3 ms·
I'd suggest everyone itching to push their pet theory first READ the informed discussion over at the theoildrum.com. Industry knowledge, not eco-hand-wringing,
by joe_the_user 16y ago
I'd suggest everyone itching to push their pet theory first READ the informed discussion over at the theoildrum.com. Industry knowledge, not eco-hand-wringing, gives this a BIG thumbs down.
"Suggesting an idea that has been consistently rejected for its several weak points literally dozens of times on this site alone, is an indicator that you havent been really paying attention. In short, explosions will not work because the bottom of the GOM is mud, for thousands of feet below the surface. any explosion at the surface will only make the problem worse. any explosion in the well shaft will only make the problem worse. Its been suggested to think of the bottom as a bowl of pudding, there is no way to use explosives to seal it up. it just doesnt work that way.
While its a common lust for most people to wanna blow up any problem they cant solve and seems to work pretty well for America in the past, it will not work here." http://www.theoildrum.com/node/6531#comment-634447 http://www.theoildrum.com/node/6531#comment-634447
- jrockway 16y agoWhile its a common lust for most people to wanna blow up any problem they cant solve and seems to work pretty well for America in the past, it will not work here. I'm convinced! This sure sounds informed to me!
- jimfl 16y agoI should think that industry knowledge has lost a little bit its cachet in recent months.
- jimfl 16y agohttp://tywkiwdbi.blogspot.com/2010/05/rachel-maddow-crucifies-british.html http://tywkiwdbi.blogspot.com/2010/05/rachel-maddow-crucifie...
- joe_the_user 16y agoI'm sure it has. But it's kind of like a lot of engineering fields. As reported in the NYTimes, engineers reported the risks and management made the decision to ignore those risks. So I'd still suggest that if those deeply involved with drilling oil say nuking the well is fucking stupid idea, then it's a fucking stupid idea - especially since already sounds like a fucking stupid idea. Perhaps it would work in a MacGyver movie.
- anon42 16y agoActually the technidue isn't to blow it up on the surface. It is to blow it up 14,000 ft below the well in order to collapse it in on itself. The russians have done this 6 times and been successful 5 times.