5 ms·
Same thing for Hacker News - you can't change your username and keep your karma. I guess the designers just don't design for that. https://www.quora.com/Why-can
by tim333 10y ago
Same thing for Hacker News - you can't change your username and keep your karma. I guess the designers just don't design for that. https://www.quora.com/Why-cant-I-change-my-username-on-Hacker-News https://www.quora.com/Why-cant-I-change-my-username-on-Hacke...
- mayoff 10y agoI wouldn't want an HN user to be able to ditch her reputation while keeping her karma.
- axlprose 10y agoPerhaps not in that case, but regardless, this is the kind of thing should be designed in deliberately as a feature (with an option to bypass it under special circumstances), rather than some accidental/arbitrary technical limitation just because the dev team didn't bother to implement the ability to update the field for whatever reason.
- CM30 10y agoGiven your profile shows all your comments and submissions (and would likely still show them if only the name was changed), I'm not sure what the big deal is here.
- mayoff 10y agoYou learn to recognize the names of active users that post in threads you're interested in. I shouldn't be able to ditch that recognition but keep my karma, and you shouldn't have to look through my history to see if I'm someone you previously recognized.
- CM30 10y agoEh, maybe I don't see it. I mean, I use a lot of internet forums running scripts like XenForo and IPB, and those let you change your 'display name' whenever the hell you like. Yet I still recognise everyone perfectly fine. There are people on my forums that change their display name, avatar and signature on a weekly basis. I still recognise them just fine. Same works on Discord too. There you can change your name whenever the hell you feel like it. Again, doesn't stop most people recognising you.
- cookiecaper 10y agoThe difference is that changing your username creates a completely new identity. It's not just correcting a typo.
- brokenmachine 10y agoThe point is that it doesn't need to be that way. Why can't username be an editable field?
- cookiecaper 10y agoBecause it creates a new identity. The only way anyone on HN can recognize you is your username. Changing it at will would allow anyone to shed their identity on HN at any time while keeping the karma and account privileges they've accumulated. Perhaps that is something that's worth allowing, and iirc dang et al have made some vague statements that they may be interested in allowing that at some point, but the ramifications would be substantial. This isn't something that should be taken lightly, nor should it be expected/implicit that a social site will accommodate new identities on-demand.
- brokenmachine 10y ago> Because it creates a new identity. And? My anonymous (to everyone but the NSA) username will be a different anonymous username. The karma/privileges are entirely dependent on the quality of my posts, not some inherent value of the username. Also the posts that generated that karma would still be there under the new username. I'm not too concerned either way , but I don't see why that would be a big deal.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAgain, identity. You're not anonymous here, you're pseudonymous. Believe it or not, but I do actually recognize a lot of people here by their HN usernames, and I would mind if those were to randomly change all the time. Anyway, I suspect that if you e-mail HN mods, they could be able to correct your username in no time. But making it any easier than that would, IMO, be harmful to community.
- Dylan16807 10y agoA brand new HN account is worthless, so typos don't matter because you can make a new account and redo your single post. Changing a name that was correct is a totally different problem from a typo at ingest.