5 ms·
It's interesting when you extend that discussion to guns, in the UK guns are quite difficult to get hold of, I wonder what the incident at Westminster would hav
by tonyedgecombe 10y ago
It's interesting when you extend that discussion to guns, in the UK guns are quite difficult to get hold of, I wonder what the incident at Westminster would have looked like if they were as available as they are in the US.
As always it's a trade off, some people loose the right to arm themselves at home but that means other people may not loose their life to a shooting.
- darfs 10y agoThere is no other way to use a gun than shooting with it. (Useful! Of course you could use it like a hammer, but... Srsly.) It's whole purpose is, to hurt someone; i think that's some point to acknowledge first.
- ajmurmann 10y agoYou can go hunting with it or shoot for fun or make yourself feel safer. What can I do with encryption other than encrypt messages I want to hide? //Playing devil's advocate
- danieldk 10y agoWell, there are very good reasons to hide messages. First of all, I don't want any company in transit, from my ISP, to the message broker, to the receivers ISP to mine my data and use/sell it for profit. Secondly, there are a lot of messages which are not illegal, but can be personally embarrassing if they were to become public. Think of sexually-tinted messages, psychological help, a kid who lives in a very conservative community and has doubts about their religion, discussions about a candidate for a job position, etc. The problem with backdoor is that the question is not if they are exploited, but when they are exploited. And this is all assuming that the organization that has backdoor access is not of ill will.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ajmurmann 10y agoI had this thought as well. However, the comparison to knives seems better. It's pretty hard to make your own gun. It's pretty straight forward to make your own encryption app on top of existing OSS libraries. Like it's pretty easy to make your own makeshift, large knife. Maybe I just see it like that because I'm a software developer though.
- Neliquat 10y agoIt is not. Smash "home made gun" into youtube sometime. $30 at any hardware store and you have a functioning shotgun.
- Neliquat 10y agoThat would mean the 1st cop he stabbed, who was unarmed, might have stopped it. Its dumb to play whatif in these situations.