18 ms·
Reasons YouTubers keep imploding, from a YouTuber
- okket 10y ago.
- macspoofing 10y agoExcept in this case the content creator is not the product. YouTube's business is to sell ads to YouTube viewers not YouTube creators.
- DoctorOW 10y agoYoutubers are product to viewers, viewers are product to advertisers
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Pxtl 10y agoStill, it does highlight how YouTube sabotages the quality of its own platform by accidentally creating pressure to post at super-high frequency. As a YouTube viewer, I'm actually quite annoyed how confusing its user-interface is. Google is so proud of their AIs that they make it extremely difficult to just get a dumb feed of "what's the latest posts from the channels I follow"? The system really wants you to explore their content and random walk until you've got some guy screaming at you about how Soros and Goldman Sachs are trying to take over the presidency.
- bauc 10y agoThe subscriptions in youtube is definitely broken for me. I use RSS feed for some of the channels as I was annoyed at how the notification count would not match what I had watched or not. That was a pain even with only a handful of channels.
- stonemetal 10y agoOn the left there is a menu the fourth item of which is Subscriptions. Click on that, it gives you exactly what you asked for.
- jcastro 10y agoThat only works for the first video, after that it doesn't play the next video in your subscription list, it plays the next algorithm-recommended video. There's currently no way to "catch me up to everything I've subscribed to" without micromanaging after each video.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- krige 10y agoIt's not implosion, it's just the outrage crowd setting their sights on a new target and gaming sites trying to settle score with the new media.
- curiousgal 10y agoI'd take that on a case-by-case basis. PewDiePie was obviously targeted. JonTron was not.
- jrkatz 10y ago'outrage crowd'. Huh. right now, the big blowup is over some guy ('jontron') spouting racist BS. This is bad enough in front of an adult audience, but in fact he is performing this for children. Shouldn't we be mad? For PewDiePie recently, the same story: He is an adult (who should know better) performing antisemitic jokes for children, who might not follow the joke were it funny. When they don't follow it, when it's not funny -- it wasn't -- it boils down to a respected figure repeating anti-semitic talking points to an adoring audience of 14 year olds. Did he mean poorly? Maybe, maybe not. If he didn't mean poorly and it was all environmental factors, "He's just trying to make a living and YouTube culture doesn't give him time to test jokes", are we supposed to apologize for him and move on? I say he took on a responsibility and failed it, so we should be angry. If he wants to perform for children he needs to respect the fact that his words have exaggerated consequences because he's dumping them into impressionable, insecure minds. Don't reduce me to some 'outrage crowd' and write me off when I'm concerned that a children's performer is feeding them rape & jew 'jokes'.
- nailer 10y ago> For PewDiePie recently, the same story: He is an adult (who should know better) performing antisemitic jokes for children, What? Pewdiepie was seeing what people would do at fiverr for five dollars. Most of the jokes were him being rejected. The joke is very clearly not at the expense of Jewish people any more than, say, Nazis doing stupid things in Indiana Jones movies is.
- jrkatz 10y ago
- jonstewart 10y agoThis is so far outside my realm of experience I do not know how to read it. I have not been hearing a lot lately about the Pew Die Guy, nor do I know who the Fine Brothers are. There are lots and lots of algorithms and data structures to learn about.
- 542458 10y agoLet's Plays are videos where people play video games and commentate over them. Fivrr is a site where people can offer small services for about five bucks. Pewdiepie is a famous youtuber who produces lets plays. He got in trouble for playing some indian men on Fivrr to wave around signs with racist messages on them on camera as part of a joke. It understandably didn't go over well and lots of people wrote angry articles about it. The Fine Brothers produce videos where people "react" to things. So you might show a bunch of kids the twist from some movie, and show their reaction to it.
- thieving_magpie 10y agoThat was a long article that could be summed up by: "Sometimes people say stupid things. Most don't record and publish it for the world".
- 542458 10y agoI thought there was lots of good insight on how youtube pushes creators to operate at a breakneck pace, how this is at odds with what makes comedy work or not work, and how companies aren't willing or able to provide editorial support (perhaps for fear of killing the golden goose) for these youtubers, unlike traditional celebrities.
- kiba 10y agoOne of my favorite youtuber only publish a new video like once a month, and he doesn't talk in the video, ever. I suspect he's the exception to the rule, though.
- slazaro 10y agoPrimitive Technology, I presume. It's a great channel.
- pdelbarba 10y agoI imagine this mostly relates to the super mainstream channels that pump out content of the same quality as the random TV shows of years past. If you follow the niche channels (that are IMO more fulfilling) like mikeselectricstuff or flightchops or whoever, they operate under different rules. Their audience will seek their postings because they want the specific content.
- FilterSweep 10y agoI was disappointed to find out the laser-focus was on scandals related to youtube celebrities, and not on the infrastructure youtube has that creates youtube celebrities. The author mentions Game Theory (another youtube channel) which has some videos that delves into these mechanics instead. My fear with Youtube as a casual viewer is that content creators (such as the author) are too focused on scandal with other channels they themselves are friends with and not focused enough on keeping engaging content and/or keeping engaged with the fans who made them money in the first place.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoUnrelated, but am I the only one who can't believe how bad both the app and the website are from an experience perspective: Website: 1. If my google home is playing music in my kitchen, I can't watch videos. It just cuts them off and gives me a licensing error. Instead it should just downgrade me to ad-driven youtube. 2. Most videos have huge 'annotations' that I can click off, but automatically get clicked back on for the next videos. Its usually people begging for you to subscribe to their channel. Its almost never to annotate anything and even if it was, the UX is terrible. It should be something I call up, not something that blocks the video content. 3. In-video ads. On top of the ad to watch the video I now need to be pestered with this little pop-up adds their ruin immersion. Oh I have youtube red, but I get these anyway sometimes. I imagine this is just a bug but even then they're a terrible experience for non-youtube red subscribers. 4. Audio quality is often terrible. Not sure if its the video itself but even the official music video channels usually have audio that sounds, at best, like 56k MP3 streams circa 2002. App on Android 1. Holy hell is is slow to startup. Worse, if you accidentally hit a youtube link and try to press back, you need to press the back arrow about 3 times before it responds. Its probably my slowest app. Meanwhile an mp4 served from imgur is near instant. Heck, even a big ugly gif starts up much faster. There should be no scenario where a 100mb gif starts up faster than a 3mb youtube video. 2. Autoplay of next video means that if I'm reading the comments and if the video ends then it wipes the comments I'm reading and replaces it with the description of the new video. 3. Quality seems variable even though I'm pegged to the same 50mbps wifi connection at home with full bars. Not to mention, the comments ranking system encourages 'hilarious' jokey comments over the more serious content. Youtube comments are usually terrible but for less popular videos they can be insightful, the problem is that the top 5 or so comments are either jokes or fairly obvious trolling attempts. I wish someone wold disrupt this space but I imagine the deep pockets you would need to host all these videos on top of the legalities of it all means that only the top 5 tech companies would be able to compete and they're just not interested. I imagine the margins are fairly low here.
- Pxtl 10y agoomg this. The YouTube android app is a disaster. Incoherent, poor propagation of what I've watched between devices, no obvious UI for how to stop watching a video (back button just thumbnails it so you can navigate - you have to swipe-sideways the video to actually close it), and it locks up for a long time starting up a video. Also, the fact that vertically-filmed cellphone videos don't fill the screen when you try to watch them in portrait mode is so bone-headed it's actually funny.
- minimaxir 10y agoIt's worth nothing that this article was posted a month ago: since then, there was another incident along the same lines where popular YouTuber JonTron imploded for the same reasons as described in the article. Jim Sterling has the most objective take on the sequence of events: http://www.thejimquisition.com/youtubers-say-the-darndest-things/ http://www.thejimquisition.com/youtubers-say-the-darndest-th...
- ForRealsies 10y agoHas JonTron's popularity gone down? I don't follow any of it, I just heard he was dropping red pills. Which is more than I heard of him before.
- minimaxir 10y agoAs typical for these type of events, a relatively small proportion unsubscribed, which was completely counteracted by latent user growth in a couple weeks.
- fein 10y agoHow far we've come that citing common statistics counts as dropping red pills. I don't have high hopes for how we look back on this period a few years into the future. Many people with their head stuck in the sand.
- thraway2016 10y agoHN is one of those odd places where supposedly rational people simultaneously believe that A. The theory of evolution is likely correct, and B. Evolution magically stopped operating on human population groups about 50k years ago. And that while animal and plant subspecies differentiated in the span of a few thousand years vary measurably on various innate behavioral and physical characteristics, human population groups are COMPLETELY exempt from evolved behavioral propensities. Because magic, or something. To not believe in magic is, of course, racist and evil.
- 10y ago
- kriro 10y agoSo errrrm...am I completely out of touch with the world for not knowing who PewDiePie is (or what the incident referenced was)? Why not explain that in the beginning? There's a link later but I kind of went through most of the article blindly.
- Raknarg 10y agoHe is the largest youtuber, he has like 50M subscribers. Did a bit pretending to be a nazi that people took out of context alongside some other things, became a huge stupid controversy.
- evilDagmar 10y agoIt wasn't taken out of context. It was an awful thing to do.
- Insanity 10y agoYou were not alone in this. I read about him some weeks or months ago because of some newspaper that features a 'scandal' about him. IIRC something about Disney dropping him from their network (did not know they had a youtube network, and I'm not entirely sure if I remember that correctly).
- 542458 10y agoI'm going to copy/paste a bit of a comment I made further down: Let's Plays are videos where people play video games and commentate over them. Fivrr is a site where people can offer small services for about five bucks. Pewdiepie is a extremely famous youtuber who produces lets plays, and is especially popular with younger audiences. He got in trouble for playing some indian men on Fivrr to wave around signs with racist messages on them ("Death to Jews" IIRC) on camera as part of a joke. The joke was delivered extremely poorly, and even in context it just seemed really scummy. It understandably didn't go over well and lots of people wrote angry articles about it. It ended up with Disney, who were affiliated with him, disavowing him and ending that affiliation.
- tonymke 10y agoThe reason this guy went on multiple racist and antisemitic tirades - including a debate where he goes off on the terrible consequences of a world where whites aren't the minority - is ~it's hard to get in the YouTube sidebar~?
- and0 10y agoThis article was about PewDiePie's nazi joke, the JonTron thing happened more recently (article is over a month old).
- KirinDave 10y agoSure, but Jontron thinks it'll raise his revenue to ally with Sargon and have that tirade. He even said so. He's under the impression that the viewers who give him revenue are all white nationalists.
- greenhatman 10y agoProbably a lot of PewDiePie's appeal is his uncensoredness. It's just unfiltered non-sense for the most part. Some people can't deal with it. But a lot of people want it. Personally, I think that's why I love Dave Chappelle so much. He seems to be able to get away with a lot as well. Few things relaxes me like someone making jokes with no filters.
- djrogers 10y agoDon't mistake uncensored for unfiltered - Dave Chappelle probably writes and tells a joke a hundred times before you ever hear it, and it gets filtered through a LOT during that time.
- johnnydoe9 10y agoNice example since his recent stand up routine is getting a lot of flack for supposed anti-LGBT statements (I haven't seen it yet so I can't say if they have any value). With regards to the Pewdiepie case I am on his side here the quality of jokes doesn't matter it was pretty clear that they weren't meant to be taken seriously and that should be it.
- ben010783 10y agoHe certainly does practice a lot. He still talks about bombing on stage in his newest standup. One of my favorite bits is how he talks about Michael Richards imploding on stage: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kth0UOU5a_M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kth0UOU5a_M
- and0 10y agoWent into the article expecting it to be silly, but there were actually a ton of interesting insights, especially about how no one knows how to manage these celebrities. Also, slowbeef is being humble; he literally invented the LP and curated the scene forever ago. His Metal Gear 2 annotated playthrough (from the mid-00s at the latest, I'm remembering HTML tables) was absolutely hysterical (at least to my teenage self), and was the only way I could read the earlier plot to that series at the time. He's also been able to figure out how to hack ROMs for translation that nobody else could and ran translation projects, like with Policenauts. He's a hero in the gaming community and totally underrated, so I'm always upset to not hear his name come up more often when people discuss Let's Plays.
- minimaxir 10y agoslowbeef is more recently known as a part of the Retsupurae duo (https://youtube.com/user/retsupurae https://youtube.com/user/retsupurae), a channel that I've been following since 2011 and has maintained high quality videos the entire time. (they used to riff on Let's Plays, but now they mostly riff on Flash games/Kickstarters) My personal recommendation is the Negotiator series of riffs: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLo4M1tlpv9ruM7k2Pr_0auqL8IveRE5gl https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLo4M1tlpv9ruM7k2Pr_0auqL8... On his personal channel, slowbeef has been streaming ROM hacking as well: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-DNICST8Zbw9ytaMAl66Ghzx5l-nbOj3 https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-DNICST8Zbw9ytaMAl66Ghzx...
- blhack 10y agoTo anyone who was initially confused here, "LP" means "Let's play" (watch somebody play videogames), not "Long Play" (record). I didn't think I was that old...
- Mithaldu 10y agoThere is ALSO a Long Play category for games, which is videos that do a full play through of a game with zero commentary, and in as few segments as possible. (Many longplays are just one video.)
- 6stringmerc 10y ago
- jccalhoun 10y agoI don't really watch any of the youtube or twitch personalities but I am aware of them. So from my perspective it seems like these are people in their 20s so it shouldn't be surprising that they make bad choices. That being said, they are bad choices and they should be criticized for them. I think the article makes a good point that it is kind of amazing that Disney bought Maker Studios but doesn't seem to be putting in the work to make sure their employees don't do something stupid.
- raesene6 10y agoI've been watching Youtube vids for a long time (well relatively, like 10+ years) and it's one of my primary forms of entertainment. It has been very interesting to see youtubers come and go, a lot of them seem to burn out on the schedule of trying to produce content regularly, which I can understand, anyone who's edited videos would realise the time it can take to produce something of good quality. Pewdiepie is an interesting case as he's far and away the biggest "real" channel on youtube (i.e. not VEVO or one of the generic youtube channels). https://vidstatsx.com/PewDiePie/youtube-channel https://vidstatsx.com/PewDiePie/youtube-channel gives you an idea of the size, he regularly gets 5-10 million views a day! The controversy seems very click-baity to me, I read the articles and watched his response videos. It seemed to me that he made some pretty bad taste comments (if you've seen much of his content that shouldn't be a surprise) and the WSJ deliberately sliced it up to take it out of context and produce the most sensationalised headline possible. All reminded me of the quote generally attribued to cardinal Richelieu. "If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him."
- pm90 10y ago> "If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him." I really don't think what he did was "honest" i.e. not meant to be provocative. As many sibling comments have pointed out, if you're making a living as a public personality, you kinda have to accept a higher level of scrutiny simply in order to avoid media hit jobs.
- raesene6 10y agoOh I wasn't suggesting that what he said wasn't meant to be provocative, the main instance they picked up was ill considered and in bad taste, but then if you watch any of his other videos this really shouldn't be a surprise. The hit job was some of the other items they'd cut together to make the "anti-semetic" charge stick. One item where he was comparing youtube policies to those of the Nazi's (i.e. casting both in a negative light) the WSJ used as "proof" he was pro-Nazi. that's what prompted my thought of the quote.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoEh....this may be an unpopular opinion but this article is supposed to make me feel really bad for the self imposed "workload" of Pewdiepie. Boo hoo, he's so disadvantaged... he made, from my quick research, something like $15 million last year alone. If $15 MILLION salary isn't enough for you that you have to keep "pushing the envelope" being "edgier" for more and more attention then I think you're probably being greedy and shouldn't really be surprised when you finally push it too far. Maybe I'm the asshole, but I just can't muster up sympathy to empathize with the plight of someone who makes millions of dollars playing video games and making off color remarks.
- empath75 10y agoHe makes enough money to hire writers.
- kmonsen 10y agoAnd a PR person to let him know what is too far and how to handle issues.
- ForRealsies 10y agoHe makes enough money to take risks.
- vlunkr 10y agoI don't think it's supposed to make you feel bad for him. Just trying to help outsiders understand what may have happened. Also, people tend to write off the work that youtubers do (they just play video games for a living!!), but nobody bats an eye that pro athletes can make 6-7 figures playing games. I don't think being a youtuber is much different than running a TV show, except that generally they do all or at least most of the work on their own, creative, technical, business, etc.
- nommm-nommm 10y ago>I don't think it's supposed to make you feel bad for him. Then it was extremely poor writing because I got the impression that was one of the main messages. Maybe there was an interesting message in there but it didn't come through. I agree that making a good, well produced, YouTube video takes a lot of work. I've never seen PewDiePie's videos but they don't sound very good or like they are much work to produce.
- FLUX-YOU 10y agoDoes Google's YouTube group host a line of communication between its product managers and content producers? Is there a service agreement between Google and its content producers around features and site behavior that will impact viewers and paychecks? If not, then content producers are simply in a bad long-term position and they need to start looking for leverage against it, whether it's taking their subscribers elsewhere or getting a seat at Google's table so website and mobile app updates don't start mucking with subscribers getting their content to users. OTOH, as a user, I don't want to be inundated with notifications and especially begging notifications if I unsubscribe to someone.
- fgandiya 10y agoYouTube has a lot of flack for not communicating well with creators. Things only get done if lots of pans are run when the creator makes a video on how limited the channels of communication are with YouTube. I remember Eli the Computer guy talking about how he got two community strikes on some really old videos and couldn't really appeal (I don't think they supported it at the time) it. It wasn't until he made enough noise that he was finally able to get a rep from YouTube. YouTube is a good platform and I can't think of any competitors as good as YT, but they really need to improve communication with the creators.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoDoes anyone here spend much of their usual 'entertainment' time watching YouTube (specifically content creators not TED talks and such)? I started doing it recently just to see what all the fuss is about as it seems pretty common for younger people (and I'm 26 so it's not like I'm old but I didn't do it). After subscribing to a few channels I started watching stuff regularly. Basically if I want to kill 10 mins I'll open up YouTube and there'll be something to watch. I'm committing so little time I don't need to really think about it before clicking (unlike say Netflix). On the other hand when I step back a minute I notice that the videos provide incredibly little value as opposed to usual entertainment sources. I could watch a crappy 20min sitcom and it may be deemed trash but it still has a story and characters it feels like it provides some value to me. I don't get that on YouTube. I've tried a variety of the most popular channels and some other stuff and it's largely memes and clickbait and something I forget about the moment I'm done watching. It seems like a lot of the popular creators don't actually produce good content but instead have managed to built a personality cult around themselves that hooks very young people. I've noticed comments where people praise 'hustle' and 'content' and 'awesome product placement'. Just interested on other people's thoughts on the platform and content. Edit: Thanks for the replies everyone, very interesting.
- raesene6 10y agoIn the Internet scheme of things, I'm probably considered old (43) but youtube is one of my main sources of entertainment. I've got some channels I follow and watch their "show" regularly and others where I'll follow sidebar links if they seem funny. There's a tonne of content out there and a lot of it isn't great, but on the other hand there's also some very funny stuff.
- aembleton 10y agoI'm 34 and I probably spend at lest an hour each evening that I'm at home watching YouTube. I don't watch any fiction on YouTube except for Adrian Bliss [1] who mocked vloggers and actually has story arcs running through the videos. I subscribe to many channels but my favourites are Casey Neistat [2], mainly just from the production quality point of view. Tom Scott [3] because he just covers some very interesting topics. And Techmoan [4] because I also have a fascination with old HiFi gear and his puppet sketches at the end of some videos are brilliant. 1. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChYARX5Yj8CapM-F2Z2vPxA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChYARX5Yj8CapM-F2Z2vPxA 2. https://www.youtube.com/user/caseyneistat https://www.youtube.com/user/caseyneistat 3. https://www.youtube.com/user/enyay https://www.youtube.com/user/enyay 4. https://www.youtube.com/user/Techmoan https://www.youtube.com/user/Techmoan
- foxhop 10y agoThe youtube algorithm and setup is really messed up, but it reminds me of the google algorithm for search. This video shows that crap uploads and clickbait rule youtube. I was actually fooled by these content creators and they used it as an example in their follow up video. It was really eye opening. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXRWGbDfVlw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXRWGbDfVlw I wonder if youtube has or will have a "panda" event.
- oliwarner 10y agoTake fairly normal people doing fairly normal things and then expose them to millions of people who think they're great and who can directly comment to let them know they're great. Or that they suck. Or both. Even the traditional distance-Holywood celebrity model makes people go crazy, but when you're letting people right into your life and they're encouraging you to do crazier and crazier stuff, you're either going to burn out or blow up.
- KirinDave 10y agoOkay, so... occasionally it comes up that I experimented with being a gaming youtuber as a way to escape some of the difficulties I was having with the SV ecosystem. I worked hard, I connected with other famous Youtubers, and bam, I was profitable (sorta) and producing content. Everything in this article about a capricious Youtube is true. Everything in this article about the underappreciated difficulty of producing this content is true. I produced a lot of media, but I easily put 5x hours into it (it doesn't help I play simulation and builder games). Everything about how expensive and difficult that job is is true. And it's also true that the communities of Youtube and their related satellites (a lot of fandom on Tumblr, SA's leftovers, 4chan, Twitter, even obscure stuff like GaiaOnline) are... They're hateful. People will find a reason to hate you. Your fans will pick fights in your name. You'll frequently get criticism from both sides of an issue, and they're not always as cut-and-dry as the PewDiePie Nazi joke cards were. I was threatened doxing by a 15 year old, I called in to the SF police to warn them that I was expecting my workplace to be SWATed because people were mad I was "an ally of the feminazi gay community". But... Folks, at the end of the day none of this really excuses humor about rape, violence, racism, etc. And if you do cross that line because you're desperate or exhausted you do get an out. You can say Mea Culpa, apologize profusely, donate some revenue to charity and people move on. The PDP's particular crisis keeps hovering (besides his degree of exposure) is that he's decided to ally with the unrepentant, openly racist parts of Youtube like Sargon. There is an implication from this article, as I read it, that it's inevitable that people will break down or make mistakes. I agree with this part, but it also implies that we should forgive unrepentant bad actors who effectively say, "It's about the money. I thought I'd make more if I had people put up cards making light of antisemitism." That's not a new thought, and these consequences are not new consequences.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoYou're so right that the modern price of fame / celebrity attention is such a minefield. There used to be misguided or mentally unstable folks who would stalk or take things too far, but I think the amount of power modern tech / networks can be deployed for purposes of, well, being mean online has more real world affects than at first. What I'm saying is that far too frequently by the time a young person who craves fame gets it, they're naive on how the system might chew them up and spit them out, and just as they're getting some valuable experience, their time has passed and they're forgotten to the sands of other failed acts.
- kh_hk 10y agoAre we going to pretend none of this is done, including the article, just for the sake of creating drama and gossip? Maybe I am trying to look too much into it, but it's pretty clear there's a network of content producers behind the scenes of all the famous Youtubers, doing all the editing, selecting 'crappy' thumbnails, and playing the videogames on which the stars will later put their own voice over. Doesn't this make a lot more sense than assuming some youtubers are supernatural and can churn out content by the hour?
- mcguire 10y ago"You need ad revenue if you want to make a living talking over video games, which means views and that means uploads." For some reason, that reminds me of the Four Noble Truths... 1. Life's a bitch... 2. ...Because you are an idiot. 3. So stop being an idiot. 4. No, really, just stop.
- pdkl95 10y agoThe internet has changed the nature of "fame". In the past, you needed to generally buy into fame. To be famous, you needed managers, publicists, etc. Media access was a limited resource that was handed out only to those that met approval. This created in the audience certain expectations about what it means to be famous. Don't treat the audience wrong or do anything too far outside those expectations or face the audience's wrath. The internet changed what it means to be "famous" because the internet is media access. Unfortunately, the sociology of the audience hasn't caught up and often still apply the old expectations. In the past, it was possible to walk away from fame because it wasn't your normal life. Being famous was a job you could (usually) leave. However, a lot of people that have become famous through the internet cannot leave. It was their normal life that became famous. Tight coupling between fame and personal life causes or amplifies a lot of these problems. For a much better explanation, I highly recommend watching Innuendo Studios' video essay "This is Phil Fish"[1]. In spite of the name, it isn't really about Phil Fish. It's about everybody who isn't Phil Fish and how they (miss-)handle internet celebrity. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmTUW-owa2w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmTUW-owa2w
- kppiskingpp 10y agoReasons Youtubers don't realize their Youtubing actually became a business and don't hire a crew (that includes a PR team). Zoella does a good job, she had a breakdown thas was very not problematic, but is mostly very professional. Pewdiepew pewdiepie whatever. he's stupid. fuck that shit. fuck hacker news. fuck you all.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ryanmarsh 10y agoWhat's wrong with just "owning it"? Why do entertainers whose viewers come for edgy jokes apologize for occasionally delivering a joke in excess of poor taste? It seems like most of the outrage comes from non-core audience members. It's a long-tail kind of thing. I'm willing to bet a big portion of any given entertainers' audience is willing to excuse the occasional bad joke for all the funny ones. Some groups have louder voices than others when you make bad jokes at their expense. Why not say, "that's what this channel is about"? There are plenty of twitter personalities I follow that occasionally go on shit posting tirades but I ignore it because everything else they post is gold. Seriously, why not say "fuck you this is what my channel is like if you don't like it don't watch"? You think the people who walked out of Amy Schumer's show in Florida were her core audience? Why'd she apologize? She jokes about how bad her pussy smells. I mean, there's a certain group of folks who love her stuff and they probably aren't easily offended by her brand of vulgarity, but would light their clothes on fire at someone else's. To each his own. Find a niche and unabashedly own it. I mean... it got Trump elected.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoDoubling down on or simply ignoring controversy seems to be the best course of action in today's outrage culture. Look at Trump: He never apologizes for anything, and controversies and scandals slide off of him like they were nothing. It seems so obvious to me that I've been tempted to try my hand at the crisis management business, but I fear a strategy of "do nothing" isn't very protectable.
- CaliforniaKarl 10y agoI'm just gonna quote something from the article: > If there is someone who’s making the stuff you enjoy ..., find ways to contribute. If they have alternate payment systems like merchandise or Patreon, consider it so they don’t have to play the “ad revenue works in volume” game. Do this. I support a number of creators via Patreon, including Daily Tech News Show and Drunk Kids Gaming. If you get value out of the content you consume, please consider giving some value back, using a mechanism (like Patreon or PayPal) where you know that most of the returned value is reaching the creator who's content you consume.
- Animats 10y agoTalking head on Youtube complains that being a talking head on Youtube is a lousy business. Whatever. I've watched a few videos of people talking while playing video games. I usually wish they'd just STFU and play the game.
- smnscu 10y agoThere are plenty of those as well and much more enjoyable, especially if you don't want to put $60 + 20h into a game and just experience the story in the background.
- briholt 10y agoYouTubers aren't imploding, rather they're growing so large that mainstream journalists think they can get clicks writing smear pieces about them.
- fixermark 10y agoIt feels like Slowbeef's take on this is pretty solid, but the takeaway from him seems, interestingly, to be "Hey, this is harder than people think," and not "It's no surprise people burn out or get hit with a huge scandal doing this; this entertainment channel is now oversaturated with amateur content and it's a sucker's game to play without a lot of investment."
- notatoad 10y ago>Now, imagine your business hinges on all these random changes. I have a hard time finding much sympathy for this argument. When you build your business on top of somebody else's business, you get to be subjected to their whims. that's how it works. If you wanted complete control over your platform, you're welcome to host your videos on your own website. And then you can see how many people view them, and the value that youtube is providing. I see Youtube acting as a buffer between the wishes of the content creators and the wishes of the viewers as a big part of their value. I subscribe to a few channels, but i absolutely don't want a push notification every time any channel i subscribe to uploads a new video. that would be annoying as hell, and i'd stop subscribing to channels if that was the default behaviour. But that seems to be what the author of this article wants. For me, the fact that youtube is exerting some control to make sure their channels don't abuse notifications is a great thing.
- almostarockstar 10y ago>On a platform that changes its rules on the fly, all the time. Is there, or has there ever been, a platform that doesn't change the rules on the fly, all the time? I'm not talking about video alone. Tastes in comedy, music, film, and books change yearly. The requirements to become successful on any platform are always in flux and never totally clear. Survivorship bias abounds. Also, I have very little sympathy for anybody making videos about gaming. Mindless drivel. If you can't keep up, it's because the market is saturated and your product or execution is not as good as your competitors.