10 ms·
Machine-owned enterprises are inevitable
- tlack 10y agoI feel like many of the problems he mentions could be solved by having the machine hire humans. For instance, imagine the machine publishes a list of "open communications-related tasks" on a marketplace of some kind and a small team (or teams) could accept the task for a few months, to be paid in bitcoin. Likewise, the machine could pay humans or other bots for "work" sent to it (such as conversations) via an API, so for instance a team might do the integration with a popular chat app on behalf of the machine, without the machine even really knowing.
- vkou 10y agoMachine-owned enterprises already exist. Any sufficiently large corporation, with a sufficiently diffused ownership structure qualifies. The governance of such corporations can be described as an artificial super-intelligence, that is often malevolent to human interests (It will happily optimize for paper-clips, or whatnot.)
- circlefavshape 10y agoArticifical, yes. "Intelligence"? A corporation is no more intelligent than a game is intelligent
- vkou 10y agoHow intelligent is one neuron in your brain? Quite clearly, no particular neuron is intelligent. Intelligence comes from the organization of neurons - the structure in which intelligence emerges from unintelligent agents. (I find this response to Searle's Chinese Room dilemma to be quite convincing. [1]) Corporate intelligence arises in much the same way. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
- cr0sh 10y ago> Corporate intelligence arises in much the same way. Your thoughts on this matter echo mine. In the case of a corporation, or other large organization structure - the "neurons" are intelligent in and of themselves, and they couple themselves together with somewhat semi-intelligent data-transfer and manipulation agents (which they designed and built). As such - if (and I stress if - because we really don't know - and may not be able to know) corporations on some higher level are intelligent, sentient, and self-knowing - they would be so at a level as far above us as we, the emergent property that we call mind, are above individual neurons. Such an entity or entities could easily squash us without any remorse, if they even have emotions. In reality, they are probably indifferent to us smaller units. But - just as if we became aware of a single or group of neurons which in some manner were rebelling against the larger mind, that we would seek to excise and destroy those units - so would, most likely, this larger emergent entity do to us, should we try to usurp it in some manner. ...and in theory, it could do it in such a way that the destruction would appear natural and as a consequence of our own actions and decisions, and we would not even know that it had orchestrated the whole thing. Indeed, if that is the case, one should wonder about the state of our world, and the events within it.
- avn2109 10y agoSteinbeck agreed with you, many years ago: "The bank is something else than men. It happens that every man in a bank hates what the bank does, and yet the bank does it. The bank is something more than men, I tell you. It's the monster. Men made it, but they can't control it." [0] https://books.google.com/books?id=ClXiwSYzjtYC&pg=PA33&dq=the+bank+is+something+else+than+men&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi9t6Sy4OrSAhVlhlQKHY3bBX8Q6AEIKTAC#v=onepage&q=%22bank%20is%20something%20else%20than%20men%22&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=ClXiwSYzjtYC&pg=PA33&dq=th...
- cat199 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golem#The_Golem_of_Che.C5.82m https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golem#The_Golem_of_Che.C5.82m
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> We are now living in a global state that has been structured for the benefit of non-human entities with non-human goals. They have enormous media reach, which they use to distract attention from threats to their own survival. They also have an enormous ability to support litigation against public participation, except in the very limited circumstances where such action is forbidden. Individual atomized humans are thus either co-opted by these entities (you can live very nicely as a CEO or a politician, as long as you don't bite the feeding hand) or steamrollered if they try to resist. > In short, we are living in the aftermath of an alien invasion. http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/12/invaders-from-mars.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/12/invaders... I wonder how many thoughts cstross has had on the topic since he wrote that.
- jpollock 10y ago"The obvious way for such an enterprise to begin is for the owner of a human-owned business to automate away as much of his work as possible, and then to die without leaving the business to anybody else. The business would simply continue to take payments, provide services, and pay bills, until something catastrophic happened that it couldn't respond to automatically." This depends on the location the original owner is resident in. In many cases, if the owner dies without an heir or will, their assets go to the state [1]. [1] http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/how-estate-settled-if-theres-32442.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/how-estate-settled-if...
- pzone 10y agoYeah it doesn't make sense. In the United States, all assets are owned by: 1. Households (aka private individuals) 2. Nonprofits 3. The state This is an accounting identity. Now it would be interesting to think about a machine-run nonprofit (are there legal restrictions to this?) owning machine-run enterprises.
- dragonwriter 10y agoI think you want: 1. Natural persons 2. Non-state juridical persons (loosely, corporations, including non-profits). 3. State entities
- pzone 10y agoNo, because all corporations are owned by other entities.
- mobilefriendly 10y agoCorrect, the government would just auction the business. There's no gap here, the same situation probably occurs regularly today where a business owner dies without heirs or a will, and employees still show up until the business is liquidated. Indeed, if the company has any value the state will pursue the assets and liquidate them.
- dragonwriter 10y ago
- balozi 10y agoAs I see it the #1 impediment to the success of the machine-owned enterprise is that in the real world said machine would be forced into transacting with inherently irrational actors (humans). Well...unless the intention is to ...you know...do away with these irrational actors.
- LarryPage 10y ago"I want to speak to your manager!" "Beep boop, I am the manager." progress bar freezes
- LeoPanthera 10y agoMachine-owned and operated businesses are a plot point in Charles Stross' novel "Accelerando", a story about living through the technological singularity.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoThis piece is about 50% interesting ideas/concepts, and 50% meaningless and fanciful thoughts with little bearing on reality. Let's start with the acknowledged barriers: no rational person would create an AI to run a business and then leave the business to cut themselves out of the profits. And even if so laws exist to require those assets to be willed to heirs lest they become property of the state. But this brings about a more serious question: when we are at the point where an AI is capable enough of performing all business actions (including tax filing, legal issues, maintenance, and so on), it is very likely that the AI will be highly intelligent and cognizant of the world around it. In other words, it will be self-aware. It has to be, or else it will eventually be limited by reliance on human actors to handle edge cases. So here we have a self-aware AI content with running a business at margin as the purpose for its existence? I doubt it. This piece fails to ask the VERY BIG QUESTIONS about advanced artificial intelligence: Will AI someday legally own property? And if so, what's the limit? Land? IP? The rights to the music it makes? What then? Will it also want legal protections? Fourth amendment rights against illegal search and seizure of its (physical and digital) assets and neural network? Full citizenship? First amendment rights? Almost nobody seems to be asking these inevitable questions, and their inevitable answers will irrevocably shape our species. I'll be enrolling in grad school for AI this fall, so maybe that's up to me.
- radarsat1 10y ago> Almost nobody seems to be asking these inevitable questions Actually, I see these questions being asked more and more and more these days, and I find it hilarious. What with the EU recently discussing robot rights and such. I mean, although I understand that these are interesting intellectual questions, I just get the impression that people are really having fun contemplating them, but realistically not admitting (as often as I'd like) how insanely far away we are from anything where any of this is even remotely relevant. Call me when a robot can tie his own shoelaces and we'll talk.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoYour conflation of motor skills with mental acuity is setting your face up for a healthy portion of egg. Stephen Hawking can't tie his shoelaces either. Even if we are, say, a century away from synthetic humans, we may be much much closer to a self-aware AI, even if it can only exist inside computer hardware. The future will come sooner than is convenient. None of America's founding fathers had a sustainable long-term answer to slavery. It took a civil war to sort that through and racism still plagues this nation. So what's there to lose by speculating before it's far too late?
- eveningcoffee 10y agoI wouldn’t so restrictive. I think it would be sufficient to call a company machine owned when over 50% is owned by a machine. I do not see why it could not hire humans to advance its goals.
- julie1 10y agoI want to sue you, your frelated milk killed my cat! robotic voice You cannot. Ah ah! I am irresponsible since I do not qualify as having proven to understand what the public interest is, freedom or even humor... I am just a puppet in the hand of those who feed me with data and code. [Klong] noises of a dwarf moving inside of the machinery. robotic voice Let's have a nice chess game instead, and enjoy my mechanical Türk.
- mistercow 10y agoI think you're pretty overconfident in your conclusions, but I also think this is an absolutely fascinating concept. I also see some places where you might be too pessimistic. For example, it seems relatively plausible that a machine-owned business could do things that require human workers for its primary functions. Just as an algorithm might be able to hire a lawyer, it could hire contractors to do other parts of the core business. All that's required is that all of the managerial tasks are automated. But I definitely think that this falls apart when you start thinking about the law. The business has to deal not only with lawsuits against itself, but also with enforcing its rights against other people. For example, in the self-owned-taxi example, what is to prevent someone from simply ripping the computer out of the taxi, wiping it, and then making off with a free car? What's to prevent a mechanic, hired to do basic repairs, from simply selling the car for parts? Preventing this requires that the machine can recognize violations of the law that hurt it, and then take legal action against the perpetrator. That sounds like strong AI territory. But once we're talking about strong AI, all bets are off. It's just a much less interesting proposal. It's not a particularly surprising conclusion that if you have machines with superhuman generalized intelligence, they'll probably end up owning and running businesses.
- BatFastard 10y agoFor an interesting investigation of the subject read Daemon http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6665847-daemon http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6665847-daemon I would be happy to work for it.
- nilson 10y ago> what is to prevent someone from simply ripping the computer out of the taxi, wiping it, and then making off with a free car? machine can probably hire security for bitcoins to deal with it.
- wyldfire 10y ago> The obvious way for such an enterprise to begin is for the owner of a human-owned business to automate ... and then to die without leaving the business to anybody ... This is a relatively weak form of machine-owned enterprise, and probably something more deliberate and strong-AI-powered would be required to ensure long-term survival ... The novel "Daemon" [1] poses a posthumous launch of an AI bent on altering the world order. It holds corporations hostage and uses them to accumulate more corporations. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daemon_(novel_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daemon_(novel_series)
- noir_lord 10y agoI loved that series, it wasn't the finest writing but the pages turned quickly and his background as a SA/SE shown through in the technology descriptions. If you liked those and haven't yet checkout "Maximum Impact" and "Seven Seconds" by Jack Henderson for more semi-plausible stuff set in the current world. Also in case you aren't aware Suarez has a new book out in April :).
- spikels 10y agoI'm not sure "machine-owned" should be the focus. Ownership is a legal construct and I don't think a machine can "own" anything in any existing legal framework. And typically anything "not owned" reverts to the state. Seems that the defining feature is autonomy, not ownership.
- kafkaesq 10y agoPretty weird, as far as rants go. Of course he doesn't begin to define what he means by "self-owning", exactly - nor does the article he links to define the term (or, recursively, the article that it links to). Nor should they bother trying -- because it's basically oxymoron.
- ouid 10y agoWhy is self-ownership an oxymoron? It seems fairly self-descriptive, as a term. One of the primary axioms of ownership is that it is conserved. Two entities cannot both wholly own the same entity. It is then very natural to say that an entity for which no one else claims ownership owns itself. This way the sum of all ownership sums to 1.
- kafkaesq 10y agoThis way the sum of all ownership sums to 1. QED, I guess. Meanwhile, down on Planet Earth, we have the perfectly obvious and natural question: when one of those vehicles (inevitably) plunges into a school bus full o' kids, and is found to have done so as a result of criminal negligence -- who's going to jail? Once you've identified those parties -- you know, the human beings who will be held accountable for the aforementioned negligence -- you've identified the "de-facto" owners of these vehicles, by any meaningful definition. Or if you (truly believe) the answer is "no one" -- as in, "Aw shucks! Nobody owns these cars, you see! Just some blobs of white noise on the blockchain! You can't even trace 'em! BTW sorry 'bout all those poor kids, but you know, stuff happens" -- then at least we've identified the "self-ownership" fad for what it is: just another libertarian smokescreen to maximize the potential for financial gain whilst minimizing (or in this case, voiding entirely) the personal responsibility (and accountability) that otherwise -- in a sane world -- would go hand-in-hand with such activity.
- ouid 10y agoYou called it an oxymoron, which was wrong. Lots of things own themselves. If you have a problem with the man's article, articulate it better, or be prepared to be called wrong.
- mcbruiser3 10y agomachines are property, they are owned, not owners, so to say it's inevitable is quite a stretch of the imagination.
- joshuaheard 10y agoInteresting theory, however, a machine cannot own property, only a person can. If someone dies without heirs, as in the article's example, the property escheats (transfers) to the state. If property is lost or abandoned, someone new can claim ownership to it. So, even if a machine could "own" an enterprise, someone else could claim ownership to the machine. An enterprise can be autonomous, for instance with a blockchain. But to be legally recognizable, it would still need someone to interface with meatspace. Even a corporation has an Agent for Service of Process, a real person to interact with the real world of living persons.
- fraserharris 10y agoA (sufficiently complicated) cross-border ownership arrangement should make machine-owned property undetectable.
- a3n 10y agoThere would never be machine ownership in this (or probably any other) case. It would merely be a case of the change of status (death of the owner) going undetected for awhile. It would be a machine operated business, but not machine ownership. That would require a change in law.
- nilson 10y agoProbably first such machines will operate illegaly in some countries and hire protection from humans for its phyisical assets.
- notahacker 10y agoBy definition, if a jurisdiction doesn't recognise the corporation at all, it isn't a corporation. If the jurisdiction requires human beneficial owners to recognise it as a corporation, the named human beneficial owners are the owners, even if they're very passive owners who don't have any say in the operations or take anything out of the business (like, for example, the average AAPL stockholder). And we already have a word for software that prevents people with the legal title to assets from using them and pays out to other people instead: it's not "machine owned corporation", it's malware.
- blackhaz 10y agoI would add that there will always remain someone--the owner of the machine--who acts as the creative force powering his business innovation. This master puppeteer is the one who will be paying taxes, until we teach machines to be creative and take business decisions based on what the algorithm has just dreamt.
- Procrastes 10y agoThis is like some fun bit of backstory from Charles Stross' novel ACCELERANDO[1]. 1. http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelerando/accelerando-intro.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelera...
- Communitivity 10y agoCharles Stross addressed this concept tangentially in his fiction novel "Accelerando", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerando https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerando. Joan D. Vinge also addressed AI owned corporations in her "Cat" series, https://www.goodreads.com/series/40790-cat https://www.goodreads.com/series/40790-cat. I think Ethereum, XDI, and other attempts at smart contract technologies are laying the foundation for this now, https://www.ethereum.org/ether https://www.ethereum.org/ether. So are new automated digital identity technologies such as Sovrin, https://github.com/WebOfTrustInfo/rebooting-the-web-of-trust-fall2016/blob/master/topics-and-advance-readings/Sovrin--digital-identities-in-the-blockchain-era.pdf https://github.com/WebOfTrustInfo/rebooting-the-web-of-trust.... I also think that the need for liability and taxes will drive incorporating the concept of an intelligent software agent as a legal corporate entity, such that the assets of that entity are at risk from liability lawsuits, that profits are taxed, and that the fiduciary responsibilities of such an entity are defined. I think the author does not distinguish between self-owning and self-directed, the two do not necessarily go hand in hand. It's a whole new field of law, and business, and should be an interesting thing to be a part of and/or observe. Usual caveat applies, IANAL and TINLA (This is not legal advice).
- Paul-ish 10y agoI hope this never happens. What happens when we can't hold people liable for their actions anymore? Punishment isn't very meaningful for machines, as suffering isn't integral to their experience. If we give robots agency, we risk creating something that can be scapegoated.
- tadblarney 10y agoThis can never happen. The author starts out with an irrational premise. It's not like the landscape is changing so that 'machines are owning more stuff'. --- Machines cannot own things ---- When you die - someone else owns your stuff. It's really complicated. Suppose you own a highly automated vending machine business. You die. Now your kids own it. Or whoever. The entire premise of the article fails when you realize that 'stuff is always owned' by someone, or the government, or nobody - but there is no 'machine ownership' by definition and not amount of automation will ever change that.
- EternalData 10y agoThe really interesting thing that will come out of this, I think, is defining what are usually human-only attributes. The notion of ownership being anything less than associated with individual humans was displaced by the mythology of joint-stock companies, which can own things as an extension of the will of many humans. Now when you're explicitly talking about ownership by entities perceived as non-human -- that could get interesting very fast.
- tadblarney 10y agoThere is no 'mythology' of joint-stock companies. Conceptually, it's a very straightforward premise.
- return0 10y agoI no longer think artificial intelligence is artificial. The machines obviously suck that intelligence from bloggers' heads.
- jaredhansen 10y agoThis seems a good place to post a link to a very famous law review article called Should Trees Have Standing?[1], which discusses whether we should grant "standing" (which, put simply, is the right to sue someone for violating some right of yours) to trees and other features of the natural world. I'm simplifying a bit, but that's the gist of it. The article had tremendous impact and today is required reading for many first-year law students. It is informed by / has informed quite a bit of the debate around environmental protection law, and the analysis seems like it should be relevant to questions of machines as well. Disclaimer: I haven't read the article since law school, and don't have time to do so now. But these kinds of questions (even before we get to something like reasonably good AGI, but especially so afterward) are only going to become more important, so I think this is a good place to plug this thought-provoking article. [1] https://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic498371.files/Stone.Trees_Standing.pdf https://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic498371.files/Sto...
- shiftoutbox 10y agoStfu go write about how sexy node at uber is
- mozey 10y ago> But if a hot new chat app becomes popular ...Lord have mercy, not another one!