13 ms·
Germany Tries to Catch Up with Startup World
- gragas 10y agolink is dead
- SyneRyder 10y agoLooks like the whole of Spiegel.de is down currently (503), even the front page isn't working for me, and on desktop the AMP version is redirecting straight back to spiegel.de.
- notliketherest 10y agoWelcome to the startup world
- zubale 10y agoWell, first they will need to learn how to deal with diversity that the startup world requires.
- otheotheothe 10y agowtf are u talking about? Over 16 mio of germans/people living in germany have a migrant background, its the second most popular immigration country after the USA according to the OECD. Src: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-05-20/immigration-boom-propels-germany-past-u-k-in-new-oecd-ranking https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-05-20/immigrati...
- zubale 10y agoIt doesn't mean they are welcome.
- otheotheothe 10y agoI don't know a single person in the german tech industry who gives a shit about where you are from, did you ever live there at all? It doesn't seem to me that immigrants are welcome in the USA either as a whole (disclaimer: i am german working for a NYC company), but the tech community is different there, more open and interested in what you can offer instead of how you look. It's basically the same from my very own experience, your whole argument seems non sense to me, Berlin, Hamburg, Cologne for example are one of the most diverse cities i have ever been to especially when i compare it to South East Asia where i currently life.
- zubale 10y agoI live in Berlin. Did you ever visit the SV to say that immigrants aren't welcome there? Diversity does not mean mixing. You can put a lot of different fluids in a pot and they won't mix. I see a lot of different people here, but except for business (aka money) reasons, there is few mixing.
- otheotheothe 10y agoYou lack reading comprehension, i said in the tech hubs immigrants are welcome more than in other parts especially rural areas. So yes, of course SV and NYC are more open to immigration then the countryside, same as in germany. Compared to SEA both countries (DE and USA) are super welcoming, here in Thailand as a foreigner it's damn hard, i cannot even own a business as a majority owner. Nor can i buy land, it's also next to impossible to ever get a permant residency. Other SEA countries are the same, its pretty discouraging.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kayoone 10y agoI work in the Berlin startup world and i can tell you that probably the majority of people are not german. Lots of new people coming from all over the world, english is the most dominant language. I myself am the only german in a company that has employees from Brazil, US, Canada, India and Spain.
- zubale 10y agoActually immigration was desperately needed by them to rebuild the country devastated by the ww2, that's was the only reason, we all know. But children born there from those people who immigrated to reconstruct their country weren't considered German until jus soli citizenship be adopted (with caveats) only in 2000. It is very normal to see in Berlin for example, German born people who aren't considered Germans, neither have citizenship, only because they are children of foreigners.
- otheotheothe 10y agoThe country has been mostly rebuild by germans itself with a lot of financial aid of course. The 60s immigration wave was caused by the west german Wirtschaftswunder (economic miracle), due to the eastern german wall it was not possible for east germans and other eastern europeans to migrate to western germany. Thus they invited turkish citizens as a lot of manufacturing jobs in the automobile industry and co. needed workers. Stop making up alternative facts.
- zubale 10y agoThanks for the explanation. Can you also explain why the children of those turkish citizens as the example that you pick, aren't considered German citizens and neither were able to get the German citizenship even after being born and growing up as adults in Germany?
- Tomte 10y agoBecause they didn't want to give up Turkish citizenship, probably. Germany severely limits double citizenship. Apart from that I cannot see a real obstacle if they have lived here for years.
- otheotheothe 10y agoYes, there are 2 old concepts which are used by most countries. 1) Jus sanguinis (latin for blood ties or right of blood), this means u get citizenship if one of your parents is a citizen of country X. 2) Jus soli (latin for right of the soil), which means u get citizenship by the territory you are born on. Both countries the USA and Germany nowadays have a mix of those, Germany had 1. back in the day and then introduced 2. over time, also special foreigner laws like getting a permant residency permit quiet eaily after you have been there for 8 years. SEA especially Thailand has still only 1. so it's quiet impossible to get permant residencies till today - but fear not, you can bribe urself in paying money and its called the thai elite card -.-
- Boothroid 10y agoLet's also not forget that lots of Germans today actually have a fair percentage of Russian blood following WW2. I'll leave the cause to the imagination.
- akie 10y agoI disagree that having successful startups requires diversity. Israel is a counter example.
- otheotheothe 10y agoA lot of israelis come to Berlin btw. and vice versa - there's a whole kind of exchange from .il and .de tech workers, not too ure why but i think both sides find the other side interesting. A lot of people in Berlin i know are tech guys from tel aviv. http://www.jpost.com/Metro/Start-up-Berlin-472928 http://www.jpost.com/Metro/Start-up-Berlin-472928 seems to be quiet a common thing.
- m_fayer 10y agoA lot of young Israeli artists and designers are in Berlin too. When I go outside here, what I hear is a mix of German, English, Turkish, Italian, and Hebrew - not a mix I ever thought I'd encounter.
- mahyarm 10y agoViber had/has a big ukraine engineering office and many IL startups open offices in the USA or move there eventually.
- Jean-Philipe 10y ago> Israel is a counter example. What? Israel is one of the most diverse places I have ever seen. Everyone there has origins all over the world.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoI'm not sure what sense of diversity Israel lacks.
- mpweiher 10y agoOn my team, we have 3 Americans, 1 Ukrainian, 1 Italian and 1 German. The whole company was/is like that, though less US-centric (got purchased by a large US company, can't speak for the rest).
- hocuspocus 10y agoSame here, ~1200 people on site, less than a third are German. Engineering teams are mostly foreign.
- Arizhel 10y agoWhat are the pay rates like compared to other countries, particularly the US (outside of Silicon Valley)?
- BjoernKW 10y agoStartups don't require diversity. The first and second wave of Silicon Valley startups were by and large run by white middle class men. In a way diversity can perhaps even be detrimental to a developing startup community. Coming back to the example of Germany, citizens with a Turkish background very often are entrepreneurs and run their own businesses, much more so than citizens with a German background. However, those businesses are hardly ever what you'd consider startups: Fast food shops, food stores, import / export businesses, travel agencies. In summary: Tried and proven business ideas.
- Boothroid 10y agoThere's definitely a trend towards fetishing diversity, as if all you have to do is have a diverse workforce, and success will follow. I halted a hiring process recently because the diversity propaganda was such a turn off. The colour of someone's skin, their accent and the contents of their pants are about the least important things I care about in a colleague.
- harryf 10y agoGoogle Accelerated Mobile Page version - https://www.google.com/amp/www.spiegel.de/international/business/germany-tries-to-catch-up-with-startup-world-a-1140130-amp.html https://www.google.com/amp/www.spiegel.de/international/busi...
- JonRB 10y agoInteresting idea - I've always associated germany with startups for some reason.
- Mo3 10y agoDon't kid yourself. Germany is much less than optimal for startups. I know, I'm German, I had one here. The German mentality and refusal to advance technologically is another huge problem. I live in Bavaria currently, deep into beer county, where the hops for most of the worlds beer come from. People who can reinstall Windows call themselves "specialists" here, their success is largely dependent on social skills and honestly, narcissism. The more narcissistic you are, the more you think you're the shit, people will believe it immediately. Actual skill is not so much important, knowing each other from drinking together, what other people say about you and inflated self-image is much more highly regarded. It makes me wanna puke on a daily basis and I have absolutely no hope for this part of Germany. A few days ago, I found out how incredibly badly the Windows server at our secondary location had been set up by a contractor before my time. No security, no logical file structure, all the good stuff. This contractor was paid 200/hour and selected because he met my boss at the local watering hole and told him about how he is the best technician in a big radius. My boss believes it to this day. I have no hope. Northern Germany is a different topic all together, they have been making some nice advances but yet still the whole foundation around them is stuck in time.
- herbst 10y agoGlad you made this conclusion for yourself. You can not compare bavaria to the rest of Germany. Even thought it is my favorite part people are generally a lot more stubborn
- Mo3 10y agoNot a conclusion, quite obvious. However I have worked in Berlin also and while of course vastly different in regards to mentality, I cannot see how small startups without a lot of funding could even possibly succeed there as well, save a few special ones. Regulatory and tax hell is everywhere and even though local politicans there at least seem to understand the internet most laws still do not.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cntlzw 10y agoMy time to shine. Where shall I start? First of all there is mentality. In Germany people kinda expect you to get a job and push through with it until you go to pension. Changing jobs a lot is often seen as a personal failure. That poor accountant that hates his job and gets paid because he just sits in the same stinky office day by day gets more honoured than anyone trying to change. People here get judged if they start a business and fail. If you are successful then fine. If not, people don't give you credit. Personally I rate the person higher that tries several times, falls, gets up and starts over. Unfortunately that is not the case. Nice example if you are from the USA. Over there it is more socially accepted to get married and divorced often than not at all. In Germany it is quite the opposite. You can't even make a failure in private how could you do that in business? Many business here have roots and are decades old. That whole "Mittelschicht" is build on family owned business. That is actually a good thing and probably one of the reasons the economy in Germany is so efficient, but it doesn't give anyone the incentive to start something. And don't forget Germany is all about bureaucracy. Lots of paperwork and money just to get a GmbH. And a GmbH is what you need to gain trust from other companies. Sorry, there is so much to it. Hopefully there will be some change in attitude. It is already happening.
- Mo3 10y agoThanks! Couldn't have expressed it better.
- harryf 10y agoThe other fun part is getting your office connected to the Internet - Deutsche Telekom will happily take 5 weeks to respond to what should be their most simplest of requests
- kuschku 10y agoDeutsche Telekom (owner of T-Mobile) is the most expensive piece of shit ever, and they take forever to do anything. But that’s intentional. They want to make it as hard as possible to switch, so you never even attempt it.
- 10y ago
- tscs37 10y agoApparently The Mirror was not ready for the sudden influx of readers... Though, on the article, Germany is hardly ready for the Startup boom, the bureaucracy is hell. I have been thinking about going self-employed as a sidejob, boost my student-income a bit.
- moreentropy 10y ago> Apparently The Mirror was not ready for the sudden influx of readers... Spiegel online is huge, that extra bit of traffic shouldn't bother them, see http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/spiegel.de http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/spiegel.de Right now the site is down supposedly because of a power outage in a data center. Can't remember the last time spiegel online was offline, the outage is so high profile that #spiegelonline is trending in .de Right now Spiegel is resorting to publishing on https://www.facebook.com/spiegelonline/ https://www.facebook.com/spiegelonline/
- otheotheothe 10y agoI did, i can only encourage you to try it. I dropped out of University even because of my self employment. I would never look back and change that. There's not much bureaucracy as a Kleinunternehmer (small business owner), depends on the niche you work in tho but for IT stuff and even importig/exporting electronics i never had big issues. I am part owner of a US startup now, we have to deal with as much bureaucracy there...The big thing that makes the US different is that it's way easier to get capital, but there are as many weird laws which differ from county to county..
- cntlzw 10y agoGo for it! I imagine your sidejob will be some sort of consulting? With your Gewerbeschein it takes little bureaucracy and you don't have much to lose. Just be prepared for taxes and the risk of Scheinselbstständigkeit. Don't make the mistage anyone does and ignore them.
- tscs37 10y agoI haven't pinned anything concrete down but I'm leaning towards SaaS, something with low maintenance (hopefully).
- rukenshia 10y agoI work for Volkswagen Financial Services and we actually opened up a completely new department in Berlin (VWFS is usually in Braunschweig) mostly to get closer to the world of startups and interact with them. So it _is_ reaching the big companies here, the Volkswagen Group is starting to have a lot of new departments here in Berlin. It's awesome to see because there are a lot of motivated people within the brand that want to work like this. It also seems like the minds of our managers are changing on the topic and they quite enjoy what we're doing here so far.
- mafribe 10y agoWhat kinds of VC deals are they offering? What are they looking to fund?
- kintamanimatt 10y agoCultural issues aside, Germany needs to make it easy and inexpensive to start, run, and close a business if it wants to compete. At the moment it seems to be a bureaucratic burden. Unfortunately Germany isn't an anomaly in this regard in Europe.
- realPubkey 10y agoI'm currently closing a buisness in germany. It takes about 40hours of work plus 400€ for notary etc. To close a f*cking buisness which had no cashflow for the last 2 years.
- kintamanimatt 10y agoIf you were to do it again in a different country, where would you choose?