3 ms·
Option 1: DRM concerns (exploiting the "analog hole" on digital level, or HDCP restrictions - how deep is HDCP actually enforced in Android?) Option 2: Privacy
by mschuster91 10y ago
Option 1: DRM concerns (exploiting the "analog hole" on digital level, or HDCP restrictions - how deep is HDCP actually enforced in Android?)
Option 2: Privacy (call recorders come to mind - unrelated: does anyone know of a working call recorder?)
- arrty88 10y agoI can record calls on iOS
- rahimnathwani 10y agoSo if I call your regular phone number (the one attached to the SIM that's in your iPhone) you can record both sides of the audio for that call? How?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- conradev 10y agoThat's hard to do using the built-in Phone app even on jailbroken devices (the default repos won't list call recorders).
- tunocina 10y agoHow?
- eli 10y agoOption 2 seems weird since I'm pretty sure Google Voice lets you record calls.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Option 2 seems weird since I'm pretty sure Google Voice lets you record calls. Only inbound calls, not outbound, and that's by design - it's to ensure both parties consent (since there's no way for Google to know whether the call falls under one-party or two-party consent laws).
- eli 10y agoWhat does inbound vs outbound have to do with consent?
- chimeracoder 10y agoWhen you start recording a call, it plays a brief message (e.g. "this call is now being recorded"). If it's an outbound call, you could start recording before the other person has actually picked up. If it's inbound, they "know" that the other person will hear the message. It's not actually foolproof if you sit down and think about the edge cases, but that's the rationale behind it. It's a decision driven by the legal team, not the product or engineering ones.
- e12e 10y agoAre there any major jurisdictions where this is actually a requirement? I was under the impression that a) it makes no sense, anyone could use an external recorder, and more importantly b) when you are talking with someone, you don't have an expectation of privacy from the person you are talking with? Where would this meaningless feature-cripling make sense?
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Are there any major jurisdictions where this is actually a requirement? For starters, twelve states in the US, including California: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_recording_laws#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_recording_laws#Unite... And telecom companies (Google acting in the role of a telecom company in this case) have certain responsibilities and liabilities if they facilitate illegal recordings.
- apostacy 10y agoI used CallRec. It wasn't easy to get it working. After rooting my phone, I had to spend hours making other tweaks. And of course the software ecosystem is so fragmented, and if you do want to find anything out, you have to sift through mountains of misinformation.