10 ms·
Great study. I think this perfectly underscores the concept of what "privilege" is, in a scientifically robust way. I have a worry about one of the implied con
by hn_throwaway_99 10y ago
Great study. I think this perfectly underscores the concept of what "privilege" is, in a scientifically robust way.
I have a worry about one of the implied conclusions, though. The high-status women were clearly discriminated against based solely on gender. However (and trying to tread carefully here), it is at least possible that a high status woman would be more likely to leave for family reasons than a high status man. That doesn't make the discrimination any better, but it also means the employers aren't necessarily acting economically irrationally (of course, there is also the chicken-and-egg problem, in that these high-status women might be more likely to take up a domestic role because they're being discriminated against in the first place). I say this not to give the employers a pass, but to suggest that any real, durable solution to the discrimination shouldn't automatically assume those social factors are imaginary.
- emodendroket 10y agoThe same rationale could be marshaled to argue that discrimination against the disabled and older workers should be allowed. Should it?
- hn_throwaway_99 10y agoBut no where in my comment did I argue that the discrimination should be allowed, and, on the contrary, I believe exactly the opposite. My main point is that sometimes discrimination is not economically irrational. If that's true, but we as a society think that these forms of discrimination are still bad, we need to come up with better, stronger solutions to make sure discrimination of this sort doesn't happen.
- emodendroket 10y agoFair enough. When you put it that way I agree completely.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoWhat you're really saying is that it's rational to be selfish and short-termist. In the long run, everyone benefits if women have the same employment opportunities as men. Women benefit, because duh, men benefit because their female relatives don't depend on them, employers benefit because they have a wider pool of talent to choose from, society benefits because unemployment falls and higher-quality employment rises, and so on, so forth. The "rationality" you are talking about is false rationality. It's rationalisation- an excuse that people tell themselves to justify their inability to give up on the prejudice they've been taught.
- FT_intern 10y ago> employers benefit because they have a wider pool of talent to choose from The OP was arguing that women have a lower expected work output over their career at a company, which is why "economically rational" was used. So the employers would technically be better off hiring a male over a female with the same skills.
- state_less 10y agoValue investors might happily pay ~10-20% higher labor costs to have an inclusive culture that lasts rather than an on edge precarious culture. Being a churn-and-burn testosterone fest is starting to look like it might have some negative long term consequences.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> The OP was arguing that women have a lower expected work output over their career at a company, which is why "economically rational" was used. I was disagreeing with that on the basis that only looking at your bottom line when trying to decide what is "economically rational" is short-termist and self-defeating, because everyone benefits from living in a society where women have the opportunity to be as productive as men- and that includes employers who don't have to look at the gender of candidates to make a decision. The benefits may be harder to measure, but that's why rationality is required, rather than rationalisation of unjustifiable bias ("women have lower expected work output"). The genuinely rational thing to do is to try and ensure that both women and men are equally productive, as workers.
- GuiA 10y agoI got mono last year, and was out for longer than some of my female coworkers who had a child were. Same observation for one of my coworker who got in a snowboarding accident. I've also had several male coworkers leave because they wanted to devote themselves fully to their family. This kind of observation ("high status women are more likely to leave for family reasons therefore it is an economically rational choice to prefer men, given equal skills") seems logical on the surface, but when you start looking into the nuances of real life it just doesn't hold. I once had a CEO say directly to me: "honestly if one of my female employees got pregnant, i would take it personally. We're a startup, we can't afford people who do that". He had no problem pushing several great engineers to burnout and firing them when their productivity tanked though.
- emodendroket 10y agoI'm a little wary of this kind of argument. Let's just accept the OP's premise for a second. If he's right that upper class women really are more likely to leave the workforce, would it make the discrimination acceptable? Personally I don't feel it would.
- GuiA 10y agoSure, I get your objection from an epistemological perspective; I don't disagree. The thing is that then you wouldn't be comparing "upper class women" vs the rest of the workforce. You should be comparing upper class women in their 30s vs upper class women in their 50s vs men who smoke vs single men in their 20s vs ... In that case you might find that upper class women in their 30s are indeed more likely to leave the workforce than single men in their 20s, but less likely than men in their 50s. At that point, the "economically rational" argument becomes to only hire single men in their 20s, which I guess is what Silicon Valley does.
- derefr 10y agoIf corporations want to be prejudiced (because it serves their rational economic interests), you can't just stand there and say "well, they shouldn't want that then!" and expect the world to change. You've got to come up with a system or context in which being prejudiced isn't useful, so that (as rational actors) corporations stop wanting to be prejudiced. And to do that, we first have to come to agreement, in the clear light of day, whether corporations do want that (potentially unacceptable) thing or not. Which seems to be a large problem in discussions like this: trying to talk about the way the world is butts up against people who want to talk only about the way the world should be, and don't want to acknowledge that you have to talk about both "before" and "after" if you want to get from one to the other.
- paradite 10y agoYes. To phrase it differently, if we have trained a perfectly rational AI, it may make the same (biased) decisions against women based on past statistics (percentage of women leaving full-time jobs) and assumption in reasoning (family responsibility affecting career performance) as you described. To change the decision would require changing either the statistics or the assumption in reasoning.
- ohyes 10y agoReasoning that can also justify eugenics or other heinous stuff.
- jimmywanger 10y agoThe opposite reasoning justifies "Harrison Bergeron".
- mrkgnao 10y agohttps://books.google.co.in/books/about/Weapons_of_Math_Destruction.html https://books.google.co.in/books/about/Weapons_of_Math_Destr...
- TuringNYC 10y agoWe are part of society, so I hope we don't "trained a perfectly rational AI" but train something that operates within constraints that we agree upon as a society. A "perfectly rational AI" might also kill of disabled people as unproductive, but we as a society will need to introduce bounds and constraints and objectives in line with our human values.
- icebraining 10y agoNo, assuming that the goal of your perfectly rational AI is to maximize profits, you can change the decision by adding a disincentive for choosing against women. Which is what governments usually do.
- clarebear 10y agoJust so you know, sometimes when women leave for "family reasons", it is because they are sick of putting up with the bullshit of discrimination while trying to balance a career with raising a family. This problem is more of a self fulfilling prophecy than chicken-and-egg.
- mod 10y ago> these high-status women might be more likely to take up a domestic role because they're being discriminated against in the first place You almost quoted him.
- Retric 10y agoReplacing 'might be' with 'are' is a significant difference.
- hn_throwaway_99 10y agoI think it's generally better to propose hypotheses if you're not backing up your assertions with data.
- ntsplnkv3 10y ago> while trying to balance a career with raising a family. As if men don't have this problem...
- Qantourisc 10y agoI suppose it's more socially acceptable that the men neglect the family. (Speculation:) Or men tend to neglect more ?
- briandear 10y agoDefine neglect. Ensuring the family is provided for is the very opposite of neglect.
- 10y ago
- amgin3 10y agoEveryone is up in arms about female discrimination, when really it is the lower-class men who are discriminated against the most.
- rayiner 10y agoDoes that criticism make sense given that the title of the article and opening paragraphs talk about the class disparity, and only get to the major gender disparity in the middle of the article?
- tristor 10y agoI'm not the person you're replying to, so I can't say what they were thinking when they wrote their comment. I'm choosing though to read their comment as referring to the larger social context, rather than this specific article. I would note however that this article is classified under the category "Gender" in the Harvard Business Review.
- emodendroket 10y agoI'm going to take the outre position that both gender and class discrimination are bad.
- clarebear 10y agoThe differences in callback rates were not statistically different between the women and the lower class men. The only statistically significant different was higher class men and everyone else.
- hn_throwaway_99 10y agoI didn't do the stats on it, but just looking at the graph in the article 5 times as many lower class women received callbacks than lower class men. What was the p-value on that?
- PeterisP 10y ago
- omonra 10y agoBut you can same the same thing about pretty much every single stereotype. Ie that's why people use them - because they usually work.
- inopinatus 10y agoI find it economically irrational to exclude or bias against half the talent pool on the frankly ridiculous basis that they might leave later. Everyone leaves later anyway and these events occur beyond the time horizon of anyone hiring at your startup and/or bigco. And yet hiring managers (of all genders) continue to suffer from this bias. I've always just chalked it up to an excuse for sexism.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 10y agoThat's not the case for partner-track positions at white shoe law firms.
- jblow 10y agoIn fact this is a reason to be skeptical of this kind of discrimination argument. If the wage gap is happening and is really so drastic, if women are being undervalued so hard, etc, then there should be a massive Moneyball-style opportunity for people to start companies that correct this error. With the advantages you'd gain by adjusting hiring, you'd completely trounce the competition. This hasn't happened yet though. Either people are being slow to do it, or the wage situation is not as straightforward as it is being put in these arguments.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoIn Moneyball, if your team can play good baseball, you win. If you hire an all-female sales staff, and each employee is technically better in every way than average men, but your customers simply do not want to be sold to by women, then it doesn't matter how good the women are, how many extra skills they have that aren't priced into the market, you will fail. That's the thing with systematic bias: it's systematic. That all said, there is still a way to capture the moneyball-style giant pile of cash (and yes, I do believe it is there. There's one for black people too, and every group we think is less employable for certain jobs than white men): You have to create a feminist company and a feminist market and spin them up simultaneously. The reason this doesn't happen all the time is it's much harder to create a 2-sided market than a 1-sided one. And frankly, due to the systemic nature of sexism, a 2-sided market probably isnt enought. You really need to create an n-sided market. You need suppliers and partners and sister companies and clients all on the same page, at least to the extent that your interface with those organizations is human-rich enough to permit sexism. This is the same reason why anarchist (property-free) businesses have been hard to create, even though the fundamentals should be more efficient than a capitalist company. For it to work you need to spin up n-anarchist companies at once so they can feed off each other. Instead people try to create them one by one, so they fail. They are chewed up by the fundamentally antagonistic world around them... Same as pro-women organizations are. It's a hard startup problem, but we are getting good at solving those. I wouldn't bet against this being solved within 20 years, at least in proof of concept.
- strken 10y agoIt also underscores why there's backlash against the concept of privilege. Lower-class men received the fewest job interviews of all four quadrants. Not only do they not get the job, they also get put in the same analytical bucket as the higher-class men.
- hn_throwaway_99 10y agoJust wanted to say I agree with you, and that's why I think this is such a well done and fascinating study. Privilege does clearly exist in this study, but not necessarily in the patterns that are assumed.
- stefco_ 10y agoI think this is really important to acknowledge. Intersectionality (i.e. subtlety and hollistic thinking) is actually a great way to think about inequity. But a lot of people who are interested in intersectionality are blind to many struggles specific to poor white males (I say this as a relatively privileged person Far removed from that demographic). Poor white males might skew more sexist and racist, but that is largely in response to upbringing, poor education, and poor economic opportunities. It is a big blind spot in many otherwise very liberal people's thinking to exclude poor white males, and that exclusion breeds resentment from a potential ally in addressing problems of inequity (and it contributes to a vicious cycle of racism/sexism leading to exclusion leading to more racism/sexism). Not saying this is an easy fix, but many other liberal people I know seem shockingly uninterested in even treating this as a problem.
- jordanb 10y agoI think it goes even deeper than that. I think for many people poor white men are one the category of people who it's still acceptable to hate. https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anythin...
- fasquoika 10y ago>There is a partly-formed attempt to spin off a Grey Tribe typified by libertarian political beliefs, Dawkins-style atheism, vague annoyance that the question of gay rights even comes up, eating paleo, drinking Soylent, calling in rides on Uber, reading lots of blogs, calling American football “sportsball”, getting conspicuously upset about the War on Drugs and the NSA, and listening to filk – but for our current purposes this is a distraction and they can safely be considered part of the Blue Tribe most of the time Damn that hits close to home
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mozumder 10y agoThe study really didn't get into a comparison of people that didn't put any extracurricular activities on their resume. We don't know if the extracurricular activities themselves hurt or helped the candidates compared to people that don't put any in.