15 ms·
LastPass RCE vulnerability fixed
- sp332 10y agoApparently this was fixed server-side and does not require any update to the client. However the default version on addons.mozilla.org is very old for some reason, so if you are running 3.x it wouldn't hurt to download the latest. You can get it either from LastPass's website directly or from https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/lastpass-password-manager/versions/beta https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/lastpass-pass...
- derobert 10y agoThe 3.x is still updated, but they're replacing it soon. 4.x is a WebExtension, with a different UI. See https://blog.lastpass.com/2017/03/plans-to-retire-the-lastpass-3-3-2-firefox-add-on.html/ https://blog.lastpass.com/2017/03/plans-to-retire-the-lastpa... for details.
- sp332 10y agoOh you're right. I was confused and there are two bugs, only one of which has been fixed so far. The first one, which is apparently still unfixed, mentioned here https://twitter.com/taviso/status/842205051082821632 https://twitter.com/taviso/status/842205051082821632 only works on 3.x on Firefox.
- koolba 10y agoLooks like this was discovered by the same guy that discovered CloudFail. That dude is amazing.
- yeukhon 10y agoWell, this is Project Zero, the security researchers working there are highly competent, but I do agree this guy is amazing. I wonder what kind of methodology do they use to even come up with these attacks.
- dsacco 10y agoHaving briefly interacted with a few of them, and following their work in general: 1. They have a phenomenal intuition for where developers get lazy, tired or simply incompetent in security-sensitive code, 2. They have, in aggregate, a vast knowledge and understanding of past vulnerabilities and how those might be repeated elsewhere or imperfectly patched, 3. They practice a lot and they read a lot (i.e. relevant research, etc). It might be more accurate to say that they have a lot of practice because of their work, not that they actively practice outside of work. 4. They are good at the general process of security research - long hours of mostly dull, complex research interspersed with brief eureka moments and bouts of euphoria. They're an extraordinary team, for sure.
- awirth 10y agoNatalie Silvanovich of Project Zero gave a talk at REcon last year about how she finds flash bugs, and she went into her methodology some: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JbvwCEOxyrA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JbvwCEOxyrA
- puzzle 10y agoHe also found vulnerabilities in many more security products out there. At some point, years ago, Microsoft became very hostile toward him, but things seem to be better now.
- snakeanus 10y ago> Microsoft became very hostile toward him What happened?
- puzzle 10y agoLittle of it was made public, but http://www.theverge.com/2013/5/23/4358400/google-engineer-bashes-microsoft-discloses-windows-flaw http://www.theverge.com/2013/5/23/4358400/google-engineer-ba... "Microsoft treat vulnerability researchers with great hostility," he says.
- wolf550e 10y agoLook at all his bugs: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/list?can=1&q=owner%3Ataviso%40google.com&colspec=ID+Type+Status+Priority+Milestone+Owner+Summary&cells=ids https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/list?can=1&q...
- romuloab42 10y agoThis is golden: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=693 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=69...
- jessaustin 10y agoI'll bookmark this for the next time someone recommends AV of any sort...
- dsacco 10y agoOne of the best vulnerability researchers in the world right now. Tavis Ormandy is a spectre of doom. He is one of the last people you want to see tweeting about your company. Every member of Google's Project Zero team is individually more capable and productive than entire teams of consultants at the best security firms.
- awirth 10y agoThis is a bit disingenuous. It's almost impossible to measure the output of the other teams/consultants because their reports are never made public. I wish that we had more opportunities available for researchers to do the work that Tavis is doing. He is very very good and highly productive, but he's not somehow orders of magnitude better at his research than others. The thing that makes him unique is that Google is paying him a full-time salary just to find bugs and post them publicly. He doesn't have to worry about only targeting stuff in bug bounty scope or working on executive-targeted write-ups and consultation reports to make ends meet. Basically, he gets paid to spend all day, every day, finding bugs and documenting them for people to see. We need more people in those sorts of positions, but only Google is really able to bankroll it.
- dsacco 10y agoYou make a fair point, but I don't think it's an argument against what I'm saying. If for no other reason than what you stated about being paid for such open goals, he certainly is more productive than most consulting teams. And given his practice and experience at that sort of productivity, he's likely more capable as well. I agree that security consulting results should be more open, but incentives are not really aligned for that to be the case.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoThe guy must get tired saving the world so frequently. I hope Google literally pays him a dumptruck full of money.
- emn13 10y agoI've got to say, this attack looks a little too obvious; that doesn't reflect well on lastpass.
- svenfaw 10y agoThe high number of vulnerabilities that keep being found in LastPass (including some that are not publicly disclosed) forced me to jump ship a while ago.
- mikecb 10y agoConcern about code quality is legitimate, and vulns discovered is one metric for that, but I worry that hopping to the unreviewed (and therefore lacking vuln disclosures) app is even worse. But I don't use lastpass.
- Analemma_ 10y agoOther managers have been reviewed, and found better success than LastPass. I (finally) signed up for a password manager a little while ago, and after some evaluation chose 1Password. A big part of that decision was that they have been reviewed/audited and there were a couple vulnerabilities found, but they were all minor, which indicates to me the system is pretty secure. The nature of the bugs was also comforting in that they seemed like small oversights, compared to a lot of the LastPass bugs which seem like "holy shit how did you let this happen".
- awirth 10y agoWhat other ones have been reviewed? I'd be interested to read the audit reports.
- mdekkers 10y agosame here. Trialling Dashlane, but not quite convinced yet..
- 10y ago
- codys 10y agoNote that this issue references another (not yet public) issue which is apparently for LastPass on firefox. I expect we'll see a LastPass + Firefox issue in the near future. > (Please note, issue 1188 which affects LastPass on firefox is not fixed, and still works)
- blakesterz 10y agoThis made me laugh: "They also said they couldn't get my exploit to work, but I checked my apache access logs and they were using a Mac. Naturally, calc.exe will not appear on a Mac."
- Exuma 10y agoThat is honestly embarrassing. I'm glad I don't use LastPass.
- elastic_church 10y agoMy girlfriend was wondering why programmers are so pedantic, and my primary response was "because they can never be wrong", and as a corollary it becomes important to always be right and develop a culture that points out every flaw in competence. Its a pretty bad trait we should do something about that and just continue striving for peer reviewable code and implementations.
- Exuma 10y agoI know what you mean, but it's also despicable when companies which are based around security don't take the extra care they should to protect their users. I don't respect that, and I think they deserve every ounce of criticism. With that said, I definitely agree on things that aren't security related.
- martin1975 10y agoI do. What else does auto form fills based on urls, client side encryption, and runs in chrome, IE and Safari?
- mcbutterbunz 10y agoI would suggest not using the auto fill feature of password managers. I use 1Password and the mini UI that sits in the tray is super easy to copy a password from and paste in the browser.
- bluedonuts 10y agoLong time unhappy user of Lastpass here. Would really like to hear what alternatives people are using that have at least the following features: 1. Mac/Window/Linux support 2. Ability to control accounts from an admin account. PW/2FA reset, export/wipe of accounts etc. 3. Reasonably secure 4. Not too terrible to use for Engineers/non-techies alike.
- marksomnian 10y agoNot sure about point 2, but 1Password seems to fit all the others. Really like it, personally.
- moyix 10y ago1Password didn't support Linux last time I checked. There are 3rd party libraries, but most of them don't support the newer keychain format. I still use it and just look up the password on my phone when I'm on a Linux system.
- nsm 10y ago1password has their opvault format spec on the website and https://github.com/OblivionCloudControl/opvault https://github.com/OblivionCloudControl/opvault can decrypt. Admittedly the UX is lacking.
- moyix 10y agoI've tried that library, actually. Last time I used it, it couldn't find some passwords in the vault, including (crucially) the one I use for SSO at work. It's totally possible I was just using it wrong – it would be nice if the repository had a demo command line tool or something.
- BenElgar 10y agoI believe 1Password only supports Windows and OS X on the desktop.
- 10y ago
- homakov 10y agoThis is why we need a mirror method for postMessage to securely receive cross origin messages https://medium.com/@homakov/why-we-need-getmessage-too-a74110783f26 https://medium.com/@homakov/why-we-need-getmessage-too-a7411...
- sp332 10y agoUpdate: another vulnerability found, not patched yet. https://mobile.twitter.com/taviso/status/844312124541186048 https://mobile.twitter.com/taviso/status/844312124541186048
- ktta 10y agoWell. This is not a good week for lastpass. And for all the users of password managers which use a browser extension or a cloud synced database, KeepPassXC[1] is a good alternative, because it won't come close to touching your browser or any remote server. It is cross platform so you have no excuse. It also has a mobile app which is not made by the same developers but a different company so I would be wary of the app. [1]:https://keepassxc.org/ https://keepassxc.org/
- peak_body_yo 10y agoIs this any better than KeePassX?
- ozo 10y agoFrom https://keepassxc.org/docs https://keepassxc.org/docs: >Why KeePassXC instead of KeePassX? >KeePassX is an amazing password manager, but hasn't seen much active development for quite a while. Many good pull requests were never merged and the original project is missing some features which users can expect from a modern password manager. Hence, we decided to fork KeePassX to continue its development and provide you with everything you love about KeePassX plus many new features and bugfixes.
- tedivm 10y agoI'm really surprised, and disappointed, that Travis announced this publicly like this. From my understanding the Google team has a policy of giving people time to patch the bug before announcing it. I know that the technical details weren't released by by confirming there is a zero day exploit he's making it more likely to be discovered and exploited. The responsible thing would have been to notify the vendor and apply the standard policy they have in place for disclosure.
- droopybuns 10y ago>>Its a pretty bad trait we should do something about that and just continue striving for peer reviewable code and implementations. COMMENT OF THE DECADE. If you think that lastpass should be embarrassed based on what Tavis has written, maybe consider taking a lit criticism class. There is a concept called an "unreliable narrator." Tavis has a documented track record of poor interpersonal behavior. It's time that people stopped focusing exclusively on the quality of his discoveries and started to ask if his behavior is one we want to implement. For all of project zero's bullshit on 90 day disclosure policies- there is clearly a different set of rules for Android. There is obvious internal discussion on the topic. Please be skeptical of Tavis' framing of what's going on. He's not projecting the personality of a sympathetic person.
- mdekkers 10y agoTavis has a documented track record of poor interpersonal behavior. It's time that people stopped focusing exclusively on the quality of his discoveries and started to ask if his behavior is one we want to implement. Given what he does, the quality of his discoveries are really the only important thing. Do you really think that "form over function" is important in the context of what he does?
- ajb 10y agoThat's a pretty serious claim to make about someone, and you haven't backed it up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Strom 10y agoIt's not like Tavis is creating these bugs. He's merely pointing out that the emperor has no clothes. Quite a socially awkward situation for town folk who've been living as if the clothes are wonderful. Additionally, in general and as is the case here, the bugs aren't in some nice kid's hobby project. It's not like he's pointing out that grandma's blog has XSS vulnerabilities. These are security products, which often seem like snake oil instead. If anything we need more stigma against people and products who claim strong security but turn out to be shams, providing only security theater. Some things just need much more expertise to do than others. You wouldn't want a hobbyist designing your local nuclear reactor, nor performing your heart surgery. Similar standards should be in place for computer security. Accepting security systems that were hacked together like another CMS will lead to our digital lives being on a foundation of straw.
- joshschreuder 10y agoThe test page is still vulnerable for me. https://lock.cmpxchg8b.com/SaiGhij5/lastpass.html https://lock.cmpxchg8b.com/SaiGhij5/lastpass.html Chrome 57.0.2987.110 (64-bit) Version: 4.1.42 Built: Thu Mar 09 2017 12:40:16 GMT-0500 (EST) Binary Component: true (Native Messaging version 4.1.34, built Jan 11 2017 01:45:24) Any idea why? I thought no user action was required? No custom error message for NXDOMAIN (I think?), I see the Lastpass site, then calc.exe opens. https://twitter.com/LastPass/status/844176201392504834 https://twitter.com/LastPass/status/844176201392504834
- shawnz 10y agoStill works for me too. I guess I'm disabling the extension for now.
- joshschreuder 10y agoJust tried again and they've pulled down the website, so the exploit is no longer working.
- bflesch 10y agoBrilliant find by taviso. So simple yet thousands of others passed over it. It takes a relentless mind to comb through all this code and actually find such an issue.
- munin 10y ago> So simple yet thousands of others passed over it. is that true? how do you know?
- bflesch 10y agoLastPas has been in the spotlight for quite some time now, and repeatedly critized by the security community. I've also read various articles about alleged security flaws with LastPass (which were quickly resolved by the team).
- username223 10y agoIs it just me, or are these "cloud password managers" a terrible idea given the typical person's threat model? First, there are hackers looking to score a huge pile of accounts. Second, there could be a relatively unsophisticated person with a grudge, like an ex-partner. In a distant third, there are nation-state-level actors. If I keep a local encrypted password file and copy it around by hand, I may have some vulnerabilities, but it's not worth a hacker's time to steal only my accounts, and I can probably protect my credentials from casual malice. On the other hand, if I put my passwords on the same service as hundreds of thousands of other people, that's a huge jackpot that attracts significant hacking interest, and the service only has to screw up once. The risk doesn't seem worth the convenience.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoAs soon as you put a Keepass encrypted database onto any cloud service (e.g. DropBox, Google Drive, etc) you've effectively just recreated LastPass. Both use an AES-256 encrypted database encrypted using a master password which is first hashed using a modern/slow hashing algorithm. Obviously it is imperfect that the LastPass plugin has bugs in it; and I won't defend that. But I will say that the convenience is worth the risk most of the time, but LastPass needs to be better than this if they want to maintain people's respect and trust. If you intend to keep your encrypted password database completely offline (e.g. USB keys) then, sure, it is more secure but very few users are willing to take on such inconvenience. Password Managers in general have resulted in less password reuse, longer passwords, and more random passwords. Last Pass in particular offers "one click" password rotation on dozens of popular services.
- wsinks 10y agoOne click password rotation! I had no idea.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoIt is neat but only on a select list of popular sites, you can see the list at the bottom of this page: https://helpdesk.lastpass.com/generating-a-password/#h2 https://helpdesk.lastpass.com/generating-a-password/#h2
- didibus 10y agoThis doesn't seem to me like it compromised the passwords though. Am I missing something?
- ktta 10y ago> Therefore, this allows complete access to internal privileged LastPass RPC commands. There are hundreds of internal LastPass RPCs, but the obviously bad ones are things copying and filling in passwords (copypass, fillform, etc). If you install the binary component (https://lastpass.com/support.php?cmd=showfaq&id=5576 https://lastpass.com/support.php?cmd=showfaq&id=5576), you can also use "openattach" to run arbitrary code. Any lastpass RPC was able to be called, which does mean that it compromised the passwords. Now, the worse part is that any code (any .bat file, which on windows is similar to a bash script) could be run on the host computer, which means they can effectively take over the host computer.
- Thriptic 10y agoHow would this theoretically affect a user with password re-prompt on for all of their accounts?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bgrohman 10y agoMost of the reported issues I've seen have been caused by browser extensions. It seems like uninstalling the extensions and just using the web app directly in a separate browser might go a long way towards avoiding these kinds of issues.