7 ms·
> easy to get started Yes. > cross platform support Yes. > Because you can write plugins in JS? Yes. --- As much as I prefer native programs as a user, i
by paulddraper 10y ago
> easy to get started
Yes.
> cross platform support
Yes.
> Because you can write plugins in JS?
Yes.
---
As much as I prefer native programs as a user, it's impossible to ignore the benefits of cross-platform development and plebeian hackability/debuggability.
- dekhn 10y agoyou can do all of this in Qt, too. Without the overhead of the inner platform effect.
- cle 10y agoYou can do it, but it's significantly harder. And with Electron, you can leverage the same skills that are used to build web applications to modify your environment and text editor as well. Those are very significant advantages. Note: I don't use VS Code or any other JS editor, I use emacs. But I can definitely appreciate the major benefits of the architecture.
- josefx 10y agoSo does it have a NoScript plugin to kill the unavoidable 200 tracking and ad scripts from Google, Facebook and who knows what running in the background? I am sorry if I offend someone with this, however the current Web experience is something I want as far away from my dev. tools as possible.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- y4mi 10y agotracking or ad scripts by facebook or google are in neither atom nor VSCode. both projects are open source if you care to verify
- fs111 10y agowell, but something similar: https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/supporting/faq#_how-to-disable-telemetry-reporting https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/supporting/faq#_how-to-di...
- y4mi 10y agoyou're being asked while installing f you're fine with anonymized usage information being send to MS for further development of the software. its a simple checkpoint and pretty much every actively developing project does this nowadays.
- efdee 10y agoWhile your concern might be valid in general, this is applicable to native software just as much.
- dekhn 10y agoI build both web apps and Qt apps. TBH, doing something in Qt is about 1/10 to 1/100 the effort of doing it on the web. The web is a morass of confusing standards, none of which work well together. To get guaranteed, predictable behavior which is documented, and will continue to work properly for 10 years after deployment (with only minor maintainence), you simply cannot use the web.
- rikkus 10y agoWe have 'native' text editors. Sublime Text is very similar to VS Code in many ways. But with Sublime I haven't got up and running writing, running, debugging code in various languages like I have in VS Code. The whole experience is important. For many, it's more important than the individual 'feature' of being light on resources. I currently ignore the fact that VS Code is 'heavy' as text editors go, because it's so much lighter than e.g. Visual Studio, leaving me much more RAM free for some of the code I'm running to gobble up and use for its own ends. I'd prefer lighter 'weight' - in terms of RAM and CPU usage - but I'm not tempted back to Sublime yet. BTW I'm a vi person, so I'm using vi keybindings in VS, VS Code, Sublime - and anywhere else I can do so. I love Vim's speed, but I can't Get Stuff Done in it like I can in more modern editors. I mastered the keys, not the inbuilt windowing system, scripting language, etc.
- braveo 10y agoI'm always confused when people say this, I've tried a lot of vim modes and to a T I've never found any that were satisfactory. I really believe that if you find these vim plugins useful you don't really use vim all that deeply. that's not a criticism, just an observation.
- Philipp__ 10y agoAnd that is OK for Notes or todo app, but text editor that is used by developers who tend to customize it with plugins and whatnot I think that is not viable option. But that's just my personal preference, maybe I am wrong...
- paulddraper 10y agoMy two cents: you get what you pay for in your IDE.
- kittenmittens 10y agoWould you mind giving some examples, mostly for the higher tier of "paying".
- randallsquared 10y agoThat depends strongly on the IDE and the user. I used to pay Jetbrains every month, but last July I noticed that I preferred VS Code to PHPStorm for essentially everything, and stopped my subscription and uninstalled it.
- cr0sh 10y agoI pay a lot of money for my copy of IntelliJ. ...indexing... ...as I was saying...
- randiantech 10y agoVS Code IS a viable option. I use it daily basis and works great.
- YCode 10y agoSeriously, coming from Visual Studio VSCode is a breeze of fresh performant air. Anecdotally I was able to create the cursor problem by minimizing/showing the VSCode window while viewing CPU usage DESC in task manager, but the effect was only ~2% usage for me (i7 processor). If one invisible (from a UX perspective) bug is VSCode's big performance problem then I'll gladly let it eat away at 2% of my CPU until it's fixed.
- ue_ 10y agoEmacs is a little harder to write plugins for, but it runs natively and the only impediment is that more people know JS than they do elisp.
- dahauns 10y agoLots of emacs functionality runs via its lisp VM. I'd hardly call that 'native'. I mean, Emacs had jokes about being bloated decades before Javascript (and Java, another contender for these jokes) even existed. :)
- gmfawcett 10y agoMost of those jokes are completely out of date. "Eight Megs and Constantly Swapping" used to be a big deal, but today it's not. I don't think running Elisp in Emacs takes away from it being "native." At least insofar as there are no popular text editors (that I know of!) which expect you to compile your plugins and macros to native code. They all have interpreters of one kind or another. What Emacs doesn't have, though, is an inner platform effect: Emacs is the platform, there isn't a second one underneath (no browser engine).
- pantulis 10y agoWhich begs the nice corollary: the definition of "native" doesn't happen to be fixed and changes with time.
- gmfawcett 10y agoWell, language is like that. :) But I don't think describing Emacs as "native" here is very different from how the word was used decades ago. To me, "native" is less about how the logic is represented (compiled vs. interpreted code) and more about its execution context. If the host system is an operating system, then the application is native; if the host system is another application, then it's not. I agree that the boundary is blurrier for applications that have scripting interfaces; but I think that most applications don't live very close to that boundary, and are clearly in one camp or the other. (Maybe Emacs is nearer to the edge: there's an old joke that Emacs is a great operating system, it just needs a better text editor.) Having said all that, I don't think that "non-native" is a pejorative. I use Emacs, but would switch to a "non-native" editor if there were a good reason. I use IDEA (native or not? you decide!) when working on big Java projects, and Emacs for everything else, because Emacs affords me a lot of power that I find lacking in other editors. "Nativity" isn't really part of the equation, it's really about functionality.
- jbmorgado 10y agoWell, you can write plugins in Python for Sublime Text and NeoVim (and more). JS and Python and both fairly uncomplicated languages when it comes to "plebeian hackability/debuggability".
- akerro 10y ago>> cross platform support > Yes. WOW FINALLY SOMETHING that will run on my LINUX and FreeBSD! ohh.. a lot of plugins don't support linux and it doesn't build on BSD?
- bluejekyll 10y agoReally? I haven't seen this at all... though I don't have a ton of plugins.
- jamespo 10y ago> doesn't build on BSD doesn't run on ZX Spectrum either
- darpa_escapee 10y agoWhy bother describing something as cross-platform if this is the attitude held?
- tedunangst 10y agoCross platform support means if you want support, you cross over to a supported platform.
- josefx 10y agoSome years ago cross platform in Microsoft speak meant it would run on at least two of the following: A version of Windows, Wincows CE, Windows Phone or Xbox. That cross platform now almost includes a non Microsoft platform is progress.
- paulddraper 10y agoDon't vim, emacs, Sublime, and IntelliJ IDEA work on FreeBSD?
- floatboth 10y ago(neo)vim, emacs and IDEA certainly do. Sublime is not natively ported, only under the linux compat layer.
- ProAm 10y ago> it's impossible to ignore the benefits of cross-platform development Performance & bugs/quirks. I'd much rather have performance.