4 ms·
The first point is completely irrelevant. Beyond that, it doesn't really seem to matter – is anyone claiming that this is illegal versus a sign that the NZ lega
by acdha 10y ago
The first point is completely irrelevant. Beyond that, it doesn't really seem to matter – is anyone claiming that this is illegal versus a sign that the NZ legal system needs to change?
- wwalser 10y agoThe point that a company paid taxes, in response to an article with a title claiming that they paid $0 in taxes, is irrelevant?
- acdha 10y agoThe article was talking about corporate income taxes. The fact that they also paid property taxes doesn't add much to the conversation, and that's even more the case about whether their employees happened to pay personal income taxes.
- Dylan16807 10y agoGoing through the list of taxes and pointing out that they paid every single one of them with no discounts, but one got weirdly routed, is relevant.
- dangjc 10y agoSounds like NZ needs a destination based cash flow tax, like the idea that is floating around Congress now: https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/01/07/upshot/the-major-potential-impact-of-a-corporate-tax-overhaul.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/01/07/upshot/the-major-poten...
- Lazare 10y agoBut why does it need to change? Would NZ really be better off if it got to tax the NZ revenue of Australian companies operating in NZ but gave up being able to tax the Australian revenue of NZ companies operating in Australia? Given that Australia both NZ's largest trade partner and much larger (and somewhat wealthier) than NZ, isn't it likely that quite a lot of NZ companies earn significant amounts of revenue in Australia? Would NZ even come out ahead from such a change, even ignoring the (very significant) costs of a massive change to the tax code? Because offhand it doesn't look like it.
- acdha 10y agoI'm not saying it needs to change but that seems to be the argument of people like the Green Party member quoted. If the intention is to have a corporate tax it seems like a problem if huge amounts of money are exempted.
- Lazare 10y agoBut it's not being exempted; it's being taxed. At a higher rate! Right?