14 ms·
Billions’ worth of high-tech research seeking to make death optional
- andrewfromx 10y ago"Can billions of dollars’ worth of high-tech research succeed in making death optional?" No, because you were never alive in the first place. Well not that in the way you thought you were. Insert Alan Watts quote.
- jodrellblank 10y agoI have a tough time seeing that worldview as anything much different from solipsism ("it's my brain which creates the world as much as the world creates me, it's you who makes the sun bright, it's you who makes the sky blue, it's you who makes rocks heavy - so you can't say anything objective about anything") and nihilism ("everything is subjective and relative, nothing matters, not joy, not torture") and fatalism ("you can't change yourself to be better, because you don't know what better is, and the you which is supposed to do the changing doesn't exist either"). As he says, you start learning that you are one with everything, because you don't realise that you always were one with everything and can never have become separated from it. A skillful person operates on two levels simultaneously. And then he enlightenedly cheated on his wife, married again twice, and drank himself to death. (Which is not to ad-hom his position, but to point out that for all his studying and meditation, he doesn't seem to have had all the answers) Well we do have a label of what death is, and we might have a chance of changing it, and if we prefer that, what does it help to say "you weren't alive"?
- bamboozled 10y agoOk, the OPs post wasn't fantastic, but I have to be honest, the logic you're applying here is a little confusing. If I understand you correctly, you're point is Alan studied Zen Buddhism but didn't take it as the gospel, therefore the original teachings are false. Which doesn't really seem correct to me I'm by no means an Alan Watts fan, it just seemed like strange reasoning.
- jodrellblank 10y agoMy main point was: Alan Watts explicitly said that concepts don't go away once you realise they exist in your head not in the world, and concepts are useful - 'skill' is being able to see both interpretations simultaneously. Well we have concepts of life and death. The parent post saying "you can't put off death if you were never alive" is like saying "you can't take colour photos after you realise the colours exist only in your heads". But you can. It sounds connected, but it's unconnected, it's crossing over two worldviews in one sentence. In one worldview you are alive and can die and can apply medical intervention to try and live longer, in the other view a rippling part of the universe that you call 'medical intervention' connects with a rippling part of the universe that feels like 'you' and the consequence is that the ripple ripples for longer. And it's .. the same thing. You can't really use that view to argue that it can't happen, or that it shouldn't happen. (Intermixed with meanderings about how that worldview seems pretty dismal in some respects, and I don't really get it).
- andrewfromx 10y agoWatts also said you are the Big Bang. Think of an ink bottle thrown at the wall and BOOM ink goes in every direction on the wall, and the tiny little bits of ink at the ends are us. We are the Big Bang, and before it went boom it was 1 solid object. That's the "real you" that can never die. And the illusion you have for 100 years is that you are this separate create called a human with the name John Smith etc etc. but it's all intentional amnesia by the real you. Because, try this, it's absolutely impossible to surprise yourself. You can't sneak up on yourself and go boo and actually be surprised. You need someone else. So, just for fun, the real you broke into different selves. And once you realize this (satori) you laugh and laugh and relax and enjoy the ride to "death" which really isn't death. Therefore drinking lots of alcohol and bringing on this death quicker isn't disallowed. Or 2nd wives or any other sin you want to name.
- omarchowdhury 10y agoThat's quite a leap, to go from finite to infinite. Or, it's not even a leap but more of an engulfing. It is not so easy and I don't think death alone is sufficient for revealing the mystery. But perhaps we can be on a trajectory to that revelation, analogous to how the entire universe is on a trajectory to its eventual collapse. The method is at the heart of religion.
- reasonattlm 10y agoWhat really aggravates me about this article is the exceedingly disingenuous dismissal of SENS rejuvenation research programs it puts forward. The author settles on allotopic expression of mitochondrial genes in the cell nucleus as an example of a project so difficult it is impossible. But allotopic expression is a very poor example to pick for something that is alleged to be "a doomed labor." The work has been accomplished for three of the thirteen genes needed; this is a capability that exists, and is underway towards completion. The allotopic expression of mitochondrial gene ND4 is the basis for a therapy that is currently going through clinical trials in Europe! It exists, it works! Yes, it took effort to get there, effort funded at the early stages by the SENS Research Foundation and those who donated to it, I should note, but so does everything else. This is one of the things that frustrates me immensely about many of the critics of SENS - they willfully ignore some of the progress that has been made, pretending it doesn't exist. Yet their behavior for progress that is so compelling they can't ignore it is in many ways worse. Let us look at what is said - and, more importantly, not said - about senescent cell clearance, something that de Grey and other SENS advocates have been promoting as a path to treat aging for the past fifteen years, on the basis of strong evidence, that they assembled from the various groups who created it across the research community, laid out, and made the argument for. It is right there in the SENS outline; hard to miss, and has been from pretty much day one back at the turn of the century. Senescent cell clearance is a core part of the SENS agenda. Fortunately for all of us, targeted removal of senescent cells has finally taken off these past few years, the evidence for a significant impact on aging has grown to be nigh irrefutable, and near everyone in the research community is enthused. Yet SENS and many researchers' past vocal rejections of senescent cell clearance as a part of SENS is swept under the rug, never to be mentioned. It is unconscionable behavior, and it happens in this article: despite covering UNITY Biotechnology, the senolytics company, no mention of senescent cells is made in connection with the SENS vision. It takes some brass to claim SENS to be a doomed effort and then roll right on in the next paragraph to a discussion with one of the UNITY co-founders on the topic of removing senescent cells to treat aging.
- RichardHeart 10y agoSENS was right, and they're not getting credit for being right, when everyone else was wrong. Let's hope their other predictions come true as well!
- jodrellblank 10y agoHow successful are humans at rejuvenating large codebases back to when they were new and small and fresh? (Without rewrites or replacements) Surely human bodies will be easier to rejuvenate than that, eh?
- du_bing 10y agoThis is the ultimate necessary thing to do actually for human beings. All economics and social activities stem from the quest to live forever, though it's impossible to implement before. But today, technologies have made this promising. Believe me, it's not absurd at all. Think about all religions, they come from the quest to live forever deeply inside human's unconscious, but today, technology and science have become the new religion, and its goal, in fact, is still the same here, because human beings never change much. Combine biology and information theory, I think this can be done before 2500 A.D..
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ashark 10y ago> I think this can be done before 2500 B.C. Uh, I'm pretty sure it's already too late for Gilgamesh. Sorry to give you the bad news.
- du_bing 10y agoSorry buddy, I made a silly mistake, you got it.
- ashark 10y agoThe date coupled with your optimism made me wonder whether the rest of the post was parody. You know, "we have the technology now. We can do this. Why, just as soon as our great God King returns from distant lands of the dead bearing the mysteries of mortality we'll build the proper Moon Temple to achieve everlasting life..." That sort of thing.
- johnfn 10y agoThis comment is hilarious. I don't have any additional remarks, but I wanted to indicate that with more than an anonymous upvote.
- deleted 10y ago
- BadassFractal 10y agoProbably no better chance for humanity to transcend its current perennial state of warfare and short term thinking than to make people live for a few centuries. Imagine a world where life is precious and they have to live with the consequences of their choices rather than having the next generation deal with their decisions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- M_Grey 10y agoBy the same token, humanity hasn't changed so much that the rich and powerful don't eventually realize the terror of their mortality, and desperately try to buy their way out of it. While it's always possible that this will be the generation to discover the Philosopher's Stone, there is no real indication that's the case. I wish I could agree with your rosy outlook, but my view of a realistic form of immortality is in line with Richard K. Morgan's vis a vis 'Altered Carbon'. People keep looking for a technology to change us as humans, but we're going to have to do it ourselves, and soon, or die. Technology doesn't change our nature, it just empowers us to act more freely on it.
- BadassFractal 10y agoAt the end of the day the impetus behind the desire to extend life doesn't matter. If the outcome is that we are around for centuries at a time, we all win as a species. It's a bit idealistic but it would be wonderful to have truly wise people in power who have to care about the long term for once, even if at first not all of the masses get to live much longer. Right now life is so short that by the time you barely start getting a grasp of what's going on, it's already time to go.
- M_Grey 10y agoThat's true, but nothing on the horizon is changing that for us in our lifetimes, no matter how desperately we wish for something else. Meanwhile problems with solutions do exist, which could enable our species to be around and civilized for long enough to eventually reach that dream. Our current course ends in death, not immortality.
- notliketherest 10y agoI just think that death gives life meaning and knowing/accepting that we will die is a part of growing more self aware and focusing on the good things in life like family and love rather than the wasteful things. Maybe that's an unpopular viewpoint in the age of technology but I also think a lot of people are scared to death that they spent decades of their life in a rat race and are desperate to get those years back. All the money in the world can't save you from death and time is our most precious resource.
- crusso 10y agoI would happily spend a thousand years contemplating whether or not you're right.
- reasonattlm 10y agoEveryone devotes resources to saving themselves from death each and every day. Every time they go to the grocery store, in fact. If you are willing to undertake that action, you should be equally willing to to visit a physician to push back your day of death by a day, each and every day. There is something about considering alterations in the current trajectory of aging that makes people say strange things. People who exercise to improve their health span, people who visit doctors to prolong their health span, people who put off death in hundreds of small ways, constantly, all the time. But suggest that perhaps aging should be modified, and people who are 100% supportive of ending heart disease and Alzheimer's suddenly develop a deep philosophical attachment to inevitable death on exactly the current schedule for inevitable death. Seems a little suspect.
- jodrellblank 10y agoEating is pleasurable and I have a biological drive to do it. I have no such drive, nor pleasure association, with visiting a physician.
- ENGNR 10y agoDeath comes for all, and I agree the finite span helps to give meaning, but maybe the 'when' doesn't have to be correlated to biology
- ronilan 10y ago"Mama always said, dying was a part of life" -- Forrest Gump https://youtu.be/nFvASiMTDz0 https://youtu.be/nFvASiMTDz0
- ganfortran 10y agoAnd Why It Is Investor-baiting Bullshit(newshacker.com)
- _rpd 10y agoOr rather, humankind's quest to not die quite so very quickly.
- ganadiniakshay 10y agoI actually believe its highly important we achieve this sooner rather than later. Because we are currently limited by death for a lot of things. One example is Inter-Planetary Space Travel. If you could live longer then you can travel farther and explore more.
- rublev 10y agoAs if it's not going to be exclusively available for the ultra billionaires. Immortality will be the final divider of the classes.
- myhf 10y agoNonsense. The promise of natural death for ultra billionaires is the only thing protecting them from the guillotine.
- philipkglass 10y agoIt's not going to be exclusively available for ultra billionaires, if it is possible at all. There are lots of things that would be powerful advantages if only a tiny elite had access to them: vaccines, antibiotics, anti-retroviral drugs, digital computers... but if a thing is demonstrated possible at all, others will figure out how to do it again. And if the first inventors refuse to sell or share the technology it will just be spread by the second or third group to figure out the trick.
- jacquesm 10y agoAlready wealth is a big factor in longevity.
- ekianjo 10y agoI don't think they will conduct clinical trials on ultra billionaires only. THere's not enough of them to know if it works...
- rwallace 10y agoConsider the cost of polio vaccine versus the cost of keeping a polio victim undead for a year in an iron lung. It's ineffective medical treatment that really costs. Even if you don't care about human life, even if money is your only preoccupation, we need life extension technology to stop the cost of end-of-life care from bankrupting modern society.
- philipkglass 10y agoSome of these "benefits" of death are just ridiculous. If you don't like a long life you can always end it. It's not like anyone is going to invent mythology-grade immortality and then chain you to a rock to be tormented by an eagle tearing at your liver. I don't expect that anti-aging research is going to significantly extend my own lifespan or healthspan. Biology is really complicated. But that doesn't justify sugar-coating age related morbidity and mortality. They are really bad. The only thing worse than death is great pain. Old age deals out both: pain and death. It torments and finally kills you. People trying to defeat death may be delusional about their prospects for success, but they are at least trying to do the best thing humans have tried to do in generations.
- AQuantized 10y agoIf you are under 40 I don't think the prospect of a fair amount of additional healthy years as a result of this research is a particularly delusional one. Actual immortality seems unlikely to me, however.
- fratlas 10y agoI feel anyone born post 1980 has a shot at slowed-aging, maybe even reversed for post 2000's. No data, just a hunch on the pace I've seen from the biotech sector.
- hueving 10y agoAs someone disconnected from that industry, I don't know of the major breakthroughs since 2000. Do you have have a "biotech advancements in the last 15 year executive summary"?
- 6nf 10y agoWell for one thing, around 2000 we completed our first human genome sequencing effort of Craig Venter's genome at a cost of $3 billion over 10 years. Today we can sequence an entire human genome for about $1000 in a few days, and we've sequenced thousands of genomes including all kinds of cells and organisms that affect human health. We're generating craploads of very valuable data just waiting to be explored. We can now take data from a computer and synthesise DNA for a cell from basically nothing, load that DNA into a 'blank' cell and start it up, making it grow and replicate - almost like making life! We can use CRISPR/Cas9 to accurately cut and paste active DNA anywhere we want with high precision. All these tools are ready, we just have to work out how to use them
- Chinjut 10y agoWhen finally science unlocks the secret of immortality, they'll raise the retirement age correspondingly…
- josephg 10y agoOfficial retirement age? Once you build up some passive income sources you can retire whenever you want. And you can do that as simply as having a nest egg sitting in an investment portfolio.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- waqf 10y agoBecause immortality is quite plausible, but the idea that your portfolio is not guaranteed to continue to return an inflation-adjusted 4% over the long term is inconceivable.
- usrusr 10y agoIn other words, you expect post-immortality born generations to work for you forever? You'd be lucky if you lived to see more than one revolution.
- josephg 10y agoI expect automation to replace most human jobs. At some point in the future we'll move to a universal basic income funded by the work robots do. I think we'll be forced to. Automation is already displacing massive numbers of workers. The Economist argues[1] that the current rise of populist leaders is partially a result of this. People in poorer areas are angry at offshoring and trade for the lack of jobs, and vote for Trump and Brexit to fix it. [1] https://twitter.com/theeconomist/status/835429157475528705 https://twitter.com/theeconomist/status/835429157475528705
- owyn 10y agoOh, it's just that easy? And I can do it whenever? I just need a nest egg? What is that exactly? Oh, but I also need a passive income source? That's all? So explain how exactly does "anyone" pull this off, or explain how there a massive gap which prevents most people from doing this. Bonus points for explaining how one or the other situation is better.
- nsxwolf 10y agoJust don't forget - eventually the universe dies, and your immortal body along with it.
- projektir 10y agoI never understand why this always gets brought up. Yes, let's worry about the universe dying after a few billion years when people are currently dying at ~100 if they're lucky. Talk about scale mismatch.
- noonespecial 10y agoI think it's because existentially, it doesn't really matter if you live 80 years or until the final heat-death of the universe. When you get to the end, you'll still want to live longer and marvel at how fast it all went by. The miracle is that we existed at all, and that we recognized ourselves (or whatever consciousness is). Next to that, duration is insignificant. A scale mismatch.
- Aron 10y agoAmy Wagers, a researcher at Harvard, told me, “Part of the meaning of life is that we die.” I wouldn't want to live forever if I had to keep hearing this.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI'd happily wait until all who keep believing that die of old age.
- petecox 10y agoIf the ages of dogs and cats don't increase accordingly, the smart money would be on domesticating longer lived species of pets. e.g. Tortoises live up to 2 centuries. I'm only in my forties and I've buried 5 pet cats already! I'm not sure I could live to 130 and go through the trauma of outliving quite a significant number more.
- hwillis 10y agoMore likely would be parrots, which can in some circumstances outlive humans, and are much more intelligent and social than tortoises. Unfortunately most birds are fundamentally fractured in their braincases and they are insane uncontrollable maniacs. They act like they are controlled by a twitch stream. https://np.reddit.com/r/AnimalsBeingJerks/comments/42vlvs/neighbourhood_bullies/czdvkhl/ https://np.reddit.com/r/AnimalsBeingJerks/comments/42vlvs/ne... "A side note, I am fully convinced that ALL cockatoos are insane. They are fun to own, they are adorable to watch, but deep inside that tiny feathered skull is a scratched, perpetually skipping warped record playing the soundtrack to Silent Hill backwards. If you could experience the brain of a cockatoo first hand, you would probably feel like you had dropped 1,000 hits of premium acid and boarded the scariest roller coaster ever imagined. I love each and every one I have ever met, but they are ALL insane."
- lawless123 10y agoor just make your dog immortal.
- a-guest 10y agoSupposing an incredible anti-aging pill is invented, what do you suppose the chances are the pill-taker begins to feel like one Bilbo Baggins? "I feel thin, sort of stretched, like butter scraped over too much bread."
- jupiter90000 10y agoWhen I see things like this, I'm reminded of a story an old co-worker told me who was a war veteran years ago in his home country. He and many others were made to go to war for their country and risk their lives. However, those who were wealthy and/or well-connected could find ways out of being compelled to go into the military and risk their lives. One of the wealthy, well connected young men he knew who got out of going into military was killed getting hit by a bus in an accident. The guy telling the story actually went into a bloody war seeing people get killed around him, yet he somehow was alive today to tell the tale. What's my point? I don't think it's pointless to research life-extending technology. It seems like some forms of death couldn't be avoided 'post-hoc', if one had a particular accident or the like, no matter how many resources were at your disposal, however. I guess lowering the overall probability of dying of 'something' in general would be nice though.
- mr_overalls 10y agoI agree. Even if you conquer conventional biological aging via nanobots in your bloodstream or whatever, you'd still be vulnerable to random space elevator accidents, particle beam malfunction, etc.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt's still better to have an option of dying than to have a certainty of dying[0]. Also, avoiding accidents and even malicious actions becomes an engineering problem to be solved too. Maybe we'll end up having mind backups, so if you die in that elevator, you'll get restored from last night's copy into a freshly-grown body? -- [0] - sure, when lifespan approaches infinity, the probability of dying due to external factors will approach 1 anyway, but it's still better than having your lifespan capped at 120 years or something (last decades of which barely qualify as living).
- mr_overalls 10y agoRight, I agree that pursuing life-extension is worthwhile. Even living a few more decades at the height of our productivity would benefit society immensely, given how long it takes to train humans to be experts at anything. I'm just trying to inject a little reality into the more starry-eyed Singularitarianist fantasies about living for millions of years among the stars as an uploaded member of a hive-mind or something. I'm not a "deathist" by any means, but I accept that one day, it is overwhelmingly likely that my consciousness will end.
- jinfiesto 10y agoOn a large scale, I don't have any objection to seeking to end human mortality. However, I'm skeptical of our ability to maintain a functional society given the existence of immortal humans. I can't even imagine the levels of inequality when portions of the population can live forever. Never mind the ethics of figuring out how to dole out immortality, and to whom.
- mikemike5000 10y ago"In an age of explosive development in the realm of medical technology, it is unnerving to find that the discoveries of Salk, Sabin, and even Pasteur remain irrelevant to much of humanity." -Paul Farmer
- Animats 10y agoWhat the article doesn't discuss is genetic engineering to make longer-lived humans. That's more likely to work than a rejuvenation scheme. But it's a tougher sell; it benefits only the unborn. A major genetic redesign might require generating a new species, one that doesn't interbreed with old-style humans. Or maybe several new species; Squibb people and Novartis people might not interbreed. That's a social problem for 50-100 years out.
- jlebrech 10y agoonce we have a 3d cancer detection, we can gamma ray cancer out. and take telomere enhancing pills. also we could replace our limbs and nonessential parts so that there are less biological parts to get cancer or get old.
- apapli 10y agoThe financial impact of this is an interesting angle to me. Considering that many of us hope to retire (or at least not have to work a stressful job) a lot of effort goes into saving up enough money to last just ~20 years after finishing work. I'm not sure how most of us would be able to ammass sufficient wealth to be comfortably retired even for 60 years (ie live to "just" 120-130 years of age).
- lumberjack 10y agoIf you have to worry about that you won't be able to afford these treatments anyway.
- kasparsklavins 10y agoStrangely, this is both reassuring and scary at the same time.
- SkyMarshal 10y agoThe point of longevity is that you retain your mental and physical facilities far longer, so it's almost a certainty people would continue working until the last ~20 years of their life, just like now. You'll still only need to save for the last ~20yrs of life, but you'll have a longer time working during which to do so.
- sebnap 10y agoRead up on Near-Death-Experiences, go with the natural and relax.
- phkahler 10y agoOne of the recent discoveries is mentioned: He praised their work with enzymes that help regulate aging; with teasing out genes that control life span in various dog breeds; and with a technique by which an old mouse is surgically connected to a young mouse, shares its blood, and within weeks becomes younger. When I originally read about that work I pictured some people with money and no moral compass kidnapping children and getting a similarly minded surgeon to perform the procedure on themselves. A recent spike in child trafficking could be a direct result of this. It makes for the most frightening villain I can think of. So lets hope they figure out how to get these benefits without grafting the young onto the old sooner rather than later.
- djyaz1200 10y agoUntil science has an effective solution for male pattern baldness I think the idea that we're going to be able to cheat death is premature. (...and please don't troll me and say Propecia or Rogaine, I used both and I'm still bald)