13 ms·
Survival of the Friendliest
- partycoder 10y agoIt happens at every level... we as organisms are made from smaller collaborating organisms: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUfNEHl44hc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUfNEHl44hc
- mturmon 10y agoThis is a really great little video (with references!). The article seems to acknowledge this evolutionary path when it says "Billions of years ago, another ancient cyanobacteria was engulfed and “domesticated” by an ancestor of plants. It shed most of the genes it needed for an independent existence and became what we now know as the chloroplast. In return for a safe environment, these chloroplasts performed photosynthesis for their hosts, fueling a new form of life that eventually spread over much of the Earth." This seems to be talking about the same hypothesis, but I'm not enough of a biologist to be sure.
- awsoutage 10y agoLiberal logic: Write an article about how evolution doesn't always favor though "violent" (read: powerful + assertive) Top the article with a photo of domesticated farm animals… How's that niceness evolution working out for those farm animals? I guess we can ask them on their way to the butcher.
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoClosing sentence: >For those most invested in the old-school Darwinian view of the survival of the fittest and violence as virtue, then, the message is clear: Just relax. Reminds me of the Oppenheimer quote: >It is perfectly obvious that the whole world is going to hell. The only possible chance that it might not is that we do not attempt to prevent it from doing so
- gadders 10y ago>For those most invested in the old-school Darwinian view of the survival of the fittest and violence as virtue, then, the message is clear: Just relax. You can't have laws without violence.
- eru 10y agoThat's not true. Laws can be useful just as a Schelling point, even without any enforcement.
- ajarmst 10y agoNo the message is "that was never the Darwinian view, why don't you actually read his work?"
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoThe message of what?
- mjfl 10y agoI don't see a contradiction between "fittest" and "friendliest", at least in certain contexts.
- zasz 10y agoWell, the point is not that you don't, it's that lots of people who like to talk about evolution don't. "Nature red in tooth and claw" and all that.
- ivrrimum 10y agoRight? The Author doesn't seem to understand that the word "fittest" is meant by fit in the environment. Not as physically fit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dwringer 10y agoOui, I think Monsieur Candie would agree with you there.
- vinceguidry 10y agoEven warfare is a highly collaborative activity. Everything about preparing and engaging in the most violent activity known to nature is governed by cooperation. Training, logistics, tactics, strategy, all of these things are greatly aided by working together. In the wild, the only creatures that can hunt alone are apex predators, of which there are only a handful in any given ecosystem. Every single other species has to band together to eat and protect themselves. That we ever thought anything different is just silly.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y ago> That we ever thought anything different is just silly. Despite having the hindsight of history, people still try to apply Darwinian theory to the social realm at almost every chance...the rat race, climbing the social ladder, or pointy-haired managers invoking quotes from _The Art of War_ or some other general even though they haven't been in any real type of physical altercation or conflict Social insects, pollinating plants, slime molds, pack hunters, etc. It seems to me that the history of life is the history of cooperation as the default state punctuated by selective pressures shocks usually due to a loss of some type of vital resource. Even our smallest functional unit, the cell, is most likely an example of cooperation between the eukaryote and mitochondria. All of our cells cooperating with our microbiome to make us who we are I've come to the conclusion that humanity's greatest asset over other species is our unparalleled ability to cooperate in large scales societies using collective fictions like religion, justice/virtue, and the corporation to give us the motivation and structure for organization. The cognitive revolution kick started this and led to the agricultural revolution and the scientific revolution Yuval Noah Harari's A Brief History of Humankind is a fantastic read exploring this topic. He also did a MOOC on the same subject, but I don't know if it's still available.
- clock_tower 10y agoYou might also be interested in Peter Turchin's War and Peace and War -- which depicts social cohesion as the measure of social health, and internal competition among like-minded members of a society as the beginning of the end. (This is confirmed repeatedly by history, especially Chinese history; I'm also reminded of how corruption and lack of internal cohesion doomed the post-Roman British kingdoms in their should've-been-a-cakewalk defense against the Anglo-Saxons.)
- justinclift 10y agoOpen Source Software Communities relate to this too. Possibly a fairly obvious point to many. :) There seems to be evolutionary (fitness?) pressure, helping shape the Communities, software, their norms, etc. * In areas without proprietary competitors, new proprietary entrants seem to be rare. * In many areas previously dominated by proprietary software, the Open Source alternatives are now often credible if not preferred. This evolution of increasing fitness seems to be continuing. If Open Source Software represents the "mammals" :D of the software ecosystem, what do the walled gardens (app stores, etc) represent?
- Radim 10y agoI don't know -- photosynthesing organisms that generate primary resources? Which resources are then indirectly consumed by OSS (at least its "free as in beer" variant), acting as a parasite in your analogy :) The money has to ultimately come from somewhere, you know, or the music stops. What would software devs do if all the oh-so-evil proprietary software disappeared? Exchange FOSS PRs with each other, until they die of hunger?
- visarga 10y agoThey would make money by using open source tools to implement specific projects for companies and end users. The fact that Node and Mongo exist is of no use, if you don't know how they work together. It takes work and experience to use the open source tools at their fullest.
- Radim 10y agoMake money from "specific projects" that are free open source software? O_o I think you missed the part where a vital piece of the ecosystem, namely proprietary/non-free software, no longer exists.
- justinclift 10y ago> I don't know -- photosynthesing organisms that generate primary resources? Not sure. On one hand, the walled garden approach does seem to have some benefits when done well, of drawing in further resources/development. > Indirectly consumed by OSS Yeah, that could definitely be the case sometimes too. When OSS Communities use offerings present in these walled gardens (eg Affinity Designer, a good vector graphics app for OSX) to further what they're doing. Not sure if parasite is correct :), but it seems reasonable there's some interplay between the produce of the walled garden(s) and the external ecosystem. From the OSS Communities perspective, I'd kind of expect (but am not really sure) that many of the resources used in the walled garden apps come from OSS. eg things like gzip, various other libraries, perhaps graphics (etc). And as a note, I don't personally believe all proprietary software is oh-so-evil. ;) The companies which develop software choose to act however they do, evil or not. The "evil" is in the actions of the companies, regardless of the OSS-or-not nature. That's just my understanding of things thus far anyway. :D
- gfo 10y agoPutting this in the category of "almost seems like common sense, but I never connected the thoughts to come up with this". Let's look at house pets for example - many dogs still exist because of their friendliness towards humans (we feed and shelter them). Same with certain breeds of cats. I wonder what would happen to this ecosystem if say, humans went extinct someday? It's pretty easy to imagine we'll be the cause of our own demise so any of these animals relying on us to survive would probably go with that, but if we disappeared tomorrow I'd be curious to see how they would survive.
- superioritycplx 10y agoThere's been cases of pets eating their owners who suddenly passed away. When push comes to shove, the beast will come out.
- danharaj 10y agoIt's a corpse at that point.
- ajarmst 10y agoAbout every 18 months someone in the popular press feels the need to point out "exciting new research" that shows that nature isn't really red in tooth and claw, but that evolutionary biology even seems to show that cooperation and even altruism can be adaptive! Except that's hardly news. Darwin himself pointed it out. It's nice that we keep confirming it and exploring its complexity, but could we just stop being so shocked by it? If nothing else, explain that the problem is that people have weird preconceived ideas about evolution, not that evolutionary theory keeps getting revised.
- good_vibes 10y agoIt keeps coming up because I believe media is a self-fulfilling prophecy for civilization. As much as we keep being reminded of this truth, we are also SOLD the idea of competing by consumption and status. Social media breeds this mentality more and more while also making the world more connected. There is a lot of cognitive dissonance happening on a global scale like never before right now.
- samirillian 10y agoThis isn't just a social media mentality; it's a capitalist mentality and an American mentality.
- good_vibes 10y agoTrue. I tend to see the world through the lenses of media and technology more and more. I feel they have the largest influence over us. I agree that is this a byproduct of capitalism and America as well.
- gech 10y agoBecause we need to keep reinforcing this in order to override the already established frame that it's dog eat dog and that we shouldn't pay for the healthcare of others or pay taxes etc.
- 10y ago
- ajarmst 10y ago"Survival of the Fittest" was not Darwin's idea. The phrase was coined by Spencer, who misinterpreted Darwin's work. It has since been used primarily to either further misunderstanding or to apply Darwinism to realms like society and race, generally to distasteful or even horrific result. It's a reliable marker for writing that will irritate people who've actually studied evolutionary biology.
- solidsnack9000 10y agoThis passage seems to be deliberately looking the other way: > Our evolution has been profoundly influenced by our selection-buffering behaviors. For instance, the appearance of some modern human features appears to be correlated with a rise in energy consumption, linked to the introduction of meat in our diet. Does buffering ourselves from selection by hunting and eating animals not subject them to more selection?
- aphextron 10y ago>"We’ve taken these metaphors for evolution to heart, reading them to mean that life is a race to kill or be killed. “Darwinian” stands in for “cutthroat,” “survival of the fittest” signifies survival of the ruthless." This is a complete perversion of the intent Darwin expressed with the term "survival of the fittest". Here it is conflated with "survival of the strongest", but that is not what Darwin meant. His point was that any species more able to adapt to change, and thus maintain their level of "fitness" to an ecological niche would be dominant.
- ycmbntrthrwaway 10y agoRelated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_Aid:_A_Factor_of_Evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_Aid:_A_Factor_of_Evolut...
- kusmi 10y ago> peace treaty among interdependent nation It is more commonly referred to as the prisoner's dilemma. This is a strange article, and I'm curious who the author wrote it for. It's certainly not written for biologists familiar with the research she refers to.