10 ms·
Boom Supersonic raises $33M to build the fastest airplane for passenger flight
- mgirdley 10y agoHow have they or do they plan to overcome the limitations and inefficiencies that happen near and past the speed of sound?
- aphextron 10y agoI wish companies like this would come out and say what they are: an acqui-hire project. A single brand new passenger jet costs more than $33 million, and that's with decades of development costs being amortized. Development costs for Boeing's new 787, a conventional aircraft, came to over $30 billion. I will be amazed if they actually even get a working prototype aircraft flying with this amount of money.
- cstross 10y agoNote that the 787 development costs included building multiple full-sized prototypes of a wide-body (read: price on the order of $225M per aircraft) and a moving vehicle production line — you can tour the Boeing plant at Everett and see fourteen Dreamliners lined up nose-to-tail at various stages of production, like 200 ton automobiles in a car plant. They also built a global supply chain, with over 50% of the components manufactured outside the USA (for WTO trade rules compliance — a side-effect of Boeing's ongoing trade war with Airbus; Airbus have had to do the same). With over 1200 orders to date (over 500 delivered) the 787 has only been available for 13 years: typical product life of a Boeing/Airbus airliner is 30 years, so they're looking at amortizing that $30Bn over roughly 2500-3000 airframes, and you should consider it as covering most of the manufacturing costs. So the $30Bn sticker for the Dreamliner gets you not only a new wide-body airliner, but a whole new global airliner manufacturing supply chain (you bet they'll use it — or a development thereof — for the next airliner they design, too), and the capacity to punch them out like pick-up trucks. This $33M funding round is to build a one-third scale flight demonstrator. Not an actual Boom airliner, or a Concorde equivalent, but something like like the HP.115 — a research aircraft with similar flight properties in some parts of the flight regime of the planned final aircraft, for test purposes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handley_Page_HP.115 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handley_Page_HP.115 (Significant difference: the HP.115 was used to investigate low speed stability and handling of delta wings. The Boom XB-1 is to investigate supersonic low noise flight.) It also lets them build up their engineering team to the point where they're actually able to get a full grasp of the magnitude of the problems they're facing. But a real Boom supersonic transport? That's going to cost at a minimum multiple single-digit billions (even if they don't go all-out and budget for a production line and supply chain for 2000 units) to develop.
- yread 10y agoThen again Boeing had the benefit of already having most of the expertise in house from building planes for decades. I'm sure if I started a company I would need a lot more than $30B to develop 787.
- cstross 10y agoYou might think that, but Airbus developed the A350XWB — a direct competitor for the 787 — on a budget of €11Bn. Even taking into account exchange rate issues, that's less than half the cost. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A350_XWB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A350_XWB (On the other hand, Airbus already had a lot of experience with composites in airliners, so the A350 was an evolutionary development, not a revolution: and they'd been working with international airliner component supply chains for decades already — it's what they do — so they didn't have to start from scratch.) My point is, the $30Bn sticker on the 787 is misleading because it covers not only a new wide-body airliner type but also a whole new supply chain management approach and a (for Boeing) revolutionary change in materials technology (from mostly-Al to mostly-carbon fiber composites).
- dragonwriter 10y ago> You might think that, but Airbus developed the A350XWB — a direct competitor for the 787 — on a budget of €11Bn. Even taking into account exchange rate issues, that's less than half the cost. Airbus also had the same kind of experience and expertise in house already built up. So, that doesn't challenge the GPs contention that for someone without that, the cost would be substantially more.
- onion2k 10y agoI will be amazed if they actually even get a working prototype aircraft flying with this amount of money. That's not the point of this funding round. When you work on insanely ambitious projects you have to do things incrementally. This is their 3rd round - the first was $120k, the second was $2.1m. Each round enables them to do enough of the tasks that demonstrate to investors that they're capable of doing the next set of tasks. I have no clue how you design a plane but I would guess the first round was entirely spent on modelling the financials and market research to see if there's even a business opportunity. The next round would be something like the really broad brush ideas for how you'd make a plane like this. This round will be spent digging in to the technology itself, figuring out what capabilities you need to have in an electric plane, and finding which parts you can buy off the shelf. If Boom are successful at that then there'll be future rounds that are spent on actual design and manufacturing. By the time anything real takes off from a runway they'll probably need to have raised billions. No one thinks you can design and build a plane for $120k+$2.1m+$33m.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoI don't see them addressing the first and main challenge to supersonic flight: regulation
- onion2k 10y agoThis is pure speculation on my part, but isn't most supersonic flight regulation essentially anti-competitive behaviour by the US government because Concorde wasn't an American-made aircraft? Even if that isn't true I think the main problem was the ludicrous sound levels from the engines, which an electric plane wouldn't suffer from (as much). If Boom demonstrate that they can make a working plane I imagine a lot of the red tape would just disappear.
- ealexhudson 10y agoThe engines don't create the ludicrous sound; the force of an object moving through the air faster than the speed of sound creates the sonic boom. While some designs can mitigate this it doesn't seem that Boom has an answer here except for keeping the aircraft small.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> I wish companies like this would come out and say what they are: an acqui-hire project. That would be, well, most of the regular startups too. The problem is, you can't tell everyone you're aiming for an exit, because exit == fucking over your existing customers, and you need those customers to be able to exit. So, startups lie about how they care about the users and their product. That's why nowadays I assume by default that a startup is just done for exit, unless proven otherwise.
- masklinn 10y agoAlso of interest, the unit price of Concorde adjusted for inflation was about $160m around the end of the production run.
- mrfusion 10y agoGoing by first principles it doesn't seem like it should cost that much. Can't computers do a lot of design work and simulations?
- anovikov 10y agoI wonder why are the investors pouring money into this. It is so obvious it can't work. Are they simply fooled, like those guys who invested into scientifically impossible power-over-ultrasound startup? I know venture investment is risky, but is there any limit on how stupid VC partners can be? Can banks who lended them money, sue them?
- nodesocket 10y agoHaven't they seen "why the Concorde failed" on YouTube? Who's putting up $33M for this? Sam say it ain't so. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a_wuykzfFzE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a_wuykzfFzE
- thatguy18121 10y agoCould be a couple of rich people looking at Musk and experiencing "rocket envy".
- BrailleHunting 10y agoThere are enough rich people in the world whom have inherited wealth but don't understand the mechanics of its acquisition, amplification and retainment.
- tim333 10y agoCool. Looking forward to the prototype.
- BrailleHunting 10y agoGood frickin' luck. If Concorde couldn't survive even without accidents... it might not be a viable business. Aerion has immense resources, talent and connections and is still slowly chugging along on allegedly building the AS2, an expensive, supersonic business jet. Might want to consider the feasibility of the real economics of jet fuel per passenger/cargo before raising a bunch of money to ignite. And also disappointing investors and losing their confidence when they ask for $5 billion more to continue development and are turned down.
- cstross 10y agoConcorde ran into (a) the oil price shock of the 1970s (the price of fuel quadrupled overnight around the time manufacturing commenced), and (b) the airport security theatre of the immediate post-9/11 era (a 3 hour LHR-JFK flight is a whole lot less attractive if you add 2 hours of queuing at security checkpoints and another hour at immigration, when you can rent a seat on a bizjet for the same money and bypass both). But what killed Concorde was (c) the airframe hitting the 30 year point; it has been alleged that Airbus demanded outrageous amounts of money to keep updating its type certification for flight after that time. (Caveat: trying to find a citation for this online is ... vexing.)
- leroy_masochist 10y agoThe budget and timeline strike me as wildly unrealistic, and the management quotes sound absurdly sanguine. With that said, if they can pull off a 1/3 scale prototype with current funding as they claim they can, one nice ancillary benefit would be the kick to the ass of the Lockheed Martins of the world, for whom $33mm is a rounding error when it comes to spending taxpayer dollars on next-generation aviation platforms.
- nl 10y ago"How could anyone be stupid enough to fund Facebook. They'll never make money" - HN. "VC's never fund anything but social media apps and advertising companies" -- HN. "Yes of course SpaceX is going to make Musk money" -- HN. "Funding a supersonic plane is a stupid idea" -- HN. (And yes, also "$41M funding for color.com is stupid" --HN.)
- sschueller 10y agoI would fund a supersonic plane if the company behind it wasn't living in another dimension. There is nothing wrong withe something taking 10 years to build. Under promise over deliver.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> "VC's never fund anything but social media apps and advertising companies" -- HN. Well, they also occasionally fund stupid shit like uBeam. > "Yes of course SpaceX is going to make Musk money" -- HN. Isn't it? Except that money is wisely reinvested into the Mars transportation project. > "Funding a supersonic plane is a stupid idea" -- HN. Supersonic passenger plane is not a smart idea for various technical and economical reasons. I don't think that's just "HN opinion".
- nl 10y agoSupersonic passenger plane is not a smart idea for various technical and economical reasons. I don't think that's just "HN opinion". AFAIK, the technical and economic reasons boil down to: "Too expensive to build, too expensive to fly, people object to the sonic booms". I don't know if there is a way around the sonic boom problem, but for the first two there's an "easy" fix: make it cheaper. I don't have a clue how to do that, but and I have no particular opinion on Boom, but if someone came up with a way around that "small" problem then everything else falls into place.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAs far as I can tell, the argument boils down to all that you wrote, relative to what you gain. AFAIK a supersonic passenger plane doesn't shorten your total trip enough, compared to regular passenger planes, to create a new quality class of travel. E.g. taking 5 hours to go to a place (2h flight + airport overhead on both sides) by a plane vs. 12+ hours by bus makes many destinations suddenly accessible to people to visit for a weekend. Except maybe on intercontinental, I don't see a supersonic passenger plane enabling another quality class of travel.
- Beltiras 10y agoThe comments are remarkably negative for a can-do crowd of entrepreneurial people. Success is built on a string of multiple failures. I'm rooting for this team to succeed.
- dingaling 10y agoMuch negativity results from 50 years of supersonic biz-jet daydreaming without anything progressing past airshow models. It's basically the original vapourware. Even experts like Dassault and Sukhoi, with more supersonic experience than any current company, have shied away. And Dassault is reknowned for its biz-jets; if anyone could do it I'd bet on them. Gulfstream looked at it from the other direction, potentially moving-up from big subsonic biz-jets to an even more exclusive and expensive aircraft. They too decided against it, even with Sukhoi's input into supersonic design. Beyond the big companies there have been a string of smaller dreamers. Jane's "All the World's Aircraft" from through the 1980s is testament to that. Can Boom do it? Possibly so, but given that they're building on the same technology as the rest of the aerospace industry then I don't see why they're any different. This isn't a problem that software can solve ( unlike Space-X ).
- Beltiras 10y agoThis is a reasoned critique of Boom's plans. Much of what I was criticising was references to Concorde and the Tupalev failure.
- arjie 10y agoIt's useful to remember that it's a bunch of people that don't know the industry. They're just googling and reading Wikipedia. That doesn't mean the project will be successful. It's just that there's zero information content to most comments that are on non-software topics. There are some things I know a little about that I haven't commented on here about, and I've seen where people are quite clearly googling and getting not the right answer but the answer that is most likely to show up on Google. Just something useful to keep in mind.
- 10y ago
- johnm1019 10y agoThis suggests engines are 50% more efficient today than in 1960, with 80% reductions in fuel per passenger seat. [1] If advanced physical simulations could produce a wing 20% more efficient than the concorde, with engines 20% more efficient, and the weight of control, actuation systems, and cabin interiors were all reduced by 20% the gains in operating cost and range would be substantially more than 20%. Gains in aircraft are typically non-linear because they all affect each other. It's exciting to think about what might be possible with 50 years of materials science, _computers_, simulation, electronics, and propulsion technology. [1] http://www.atag.org/component/downloads/downloads/59.html http://www.atag.org/component/downloads/downloads/59.html [pdf]
- 1ba9115454 10y agoThere's not market for this. Passenger don't care about saving time transatlantic because the people who can afford it can now sleep in a bed in business or first. Airlines don't want it because super sonic capable engines take way more fuel than current day engines and therefore the costs would be high. If there was a demand for supersonic planes Boeing or Airbus would be building them already.
- melling 10y agoYou are wrong on all points. http://interestingengineering.com/real-reason-why-supersonic-passenger-jet-concorde-failed/ http://interestingengineering.com/real-reason-why-supersonic...
- markonen 10y agoYou're nuts. First and business class comforts are about making the best of a bad situation. At equivalent seat prices, nearly everyone would pick the more than twice as fast option. Boom's business model relies on this, obviously, but so do their passenger-seat-mile economics. Boom claims that the per seat fuel consumption (and ultimately the ticket prices) would be same as for business class seats currently. This is possible because making a currently-seven-hour flight in three hours enables them to replace a full flat bed with a recliner seat, saving 2/3 of the floor area per passenger.
- lostboys67 10y agoAnd that is not counting the OH cost of the dead time flying. Black in the 80's I worked at a place where they looked at chartering a plane for one project - doing some R&D in a deep coal mine. As the cost of the senior engineers at our > 600% oh rate for them to drive to the site was more expensive than a plane charter - we where based at an airfield
- 1ba9115454 10y agoThat's not what happened. People stopped using Concorde and started using the new comforts of business class on larger albeit slower planes. The per seat fuel consumption is perhaps optimistic on their part.
- mrfusion 10y agoI think it's amazing that adding some kind of valet system at the airport would speed up my travel more than this kind of marvel of engineering.
- danesparza 10y agoThis comment makes me so sad. Because it's so true.
- jmknoll 10y agoExactly. Travel speed once you're in the air is basically the last problem with air travel. Travel time to the airport, looking around for a parking space, an outdated checkin process, endless security theater. These all seem like easier fixes than making planes move faster. Even with no other improvements, I would probably take reliable in-flight wifi over a 25% improvement in flight times.
- jandrese 10y agoMaybe for you, but for the people this product is targeting they already bypass security on the way to their private jet.
- Balgair 10y agoIt's funny, this sentiment reminds me of this quote from Patton during WW2: 'Amateurs talk tactics, professionals talk logistics '. These engineers are so focused on the 'cool' stuff and the 'hard' stuff, the super-sonic stuff, basically the tactics of moving infantry and doing flanking maneuvers and tank charges. But the real stuff that will really get the times down is 'boring' and intellectually 'easy'. Its the flow of parking, the security line, the scheduling reroutes when a blizzard strikes, the logistics side of feeding troops and making sure extra parts get to the lines and counting the number of shells used per hour. War and business are generally very simple, have more guns/money than your enemy.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y ago> NYC to London […] at a cost of $2,500 > cabin comforts If they can actually deliver on those two, then they can succeed where Concorde failed (couldn't compete against first/business class given the tickets cost far too much and offered economy-esque seating). That's a big “if”, though.
- ajarmst 10y agoPeople always seem to grossly underestimate the cost to crew-rate, and then passenger-rate vehicles. Especially with new technology, which usually involves killing people along the way. It is much, much, more expensive to develop a system to the point where you can put a fare-paying passenger on it than it is to take it to where you can reliably put a sensor package in it or even a test pilot that you expect to survive. The cost of an uncrewed scale model isn't even noise in the cost of a full-size passenger-rated project, and its success isn't particular predictive of the actual project. The sonic boom problem isn't trivial. You need to be able to land the vehicle near cities, because that's where the customers are. That means you have to spend a good chunk of time (maybe a long chunk of time if you have to orbit waiting to land) flying low and slow---a vehicle designed to use fuel efficiently when high and supersonic is almost by definition going to be less efficient than traditional vehicles when forced to fly in that regime. Which means it has to carry a lot of fuel, which means weight, which means ... etc. As other commenters have noted: shaving an hour or two off of time spent at the terminal will generally be much more effective in speeding up travel. There is another city a three-hour drive from where I live, and it is faster for me to drive there than fly. And replacing the aircraft with a missile wouldn't change that.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoSuch a well written summary I think it should pretty much be a footnote to any of the super sonic / hyper sonic / quad-copter-automated-flying-thingy forward looking statements. I think projects like Boom are perfectly fine for rich billionaires to throw money at in their spare time, because they still run into physics and logistics. In doing research for a project, I came across some Annual Reports for the company Sabre. Some might recognize the name, as they were an in-house tech / logistics / travel operations company for American Airlines that got spun off into its own entity years back. Point being, they have a vested interest in air travel, and over and over, the CEO was concerned and frustrated by the lack of modernization in flight systems and overall system improvements. A very consistent theme, and I can't disagree with him. Looking at it another way, the scale of persons affected by system upgrades and improvements drastically overshadows those who would, uh, gain from supersonic travel. Just makes sense.
- JofArnold 10y agoThe ex-aerospace engineer in me is super excited. But the realist in me fears this a decadent polluting toy for elites in a post-combustion world. Versus VR and other remote technologies which will solve many of the issues it also attempts to address it just seems like a moonshot from a bygone era.