9 ms·
The High-Speed Trading Behind an Amazon Purchase
- whyenot 10y agoHere is a link without a paywall: http://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/20170326515/the-high-speed-trading-behind-your-amazon-purchase.aspx http://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/2017032...
- sverhagen 10y agoSorry for the off-topic, but why is this available free on Morning Star, and paid-for on WSJ? Don't assume Morning Star is ripping WSJ, so is the pay wall a lie (for this (sort of) article)?
- Terribledactyl 10y agoIt's syndicated, and morning star is more welcoming than wsj.
- rgbrenner 10y agothe author works for wsj.. both wsj and dow jones newswires are owned by news corp. The article was published on dow jones newswires, which morningstar has subscribed to and is paying for. So the answer is, morningstar has paid for this article.. and they've decided they can make it up using ads or other sources of revenue.
- nodesocket 10y agoWonder how much morningstar pays to syndicate? E.G. how much advertising revenue until they break even?
- SEJeff 10y agoMods can we set this as the URL to avoid the paywall please?
- mcnaughtonrules 10y agoClutch.
- QuadraticFizz 10y agoDoes anyone have a mirror? The article is behind a paywall.
- jeron 10y agohttp://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/20170326515/the-high-speed-trading-behind-your-amazon-purchase.aspx http://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/2017032...
- thinkloop 10y agoIt's interesting to know that products on Amazon might not be the lowest price, or always close. I thought there was more manual price research and setting, like Walmart.
- Animats 10y agoWalmart can't change their prices as fast; humans have to re-label things. For now. Brick and mortar retailers can use radio-controlled e-ink shelf price tags for minute by minute price changes.[1] This hasn't really caught on yet, but the technology is ready. [1] http://www.eink.com/esl_tags.html http://www.eink.com/esl_tags.html
- ftlio 10y agoMy mother used to be a scan coordinator at a grocery store. We have been talking about this eventually happening for over a decade. Although based on her experience, the infrastructure for even letting her know what pricing should be requires a major IT overhaul as well.
- trome 10y agoThe cost and wiring to power eink displays is too much, due to the USD being fairly stable, prices don't change daily/hourly, which would help eink signage for shelving make sense. You essentially either need a power drop to each section of shelving, or you have to replace batteries on every sign through your store every X months or years.
- Spooky23 10y agoSounds like a solution looking for a problem to me. For all of this complexity, Amazon rarely has a significant price advantage versus most retail stores. From a customer point of view, competitive categories have a flea market quality to them. For a company that is usually optimized for customer experience, this is a weird science experiment. IMO, they should make price adjustments less fluid. Require merchants to get to the lowest price as soon as possible, and punish stupid resellers that throw up divergent high/low prices by forcing them to live with it.
- thinkloop 10y agoThe issue is that there is no such thing as "the lowest price", it depends on supply and demand, and either can fluctuate drastically in short periods of time (i.e. surge pricing for uber). The manipulations the article mentions, that exist in all markets, are very rare.
- galuano1 10y agoThere was a low price once, the cost price. But then in todays world, VCs eat the difference.
- maxander 10y agoI suspect (here as with the earlier story about imposter goods on Amazon) that the explanation for Amazon's behavior is that it doesn't have the resources to moderate the system its created. Disallowing price adjustments altogether wouldn't work for many categories- sometimes the price of milk just does go up, and retailers can't always just eat the difference. Disallowing only manipulative price adjustments would require either a sophisticated AI (which would be liable to fail in perverse-looking ways) or an expensive team of human analysts (which would at least only fail in plausible-looking ways.) But until these sorts of issues really start effecting Amazon's bottom line, its not going to touch them.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt's hard to know how it affects them because Amazon is held to a special standard where making money isn't really a thing. I know anecdotally that non-techie people whom I associate with increasingly are wary about Amazon after getting scammed by fake phone accessories or gouged by Christmas toy prices. When you consider that Amazon is moving into new categories where trust is critical, like food, this is going to hurt them. Every grocer peddles trust, "we're good neighbors", etc.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoI don't see what's so special about continuously updating your price as a seller. This happens in pretty much every grocery market in the Middle East or Eastern Europe. I also don't understand how the supposedly fierce competition between sellers ends up yielding prices that are higher than offline stores. Seems the reporter missed the true story.
- tedunangst 10y agoIs it common to see a guy hawking $1000 tomatoes from an empty stall in such markets?
- dx034 10y agoNo but that's also not what happens on Amazon. Prices may double but that's also pretty standard for fruits & vegetables when supply doesn't match demand.
- Laforet 10y agoIt's quite likely that many sellers don't actually have the stock they claim to have and relies on getting them elsewhere in case a large order comes through, which incurs an overhead. My experience in online retail is limited to electronics but this kind of inventory inflation is extremely common. Apparently book sellers do this as well. http://www.michaeleisen.org/blog/?p=358 http://www.michaeleisen.org/blog/?p=358
- michalskop 10y agoWhat places do you have in mind talking about Eastern Europe? "Grocery market" for 99 % of people (from Eastern Europe) is a "shop"/supermarket/mall (think of Lidl, Tesco or Carrefour as examples) and even outdoor markets, if they exist at all, usually have set prices (which may change during the day, of course).
- dsl 10y agoI wanted to buy some mini marshmallows recently, so I went on Amazon. Perhaps because of their resemblance to packing material -- light, bulky, ubiquitous -- I figured they'd be cheap. But when I found the most popular brand, not only did the marshmallows cost twice what I'd pay at my local store, but the price had skyrocketed overnight. Just beneath the placid surface of a typical product page on Amazon lies an unseen world, a system where third-party vendors can sell products alongside Amazon's own goods. It's like a stock market, complete with day traders, code-slinging quants, artificial intelligence algorithms and, yes, flash crashes. Amazon gave people and companies the ability to sell on Amazon.com in 2000, and it has since grown into a juggernaut, representing 49% of the goods Amazon ships. Amazon doesn't break out numbers for the portion of its business driven by independent sellers, but that translates to tens of billions in revenue a year. Out of more than 2 million registered sellers, 100,000 each sold more than $100,000 in goods in the past year, Peter Faricy, Amazon's vice president in charge of the division that includes outside sellers, said at a conference last week. It's clear, after talking to sellers and the software companies that empower them, that the biggest of these vendors are growing into sophisticated retailers in their own right. The top few hundred use pricing algorithms to battle with one another for the coveted "Buy Box," which designates the default seller of an item. It's the Amazon equivalent of a No. 1 ranking on Google search, and a tremendous driver of sales. To see what all this means for the consumer, download the Chrome extension Keepa, which will show you the price history for any given item on Amazon. For the marshmallow listing I had been eyeing, the wild pricing gyrations resembled a penny stock during heavy trading. Amazon's retail business "is like this massive slowed-down stock exchange," says Juozas Kaziuk nas, founder and chief executive of Marketplace Pulse, a business-intelligence firm focused on e-commerce. The usual market dynamics are at work: Sellers entering and leaving the market, temporary scarcity when someone runs out of stock or a manufacturer falls behind, and sellers testing consumers and each other with high and low prices. The vendor of the marshmallows I wanted told me his high price was an attempt to bait competitors into raising their own asking prices for the item. This works because sellers of commodity items on Amazon are constantly monitoring and updating their prices, sometimes hundreds of thousands of times a day across thousands of items, says Mr. Kaziuk nas. Most use "rules-based" pricing systems, which simply seek to match competitors' prices or beat them by some small fraction. If those systems get into bidding wars, items offered by only a few sellers can suffer sudden price collapses -- "flash crashes." More sophisticated systems for pricing are offered by companies like New York City-based Feedvisor, which claims to use artificial intelligence to learn the market dynamics behind every item in a catalog. This system is "set it and forget it," says Barry Lampert, one of Feedvisor's customers and a top-500 seller on Amazon. The algorithm will often raise the price on items in a seller's catalog, to see if other sellers will follow suit. The goal is to maximize sales while avoiding bidding wars that can be a race to the bottom. The result, said my marshmallow merchant, is that the customer isn't always getting the absolute best price, especially compared with in-store retail. But the point of Amazon, he adds, isn't to offer a consumer the absolute lowest price possible; it's to offer the lowest price possible given the convenience that Amazon offers. "Free shipping, " after all, isn't free for the seller. As more sellers compete on Amazon, it's possible price volatility will increase. At the same time, the percentage change in any given price is likely to shrink, says Victor Rosenman, chief executive and founder of Feedvisor. Just as in any other market, the more sellers there are for an item, the less power any one has to affect its price. The rapid growth of Amazon's third-party seller program and the cutthroat competition Amazon encourages mean the mix of sellers on Amazon has changed tremendously since its inception, and will continue to change, says Mr. Kaziuk nas. Initially, it was mostly sellers engaged in retail arbitrage -- buying things from actual stores or wholesalers, then selling them for a higher price on Amazon. Later, better-organized resellers who bought directly from manufacturers piled on. Now, many resellers are feeling squeezed out both by manufacturers, who are more than ever selling through Amazon directly, and by bigger, tech-savvier fellow merchants. The most vigorous competitor to sellers on Amazon is, in many cases, Amazon itself. The merchants I interviewed say it is common for Amazon to notice a product category that does well and begin selling it as well. Amazon may even go further and develop a house-branded version of a product. While the price of a pack of Duracell AAA batteries, for instance, fluctuates from one day to the next, the price of Amazon's own brand of AAAs is stable -- and, as of this writing, costs almost half as much per battery. Mr. Lampert says he worries every day about Amazon moving into his most lucrative product categories, which often happens. That's one reason he maintains shops on other platforms, including those operated by Amazon competitors eBay and Wal-Mart's Jet.com. In the end, Amazon seems to be fulfilling its promise of using its platform to lower prices while expanding the variety of items available to the customer. The question for its partners, however, should be whether or not their own businesses may eventually be disrupted in the name of customer service. Write to Christopher Mims at christopher.mims@wsj.com
- ikeboy 10y agoI've used several repricers, it's a must when selling competitive products with a large numbers of skus. One thing I'll note is that there's up to a 15 minute delay before a price change takes effect. Also, Amazon will often "suppress" the buy box if no sellers have a good price. You can still buy, but there's an extra step needed. "Other sellers", then add to cart.
- berberous 10y agoOff-topic: Am I the only who can never load the comments on WSJ articles? This is across browsers (Firefox/Chrome) and platforms (Windows/Mac/iOS), and even with adblockers turned off. This article says it has 36 comments, so it must be working for most, but I can't seem to figure out why it never works for me.
- pirocks 10y agoWorks for me. Sorry that this comment isn't very helpful. Do you still get the same problem on different network/region/country?
- downandout 10y agoI try to put this on all WSJ articles that make the front page. Here is a direct link to this story that will auto-kill the paywall: https://m.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsj.com%2Farticles%2Fthe-high-speed-trading-behind-your-amazon-purchase-1490532110%3Fmod%3De2fb https://m.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsj.com%2Fa... If you want a draggable bookmarklet that will bypass the paywall for all WSJ articles, go here: http://salzeko.com/wsj/ http://salzeko.com/wsj/ It would be nice if HN would make a change to their link submission code so that it automatically changes WSJ URLs to use the Facebook redirect workaround, since they are the one major site that disabled the Google workaround. But until then we have to do it this way.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoOr pay.
- downandout 10y agoMost people on HN are not WSJ subscribers. Given that the purpose of posting links on HN is to be able to discuss them, WSJ links should either a) not be posted here, or b) they should have a paywall workaround automatically built-in. The entire reason that the "web" link exists is because it was assumed that sites would not risk being deindexed by Google for cloaking, and would therefore disable their paywalls when Google was the referrer. WSJ is the only major site that has chosen to brazenly run afoul of Google's cloaking policy (sadly, they have not yet suffered the consequences). So they warrant special treatment here, and by implementation of the "web" link, HN has already shown that it is willing to assist in paywall bypass.
- jrullman 10y agoThis Chrome extension does much the same thing — https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/xray/dgkdfehohjdbmnldpcegekjakcdjlnkg https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/xray/dgkdfehohjdbm...
- mirimir 10y agoAmazon’s $23M book about flies (2011) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10289742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10289742
- israrkhan 10y agoThis is a very unfortunate trend where sellers are selling not based on the value of the item/service, but demand/need of the consumer. It has been a common practice in airline industry, and upto some extent in healthcare. But now this practice is creeping into online shopping too. This can soon fall into unethical territory. Imagine an item, that costs $1. Just because it could be life-saving for someone, or someone needs it badly, you sell it at much higher premium. You are not charging for your service, but exploiting other people need.
- bognition 10y agoyou've just described capitalism
- pmorici 10y agoOr price gouging. In capitalism if the price rises too high sellers should be motivated to bring more supply to the market.
- alasdair_ 10y agoAssuming the seller lacks a monopoly, that is exactly what happens.
- ubernostrum 10y agoAlso, most people don't really understand how airlines price their tickets, and so assume some sort of "we're watching and will raise the price on you" scheme when there are more mundane explanations available.
- liotier 10y agoIt is called "yield management" : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yield_management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yield_management - it is a commercial technique which is not specifically capitalist.
- an_account 10y agoThat's always been true, nothing new to online shopping. If there's a large profit margin other companies will come in and undercut the price.
- rahilb 10y agoOnce upon a time I worked at an ebook company. We were naively trying to compete with Amazon (i.e. we sold every book we could get our hands on). Sometimes we'd negotiate a deal with a publisher, and slash the price of a book to a point where no one involved in the transaction was making money, sometimes we and the publisher would be losing money... Without fail within an hour the list price of the content on Amazon would be exactly what we set. Amazon were/are prepared to eat the loss: I suspect this is the case for all products that are sold by Amazon. It was a very effective strategy for them. My company went into administration after just 9 months.
- ortusdux 10y agoI once read the account of a student who gamed the bots sellers use to competitively price their products in order to get cheap textbooks. The person made a dummy seller account, setup a bot, and listed the books they needed. As they lowered their listing prices, the real sellers' bots auto-price matched. The student then bought all their books at ~1/10th the original price, canceled any orders they may have received, and deleted their store.
- i336_ 10y agoThat sounds heartwarmingly difficult to police...
- ergothus 10y agoA friend of mine once claimed that Amazon could sell at cost and still profit - they'd charge the customer for an item immediately, but have 30 or 60 days until they had to pay the supplier, so the interest on the payment in the meantime was profit. Not a lot on a $15 collection of toilet paper (for example), but multiple by the number of Amazon customers... Of course, that skips the costs of Amazon staffing and infrastructure, and I'm sure Amazon sells most items above cost (and potentially some below), but I took it as a good example of how the scale involved meant that few can compete with Amazon.
- discodave 10y ago