12 ms·
Howard University opens a new campus at the Googleplex
- komaromy 10y agoGood. I hope they're looking into a pipeline that reaches these students before they're junior- or senior-aged as well.
- harryjo 10y agohttp://www.gettingsmart.com/2011/03/jordan-lloyd-bookey-k-12-education-outreach-at-google/ http://www.gettingsmart.com/2011/03/jordan-lloyd-bookey-k-12... Examples of Google’s programs include: ● Google’s Computing and Programming Experience (CAPE): This four-week experience is for 8th graders to gain exposure to CS. This summer we will have around 130 students, and we hope to further expand this content to organizations and schools around the country. We are looking to test this new model with MS2 in Washington, DC this summer. ● LEAD Program for Computer Science: This is a rigorous and exciting summer residential program for underrepresented minority students in grades 9-11, held at four universities in its upcoming inaugural year.. ● Trailblazer Award: This is an award (in Europe) that is given internationally for participation in national science fairs. Winners are all treated to a 2-day Trailblazer retreat with fellow winners to learn more about the possibilities of a career in CS. ● Counselors for Computing: This program trains counselors to teach their fellow guidance counselors the benefits of CS degrees. Through our partner members at NCWIT, we are hoping to scale impact through these critical influencers. ● CS4HS is an initiative sponsored by Google to promote CS and Computational Thinking in high school and middle school curriculum by hosting CS teachers at campuses worldwide to learn about leading edge practice in the field. ● Computer Science Teachers Association: We are an ongoing supporter of the CSTA and, in particular, recently hosted their CS&IT symposium for 200 CS teachers at our Mountain View campus.
- tabeth 10y agoOne thing I struggle with is measurement of progress. For example, what Google is allowing here with Howard U is obviously good for the AA community. However, is Google in general doing things that are good or bad for AAs in general? It's difficult to say. Excessive advertising can be used to poor people's disadvantage by creating more debt by encouraging more unnecessary expenses. AAs consist of a disproportionally large percentage of poor people and have chronically low wealth levels [1]. One could argue Google is bad for AAs by making advertising more mainstream and accurate. In any case, at least they're trying, PR or not. Some companies do nothing. I do feel strongly about this because the amount of segregation in Boston is ridiculous. [1] http://money.cnn.com/2016/06/27/news/economy/racial-wealth-gap-blacks-whites/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/06/27/news/economy/racial-wealth-g...
- gk1 10y agoWhen a positive outcome is almost certain, there's less need for fine measurements. For example, how much effort is it worth to determine whether tech job placement for Howard University students goes up by 2x or exactly 2.15x?
- tabeth 10y agoI disagree that a positive outcome is almost certain. What's happening here is effectively Affirmative Action, and that's hardly a positive outcome in everyone's eyes. For example, Google could just simply give internships to those at HBCU's, an action one may see as definitely positive. However, if for whatever reason those students fail to perform, in the eyes of the non black colleagues, stereotypes of incompetence will be created, if not exacerbated. Black people are punished more harshly for signs of incompetence of similar magnitude than Whites [2]. A somewhat similar thing happened with minority lawyers, as law schools tried to prop up the supply with affirmative action policies [1]. Things are just complicated, in general. [1] http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2007/08/29/is-affirmative-action-at-law-school-actually-hurting-minorities/ http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2007/08/29/is-affirmative-action-at... [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/05/27/black-students-punished_n_7449538.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/05/27/black-students-puni...
- perfmode 10y ago> For example, Google could just simply give internships to those at HBCU's, an action one may see as definitely positive. This is a straw man. Google isn't doing that. Google and Howard are providing instruction.
- harryjo 10y agoGoogle is doing that (not exactly for HBCUs, but for underrepresented subpopulations) https://www.google.com/about/careers/students/engres.html https://www.google.com/about/careers/students/engres.html
- startupdiscuss 10y agoThis is exciting for a simple reason: it might actually work.
- throwa34567 10y agoI'm very happy to see this. I grew up in a town that, before I was born, decided to actively integrate (from being an historically all white, wealthy suburb) and I'm certain I'm better off for growing up in a diverse community. I'm in mountain view now and it's all "silicon valley white", and something actively needs to be done. I worry when I realize my kid can go a week or more without seeing a black person, and I'm disappointed in myself when I realize I have no black friends (when as a kid they were my neighbors).
- jedberg 10y ago> silicon valley white Interesting term. Does that basically mean Asian (both eastern and southeastern) and White?
- throwa34567 10y agoYeah, I don't know how common the phrase is, but that's what I and the other folks I know who say it basically mean.
- differentView 10y agoDoes the term exclude all non-whites/Asians, regardless of upbringing, education, and background?
- vostok 10y agoAnd South Asian!
- nonce42 10y agoMy prediction is in 20 years Asian will be considered part of white. Maybe it's just being in the Silicon Valley bubble, but it already feels much of the way there. (Not trying to offend anyone, but feel safer with throwaway account.)
- tptacek 10y agoThis isn't a crazy prediction. "White" means a lot less than people pretend it does. Before the 20th Century, it excluded many European ethnicities. At various points, the Irish, Italians, Greeks, and Jewish people have been "non-white". Solidarity among the relatively fair-skinned only became a thing during the fight to perpetuate Jim Crow, and as a response to the Great Migration. It's hard to pin this down because there's a powerful cultural normalization effect around "whiteness"; we accept the notion that there are "white", "black", "latino", and "Asian" people, in part due to history and in part because breaking "white" down further would be cumbersome. But it's worth remembering that while there really is a sui generis "black" culture (the US African American culture, a product of displacing millions of Africans and stripping them of their original culture), there isn't "white culture". Irish and German people don't have that much in common culturally: they don't share a language, they don't eat the same food, they don't listen to the same music, they don't have the same folklore. Since one important sense of the concept of "whiteness" is "membership in favored ethnicity", it's not unreasonable to predict that it will eventually expand to include non-European ethnicities, too.
- Blackthorn 10y agoNobody's really worried about competent students not being able to perform.
- tabeth 10y agoI'm not really sure what your point is.
- Blackthorn 10y agoWell, you said this: > However, if for whatever reason those students fail to perform, in the eyes of the non black colleagues, stereotypes of incompetence will be created, if not exacerbated. It's not really a concern. Nobody's worried about competent students underperforming.
- tabeth 10y agoI really must be missing something. You even said it yourself: "Nobody's worried about competent students underperforming." I didn't say this, nor did you... so who are you replying to? Unless you assume all black students will be competent or somehow black students don't have regular instances of incompetence like their white, asian and hispanic peers?
- lr4444lr 10y agoVery inaccurate statement. http://www.apa.org/research/action/stereotype.aspx http://www.apa.org/research/action/stereotype.aspx
- SamReidHughes 10y agoYou're talking about this phenomenon? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat#Failures_to_replicate_and_publication_bias https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat#Failures_t...
- lr4444lr 10y ago
- monkmartinez 10y agoWhere are the all Hispanic Schools? How about some Hispanic related "campuses?"
- harryjo 10y agoSince the USA does not have a long history of legal segregation against Hispanics, there are no Hispanic colleges. However, there are Hispanic Serving Insitutions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hispanic-serving_institution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hispanic-serving_institution I also wonder how much you cared about Hispanic schools before you heard about someone helping a Black school. Why the sudden interest?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 10y agoHistorically-Black Colleges and Universities are a product of the history of absolute exclusion of blacks from other institutions in much of the US. While Hispanics have faced disadvantages and discrimination, they have not faced the kind of outright exclusion that blacks faced for about a century under Jim Crow.
- mtanski 10y agoThe reason we even have HBCs in the first place because most universities did not accept black people. So HBCs were created by black people and their allies. Many HBCs pre-date the civil right changes and school integration prior to the 1960. Many of them go back to the Civil war and some event pre-dated the war. There's also HSI, short for Hispanic Serving Institutions. This concept was create in the mid-1960s. Unlike HBCs, institutions could be designated HSI as a result of a federal law. And the law didn't require that these were primarily representing hispanics. Instead the law allowed general institutions to be labeled HSI if they enrolled a certain percentage of latina/latino students along with some additional socio/economic pre-conditions. As you can see HBCs / HSIs are somewhat different concepts and have a different history. Additionally, in recent years there's been an iflux of hispanic students to HBCs as well. I hope that other large organizations like Google have more partnerships with HBCs/HSI/Native/Tribal educational organizations. This seams like a start, no real to not cheer it on. There's no reason to pit groups against one another... it's much better to work together. There's a great datapoint in the history of the VRA (Voting Rights Acts) the people who became enfranchised with the first passing of it fought for expanding the VRA via the 1975 amendment to expand the VRA to other groups including Hispanic/Native/Tribal & Asian minorities. Prior to that states and manipulates in Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, south California were actively working to suppers the Hispanic (such as the Chicanos) vote.
- protomyth 10y agoIt would be cool if some tech company did this with a school like http://www.haskell.edu/ http://www.haskell.edu/
- startupdiscuss 10y agoLet me guess: it is a purely functional university?
- protomyth 10y agoIf it helps some SV exec donate, then sure, why not.
- nybbler 10y agoYes, instead of the students learning anything, when you send a student to the university you're returned a new student which is almost the same only with more knowledge.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoThanks. I thought the (in my opinion, very funny) joke was getting lost based on the down-voting.
- robotresearcher 10y agoThe opposite of a state school?
- misterbowfinger 10y agoI want to comment on the anti Affirmative Action arguments here. I went to a really prestigious high school in New York City. For the summer of my junior year, our AP Computer Science teacher hooked up a few of us with internships at the finance firms, specifically in tech (Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, etc.). Now, sure, I did really well and studied really hard to get into my high school. However, I did practically nothing to earn that internship besides taking AP Computer Science. My Computer Science "expertise" was hardly valuable. I knew just about as much as any other AP CS kid in the country. In the end, that internship did wonders for me getting into college and getting future jobs. And plus, I made 3k that summer. And yes, I finished a useful project at the firm. But the reason I had that opportunity was totally orthogonal to earning the opportunity. I know we like to boast about being a meritocracy and all that, but this is one of those cases where it was correlation, not causation.
- vostok 10y ago> I knew just about as much as any other AP CS kid in the country. I think you do your high school a disservice. Almost everyone I have interviewed from your school has done better than average.
- misterbowfinger 10y agoDoubt it. We're all idiots :-P After graduation, sure we probably do better than average. But at the moment I received the internship, my skills were no more or less qualified than any other CS student. And, at the end of the day, am I really that much better of a developer than most people? I really doubt that.
- reader5000 10y agoBecause you're not the person AA hurts. AA doesnt hurt top 1% people, it hurts say top 10% people who are in the wrong ethnic group and lose out to people in the correct ethnic group. Just ask a lower class Asian person with top 10% MCAT scores, and why he lost a med school spot to a middle class URM person with top 20% scores.
- wehadfun 10y agoIs this a way to use blacks to increase the supply and decrease the salary of software engineers? Regardless the people that go to Howard are pretty well off anyway. Its a private U so either you have money or enough educations/connections/... to get a scholarship. Edit: Im not criticizing this. I think it is great.
- John23832 10y agoHoward is prestigious for an HBCU, but it's not Harvard. HBCU's deal with a notorious lack of funding, so the connections that you assume are not always there. I can say this specifically applies to Howard.
- Zigurd 10y agoIf you build a company without thinking too much about diversity and it finds itself unbalanced in race and sex when it has thousands of employees, the math becomes daunting. 10% set-asides would take decades to get you near balance. This is why extraordinary efforts have to be made, and made at scale.
- komali2 10y agoIt's nitpicky and maybe trivial, but I'm happy to see them use the word "Black" so prominently. I always got peeved at "African American." If we're going to discuss race, nationality doesn't really figure into the equation. Then again, if you start talking scientifically, the concept of "race" is shaky at best, but there's no denying the cultural implications of the idea.
- uncletaco 10y agoIt is nitpicky but not so trivial. As I understand it, once upon a time you would have German Americans and Italian Americans as distinctive subgroups in the United States with their own unique cultures. But Negroes couldn't really say they were Nigerian-American or Angolan-American, largely because most colored people did not know exactly where in Africa they came from. In a historical context it makes sense that a subgroup defined by both culture and appearance would be intentional in adopting a name. This is especially true when the names given to them: negroes, colored folk, and even black had racist baggage associated with them. I personally don't mind African American for the same reasons I don't mind Asian American. Both subnational groups are comfortable with their designation I believe. Speaking of Asian Americans, are you peeved with the term "Asian American"? Would you rather them self-identify as "yellow"? I ask because I like consistency.
- komali2 10y agoHm, good point regarding Asian American. Using "yellow" seems ridiculous but is value-wise the same as saying "black." And I can't just claim "just get rid of it all and call'm people!" because there are very useful reasons to be able to define general race (for example, when reporting a crime, you give gender, race, hair, clothing, approximate height). Even that though will become trickier as the genetic pool equalizes. Dunno man, good point. I hadn't thought of it because all of my "Asian-American" friends have very distinguishable country-specific characteristics that they can identify because their family migrated more recently than your average Black family's, and they don't have a history of slavery obfuscating their origins. EDIT: Thinking more on it, I believe I'm used to hearing "Asian" to describe race, as opposed to "Asian-American" to describe heritage or nationality. EDIT2: And also thinking more, I believe my friends use "FOB" to describe an actual Asian, i.e. someone born in Asia. Which probably will be a horribly offensive slur one day and I'll be the 2060 equivalent of "the grandpa that says 'negro' way too much."
- FT_intern 10y agoI think we are in need of an open discussion on redefining "diversity". Race is not a good metric for diversity. Nationality completely trumps it. People of the same nationality with the same primary language have much more in common with each other. You can actually see this dynamic play out at work where people hang out with others from the same nationality. Americans hang out with Americans, Mandarin Chinese hang out with Mandarin Chinese, Indians with other Indians (don't know enough about Indian culture to split this group up further), Germans with Germans, etc. Cultural_Difference(random_nationality1, random_nationality2) > Cultural_Difference(same_nationality_different_race1, same_nationality_different_race2) With this metric, tech is one of the most diverse fields in the world. Seen through this new point of view, the racial categories are very shortsighted. The difference between Indian and Chinese (or even Chinese and Korean) cultures is immense, yet they are assigned as part of the same category. African Americans have their own category, yet they are culturally and linguistically(same native language) very similar to white Americans. Now let's move onto the controversial "disadvantages" discussion. African Americans generally have family whose native language is English and who understand American culture and can impart these skills and knowledge to their children. They have the language and cultural knowledge to fight for their interests and a powerful organization (NCAAP) to back them up. With these advantages, African Americans are basically seen as honorary Americans similar to white Americans. These advantages even put them in a better position than white immigrants (and sometimes their American born children who have a harder time assimilating). With these advantages and affirmative action based advantages(educational programs, scholarships, diversity internships and hiring, easy access to colleges/universities from affirmative action[works out to something like +150/2400 SAT and +0.2 GPA which is huge when competing in top percentiles]) middle class and upper middle class African Americans are very privileged. Edit: And on disadvantages in the workplace. Americans are the largest group and the language spoken is English, so Americans (of any race) and native English speakers are privileged.
- and0 10y agoIt's kind of wild you think the NAACP is this huge factor tipping the scales. I'd guess that's a product of consuming alt-right news, which tends to massively amplify organizations and figures within the black community that can be smeared as corrupt, but who knows. Every study I've read relating to economic mobility points to having economic leverage in the first place as the greatest factor. Blacks have a disproportionately low share of wealth ownership in America (can't cite this atm), which combined with systematic biases puts them at a pretty significant disadvantage. Speaking English isn't enough to counteract that. You make some interesting points re: how to categorize diversity, but it sounds like you're just moving the goalposts.
- gumby 10y agoI know this doesn't add to the conversation but I'm really excited by this and had to say so.
- nybbler 10y agoIf this succeeds, how will Google and Howard keep whites and Asians from taking too many positions in the class? Outright racial discrimination in university admissions is still illegal, and Howard couldn't seriously argue that they're engaging in affirmative action (their student body is over 90% black)
- twunde 10y agoI have to say just how excited I am about this. I know two black developers. TWO. I've worked with numerous female developers and know plenty more. I've worked with hispanic, asian, white and european developers (no native american that I know of). I think that this is a great move to help bring in more diversity (and certainly a very different perspective)
- WillyOnWheels 10y agohttp://n-gate.com/ http://n-gate.com/ is going to have a lot of fun with the comments here
- nsxwolf 10y agoIs this legal? Is this really a school that only allows people of a certain race? I don't mean scholarships or other affirmative action type stuff. An actual entire school that excludes based on race? Where is my misunderstanding?
- CoachRufus87 10y ago> Is this really a school that only allows people of a certain race? No.
- nsxwolf 10y agoAsk an honest question, get stupid one word non answers and downvotes.
- CoachRufus87 10y agoI'm not sure what I could've said to make my 'non-answer' to that specific question any clearer.
- oh_sigh 10y agoYour honest question got an honest answer - NO. Anyone can apply to Howard, anyone can get accepted to Howard.
- nsxwolf 10y agoI know that is true of the regular Howard University campus, but what about the new program that's the subject of the article?
- CoachRufus87 10y agoDid you bother to read the post? > Rising juniors and seniors in Howard’s computer science (CS) program can attend Howard West, for three months at a time.
- deleted 10y ago
- mynameishere 10y agoYou got yours. Now you're interested in virtue signaling.
- dang 10y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed here. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13942559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13942559 and marked it off-topic.
- Animats 10y agoThat's an effective bit of action by Google. Three months at Google will do wonders for anyone's early career opportunities.
- swframe2 10y agoI want to suggest a naive way to reduce the effect of affirmative action. 1) Join forces to donate to educational institutions specifically to increase the number of students they enroll. If there are X spots being reserved for AA, then ask the school to add X additional spots not usable for AA. Donate specifically for them to build additional dorms, classrooms, etc. For some schools, their endowment is so large, they don't really need the donation, they just need pressure. I think pressuring them to expand should be more likely than pressuring them to end AA. 2) Invest in poor communities. AA stems from the desire to end a cycle of poverty. If we worked to "upgrade" poor communities then the need for AA would greatly decrease. So invest to improve K-12, housing, and businesses in poor communities. I use the word "invest" because real estate in poor areas is usually under market. I think you can make a really good return if you build high quality housing. Just make sure you are willing to sell/rent to the current residents at below market prices. You should still be able to make a profit from the housing you build that is sold/rented to the middle class looking for better deals in your "upgraded" community. There doesn't have to be a zero-sum battle between those who benefit from AA and those who don't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 10y ago> There doesn't have to be a zero-sum battle between those who benefit from AA and those who don't. When resources (jobs, college admissions slots, government funding for programs, etc.) are scarce, there often will be. When I was in college, one of my classes included a unit on public speaking. We were encouraged to speak on a contentious topic and attempt to be persuasive. On the day I presented, I sat through multiple presentations on the subject of affirmative action. All of them were against it on the basis that it hurt certain ethnic groups. None of the people presenting on that subject were white. (Me? I was ranting against DRM. Not important.)
- downandout 10y agoPrograms like this promote the very discrimination that they are intended to counteract. People of all other races will see this and argue - correctly - that black students at Howard now have an advantage over them at one of the premier employers in the tech industry. This is wonderful for Howard students, and probably for black CS students looking for employment at Google in general, but not so great for everyone else. You cannot fix racism by implementing racist programs. You do it by removing race from the hiring equation to the maximum extent possible, and making it known that applicants of all races are welcome and that they will be judged based solely on their skills and qualifications. The kind of program announced today will, and should, backfire on Google.
- burkaman 10y agoThe point of affirmative action is that it's impossible to remove race from the hiring equation, because race affects your applicants right up to the point they send in an application. If you say "I'm colorblind", you're also pretending that everyone else in the world is colorblind, and race had no impact on your applicants' resumes. Race is a society-wide issue, and it's not possible to solve without recognizing and correcting for it. If you close your eyes and ignore it, racism will still exist and continue to affect people. Even if racism disappeared from America overnight, the issue would not be solved because there would still be lingering cyclical effects from past racism. Parents with fewer opportunities raise kids with fewer opportunities because we live in an imperfect world, and these things require active correction.
- downandout 10y agoBy the time anyone of any race becomes a viable Google candidate, they have excelled in both high school and at elite universities, earned advanced degrees, and in many cases have already done interesting things in their field. Their socioeconomic background is irrelevant by that point in their lives. People wind up in Google interviews because they have earned the right to be there with the best and the brightest. At that level of competition, it would truly be a shame for race to play any part in a hiring decision.
- thex10 10y agoThis sounds really cool to me just because of the novelty of having a campus at a megacorporate site. I would've loved to work at the Googleplex as a college student! I think it's really cool that kids these days can have that opportunity, and hope more companies will follow suit.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoGoogle is trying to bring good jobs to people in the US who need good jobs by helping to develop their talent and match it to a role within the company. i don't think that's a bad thing. i think Google will be happy to see how well this approach works.
- nether 10y agoThis is unfair. It is also unfair that blacks receive harsher punishments, starting in preschool, and that this prejudice follows them their entire lives. Can you imagine that? Being told by society that you are bad and predisposed to being a criminal, probably every fucking day? In small and large ways. Learned helplessness is real. I may not see the injustice vividly, because I am not black nor do I have any close black friends (I have a college bud that I hardly talk to, that's it). But it's everywhere. Google knows the inequity exists and is taking a step to address it. http://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2014/03/21/292456211/black-preschoolers-far-more-likely-to-be-suspended http://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2014/03/21/292456211/... https://newsone.com/1859475/black-people-receive-60-longer-sentences-for-same-crimes/ https://newsone.com/1859475/black-people-receive-60-longer-s...