13 ms·
You can't pay an American worker 20 times as much to make the same product in the same number of hours. The only way to be competitive at 20 times the pay is fo
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
You can't pay an American worker 20 times as much to make the same product in the same number of hours. The only way to be competitive at 20 times the pay is for each worker to produce 20 times the output, i.e. automation. So what we have is a choice between fewer American manufacturing jobs (automation) or no American manufacturing jobs (outsourcing). People don't want to hear that, but those are the alternatives.
And given that, automation is clearly the right answer. Some manufacturing jobs is better than no manufacturing jobs, and more local manufacturing creates more local non-manufacturing jobs in sales, transportation, administration, etc.
- lkrubner 10y agowe have is a choice between fewer American manufacturing jobs (automation) or no American manufacturing jobs (outsourcing) That is simply incorrect. Consider the economic facts of the 20th Century. In each decade, the nation with fastest rising productivity also had the lowest unemployment. There is no obvious correlation between automation and job loss. Sometimes automation gets rid of jobs and sometimes it simply leads to more hiring in that sector, because that sector is profitable.
- dredmorbius 10y agoAdam Smith tied rising wages and high labour demand to growth. Which becomes problematic if the gravy train stops. But it would be otherwise in a country where the funds destined for the maintenance of labour were sensibly decaying. Every year the demand for servants and labourers would, in all the different classes of employments, be less than it had been the year before. Many who had been bred in the superior classes, not being able to find employment in their own business, would be glad to seek it in the lowest. The lowest class being not only overstocked with its own workmen, but with the overflowings of all the other classes, the competition for employment would be so great in it, as to reduce the wages of labour to the most miserable and scanty subsistence of the labourer. Many would not be able to find employment even upon these hard terms, but would either starve, or be driven to seek a subsistence either by begging, or by the perpetration perhaps of the greatest enormities. Want, famine, and mortality would immediately prevail in that class, and from thence extend themselves to all the superior classes, till the number of inhabitants in the country was reduced to what could easily be maintained by the revenue and stock which remained in it, and which had escaped either the tyranny or calamity which had destroyed the rest. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/Chapter_8 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/...
- elipsey 10y ago20 times as much as who? As far as I can figure out, there is a minimum wage in China, for example, which is between $2 and $3 per hour. So who works for 36 cents hour? EDIT: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-average-hourly-rate-for-a-factory-worker-in-China https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-average-hourly-rate-for-a-... Welp, there's one answer. I guess either this is common knowledge, or no else cared enough to check. :p
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe traditional US manufacturing jobs we "want" pay middle class wages.
- elipsey 10y agoYou said "we have is a choice between fewer American manufacturing jobs (automation) or no American manufacturing jobs (outsourcing). People don't want to hear that, but those are the alternatives." Why is it impossible to pay closer to the world market rate for labor, at the U.S. federal minium wage of $7.25/hr? I'm not saying you're wrong, these are intended as real questions :)
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoIn practice the answer was traditionally "unions". The United Auto Workers won't let you eliminate all pensions and benefits and pay minimum wage, but they can't stop you from building a factory in Mexico, so what happens? In theory we could try to compete with Asia on labor costs, but nobody really wants that. It's better to have middle class jobs than a larger number of subsistence-level jobs, especially when the output is the same.
- Jabanga 10y agoPeople will take the best job available on the market. If bringing back manufacturing brings back a lot of subsistence level jobs, you won't have people in middle class jobs leaving those jobs for the subsistence jobs. The only people who take those new jobs are those who are in a worst position than what the subsistence level would provide them, and thus are better off with the subsistence level job than without. This is basic free market economic theory that any economist (other than perhaps Marxians) would agree with.
- Chaebixi 10y ago> You can't pay an American worker 20 times as much to make the same product in the same number of hours. That's not true: you failed to mention the possibility of the customer paying more to make up for some of the difference in labor cost. > People don't want to hear that, but those are the alternatives. Those are the only alternatives, but only if you are restricted to thinking like a free-market economist. Other ideologies allow for other possibilities.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThis is actually where free-market thinking matches the real world - unless you find a way to force people to follow your ideology, they'll keep choosing what's cheaper.
- wazoox 10y agoIt's only cheaper because you don't account for social and environmental costs, and simply get rid of them as "externalities". But they're not externalities anymore, and their effects are coming down on us, and badly.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThat it true, but it doesn't invalidate the observable fact that people tend to pick cheaper things if presented with a choice.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoCustomers have repeatedly demonstrated an unwillingness to pay a large premium for a made-in-USA tag, and protectionist tariffs don't help you export American products.
- mch82 10y agoBut consumers have also demonstrated willingness to pay for shipping, wholesale markup, retail markup, and other fees that dwarf the differences in regional labor and manufacturing costs. So local made goods can be competitive. "How the cost of a shirt adds up" http://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-the-cost-of-a-shirt-adds-up/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-the-cost-of-a-shirt-adds-up/
- gshulegaard 10y agoThere is a lot more complexity here than that. For example G&E moved some manufacturing back to the US back in 2013: http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2014/01/22/265080779/as-overseas-costs-rise-more-u-s-companies-are-reshoring http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2014/01/22/265080779/a... Another article covering the same trend around the same time: http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21569570-growing-number-american-companies-are-moving-their-manufacturing-back-united http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21569570-growin... And from the Atlantic: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2012/12/the-insourcing-boom/309166/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2012/12/the-ins... Bottom line is that shorter supply chains, better/cheaper infrastructure, and better quality control has made bigger companies re-evaluate "overall" cost of production and the maintenance tails therein. And, contrary to popular belief, America is not so far out of the race as to not have a chance. Edit: One more from Forbes... https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnmcquaid/2012/12/06/why-apple-is-bringing-manufacturing-back-to-the-united-states/#680b4cfd3208 https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnmcquaid/2012/12/06/why-appl...
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoCompletely agree that there are advantages to manufacturing here, but if they actually outweighed the pre-automation labor cost, more companies would be doing it. And a lot of the companies still manufacturing here are using automation. GE literally has an industrial automation company: http://www.geautomation.com/ http://www.geautomation.com/
- zebrafish 10y agoLooks to me like all of those articles are about the Louisville, Kentucky GE Plant where they negotiated lower pay for their workers. I'd say that's an example, not a trend. Companies have been looking at overall cost of production for a long time. That's how they've calculated margins and filed a 10-K for the past 50 years. The bottom line is until overseas workers demand increased standards of living or US consumers show a willingness to pay a higher price for locally manufactured goods, this trend will continue. My question is, what does the end-game look like for a fully automated economy? You're either an entrepreneur with a fully automated supply chain, manufacturing, marketing, sales, and finance organization producing a good that is highly demanded by other fully automated businesses, or you starve?
- akie 10y agoThese are not the only two options: Germany pays (very) high wages, but has many manufacturing jobs -- and they're not in danger of going away.
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y agoGermany also has a much higher degree of automation compared to the US: https://twitter.com/TheEconomist/status/846769129763880961 https://twitter.com/TheEconomist/status/846769129763880961
- ed_balls 10y agoAnd you base that on what? Tesla is doing 10x improvements in automations and will force BMW/Audi/Mercedes to do it as well.
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y agoI think you underestimate the level of automation at a german car manufactures (e.g.: https://youtu.be/VreG1iC65Lc?t=1m6s https://youtu.be/VreG1iC65Lc?t=1m6s).
- PopsiclePete 10y ago>People don't want to hear that, but those are the alternatives. I wish we had politicians who would treat Americans as adults and tell them things they don't want to hear. We watched a whole country get swindled by a conman who promised a return to glorious 1958. Nobody shed any tears for the horse-and-buggy industry, or the cotton-picking industry, cobbler industry, the millions of people who used to be employed in manual farming methods - why are suddenly people who used to be employed in factories this tender, can't-be-told-the-truth "protected" class of people we all must bow down to? Yeah I get it - your father raised 4 kids in a white-picket-fence 2-car-garage house by pushing a button in factory, all while being barely literate and not being able to point out Canada on a map. So those days are gone, forever - so what do we do going forward? Instead, the entire country is now held hostage by the pissed-off, unable-to-accept-the-truth rust-belt blue-collar class who've been told they're the "real" America or whatever and are now dragging everyone else down with them. Wonderful.
- cortesoft 10y agoWe have politicians that tell the hard truths, and they don't get elected.
- clock_tower 10y agoOr at least don't get re-elected. Jimmy Carter was right about almost everything, and look where it got him...
- gnaritas 10y ago> I wish we had politicians who would treat Americans as adults and tell them things they don't want to hear. If that's what Americans wanted, they'd vote for it; but they don't, they prefer politicians who tell them what they want to hear and so that's who they put into office. Want to lose an election, tell the truth.
- robryan 10y agoI suspect it is hard to sell the electorate as a whole on the nuance required to tell them these jobs aren't coming back but you are the best choice for election. Pretty much every election campaign seems to be run on "the county is in crisis and we can save it", regardless of the state of the constitution country. Here in Australia there is a decade old thought, not back up by evidence, that the Liberal Party are better enconomic managers. Even after months of compaigning on complex issues you will have that line bought up on Election Day as to the rationale of their vote.
- pdog 10y agoYou're grossly mistaken if you think that American workers are paid 2000% (!) more than comparable manufacturing workers in China, Germany, and Japan (the other top manufacturing countries).
- brownbat 10y agoThis hinges on a common fallacy that insists there are a fixed number of jobs. If it wasn't possible to expand opportunities for employment, we would have run out of jobs as a country of 5.3 million people in 1800. As we automate, new labor emerges. Trade has taken a huge cut of the US textiles industry. But in the early 1800s, a textiles industry on the scale of what we have would have been inconceivable. Many families were making clothes from sheep to stockings, or grew a quarter acre of flax to begin the hard strenuous work of breaking it down and turning it into a scratchy fabric. They had a couple outfits and called it good. http://www.connerprairie.org/education-research/indiana-history/clothing-in-the-1800s-1 http://www.connerprairie.org/education-research/indiana-hist... If you told those people about a society where even a median income would let you buy a variety of shirts with different patterns and levels of comfort, then just throw them out or give them away each season if they fade a bit, they would have just stared back at you slackjawed. As far back as the BLS has data, the employment-population ratio has stayed within a narrow band around 60%. That strongly suggests there are feedback mechanisms that create new opportunities even when underlying sectors and conditions drastically change. The future of labor will probably surprise us just as much as the farmers in the 1800s. We'll have people do things that we can't even imagine how it would be efficient or profitable to hire out. On the order of unlikeliness of hiring someone to brush your teeth, or sing your theme song when you walk into rooms. EDIT: Added BLS point, we have no historical evidence of labor/population ratios shifting in the way people argue is imminent. It climbed sharply in '83 and dropped like a rock in '07. Those were not due to either automation or trade. It's hard to link to BLS, but basically go here, then expand back to 1947: https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS12300000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS12300000
- marcosdumay 10y ago>This hinges on a common fallacy that insists there are a fixed number of jobs. There's a very common fallacy that says that people have an unlimited amount of desires. Urban people (that are most) consume basically all the time, so you won't get all those new jobs unless you greatly increase the complexity of people's desires (we are doing that) or automate consumption.
- 10y ago
- cmarschner 10y agoIf labor costs are only a small fraction of overall production posts and the rest is capital (i.e. machines), then this difference becomes unimportant. And this is increasingly the case.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> If labor costs are only a small fraction of overall production posts and the rest is capital (i.e. machines), then this difference becomes unimportant. And this is increasingly the case. ...because of automation.
- lettergram 10y agoHmmm I don't know about that. Growing up my father was a tool maker (worked for Molex), that means he figured out how to make the molds people designed. That sounds easy to some, but understanding how to cut different materials the right way is a pretty unique skill. Anyways, he basically trained his replacement(s) before they laid off a large portion of his machine shop. He trained probably 15 - 20 Chinese over the course of a few years. In the end, as expected, they laid him off. Fast forward 10 years and they had to bring a lot of the tool making back. Turns out the Chinese either had worse quality control or poorer skill, but they simply couldn't produce at the same level. You only need a few molds for a production line, but each needs to be near perfect. The Chinese couldn't do it. And even when they did / could, the intellectual property was often stolen, so competitors would pop up and customers would get pissed. You're correct automation is needed. However, so is high quality standards, higher education, higher moral codes / higher pay to keep people honest. The fact is, you can't really find skilled labor elsewhere easily (they want the same as the US wages). That's why the US's number one export is education, and probably why every company still fights over software engineers and really every STEM field. Unfortunately for manufacturing, the fight is over. When they tried to bring the tool making back there were very few people still doing it. Every single one of my dad's friends (including my dad) had moved on to other jobs. The fact is, all that tribal knowledgewas passed down from master to apprentice was lost. After they laid off the masters, there was/is no one left to really continue. Personally, I view this as a loss of critical mass and now our skills are likely no better than anywhere else, at least for tool making. I think this is a warning for every business. Sometimes it's worth paying the price to keep talent. Companies like Google, Apple, et al, know this. Hopefully, that will keep tech and a lot of the other large US companies from losing their way.
- jasode 10y ago>the Chinese either had worse quality control or poorer skill, but they simply couldn't produce at the same level. ... The Chinese couldn't do it. It seems that China's workers can make Macbooks and iPhones with high precision and low tolerances according to Apple's specifications. Were the Molex molds more complicated than that? In other words, if those specific 15-20 Chinese workers failed, maybe choosing a different set of 20 Chinese employees (or partner manufacturer) would have given the quality desired?
- branchless 10y agoWhy do they need higher wages? Land prices due to financialisation. Why are land prices still at a level that kills your economy?
- dredmorbius 10y agoOh, you with the pesky questions! https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/608w97/asset_price_inflation_of_maslovian_and_productive/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/608w97/asset_p...
- branchless 10y agoCongrats on avoiding the hacker news rentier lobotomy!
- emodendroket 10y agoIt may not be palatable to you but trade protectionism is also an answer you haven't accounted for.
- bigger_cheese 10y agoKeep in mind Labor cost is only one part of the puzzle, it depends a lot on what you are manufacturing. In large heavy industries (Metals, chemicals, plastics etc) the raw materials costs can dwarf the labor cost by a significant amount. Obviously the story is different for lighter manufacturing (component assembly etc) where labor costs probably do make up a higher proportion of overall expenses. An example from the industry I'm familiar with - Steel: The raw materials which go into manufacturing steel; iron ore and coal are such a huge portion of the operating costs that labor expenses almost look like a rounding error next to it when you tabulate out the expenses. A lot of heavy industry is similar (Aluminum has added expense that it required large amount of electricity which is why traditionally aluminum smelters have been linked to hydro sites). If you can improve yield (ratio of raw materials consumed to product produced) by even a small margin you can justify your salary many times over which lends support to the idea you want to be employing smarter people not necessarily less people. Here is Australia what has rocked my industry is falling demand, largely driven by GFC which has led to a sudden decline in new commercial and residential construction etc. (It is starting to recover now but is pretty staggered). As well as increased completion from imports. I haven't seen any data supporting this but what I keep getting told is that in some cases Chinese government heavily subsidizes their industry so they can export at what would otherwise be a loss. This is called "Dumping" and is a form of predatory pricing the idea being you flood the market with very cheap goods then raise prices when competition is driven out of business. There is evidence this is happening to the US as well here is an article I found from Jan this year (http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/18/us-affirms-finding-of-china-steel-plate-dumping-subsidies.html http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/18/us-affirms-finding-of-china-s...) If I wanted to stimulate manufacturing I'd focus on demand (i.e government funded infrastructure projects) and trade policy (Better anti-dumping legislation etc).
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoAlso in the steel industry in Australia (Tasmania). Mostly structural steel at our workshop but also marine and agricultural at our other sites. Huge slump right now. We need multiple large projects on the go at once to keep all four workshops busy but the work just isn't available.
- mathattack 10y agoYou can't pay an American worker 20 times as much to make the same product in the same number of hours. The only way to be competitive at 20 times the pay is for each worker to produce 20 times the output, i.e. automation. This is only true if labor makes up the largest component of the cost. If the worker is only 10% of the cost of the output (versus say raw materials like steel) then being more 2X (or even 20X) more productive requires a much smaller productivity increase. It's also worth noting that manufacturing can carry significant negative externalities in the form of pollution.
- yuhong 10y agoYea, personally I care about the trade deficit more than jobs anyway. That is because the current economy is based on credit and that is not a good thing.
- onion2k 10y agoYou can't pay an American worker 20 times as much to make the same product in the same number of hours. Some people believe the solution is to that problem is to pay American workers less. For example, Trump has stated he believes American wages are too high to compete with foreign imports. http://www.politico.com/story/2015/11/donald-trump-wages-215812 http://www.politico.com/story/2015/11/donald-trump-wages-215...