16 ms·
A hot bath has benefits similar to exercise
- woliveirajr 10y ago> These activities – such as soaking in a hot tub or taking a sauna – may have health benefits for people who are unable to exercise regularly. I would add not only "unable", but "unwilling". Some people don't get any pleasure by exercising, and perhaps having 50% of the benefits of cycling is better than having none.
- nsxwolf 10y agoCount me amongst the unwilling! I can't wait for a magic bullet or pill that gives me the results I want without trying. I'm supposed to feel guilty about that admission, but I do not.
- bananabill 10y agoit's called cosmetic surgery
- Jtsummers 10y agoThat will only give you the appearance of fitness, not the effect of it. You'll still be huffing and puffing as you climb the flights of stairs to the office the day the elevator breaks, though being lighter through liposuction will help reduce the difficulty of the task.
- mulmen 10y agoWhat's the going rate on an intelligence implant these days? Having cosmetic surgery to overcome a lack of exercise is like moving your fuel gauge to "Full" so you ever have to buy gas.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoIt's an interesting idea. Personally, I wonder how much of the benefit comes from facing and overcoming that unpleasantness. I feel that must be a part of how exercise engages your mind as well as your body.
- mulmen 10y agoI think considering exercise to be unpleasant is similar to considering math "too hard". It's a matter of attitude and perspective. You are probably right that there are benefits from overcoming that perspective but it's unfortunate that we continue to perpetuate the perception that these positive experiences are somehow negatives in the moment. We should really improve our internal marketing campaigns.
- mej10 10y agoThe problem with not exercising for HN-types is that your brain suffers because of it. Your cognition isn't as good as it could be and will decline faster than if you exercised. Also more likely to develop neuronal disorders later in life, and those aren't very fun. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurobiological_effects_of_physical_exercise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurobiological_effects_of_phy...
- ouid 10y agoright, he would like a pill which does this.
- nsxwolf 10y agoExactly!
- DanielleMolloy 10y agoDoes this take into account the time she could have spent learning new programming skills? Serious question. With pre- and post phases (changing clothes, shower) and the post-sluggishness, the exercise that you are doing in your free time just to do exercise can be quite an extra time investment. (no anti-exercise opinion here, but I find it better to combine exercise with commuting or real hobbies)
- mulmen 10y agoI think you are drawing a false dilemma here. Exercise is absolutely critical to mental and physical health, there are no substitutes. Studying and exercise should be balanced as time allows but exercise should never be eliminated. Studying without exercise would be like studying by only skimming text. It's really not worth the time if you can't understand and retain what you are studying.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoI think the problem with trying to mix exercise with hobbies or commuting is that they don't really satisfy the same physical goals. Hobbies are for fun. Commuting is for travel. They may involve physical exertion, but they repeat the same movement patterns over and over. You don't exercise all your muscles. E.g rock climbing is hard but doesn't exercise any pushing movements. Which can become a problem when only one set of muscles is trained. Good exercise will not only make you fitter in a generally useful way, but help you fix problems like flexibility or posture. I.E we are trying to fix your weaknesses, not just cater to your strengths.
- ouid 10y agoI too desire this, I feel guilty about it, but less so after this comment. Thank you.
- magic_beans 10y agoYour body WANTS to move around. There has to be some sport or physical activity you enjoy! Soccer? Badmitton? A game of tag? Land Quidditch?
- quakenul 10y agoLand Quidditch sounds awfully close to something something my mom would have made up, when trying to market something healthy but inherently boring to us as kids. Don't play with my heart like this. The disappointment is too real.
- zingermc 10y agoMany colleges in the US have (land) Quidditch teams. I've heard they sometimes have horrific injuries because the people on the team are not conventionally athletic.
- nsxwolf 10y agoMy brain doesn't want to move my body around. If my body enjoys it, it certainly has never told me it does. Quite the opposite.
- __jal 10y agoDitto. Some people simply don't understand that other people hate exercise. It is extremely unpleasant for me. I get that other people enjoy it. Wish I did, but I hate it. The only choice of activity that makes physical work bearable for me is some sort of tangible payoff - I can work hard building things. Some of my heaviest physical activity is carpentry and light construction. I still don't enjoy it, but working towards making something is enough payoff to make it worth it. For this reason, I do quite a bit more of that sort of thing than is probably normal for a desk jockey. I also walk about two miles a day, just two and from work. For whatever reason, my brain wiring doesn't see "vaguely feeling a bit better in three months, maybe living an extra year or two when everything is falling apart anyway" as sufficient. The puritans can start on with the you-weren't-raised-right judgements now. I've heard it before.
- coldtea 10y ago>I'm supposed to feel guilty about that admission, but I do not. It's not the admission that's problematic. It's that, until said magic bullet is found, this mindset leads a person nowhere health wise...
- nsxwolf 10y agoMaybe if there was a health reward of some kind every time you exercised then it would be different. But there's nothing. I just can't stick with doing something for weeks and weeks and weeks before I realize that I'm losing a small amount of weight, or able to perform a bit better than when I started.
- other_herbert 10y agoIt's called strava for running or cycling... It will show your progres on the same routes or over common segments... You don't even have to share that info with other people if you don't want to
- coldtea 10y ago>I just can't stick with doing something for weeks and weeks and weeks before I realize that I'm losing a small amount of weight, or able to perform a bit better than when I started. Hard or not, that's a bad attitude in life in general. Instant gratification seldom got people places...
- nsxwolf 10y agoI can think of very few other things with such poor reward systems. When I start washing dishes, I start seeing clean dishes immediately. Even if I have hundreds of dishes to wash, I can feel good about that first clean dish.
- coldtea 10y ago>I can think of very few other things with such poor reward systems. Anything important has a "poor reward system". General education for one. Better eating. Advancing at a career. Playing a musical instrument.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- atourgates 10y agoTrue, but the "50% of the benefits of cycling" isn't accurate. When I cycle for fun/exercise, with a heart rate monitor, I've burned (an estimated) as many as 650 calories in a half hour. A "normal" ride is typically closer to 800-1,000/hr. According to this chart[1] - a 150lb person cycling at a "moderate" pace would burn 563 calories. In the study, people sitting in hot tubs for an hour burned about 150 calories per hour, which is about 2x what you'd expect to burn during an hour of sleep. According to the study, sitting in a hot tub for an hour is more like 25% of the (calorie burning) benefit you'd expect from an hour of moderate cycling, and just under 20% of the benefit you'd expect from an hour of vigorous cycling. [1] http://www.nutristrategy.com/fitness/cycling.htm http://www.nutristrategy.com/fitness/cycling.htm
- mikeryan 10y agoSame here on calorie burn for cycling. Its 50% the caloric benefit of walking which seems a pretty low bar.
- dave_sullivan 10y agoOne thing I don't hear mentioned very much w/ exercise and calorie burning is that your body continues burning calories after working out and exercise changes the rate that your body burns calories throughout the day. For my workouts, I've found sprints and lifting weights on the heavy side to be great because my body spends a lot of energy rebuilding that muscle for a day or two after. I'd be surprised if baths can change your resting calorie burn rate but I could see them improving circulation and heart health. People should probably still exercise though. Heh, finally I have an excuse to get that jacuzzi in the living room...
- jnordwick 10y agoIt isn't very much. There are charts that show the post workout calorie utilization, and might was well not bother counting it. And if you are running a caloric deficit anyways, it might actually hurt you since your body cannot repair itself well anyways. Example, if you are trying to keep[ muscle while dieting (in caloric deficit), running and lifting heavy is a way to lose muscle.
- atom-morgan 10y ago> Some people don't get any pleasure by exercising Couldn't this be a result of not exercising? It doesn't seem to be a coincidence that people who've made exercise a habit generally seem to enjoy it more.
- Nadya 10y agoI've faithfully gone to the gym 5 times a week every week for a year and a half. I still despise exercise - but I like the results enough to keep going. My inspiration is simple [0]. Ultimately, I'm in control of how I look and feel. Exercise sucks - but it's the best way to keep myself looking how I want to look. That's the only motivation I need to suffer through it. [0] http://i.imgur.com/B63LzdF.jpg http://i.imgur.com/B63LzdF.jpg
- E6300 10y agoMaybe it's not exercise you hate, but the gym. I tried the gym once and dropped it because I hated it. A few years later I found running and loved it; then I found cycling and loved it even more. Exercise is tiring enough as it is (that's the point). You should at least find something you enjoy, otherwise it's even more likely that you won't do it.
- other_herbert 10y agoI agree.. I have had a greenway near me for 5 years before I started using it... If you can do something without even having to commute to it, it can be even easier to start a habit
- Nadya 10y agoI tried everything - lifting weights is the only thing that 'stuck'. I'd love to swim, but the only pool is at the gym and it's heavily chlorinated and I have to shower before and after swimming which is now outside of "convenient to exercise". The gym is a few minutes up the road, I'd jog but it's on an incline - terrible for the knees. Scan in, get changed, throw some weight around, wipe off the sweat (not enough time for a full shower), leave. It's convenient enough and something I've managed to stick with long-term.
- r00fus 10y agoWere they measuring outdoor cycling or indoor (exercise bike)? I think there's a huge qualitative difference between the two - breathing the outside air (and absorbing the sun if I'm lucky) probably do much more to improve my health and outlook than the simple calories burned.
- atourgates 10y agoI don't think it matters for this study. They only measured calories burned and inflammatory response, which, assuming the same amount of energy expended, I'd expect to be identical cycling on a trainer or outdoors.
- jwtadvice 10y agoI see a number of these articles from time to time about the health effects of (warm|cold) water treatment. Seems to me not to be a replacement for exercise, a healthy diet, and good sleep. Maybe as a supplement. Or maybe for someone who is injured or old or has limited opportunity. Unfortunately good scientific work along these lines very often lead to headlines that lead people to think: wow this is like a shake-weight but there's a science paper proving it. There's no replacement for hard work.
- gph 10y ago>There's no replacement for hard work. Not yet for physical health. But that saying kind of annoys me in a general sense given that the majority of technological advancement has specifically been to replace hard work we don't want to do. So there's good reason to believe a technological solution for physical health that doesn't require hard work will exist some time in the future.
- tbrownaw 10y agoDoes not follow. Just because we want something is not a good reason to think that it's possible. As I understand it, the health benefits of hard work are currently believed to be an integral part of that hard work. And, they're at least somewhat localized to whatever systems are doing the work. Or from another perspective, weight machines and indoor air-conditioned treadmills are your technological solution.
- cosmie 10y agoThey're the current technological solution, but they're essentially proxies to condense a naturally occurring process into a more efficient process; weight machines and treadmills provide an efficient method to work out whatever systems your exercise regime is designed to affect. But what you're after is the resulting byproduct of that exercise, not that exercise itself. Similar to how biking uses the same inputs as walking, but makes it more efficient. So if your goal is to get somewhere as efficiently as possible rather than walking in and of itself being the goal, you're going to bike instead. Then comes along the car and you're no longer constrained to the natural capabilities of your body in order to travel, and it's a whole new ballgame. Exercise has a lot of health benefits because it causes things in the body. From stretching things to tearing muscle fiber to causing your body to generate and release different hormones and steroids (and many, many other effects). The technological solution the OP wants is something which simulates the effects of exercise on the body but without the exercise itself. Such as nanomachines that can be designed to stress test different components of the body and keep them active or that cause the same types of micro-tears in muscular tissue that weight lifting does. As we learn more about the body, and we make smaller and smaller machines that are capable of operating from within the body, we can leverage those machines and that knowledge to directly maintain an ideal state of fitness regardless of externalities such as an individuals predilection or capacity for the level of working out needed to maintain that ideal state.
- mamon 10y agoThere's also one significant downside: hot bath lower testosterone levels in men, hurting fertility, so please don't do it if you are trying to make your partner pregnant.
- blacksmith_tb 10y agoThere's certainly some evidence that hot baths reduce sperm counts[1] but nothing I see about testosterone levels. At the same time, it's clear that men in cultures with traditions of soaking or saunas do still seem to father children... 1: https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2007/03/5541/hot-tubs-hurt-fertility-ucsf-study-shows https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2007/03/5541/hot-tubs-hurt-fertili...
- cableshaft 10y agoDamn. My muscles have been feeling more fatigued lately and I was planning to start going to a hot tub on a semi-regular basis :/.
- ouid 10y agoI don't think that you need data from a well respected journal to validate that point.
- pc2g4d 10y agoI always wonder about the effects of pervasive air conditioning. Living in cool environments all through the summer certainly isn't natural, right? Maybe the energy required to regulate body temperature in warm environments is actually a good thing, and air conditioning prevents us from getting the benefit.
- acjohnson55 10y agoSome people also tout the benefits of mild hypothermia. I suppose any type of thermal regulation is a workout for the body.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- atourgates 10y agoDepends on what part of the world you're living in. Where I live (North central Idaho, at an elevation of 2,500 feet), new houses were being built without air conditioning 10 years ago, because it typically didn't get hot enough in the summer to justify it. Our summers are getting hotter, so that's changing, but here that change has occurred in the past 10 years. Many people still live without A/C on much of West Coast (Oregon, Washington and BC), so long as they live in a temperate climate near the water there's rarely a need. So, living in a house where the temperature is A/C controlled at 75°F in the summertime, isn't going to be too different than living in a climate where summertime temps don't often get above 75°F.
- freehunter 10y agoOn the other hand, heat stroke kills a lot of people every year, and suffering through ever changing weather takes a toll on productivity. There are a lot of things that may be bad for us as individuals but necessary to our society.
- clock_tower 10y agoTake ancestral environment into account. Asia and Africa have torrid summers, but Europe -- at least Western Europe -- mostly doesn't; this is especially true of the British Isles, a temperate-rainforest zone comparable to the West Coast or parts of inner Appalachia. For US residents with mostly British (including Irish) ancestry, air conditioning is a return to ancestral environments, not a departure from them.
- HillaryBriss 10y agohasn't this sort of practice been a common thing in Japan for centuries?
- Jtsummers 10y agoYes, but a common practice doesn't mean that whether or how it's beneficial has been studied.
- fsiefken 10y agoSo are 40 degree Celcius hot tubs as effective as 80 degree Celcius Sauna sessions. I was just about to buy a portable sauna, but if a bath gives me a similar effect I wouldn't buy it. Except that I can watch TV while I'm sitting in my portable sauna chair and my S.O. lounges on the couch.
- sushisource 10y agoI mean, buy one if you want one. I wouldn't buy it for this reason. It might be sort of good for you, but so are lots of things as research constantly reveals. A 30 minute run everyday will do way more for your health if you're not exercising.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flippyhead 10y agoI always figured that it's diversity of stimulus/experience/etc that is the biggest factor. The operating envelope of our bodies (and minds) presumes season changes, pretty much constant walking, and (typically) a very different social environment. Putting how we modify all this with various drugs aside, our environment in modern times is very different from the one our bodies expect. Some of this seems better understood, like how the insane abundance of sugar is something our bodies cannot cope with. Another interesting one is the entire discipline of orthodontics; turns out our teeth would come in completely straight if it weren't for all our soft processed food not giving them the input they need to orient themselves correctly in our jaws. I suspect exposure to cold and heat is simply another thing we've lost.
- jacobolus 10y ago> Another interesting one is the entire discipline of orthodontics; turns out our teeth would come in completely straight if it weren't for all our soft processed food not giving them the input they need to orient themselves correctly in our jaws. Do you have a source for this? Sounds interesting.
- cm2012 10y agoConsidering plenty of mummies had horrible teeth, I doubt it.
- komali2 10y agoThe Egyptians didn't each much better than us - lots of breads. I would assume OP means by "feedback" the constant ripping and tearing of meat and incessant chewing of highly fibrous plants and vegetables.
- cm2012 10y agoWhich doesn't mean highly processed foods, just not living like hunter gatherers.
- fsiefken 10y agoDoes anyone know where the Shutterstock picture has been taken? I haven't seen a swimming pool with chess games in it. I once thought about playing with hive pieces on the bottom of the pool. It'd be nice to read a book in bath or in the water, but water and books don't really get along.
- jonlucc 10y agoBudapest! I only know this because of a tweet I saw today [1]. [1] https://twitter.com/WeeMissBea/status/843888937659744257 https://twitter.com/WeeMissBea/status/843888937659744257
- crooked-v 10y ago> It'd be nice to read a book in bath or in the water, but water and books don't really get along. An ebook reader in one of those waterproof device bags might work. You'd need one with a resistive screen or all hard buttons, though.
- bradam 10y agoIt's Széchényi Spa[1] in Hungary. [1] http://szechenyispabaths.com http://szechenyispabaths.com
- magic_beans 10y agoLooks like the Hungarian baths!
- js2 10y ago"Szechenyi Baths (Budapest, Hungary), traditional Hungarian thermal bath complex with spa treatments." -- https://www.shutterstock.com/image-photo/budapest-hungary-november-2-2008-szechenyi-205346587 https://www.shutterstock.com/image-photo/budapest-hungary-no...
- StavrosK 10y agoI've been there, it's great (and in a very nice building).
- drpgq 10y agoI wonder how cold a bath has to be to get the same calorie burn as for 40C water.
- cik2e 10y agoBest news ever! Now I can finally justify my exuberant daily morning bath ritual to my friends and family with more than just "I like it so stfu". On a serious note though, I've always known how good I feel after a nice 30-60 minute soak so I'm not entirely surprised. But I'll be sure to keep the water temp up from here on out though. I've grown accustomed to a "nice and warm but not excessively hot" setting. Come to think of it, 40 C (104 F) might be where I'm at already--that doesn't sound like a crazy high number. Perhaps it's time to take things to the next level and install a bath thermometer along with measuring my body temp pre and post bath.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stretchwithme 10y agoMy feeling is that diabetes is, at least in part, caused by poor circulation. The peripheral neuropathy commonly associated with diabetes may actually be caused by poor circulation as well, not by diabetes. If blood flow to your limbs is impaired, your limbs can't process insulin very well. Given this view, anything that promotes circulation is going to help diabetes.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"Water immersion resulted in a greater increase in body temperature compared with exercise, as well as a greater reduction in average arterial blood pressure." Was that reduction in blood pressure seen after the bath or only while in it? If after, how long after? I wouldn't be at all surprised if there was lower blood pressure while lying still in a bath compared to while performing vigorous exercise. But what about after?
- clock_tower 10y agoHow many years until we get the headline, "A hot bath doesn't have benefits similar to exercise"? I predict five.
- drcode 10y agoYou basically summarized today's new episode of EconTalk, on the perils of statistical significance: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/03/andrew_gelman_o.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/03/andrew_gelman_o.htm...
- clock_tower 10y agoThe thought certainly isn't original to me! I think that Slate Star Codex and The Last Psychiatrist both had pieces on the reproduction crisis, especially in psychiatry, and I'll check this episode out as well.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoSo exercise is good, fasting is good, heat is good, cold is good. It seems all short term stress is good. I'm waiting for the study that shows binge drinking is good :)
- trentmb 10y agoFasting seems like the opposite of stress- your digestive tract isn't actually doing anything
- robbiep 10y agoActually, you're well off, but not for the reason you think. Let me explain. Fasting invokes all your counter-regulatory hormones: cortisol, adrenaline, others but they are the big players - because not having easy access to sugar leads to a stress response. So it isn't gut rest, it's physiological phase change that is causing the stress response
- agumonkey 10y agoHow long is the stress response ? is it only transient before switching to a "fasting" regime or is it long lasting ?
- robbiep 10y agoI guess depends on your definition of a stress response; most people would consider it to be a 'stress response' whilst you have high adrenergic/sympathetic activity. Upon activation of the parasympathetic nervous system there will be a gradual decrease in cortisol and a rapid decrease in adrenaline. Thyroid hormone is also going to be implicated somewhere along with a host of other hormones so I have simplified but suffice to say it's shades of grey on the way in and out
- spydum 10y agodigestive tract maybe not, but metabolism/endocrine system does actually respond.
- waxing-gibbous 10y agon = 7 per group, no control, main effect p ~ 0.05. Nothing to see here unfortunately.
- seanwilson 10y agoYeah, I'm not sure why this is being discussed so seriously. There really wasn't a control group?
- halis 10y agoWhat I like to do is have a hot bath and then 30 minutes in take a freezing cold shower for about 10 minutes then get back in the bath for 30 minutes, followed by another freezing cold 10 minute shower. If you think you can't do a freezing cold shower, you'd be surprised. Start off luke warm and just keep lowering it little by little. Before long you'll have the water all the way on cold. Once it's cold I try to do 2-3 minutes on front, back, left and right. This will get the endorphins flowing and is good for weight loss. I've also read that it will release something in your body that tells it that it needs to start burning fat reserves, which makes sense given our history.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 10y agoI guess I’m not the bathing type, 1 h 20 min seems excessive too me. I rather spend this time in the gym exercising and raking in all the additional benefits compared to bathing.
- joshgel 10y agoExercising (moderate physical activity) for 2-2.5 hours per week leads to a 20% reduction in all-cause mortality (not to mention its many other benefits). Exercising for an additional 5.5 hours leads to another 20% reduction. No preventative intervention we have in medicine leads to that kind of gains (except maybe quiting smoking). Articles like this are probably causing harm to the people that read them by discouraging them from exercise [conjecture]. Until I see rigorous mortality data on taking bath, I think I'll stick to my exercise routine... Source: https://www.cdc.gov/physicalactivity/resources/recommendations.html https://www.cdc.gov/physicalactivity/resources/recommendatio... (see 2008 Physical Activity Guidelines Advisory Committee Report [PDF - 4.5MB])
- pdxandi 10y agoAnyone who believes they can bathe instead of exercise is probably not exercising to begin with. I doubt this study would result in reduced exercise. But I could be wrong.
- mulmen 10y agoIt does help to perpetuate a myth that there are alternatives to exercise which could enter in to a persons decision to exercise or not, even if they decide to do something else with their time.
- danielweber 10y agoEvery generation has to create its effort-free alternative to exercise, whether it's electrodes you attach to your abs or standing there while a vibrating belt shakes your body. Even George Jetson would sit around while the computer exercised for him, so I guess we know what's coming in the future.
- zeamaize 10y agoCrippling socialized medical costs as the obesity rate skyrockets. :-/
- Mz 10y agoI bet that hot baths move lymph at higher than normal rates, just like exercise. This is the mechanism by which our bodies cleanse our tissues. But, that is considered "woo" by a lot of people. I am sort of annoyed at the heat molecules explanation at the end of the article. Like, we can't just admit that maybe our own body's mechanism for taking out the trash matters when it gets pumped up to a higher rate? That is too...weird? or something?
- 100ideas 10y agoWow crazy. The article ends by speculating that activities that activate “heat shock protein” pathway may help blood sugar control. It’s interesting b/c this pathway is well-studied in microbes like e coli and we were taught about it in my genomics classes. But I didn’t realize it was conserved to the point that it is significant in humans (maybe it isn’t). It’s a bit of a misnomer, actually. It was identified in e. coli as molecularly central to their response when exposed to immediate stress, such as going from 32 C to 40 C, but also on exposure to UV, or cold?, pH change, salinity change etc Basically it’s bacterial-molecular version of calling 911. But because it was first identified by heat shock experimental condition, that’s what it was named. Did the author just read about "heat shock protein" in humans and assume it was related how gene expression changes in human cells when body temperature is elevated 1 degree C? Or was it mentioned in the primary literature they are summarizing...
- mtw 10y agoThere are similar studies showing that regular saunas lower cardiovascular risk and dementia risk up to 63% (a summary here http://outcomereference.com/causes/108 http://outcomereference.com/causes/108 ) Like the hot bath study, these were limited to very specific populations (Finnish). I have yet to see studies of hot bath or saunas on different ethnicities or different locations. At the end of the day though, nothing beats regular moderate exercise. It's the only lifestyle that has no side-effects, cheap, accessible to everyone anywhere, and with demonstrated short-term and long-term effects. Walk, run 5k, hike, bike to work, your heart and your family will be grateful!
- mtw 10y agoThere are similar studies showing that regular saunas lower cardiovascular risk and dementia risk up to 63% (a summary here http://outcomereference.com/causes/108 http://outcomereference.com/causes/108 ) Like the hot bath study, these were limited to very specific populations (Finnish). I have yet to see studies of hot bath or saunas on different ethnicities or different locations. At the end of the day though, nothing beats regular moderate exercise. It's the only lifestyle that has no side-effects, cheap, accessible to everyone anywhere, and with demonstrated short-term and long-term effects. Walk, run 5k, hike, bike to work, your heart and your family will be grateful!
- Gatsky 10y agoHope you are heating your water with renewables. A coal powerplant would produce ~ 8-10 pounds of CO2 to heat a bath, 3.5x more than a shower. https://www.withouthotair.com/c7/page_50.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c7/page_50.shtml https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11
- peterwwillis 10y agoWe've known for a long time that temperature will change calories burned at rest, and a reduction in peak blood pressure is not the same as a reduction in overall blood sugar. These same temporary effects can be gained merely by slight changes in diet, and don't provide the other positive effects that light exercise brings. The comparison to exercise is quite misleading.
- maruhan2 10y agoThis is just a simply "I heard that ...", so take it with a grain of salt. I heard that heat (such as sauna) can help you lose weight, but it also loses muscle, so it's not a great method of diet.
- Nomentatus 10y agoJ Physiol. 2016 Sep 15;594(18):5329-42. doi: 10.1113/JP272453. Epub 2016 Jun 30. Passive heat therapy improves endothelial function, arterial stiffness and blood pressure in sedentary humans. Brunt VE1, Howard MJ1, Francisco MA1, Ely BR1, Minson CT2. A recent 30 year prospective study showed that lifelong sauna use reduces cardiovascular-related and all-cause mortality; however, the specific cardiovascular adaptations that cause this chronic protection are currently unknown. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27270841 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27270841
- nocoder 10y agoSuch articles are so frustrating. What is with our fixation to trying to do as little as possible for max. gains. It feels like there is this whole group of individuals out there who are trying to convince (without solid evidence) that exercise is replaceable my other things.Human beings are not efficiency optimization machines. Moreover, everyone who exercises regularly can tell you that fitness is the low hanging fruit. There are so many other benefits of exercise like opportunity to meet new people & benefits to mental health and more.
- ForFreedom 10y agoWarm bath would be better than hot bath.
- akhatri_aus 10y agoFunny, because the comments on here a few months ago implied a cold water shower does miracles for you too and practically bashed hot water cleaning to oblivion.