8 ms·
I own a Volt. Best car I've ever driven. GM doesn't care much for it. The only advertising they really do for it basically is trying to steal EV customers from
by Robotbeat 10y ago
I own a Volt. Best car I've ever driven. GM doesn't care much for it. The only advertising they really do for it basically is trying to steal EV customers from Nissan's Leaf. Really dumb. And the dealers don't like it because 1) they don't know how to service them and especially 2) they almost never need servicing. If you run almost exclusively on electric, you only need like 4-5 oil changes in the entire life of the car. And the brakes last forever, too.
- vvanders 10y agoYup, which is why any entrenched player is going to have to both build an incredible car and fight against their dealerships to sell it.
- timr 10y agoActually, the reason GM "doesn't care" about the Volt (I'm exaggerating here; they obviously care a little bit) is because they're rational: electric cars are not popular with mass-market consumers, and it's far from clear that they're going to become popular. GM is investing in what sells, and right now (i.e. for the last decade or two), that's SUVs and light trucks. Which doesn't bode well for Tesla, at least in the near term. You can certainly argue that fuel prices are going to go up and make electric cars popular. The question is: does it happen before Tesla goes broke? (Edit: downvoting doesn't change facts. From GM's own 2017 outlook [1]: "Ten all-new or recently redesigned crossovers are expected to drive GM’s sales and share higher in 2017, including the Chevrolet Equinox and GMC Terrain, which will compete in the industry’s largest segment." And they're not joking about that last part. As of February 2017, SUVs and Trucks dominate the list of most-popular vehicles sold in the USA [2].) [1] https://www.gm.com/investors/sales/us-sales-production.html https://www.gm.com/investors/sales/us-sales-production.html [2] https://www.cars.com/articles/top-10-best-selling-cars-february-2017-1420694288140/ https://www.cars.com/articles/top-10-best-selling-cars-febru...
- Robotbeat 10y agoThe whole point of advertising is to make something popular that isn't already or to maintain popularity for something that would otherwise decline in popularity. As long as all GM is doing is sniping at other electric cars while doing general broad-based advertising of their fossil fuel powered vehicles, they're not lifting a finger to expand the EV market. I wouldn't worry about Tesla, anyway. Tesla has huge brand clout and advertises by making really awesome, inspiring vehicles. You want the fastest production sedan? There's only the Model S. And Model X is, after all, an SUV/crossover. And Model 3, which isn't, will be the basis for the Model Y, which /will/ be a crossover and/or light truck. Again, Tesla will be perfectly fine on the demand front.
- timr 10y ago"The whole point of advertising is to make something popular that isn't already or to maintain popularity for something that would otherwise decline in popularity." You can't push on a string. Consumers buy bigger cars when gas prices are low, and more efficient cars when gas prices are high. It's why Toyota (which has built a brand identity around fuel efficiency) does worse when fuel prices go down. Marketing can influence consumers' affinity for brands and perception of product quality. It can't change economics. "Tesla will be perfectly fine on the demand front." I'm sure there's a market. After all, Lamborghini is "perfectly fine on the demand front", too. But will the demand for electric vehicles justify a valuation on par with General Motors? That's the rub.
- kbenson 10y ago> Marketing can influence consumers' affinity for brands and perception of product quality. It can't change economics. Actually, I would say marketing is one of the few things that actually can change economics, since it affects perception. Marketing can make someone think they need a new car when they don't, or that a car is affordable than an alternative when it really isn't (given financing, fuel economy, services, etc which are not always taken into account). People don't make decisions based on reality, they make decisions based on their perception of reality. If you can change that perception, you may change their decisions.
- chrishacken 10y agoClose to 200,000 Prius's are sold each year. While that's no where near the "best selling" car, their Camry (400,000 cars a year), that's substantial.
- timr 10y agoFord sold 66,000 F-Series pickups in February 2017, alone. Small car sales are declining, across the board. https://www.cars.com/articles/top-10-best-selling-cars-february-2017-1420694288140/ https://www.cars.com/articles/top-10-best-selling-cars-febru...
- chrishacken 10y agoYou can't really compare the "F-Series" with a single car. A more accurate comparison would probably be all sedan's with the F-Series. But yes, trucks are on the rise again.
- greglindahl 10y agoI'm having a hard time connecting the facts with the discussion. Are you saying that GM should have made a crossover instead of the Volt/Bolt? Are you saying that Tesla doesn't have a crossover?
- timr 10y ago"I'm having a hard time connecting the facts with the discussion. Are you saying that GM should have made a crossover instead of the Volt/Bolt? Are you saying that Tesla doesn't have a crossover?" GM already has a crossover line. In fact, it has a bunch, and they sell really well: http://www.gmfleet.com/vehicle-search/by-body-style/suvs-crossover.html http://www.gmfleet.com/vehicle-search/by-body-style/suvs-cro... Point out Tesla's crossover SUV with the range of a gasoline vehicle and the price point of a Chevy Equinox ($25k). I'll wait.
- chc 10y ago> Point out Tesla's crossover SUV with the range of a gasoline vehicle and the price point of a Chevy Equinox ($25k). I'll wait. Whoa — you have to realize what you just did there, right? This is a massive shifting of the goalposts from what you said Tesla's problem was earlier, which is that SUVs and light trucks are what sells. Anyway, I don't think most people with SUVs actually go through a full tank of gas a day, so having completely equal range doesn't seem like that big an issue. So now it sounds like Tesla's major problem is that they're competing with the Range Rover rather than the Equinox.
- astrange 10y agoHow large are those cars? No wonder traffic is so bad.
- vvanders 10y agoYou're getting downvoted because you missed the argument that I presented. It's not about what market segment that sells, it's that dealers have no incentives to sell electric vehicles since there's no margin on services and maintenance.
- caminante 10y ago(Assuming non-material edits by the parent,) IMHO, he didn't miss your argument. The topic's GM and GM dealerships. You said GM has to fight the GM dealerships due to conflicting interests, whereas, he's saying GM and the GM dealerships don't want "non" mass-markets customers to begin with (i.e. no conflict).
- hockley 10y agoThis kind of proves the thesis. EV is a hobby for the legacy guys that competes with much more powerful (by revenue) business units in the company. It's like expecting Kodak to compete and win with their own digital camera.
- sremani 10y agoEvery one does not start with a blank slate, that is a luxury Tesla has as an upstart. GM is "saved" to save jobs by US government. GM has paid back, but its operational reality depends on selling "profit-making" vehicles, which are SUVs and Trucks, pair it with cheap gas prices, there is a strategy for GM to be profitable. Tesla on the other hand, lives and dies by its EV performance, and their approach to the market at higher end kept them alive along with loans from US with few strings attached (for various reasons). Tesla did not "break through" any thing. If any thing, existence of BoltEV and Volt does demonstrate couple of things, a legacy car company when there are profits are going to turn on dime and make shit ton of EVs, if that is what market wants. Tesla has brand recognition behind it, but again as some one pointed out when the market for EVs in high demand and profitable, from BMW to GM, you will have them roll EVs in millions.
- mikeash 10y agoEVs are unpopular because cheap ones aren't very good yet. You have to choose between almost unusably short range, or a very high price. Something like the LEAF is affordable, but only useful as a city car. A Model S is a great car, but extremely expensive. The cost is coming down. Chevy is now selling the Bolt, which has pretty good range, for under $40,000. Tesla's Model 3 is coming soon. More will follow. The high cost comes from the batteries, which are getting cheaper all the time. I'm not sure that "unpopular" is quite the right word. A lot of people really like Teslas. Most of them can't afford them. The desire is there, the means is not (yet). It's smart to invest in what sells right now... until things change and that's no longer what sells. GM is investing in what sells today. Tesla is investing in what might sell in a decade or two. Tesla's approach isn't certain but if they're right then GM is going to relive their experience of the 1970s where they take way too long to react to a changing market.
- paganel 10y agoI've had the exact same discussion with somebody else today on /r/futurology, more exactly I told him that "under $40,000" it's still pretty damn expensive for a small hatchback. My 1.4l European small hatchback costs around 13,000 euros new, you just can't expect people to not take into consideration the huge difference between the 2 prices.
- yawz 10y agoI'm not sure if this year all figures are the same, but when I was car-shopping in November, Colorado state granted up to $6,000 in tax credits for new EVs. Federal tax credit was $7,500. And on top of that, Nissan was adding their own discount for their new Leafs. So, nobody pays the full price of an EV at the moment. You can currently buy 1-2 year-old, certified Nissan Leafs for less than $13,000.
- rootusrootus 10y agoWith the number of reservations Tesla has for the Model 3, we are going to find out rather quickly what effect losing the big tax credits has on electric adoption. Maybe that is hidden somewhat by the leasing -- buying an EV right now is foolish, leasing is a much better choice. Even the Model S is going through the auctions at half MSRP or sometimes less, and less prestigous cars like the 500E are auctioning at 4K or so. Anybody who purchased on outright a few years ago is going to be extremely upside down for a while longer.
- sremani 10y agoI am an Volt owner and I approve your comments. GM with BoltEV and Volt has demonstrated they are up with the EV tech, did they make miscues? Yes, no doubt. But the market needs to educated and for now Tesla is the Apple of Cars and the only brand Customers are willing to be educated from. Nissan Leaf had a decent start, but they cut too many corners, and I do not recommend Leaf. i3 is too limited. Even though I whole-heatedly recommend Volt esp. Gen2. The market is not ready yet, and GM is doing what an established Car company does. Tesla's life depends on pushing EVs, so they are who they are.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> GM is investing in what sells, and right now (i.e. for the last decade or two) Yup. They haven't adopted the Andy Grove/Bill Gates/Larry Ellison philosophy of "Only The Paranoid Survive," yet. They are banking on the expectation that if/when consumer interest spikes they'll be able to use their influence to jump to the front of the line, like they did with past ICE competitors. The question is... will the electric car market be more like the ICE market where paranoia is (apparently) unnecessary, or the semiconductor/software markets where it is (apparently) quite important.
- jcfrei 10y agoVery interesting points. So as the other comment has pointed out, traditional automakers will have difficulties selling through their dealerships. Do any of the established players have any plans for their own dealerships / showrooms?
- koolba 10y agoThey can't as the rights to having local dealerships has already been split out. They'd have to buy out their dealers and probably change a bit of State law to accommodate that.
- voidmain0001 10y agoYes. https://www.thestar.com/business/2016/04/19/cinespace-sells-studio-land-to-general-motors.html https://www.thestar.com/business/2016/04/19/cinespace-sells-... GM Canada purchased land in downtown Toronto and made the announcement for a corporate campus with a dealership/showroom. The challenge will be with the existing franchise dealerships that will balk at GM taking a bite out of their market share. edit - The GM official announcements specifically refers to the sale and service of electric vehicles. http://media.gm.com/media/ca/en/gm/home.detail.html/content/Pages/news/ca/en/2016/Apr/0418_Double_Win.html http://media.gm.com/media/ca/en/gm/home.detail.html/content/...
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoI'm about to buy a Volt as soon as VW buys my dieselgate car back from me. I have had to go through a few different dealers to find someone who is serious about selling the thing. The platform looks amazing. It boggles my mind in all the years this vehicle has existed that they haven't made more vehicles based on it.
- Robotbeat 10y agoAgreed. A pickup based on the Volt technology would be fantastic. Electric can allow crazy good torque. And you have a nice big battery, backed by a quiet and efficient built-in generator that only needs to run occasionally, to run power tools off of.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoI'm a small minority market, but I'd love an electric replacement for my 30hp diesel small compact utility tractor. It's a natural fit. The extra weight is a positive not a negative. The tractor is already a hydrostatic transmission in order to get continuous torque across RPMs and some in this market already use an electric motor for hydraulics (powered from a generator via the engine). It's only used for short bursts of activity so doesn't need a particularly huge battery even. But such a product doesn't exist yet :-(
- radix07 10y agoIt is coming soon! Here is a Hybrid ZTR prototype my company has been working on. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J34KU9OG9M8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J34KU9OG9M8
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoThat's nice and I would even consider buying one, but it's not a tractor. Need three point hitch, loader, PTO, and industrial tires. When you (or someone else) makes one with equivalence to about 30 or 40hp for under $30k and, I will instantly buy it.
- michel-slm 10y agoI'm on a work visa here in the US, and I couldn't get financing on a Volt because GM Financial insisted on doing > 30 months lease on their hybrid cars (and my work visa expires before then, though it's likely to be renewed anyway). Go figure. It's not like I can't afford the monthly payments.
- chiph 10y agoDid you talk to an independent leasing company? You don't have to lease via the automaker. http://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-greatest-auto-lease-deal-ever-in-two-simple-steps http://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-greatest-auto-lease-dea...
- michel-slm 10y agoWill bear that in mind for next time, thanks! My other consideration is I am still trying to build a credit history, and don't really want more hard hits on my file than necessary...
- FireBeyond 10y agoSheesh. When I bought a Prius (admittedly, 2007), I was here on a fiancee visa. Toyota Financial had no problem okaying a three year lease even though my visa was (technically) three months (but available for extension).
- michel-slm 10y agoAh, interesting. A colleague had a similar experience to me getting an Audi (his lease doesn't extend beyond the H-1B expiration) so I wonder if the regulation is tightened up by now. Then again, maybe statistically people on fiancee visas are more likely to end up with permanent residency than people on H1B?
- btian 10y agoWhen people claim "best X I've used", they should list all models of X that they have used.
- Robotbeat 10y agoGranted. :)
- zild3d 10y agoIs there something special about the brakes? Less maintenance needed makes sense, but I would have thought the brakes are no different than gasoline cars?