5 ms·
The eu's Parliament has de facto no power and all of the authority rests with the European commission, which is an unelected entity.
by dnautics 10y ago
The eu's Parliament has de facto no power and all of the authority rests with the European commission, which is an unelected entity.
- bengale 10y agoAll of the authority? You've been misinformed.
- dnautics 10y agoI apologize, I should not have been hyperbolic.
- ricw 10y agoThis is entirely false. Every legislation coming from the EU commission has to be approved by the parliament.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoYou're right it's unelected but there's much more complexion to it than that: >Selecting the team >The president-elect selects potential Vice-Presidents and Commissioners based on suggestions from EU countries. The list of nominees has to be approved by all EU heads of state or government, meeting in the European Council. >Each nominee must appear before the parliamentary committee with responsibility for his or her proposed portfolio. Committee members then vote on the nominee’s suitability for the position. Once the 27 nominees have been endorsed, Parliament as a whole votes whether or not to approve the entire team. Following Parliament's vote, the Commissioners are appointed by the European Council. Accountability >The European Commission is held democratically accountable by the European Parliament, which has the right to approve and dismiss the entire political leadership of the Commission. >The European Commission is also accountable for putting the EU budget into practice. Every year, the Parliament chooses to give (or not) its blessing to the European Commission on the way it has managed the EU budget. This process is called the discharge. The Parliament bases its decision on several reports from the European Court of Auditors and from the European Commission, including the annual management and performance report for the EU budget. https://ec.europa.eu/info/about-european-union/organisational-structure/political-leadership_en#how-the-commission-is-appointed https://ec.europa.eu/info/about-european-union/organisationa...
- rbehrends 10y agoFalse. 1. The European Commission is elected by the European Parliament. 2. The European Commission has the power to initiate legislation, but EU legislation is enacted by the European Parliament (lower chamber of the legislature) and the Council of the European Union (upper chamber of the legislature). This is why EU legislation begins with "REGULATION/DIRECTIVE ... OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL" [1]. [1] Example: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj http://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj
- Nursie 10y agoThe Commission is appointed by the Council, not elected by the Parliament. The Commission then originates all legislation, which Parliament can approve or not. It's not a system I would buy into voluntarily.
- rbehrends 10y agoFalse. The Commission election involves several steps. First, the President is nominated. While this is technically a power of the European Council (not to be confused with the Council of the European Union), in 2004 the Parliament won the right to determine the president and the nomination by the European Council is only a formality. (Similar to the appointment of the British PM by the British monarch). In practice, the choice of president is now the result of the elections to the European Parliament through the so-called "spitzenkandidaten" process [1], where each group in the EP nominates a candidate and the candidate of the largest party that can command a majority in the EP is chosen, who is then formally appointed. Second, the Commission President in conjunction with the member states nominates the remaining commissioners. The EP conducts hearings, after which the Commission is voted on. The EP can reject the Commission. In 2014, this resulted in the rejection of the Slovenian commissioner [2] and the Hungarian commissioner being stripped of the citizenship portfolio [3] as the result of questions regarding Hungary's human rights record. The EP can also remove the Commission through a motion of censure, Article 234 TFEU. This is what happened to the Santer commission (except that they resigned before the EP could vote them out of office). Note that under the British system, the Prime Minister and his or her cabinet does not even have to face hearings. The members of the cabinet are simply chosen by the PM, the PM is appointed by the monarch. That only the Commission can initiate legislation is not much of an issue and has more to do with how complex EU legislation is, which has to conform to the legislation of all the member states. The EP can propose legislation through Article 225 TFEU, can attach legislation to other legislation (such as the budget) through amendments if necessary (similar to how the US Senate gets around the Origination Clause) and simply force the Commission to initiate legislation or block other legislation (or, in the worst case, vote the Commission out of office). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_European_Commission#Spitzenkandidaten https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_European_Comm... [2] http://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/slovenia-s-nominee-for-european-commission-rejected-1.1956712 http://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/slovenia-s-nomin... [3] http://www.novinite.com/articles/164253/Hungary's+Navracsics+Deprived+of+Citizenship+Portfolio+in+New+EC+Panel http://www.novinite.com/articles/164253/Hungary's+Navracsics...
- matt4077 10y agoParliament has gained a lot of 'de jure' power since Lisbon. With it (and, some argue, a few good moves by the previous President of the EU Parliament) has come a rise in 'de facto' power and visibility. Entirely left out of your answer is the Council, with heads of state elected by whatever their country deems to be a democratic process. In practice, EU legislation requires agreement between the three institutions.