18 ms·
Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard
- Animats 10y agoThose numbers are worse than I thought they were. I thought US production had recovered to 2008 levels. This isn't good, and it's really important. To some extent, Trump was elected to fix this, but so far, no initiatives have appeared which help US manufacturing. How much protectionism the US should have is a real question. China has a considerable amount, and is trying to become an autarky, not dependent of the rest of the world. That's been quite successful in the Internet sector. China can probably do it; they're big enough.
- makapuf 10y agoWell, are the USA really not an autarky Internet wise ? Of course it's theoretically open to other countries services but let the proof be in the pudding: which are the important services or sites used in the US and not made in USA ? (just a thinking experiment, of course I remember there are reasons. There may also be reasons for Chinese)
- fnordfnordfnord 10y agoIf the manufacturing jobs come back, they're bringing developing-nation-style quality of life with them. POTUS can't do anything other than protectionism, and that will only stave off disaster, while driving quality to the floor.
- PKop 10y agoPretty sure removing regulations on energy development (and therefore, cost) are an effort to supporting manufacturing, and Trump has taken an aggressive stance at repealing as much regulation especially in the energy sector, as he can[0][1][2]. Those are just a few citations, but just look up some of his executive actions and orders, as well as some recent legislation he's signed. Some of these addresses repeal of regulations (Using the Congressional Review Act). The GOP border-adjustment tax is being worked on currently. While debatable in how it does or does not favor imports or exports, at the very least seems to favor establishing business in the US and eliminate tax benefits of incorporating outside the US.[3] This, and his general desire for a slashing of the corporate rate, should incentivize corporations (manufacturing and otherwise) to move, stay, and hire in US, and move US from one of highest rate countries to one of the lowest. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2017/03/28/trump-in-the-name-of-american-energy-independence-scraps-obamas-climate-plans/#4c2ab7442258 https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2017/03/28/tr... [1] http://dailycaller.com/2017/02/02/trump-to-sign-repeal-of-obama-era-coal-mining-regulation/ http://dailycaller.com/2017/02/02/trump-to-sign-repeal-of-ob... [2]http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/319488-trump-signs-repeal-of-transparency-rule-for-oil-companies http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/319488-trump-si... [3] https://taxfoundation.org/faqs-border-adjustment/ https://taxfoundation.org/faqs-border-adjustment/
- WorldMaker 10y agoThese are supply-side arguments that still continue to fail to impress when implemented in reality. Just to narrow to one obvious piece: the difference in type of energy matters if the goal is to support local manufacturing. It's a variation of the "Buy Local" argument applied to manufacturing suppliers. Reducing the cost/regulation of oil/gas/coal doesn't support local manufacturing near as much as it continues to support/cheapen global shipping costs (because oil/gas/coal continue to transport well across borders, and continue to keep cargo ships/planes fed). On the other hand, increasing solar/wind is a much more "local" energy resource investment (it's tough enough just to store it for time-shifting, much less to transport across borders) and might be better for the stated goal.
- xenadu02 10y agoElectricity in the US is already cheaper than China thanks to renewables and natural gas. You're really reaching there.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoI think this argument is a bit specious. While taking steps to reduce the cost of energy may have an indirect effect on manufacturing in energy intensive industries, the main goal of this policy is to improve the bottom line of energy companies to the tune of billions of dollars. Companies which also happen to be huge campaign contributors. This would be like claiming that loosening the banking regulations was part of the Administration's plan to boost consumer spending, while ignoring the fact that it also helps those companies make billions of dollars more than they otherwise would have.
- icelancer 10y agoWeird; I had the opposite reaction. The data in the charts seemed soothing to me. I thought manufacturing had been crushed by double digit percentages, even today. It's rebounding significantly and while the author asserts it is a plateau, I think it's far too soon to make that call. I don't disagree with the author's main points about manufacturing and the economy in general; I just don't see the dire situation in the data.
- beedogs 10y agoTrump duped people into thinking he gave a shit about this. Unfortunately -- but also predictably -- he will do absolutely nothing to fix it before his inevitable removal from office.
- MarkMc 10y ago2008 was the height of a debt-fuelled bubble - I wouldn't take it as the starting point for long-term growth trends in industrial output.
- intrasight 10y agoIndustry doesn't need a "helping hand". It needs a free hand and a level playing field. If government wants to offer a helping hand, how about helping to address the rampant industrial espionage on the part of our trading partners.
- Frondo 10y agoAgreed. Businesses don't. People do. Level the playing field for businesses, access to education, health care, and universal basic income for people.
- cmdrfred 10y agoMedicare for all would cost 2.5 - 3 trillion a year. Current tax collection collects about 1.5 trillion. If you tax millionaires at 100% you'd see maybe another trillion. Cut defense by 100% and you'd save 600 billion. With the high taxes required in order to implement your ideas I don't think businesses would grow and its possible a great many would fail.
- IIIIIIIIIIII 10y agoBut in an economy one side's costs are people's income. It's an economy, not a household. Money circulates and performs work when it does, like water. What kinds of mills should it drive? A good health care system seems to me like a good candidate, since it fulfills the most basic needs of humans after food, warmth and shelter. Also, you assume "all other things remaining equal", which is unlikely.
- gnaritas 10y ago> Medicare for all would cost 2.5 - 3 trillion a year. Isn't that assuming current costs for care don't change? Seems a bad assumption since medicare for all would cost less than health insurance for all and be a much more efficient and thus less overhead process while simplifying the system across the board for doctors and hospitals greatly reducing the costs to them by virtually eliminating the huge hassle that is medical billing these days.
- ben_says 10y agoPeople shop for the best deal. Companies look at countries and do the same. Give them a better deal by lower taxes and reducing regulation, and back they come. Raise taxes and regulation, and away they flee.
- ben_w 10y agoThat has to be an oversimplification, else all the companies would have already moved. Suspect that "I am used to things as they are" is a powerful incentive to keep business, not just citizens. (I say this as someone trying to move out of the UK because of the combination of Brexit and the Investigatory Powers Act: moving is extremely unpleasant).
- abfan1127 10y agothere is always a barrier to leave... but there is also a barrier to return.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoThis piece is lacking in details about non-manufacturing, non-agricultural output, with the obvious exceptions of finance and real estate. Completely lacking is any assessment of American economic juggernauts: high-tech (like Silicon Valley) and culture (like Hollywood). Both represent industries that are very very hard to replicate because they require immense talent ecosystems. You can't simply cut taxes and labor costs and get a Hollywood - with massive global consumption - out of nowhere. America is very safe in these kinds of industries. Typically when other countries develop their own they either end up with extremely niche products (like India's Bollywood) or bland products with little real mass appeal (quick, think of the last Chinese movie you enjoyed that wasn't Ip Man).
- dmoy 10y ago> quick, think of the last Chinese movie you enjoyed that wasn't Ip Man Lost in Thailand. Hilarious slapstick comedy.
- varjag 10y agoProblem is this view makes 90% of American population and territory redundant. You can just substitute 'America' with 'California' and that won't alter the sentiment at all.
- arcanus 10y agoFinance in NYC Oil refining and seismology in Houston Biotechnology in Boston The USA absolutely has a series of high tech clusters outside of California that are globally competitive.
- Animats 10y agoAmerica is very safe in these kinds of industries. Baidu. Tencent. Foxconn. Didi. Think of the last Chinese movie you enjoyed that wasn't Ip Man "The Great Wall"
- wcummings 10y ago>"The Great Wall" You might be the only one, it lost money in the US and was panned by critics. And that was a big budget movie made to prove China can compete with Hollywood. It can't (yet).
- ffjffsfr 10y agoThe article doesn't present any sound evidence for hypothesis in the title. Manufacturing output has declined sure, but real gross domestic product grew and it is still growing. This means that maufacturing production is replaced by other sectors of economy: mostly services. It seems logical to expect that in the future we'll have more jobs in services (e.g. tech) and less jobs in manufacturing. This is good for everybody, good for workers, because jobs in services are less dangerous, and good for economy too.
- porpoisemonkey 10y ago> jobs in services are less dangerous This depends on how you define dangerous. Heart disease is the number one cause of death in the United States killing ~614,000 people per year whereas accidents account for ~136,000. Sedentary behavior has been shown to increase the odds of heart related disease. Moving from more active manufacturing jobs to more sedentary service jobs could arguably be more dangerous to the longevity of a person's life. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm "Physical inactivity has become a major public health concern because it is the second leading single cause of death in the United States, trailing only tobacco use (31)." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2857522/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2857522/
- aidenn0 10y agoAlso to note: when I worked retail, I was significantly less active than when I started working software. With retail, my feet just hurt too damn much for me to want to play sports on my days off. When I started a software job, I had 3 weekly semi-organized games I played in most weeks, as well as occasional pickup games on other days.
- porpoisemonkey 10y agoCould you clarify why this should be noteworthy? I mean this in the nicest and most respectful way possible - I'm not sure how the statement fits into the discussion.
- manis404 10y agoThis article is wrong. 1. Manufacturing has to be outsourced to cheaper labour countries. 2. Those affected by the outsourcing should be put on welfare and/or retrained. This simple formula is working - proof is the evolution of the GDP of the US. The article looks like a typical trump supporter hit piece on Hillary.
- arbuge 10y agoThe article does not prove the headline in any way. Towards the end it mentions a couple of experts who believe in this premise, but doesn't actually provide anything of substance to back up that belief.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoYou can't pay an American worker 20 times as much to make the same product in the same number of hours. The only way to be competitive at 20 times the pay is for each worker to produce 20 times the output, i.e. automation. So what we have is a choice between fewer American manufacturing jobs (automation) or no American manufacturing jobs (outsourcing). People don't want to hear that, but those are the alternatives. And given that, automation is clearly the right answer. Some manufacturing jobs is better than no manufacturing jobs, and more local manufacturing creates more local non-manufacturing jobs in sales, transportation, administration, etc.
- lkrubner 10y agowe have is a choice between fewer American manufacturing jobs (automation) or no American manufacturing jobs (outsourcing) That is simply incorrect. Consider the economic facts of the 20th Century. In each decade, the nation with fastest rising productivity also had the lowest unemployment. There is no obvious correlation between automation and job loss. Sometimes automation gets rid of jobs and sometimes it simply leads to more hiring in that sector, because that sector is profitable.
- dredmorbius 10y agoAdam Smith tied rising wages and high labour demand to growth. Which becomes problematic if the gravy train stops. But it would be otherwise in a country where the funds destined for the maintenance of labour were sensibly decaying. Every year the demand for servants and labourers would, in all the different classes of employments, be less than it had been the year before. Many who had been bred in the superior classes, not being able to find employment in their own business, would be glad to seek it in the lowest. The lowest class being not only overstocked with its own workmen, but with the overflowings of all the other classes, the competition for employment would be so great in it, as to reduce the wages of labour to the most miserable and scanty subsistence of the labourer. Many would not be able to find employment even upon these hard terms, but would either starve, or be driven to seek a subsistence either by begging, or by the perpetration perhaps of the greatest enormities. Want, famine, and mortality would immediately prevail in that class, and from thence extend themselves to all the superior classes, till the number of inhabitants in the country was reduced to what could easily be maintained by the revenue and stock which remained in it, and which had escaped either the tyranny or calamity which had destroyed the rest. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/Chapter_8 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/...
- whack 10y ago"Why should a country specialize in making things, when it can instead specialize in designing, marketing and financing the making of things?" "This is a legitimate question... Ricardo Hausmann believes that a country’s economic development depends crucially on where it lies in the so-called product space. If a country makes complex products that are linked to many other industries -- such as computers, cars and chemicals -- it will be rich. But if it makes simple products that don’t have much of a supply chain -- soybeans or oil -- it will stay poor. In the past, the U.S. was very successful at positioning itself at the top of the global value chain." I would certainly call Google's search engines, Apple's iPhones and Intel's processors "complex products that are linked to many other industries". Comparing the fortunes of Apple vs Foxconn also shows that the top of the value-chain certainly lies in design/marketing, as opposed to manufacturing. The evidence the article presents is utterly baffling and unconvincing.
- wickedlogic 10y agoExcept the status quo of the value-chain may not be representative of the natural settling over time. Design/marketing rest very much on the stability and practical enforcement of "IP" in our current attempted world view. That is unlikely to play out in the long run. The world is unlikely to consistently enforce the cost of a one-but-no-longer complex process, when a simple/cheaper process produces essentially the same outcome. Minus rarity of material requirements. What out of "IP" survives? Local trademarks/service marks, sure. Copyright with meaningful global enforcement... not likely. Production of small intricate things/electronics ... likely. Production of easy-to-future-produce/assemble, seems unlikely.
- vkou 10y agoGoogle has a market cap of $570 billion USD, and employs 70,000 people. GM, Ford, and Chrystler have a combined market cap of ~$130 billion USD, and employ 600,000 people. Google makes a lot of money, and pays its employees well. Unfortunately, it hardly employs anyone.
- wyldfire 10y agoYou summed three competitors' employee counts as a comparison against Google. I don't understand. You say "it hardly employs anyone" but from your numbers I read, "70k is a little less than half of 200k".
- fovc 10y agoI was discussing something like this with an economist friend recently. His view was that most economists (rightly I think) focus on consumption not production. In theory, you can run a trade deficit forever to keep consuming more than you produce. Where I think the model probably breaks down is that you can't have infinite debt levels, so your consumption growth is capped by your production growth. I would think you run out of assets (e.g., Manhattan, London real estate) to sell to net-export economies, but I guess there's always financial innovation to bring you new products to sell
- terminallyunix 10y agoThis reminds me of a quote from Neal Stephenson's epic Snow Crash novel: “When it gets down to it — talking trade balances here — once we've brain-drained all our technology into other countries, once things have evened out, they're making cars in Bolivia and microwave ovens in Tadzhikistan and selling them here — once our edge in natural resources has been made irrelevant by giant Hong Kong ships and dirigibles that can ship North Dakota all the way to New Zealand for a nickel — once the Invisible Hand has taken away all those historical inequities and smeared them out into a broad global layer of what a Pakistani brickmaker would consider to be prosperity — y'know what? There's only four things we do better than anyone else: music movies microcode (software) high-speed pizza delivery” ― Neal Stephenson, Snow Crash
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mjevans 10y agoI'd rather work at the Central Intelligence Corporation (IE Google / etc) than at USCAS or whatever that 'military turned software hell hole' (think EA) was...
- mirimir 10y agoYeah, he pretty much nailed it. But pizza delivery was a euphemism, I think.
- eridius 10y agoHiro Protagonist is literally a pizza delivery driver, so it's not a euphemism. Neal Stephenson could perhaps have used pizza delivery as a metaphor for something, but if so, I have no idea what, so it's probably actually just commentary on America's obsession with fast food.
- mirimir 10y agoUncle Enzo, maybe?
- 10y ago
- cylinder 10y agoThe disturbing thing is that the US is not building its own robots to automate the factories, they are being imported. Clearly we aren't as innovative a nation as we think we are. Hey, at least we have Uber.
- javajosh 10y agoFor a long time now the wisdom was that only suckers make (or fix) real things. Slightly less suckery were the people designing things to be built; but the real winners are the ones that make a living allocating vast sums of other people's money across many firms (often abstracted through derivative instruments). This is a pure information operation, with no expectation of concrete productivity. Business owners, and sometimes leaders, can also be winners in the sense that they make socio-economic decisions related to a given firm. They set high level policy like "culture" and stay aware of the "winner" landscape of flush firms who might be looking to buy you - and the poor performing firms who may about to shed talent. Then there is the professional class, primarily inside lawyers and accountants. The remainder are mostly office drones, who's value is mostly emotional and social. They are the fat that demonstrates health. We all are trying hard to make a living from pure information, but the finance guys are doing it with the most honestly. Engineering guys make things (electron states), so its messy and we can fail. And we affect the real world, with its constant scary existential threat from government, making it even more risky. I mean, it's nice when the money is flowing wide and deep, and you really all you do is give some speeches, keep an eye on projects, make a strategic decision twice a year, and play golf with investors and other CEOs. Sign me up!
- jfoutz 10y agoPretty sure the us is the world leader in factory automation. We export robots to build washing machines, and import washing machines.
- dahauns 10y agoSorry to burst that bubble - that couldn't be further from the truth, especially when it comes to high-tech automation, i.e. industrial robotics. Japan is still THE undisputed powerhouse in this field (Yasakawa, Kawasaki, Fanuc, Mitsubishi, Epson...), with the EU a distant second (ABB, KUKA, Stäubli, Comau...) and China rising quickly (e.g Siasun, Foxconn).
- eldavido 10y agoWhat it really comes down to is societal priorities. The Chinese have been willing to do things over the past few decades that the US isn't, and it's given them an advantage in low-cost production. One of those things is trash their environment. In the US, we have the federal clean air act, an EPA to enforce it, and various similar laws and enforcement bodies at the state and local level (e.g. CEQA). A second major example of this is labor laws. Workers in the US have strong protections including the right to organize, vote, minimum wage protections, not to endure wrongful termination or sexual harassment, as well as various overtime provisions and strong protections of salary in bankruptcy. They have none of this in China. In China, due to lax enforcement of safety, major industrial accidents happen as a matter of course. I recall reading two separate times in the Economist over the last several years when workers were trapped inside of a burning building, leading to hundreds of deaths. And I keep hearing stories about workers getting woken up in the middle of the night, handed tea and biscuits, and asked to start working. Anecdotally (I'm not as sure about this) I think many people in China work much longer hours than we do in the US. Most middle-class jobs in the US give at least a day or two off per week; I'm not sure how common this is in China. We also have strong protections of rights in the US including freedom of speech, rights to a fair, speedy and open trial, break time to vote, and various protections relating to bona fide religious practice, including exemption from some collective bargaining agreements. All of these things cost money -- a lot of it. So we're going to have a slightly higher cost of production, or perhaps a bit higher taxes. The real telling thing though is the flow, not of goods or money, but of _people_. Net in-migration to the US from Asia feels much stronger than vice versa. And so I ask: perhaps our manufacturing is in decline, but, why do so many people move here from the rest of the world? Is it possible that the Chinese middle class is getting tired of lead paint in their food, random lengthy incarcerations of political prisoners, a one-party state that openly engages in religious persecution, lack of a free press, or lack of a functioning civil court system? Now, one can certainly make the argument that some of these protections have gone too far in the US. Perhaps unions have too much power. Maybe companies like Uber/Lyft will force the discussion on making the employment regime less onerous in places like Illinois (my home state), where firing someone is almost always a lengthy court case due to a shockingly pro-labor employment law regime. Perhaps the pendulum could stand to swing back a big in the direction of economic competitiveness. Or maybe the US and China will converge. I consider myself a pretty strong libertarian, but it really makes me think.
- Spooky23 10y agoThis is why people don't trust news media and government. This stuff was 100% obvious back in the 90s days, when the left wing people were protesting globalism, what was left of manufacturing imploded, and big agribusiness crushed Mexicos economy. Since that time, we've been told time and time again by economists that we're all wrong, the service economy is great and life is great... just go to college for retraining.
- vkou 10y agoThat's because the left (Or more specifically, its social policies) has been co-opted by neo-liberalism. We now have people who, with a straight face, can claim that Hillary or Obama have liberal policies.
- mozumder 10y agoThat's because they ARE liberal policies. Globalization means everybody in the world benefits, not just Americans. Or did you want Nigerians and Sri Lankans to remain in poverty forever?
- vkou 10y agoYes, offshoring all our manufacturing to places with no worker protections, no environmental protections, long work weeks, and poor wages is absolutely a liberal policy. We're all about winning the race to the bottom. The World Bank and the IMF have always been the left's shining beacons, that bring progressive enlightenment to the downtrodden masses, the global south is not being ruthlessly exploited by multinationals, and we've always been at war with Eastasia. I mean, that's not how I remember the politics of the 90s, but who's to say?
- mozumder 10y agoIf you want those places to start having worker rights and environmental protections, then you better make sure they're rich first, by giving them jobs and trade. The only reason they don't have these things is because they're poor in the first place. Only wealthy societies can afford those things. Free trade is the global labor and environment solution. Or maybe you want those countries to be environmentally destructive forever?
- jitix 10y agoTo move to a more automated manufacturing industry and to expand the service industry the US needs more educated people. You can't do hi-tech manufacturing with high school graduates. I think US needs to fix it's education system first to make sure that all deserving people get a chance to go to college without incurring debt. It can easily be done considering the money the government spends on defense and other (I'd call useless) agencies like NSA, DEA, etc. One of the first steps could be to pay college tuition for students matching certain criteria (I'm not sure what the criteria could be - maybe GPA - but I'm certain that some elibility criteria can be defined).
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoYou could do hi-tech manufacturing with high school graduates if they actually studied a high-tech curriculum or had the opportunity to apprentice for 2-3 years. College is not (and should not be) required for everyone who wants a decent middle class job.
- jdmichal 10y agoGermany has been mentioned a lot here. Education is another place where the country is "ahead". Occupational schools and apprenticeships are a common higher education route. My understanding is that only people slotted for college get an abstract curriculum similar to what Americans would call "high school".
- aidenn0 10y agoMany regions in Germany accomplish this through heavy uses of Tracking[1] which, regardless of your stance on it, is a political non-starter in the US. One place I visited (it varies heavily with region), the students were sorted towards Gymnasium (college prep) or Realschule (ends at 10th grade with a sight towards job, apprenticeship, or further vocational training) around 3rd grade. Good luck implementing that in the US.
- jitix 10y agoThat would probably require a major reform of the K-12 system, and also a cultural shift where people actually become interested in tech curriculum. And to do that STEM subjects need to be given importance at a very early stage.
- bwb 10y agoHow does manufacturing view internet businesses where the product is a SAAS and pulling in global revenue?
- AndrewDP 10y agoMy wife works in fashion. What they have found is instructive. They have spent 20 years outsourcing their production to China. After 20 years of economic and wage growth in China the cost savings once you take into account shipping etc is eroding. Adding to increased demand from the local economy, the value for outsourcing is quickly eroding and most fashion companies are looking for the next low cost production region (Vietnam and Pakistan are two). I am no economist, but I believe that there will be a global rebalancing in the near future: manufacturing will return as the rents in low-cost regions approach the local cost of manufacturing.
- kgwgk 10y agoThis has been happening for a while: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/17/business/global/17textile.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/17/business/global/17textile....
- vinceguidry 10y agoReally this is about increasing demand and not supply. Americans need to be trained to not want cheap shit. They need to learn to value stuff like repairability and durability. Americans need to want things that only Americans can make. As long as they want stuff that can be made by the dozen, then they're just going to get all that from the cheapest maker.
- sanderjd 10y agoThis seems like a diffuse cost / concentrated benefit problem to me. It will be an uphill battle to get a large number of people to pay more for things in order to benefit a relatively small group of those employed in making those things. This doesn't even really work for local face-to-face service work where the benefit to the local community is fairly obvious, let alone for manufacturers largely located in completely different states.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wiz21c 10y agoNobody talks about software, damn is it HN ?