been said in the article linked is true) was not good.
- alistairSH 10y agoHow does a potential AirBnB "landlord" ensure the potential "tenant" isn't going to wreck the house? In a normal year-long lease, you can run background checks, credit checks, verify employment. Are you really suggesting we should do that for a weekend long AirBnB?
- DanBC 10y agoIf his neighbours suffered damages they are free to sue AirBnB to recover their losses.
- bigbugbag 10y ago> I find it interesting that the host is only sending a bill for $8000. It seems as if he is only trying to get paid for his damages and not even considering the damage and disruption to his neighbors Could be related to the fact that those are not covered by the AirBnB guarantee: What’s not protected? The Host Guarantee should not be considered a replacement or stand-in for homeowners or renters insurance. The Host Guarantee does not protect: cash and securities pets personal liability shared or common areas