11 ms·
Cardiovascular Deaths Linked to Poor Dietary Choices
- Toine 10y agoThis was known for decades. People in the future will not believe how bad we were eating in the last 50 years. Food is so important to our physical and mental health. We are literally killing ourselves, at this point the food industry is almost guilty of mass murder for profit. Same for fossil fuels, pharma, etc. I don't understand our "developed" countries.
- a_imho 10y agoThe term food industry just feels wrong to me.
- ehnto 10y agoThat's what it is and frankly, that's what's required too. We have too many people to be able sustain them all with cutesy farm to table ensembles and home grown vegetables.
- tracker1 10y agoAgreed.. I'm not anti-grower, or anti-gmo... the cost/benefit of "organic" is dubious at best (aside from some berries, iirc). But man, the balance has to shift at least a little... we really need to move away from highly refined/pre-prepared everything, every meal, lots of snacks, lots of sugars, every day. Edit: I also know a world-class chef who agrees that the McRib is one of the most tasty things ever developed. But you don't eat that every day...
- fidrelity 10y agoThe Rodale Institute[1] has a long running trial comparing different farming systems. In the long run organic farming outperforms "conventional" methods in terms of yield, resilience and cost[2]. If you believe their research that is. [1] https://rodaleinstitute.org/ https://rodaleinstitute.org/ [2] https://rodaleinstitute.org/assets/FST-Brochure-2015.pdf https://rodaleinstitute.org/assets/FST-Brochure-2015.pdf
- lawless123 10y ago>We have too many people to be able sustain them all with cutesy farm to table ensembles and home grown vegetables. We would have plenty only so many want to eat meat with every meal.
- coldtea 10y ago>That's what it is and frankly, that's what's required too. We have too many people to be able sustain them all with cutesy farm to table ensembles and home grown vegetables. Citation needed. It's not like we'd have some food crisis if we didn't have a "food industry", by which people usually mean the actively harmful and inducing food staff that's mass manufactured, you know the 20,000 mass market varieties of sodas, chips, snacks, burgers and such. If you just mean "agriculture at scale", we had that since ancient Babylon. In fact, outside of floods and famines that are orthogonal to what we're talking about, many countries do just fine feeding their populations with 1/10 or 1/20 of such an industry as it exists in the US.
- tracker1 10y agoDiet Industry, Snack Industry, Soda Inc... what would you prefer... when most people are eating processed and or pre-prepared foods, things aren't good. And imho things like hamburger helper aren't very far off. I ate a lot of food that came from cans, boxes and packages growing up.. and today its' far worse... I know a lot of people around my age (early 40's) who never eat any vegetables at all. none... Unless it's filler in something else they're eating. Lots of refined starches, more than enough meat... but very few actual veggies. I mean, I'm not all about the veggies, I'm far from getting enough every day (per whatever standards), but I at least get 4-5 salads a week, and have at least 3-4 other times with at least a vegetable side that aren't starches (root-veg) a week. But man, there's something to be said for going from at least some, to almost none. I'll admit, I do tend to favor lower-carb (I'm diabetic, I really have to), but the anti-fat fads of the late 70's through the 90's did more harm than good. Compounded by the proliferation of snack items and refined fats (mostly vegetable source), starches, preservatives, fillers and stabilizers is astounding. I no longer have any children living with me, but I can't believe the number of ads for foods that aren't whole or at least minimally processed on TV, targeting kids... "fruit rollups", gellies, gogurt, soda, pops, drinks, fast-food and the rest... It's time to start saying no to kids, no to ourselves and trying to lead by better examples. Another issue is thinness !== healthy. Metabolic syndrome is really dangerous when you don't show the typical outward symptoms right away. Body shaming doesn't work... We, as a larger society need to start making better choices for ourselves. And I say this as someone who has McD's for breakfast pretty much every day (breakfast sandwich, sometimes just an egg and sausage, no bun with a water to drink). If you eat fast-food, skip the side of fries and the sugar-water. Hell, use a calorie tracker for a week, and be surprised how much you really take in (including snacks, drinks, etc)... it can actually be hard to take in under 2500 kcal a day.
- Toine 10y agoTech people know how hard it is to scale things. More precisely, we know how hard it is to maintain quality (of code for example) in an environment where quantity increases rapidly. Take a look at this graph : https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/3a/Human_population_growth_from_1800_to_2000.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/3a/Human_populat... The industrial era. What happened in the last 50 years is that the quality/quantity ratio went to almost zero. Industries now produce a LOT of stuff for a LOT of people, but the quality of this stuff is insanely low, food included. Industrial food is sometimes void of anything good for your health. In my view we have two options : rebalance the quality/quantity ratio, ie make a LOT of stuff of quality, or if we can't, drastically reduce the quantity of stuff needed. I let you imagine the consequences of the second option. I'm optimistic, but scared.
- tracker1 10y agoFortunately, at a macro level.. something like 70-80% of what we take in are purely caloric needs... I mean, under 100g of sugars a day, and over 80-120g of protein.. but otherwise, for the most part calories are calories. We do need to reduce the amount of refined sugars, starches and fats in our diets, and increase the amount of raw vegetables and fruit... I'm not talking a veggie/vegan diet.. but having some mix, and keeping some things in that above/below block. Adjusting for special dietary needs (diabetes, allergies, pku etc).
- blacksmith_tb 10y ago80-120g of protein per day is on the high end of the spectrum, the minimum values are typically given as 46g for women, 56g for me[1] (unless you are a competitive athlete). Not to mention that switching away from animal protein sources is potentially a good idea[2]... 1: http://healthyeating.sfgate.com/usda-protein-requirements-grams-8619.html http://healthyeating.sfgate.com/usda-protein-requirements-gr... 2: http://www.eufic.org/en/whats-in-food/article/plant-protein-may-decrease-risk-of-death http://www.eufic.org/en/whats-in-food/article/plant-protein-...
- tracker1 10y ago
- cies 10y agoIt follows the same trajectory as the tobacco industry. I think when it comes to tobacco we already can "not believe" how prevalent smoking was just 50 years ago. > at this point the food industry is almost guilty of mass murder for profit Agreed. Now how to fix it? I like Dr Greger's "How not to Die" book, as it brings a lot of scientific evidence to the table. He also has an app "the daily dozen" that helps people improve their diets. Given the power of lobby groups I do not expect that we can effectively use gov't to change the status quo.
- tracker1 10y agoThe difference between diet and related (fat, diabetic, metabolic syndrome, mixed allergies) issues with things like tobacco and other drugs is you literally can't just stop eating. I agree there's been far too much effective lobbying (and spending on junk research) in and outside the government that separating agenda and getting any change to the status quo will be hard.
- jlebrech 10y agoyou don't have to stop eating, just eat more fibre.
- agumonkey 10y agoThe more comfortable a society is the easier it is to ignore pillars of life.
- lawless123 10y ago>pillars of life The what?
- agumonkey 10y agoThings that are important if you don't have modern technology to fix you.
- BrailleHunting 10y agoA corollary is "the richer the fool, the greater the acceleration of the universe's entropy (to include their body, health and a shorter life)." There are a number health effects no amount of pills or surgery can reverse because entropy, despite marketing. Eat enough peanut-butter bacon sandwiches and cause enough chronic inflammation damage from smoking, then become obese, get diabetes and cancer.
- agumonkey 10y agoThere are also, I believe, higher layers of health. Societal, existential; that this society tries to shield us from. Like not playing guitar because it might hurt your fingers. Often I read that there's everything to be as happy as you can on the ground, but we lock ourselves into to sweet nests.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoThis silly. In the last few months I have been changing my diet because of cholesterol readings. It's annoying, because I like steak, and I like coconut, and bacon, and ghee, and prawns and, and, and... Desire for such a diet has always been with us. The food industry has, for the first time, made it affordable for hundreds of millions of us. They are guilty only of mass feeding for profit.
- Toine 10y agoThen drug dealers shouldn't be stopped? People should get unlimited dose of heroin ? I don't understand your point. Of course we are addictive beings, that's why we invented laws and rules in the first place : so that we can live in order and not chaos. If we let people have access to everything they want (including killing half the planet, eating your children, murdering your parents), do you realise how chaotic the world would be ?
- scarface74 10y agoYou mixed two different things. If a person wants to shoot heroin -- or in this case eat bad food. They should be allowed to. It only affects them. Murder takes away someone else's right. But on the other hand, the government shouldn't be subsidizing heroin or food.
- Toine 10y agoNo it doesn't, it affects their parents, their children, their friends, their pets, their colleagues, the companies they work in, their clients, and everyone else actually. You don't live in a vacuum, you live in a interconnected system where everyone has an effect on everyone, direct or indirect. Liberty is extremely important, but we should always remember we're not alone. This belief that everyone should be 100% free and have the right to be whatever he wants with his life is, if not the only reason, part of the reasons why we're in this mess today.
- scarface74 10y ago
- adrianratnapala 10y agoThis silly. In the last few months I have been changing my diet because of cholesterol readings. It's annoying, because I like steak, and I like coconut, and bacon, and ghee, and prawns and, and, and... Desire for such a diet has always been with us. The food industry has, for the first time, made it affordable for hundreds of millions of us. They are guilty only of mass feeding for profit.
- rimliu 10y agoBut many things that "were known for decades" turn out to be not known at all. Fat was root of all evil for decades, but now—maybe not? Salt was bad for decades, but now—maybe not? And growing life expectancy while we are literally killing ourselves does not compute.
- narutouzumaki 10y agoOur life expectancy increases despite, not because of our bad diet.
- SmellyGeekBoy 10y ago> And growing life expectancy while we are literally killing ourselves does not compute. This is a result of the vast improvements in healthcare and medicine in the past 50-100 years. It's not rocket science.
- ashark 10y agoIt's also important to separate, say, life expectancy at 30 from overall life expectancy, which usually includes infant mortality and fatal childhood illnesses of all sorts. Those are important per se of course, but basically irrelevant to the effects life-long nutrition and later-in-life medical care.
- guelo 10y agoHey seen salt so directly linked to heart disease.
- tracker1 10y agoSalt is generally only an issue if you already have, or are via family link likely to have heart issues... Of course, the anti-saturated fat and dietary cholesterol claims were also unbalanced and not well supported. However, most people have far more salt in their diet than they need anyway... What gets me more is the amount of "natural" flavors added to food... when you have a hypersensitive sense of smell and taste man some of that stuff is nasty, and 19 of 20 can't even smell/taste it. It may be natural and some people will respond positively to additives, but it's really harsh to some of us.
- scarface74 10y agoInspired by Pascal's Wager: Even if it's not clear that salt intake and saturated fat is bad for you, why take the chance? Three choices: 1. Salt/saturated fat are bad for you and you eat too much of both -- bad outcome. 2. Salt/saturated fat are not bad for you and you eat too much of both - neutral outcome 3. Salt/saturated fat are bad for you and you limit your intake - good outcome. I don't think anyone is arguing that too much salt and saturated fat are good for you, so the three scenarios above are the logical choices. If the scientific studies are wrong and you cut back anyway, you have "lost nothing". If they are right and you cut back, you have gained. There is no benefit by taking a chance that the accepted wisdom is wrong.
- humanrebar 10y ago> Even if it's not clear that salt intake and saturated fat is bad for you, why take the chance? Pascal's Wager makes sense in that you have mutually exclusive options. Dietary choices don't work like that. Practically speaking, if you avoid certain ingredients, you expose yourself to more of others. Psychologically speaking, the average person only has so much willpower. It's best spend avoiding the worst foods and pursuing the best ones. Spending energy on pointless diets affects one's ability to pursue good ones.
- cies 10y ago> Diets low in omega-3 fatty acids, found in seafood [...] also played a role. In seafood you also find a lot of toxins, especially mercury. So trying to get your omega3s from there comes with it's own problems. Thank God for flax seeds! A cheap and pure source of omega3s. Freshly grind 2 tsps and mix in your food every day: you will have covered your omega3s, amongst other micro-nutrients.
- chestervonwinch 10y agoWhile looking for a comparison between flax seed and almonds, I came across this neat wiki article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratio_of_fatty_acids_in_different_foods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratio_of_fatty_acids_in_differ...
- stagbeetle 10y agoMercury binds to selenium and inactivates its "toxic" effects. Thankfully, fish is high in selenium (almost 1:1 to with mercury, thus canceling both out, in swordfish. Most others have ratios < 10:1).
- narutouzumaki 10y agoDoes that mean that tuna does not have much selenium? Would it be possible to mitigate the effects of a tuna rich diet with by also eating other food rich in selenium?
- stagbeetle 10y agoI don't have the ratio for tuna off-hand, but IIRC a selenium supplement is all you need to counteract a fish-heavy diet. But, yes. You can also supplement fish with higher sel:merc ratios to balance it out.
- nibstwo 10y agoTuna is a big fish. The smaller the fish, the higher the ratio of selenium to mercury. Tuna is the cut off, size wise.
- qrybam 10y agoAnecdotal: Growing up, our parents never added salt to our food, avoided as much as possible any processed foods and made everything from fresh ingredients. After moving out and living with various people, shifting my diet multiple times, I generally feel worse now than I did before. When I fast and shift myself to healthier eating I feel better. What interests me is why most people don't feel "bad" when they're eating the food that I would feel sluggish from the next day. My pet theories are their body is accustomed to it/or they simply don't know what it feels like to not feel that way- if you know what I mean. I thought it was self evident that anything that weakens you is likely to be bad for you. Glad that these findings are going more mainstream.
- Toine 10y ago“How could they see anything but the shadows if they were never allowed to move their heads?” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegory_of_the_Cave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegory_of_the_Cave
- tracker1 10y agoNot just salt, but refined sugar, starches and fats/oils... fats are good, those requiring multi-step refinement, centrifuge processing, perfuming and dying to be palatable, not so much.
- sebleon 10y ago> What interests me is why most people don't feel "bad" when they're eating the food that I would feel sluggish from the next day. Eating processed foods for years causes huge changes in the gut microbiome. Presence of different microorganisms means you'll process various foods differently from others. http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/07/16/processed-foods-immune-system-gut-health.aspx http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/07/1...
- sushid 10y ago> I thought it was self evident that anything that weakens you is likely to be bad for you You would be surprised. There's compelling evidence that small doses of things that normally weaken you (e.g radiation, alcohol, etc.) are actually beneficial to your health. [0] Of course, I'd agree that eating less processed food is ideal, but don't let that get in the way of fasting or consuming alcohol. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hormesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hormesis
- cies 10y agoThe "TLDR" summary of the article: > Cardiovascular disease claims 610,000 lives in the United States each year. It is the leading cause of mortality nationwide, accounting for one in every four deaths. > A new analysis, funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, shows that a substantial portion of these deaths could be prevented by healthier eating. Nothing new; has been shown numerous times. Article does not state how this analysis is different. > In 2015, more than 400,000 [2/3rds] deaths from cardiovascular causes were linked to unhealthy diets, according to the research According to the article, for a healthy diet we need to eat more: * whole plant-based foods (nuts, seeds, vegetables, whole grains and fruits), and omega-3 fatty acids ...and we need to eat less: * salt (sodium), trans-fat, saturated fat, processed meat, sugar > Ashkan Afshin, co-author of the study, said: “some of the leading risk factors are not high intake of unhealthy foods, but low intake of healthy foods.” > Over all, the results of the study were consistent with global patterns. ----- Now my observation. When they talk about what we should eat more of, the instruction is clear (only omega3s are cryptic). But when stating what we should eat less of most of it is cryptic. Well let me decrypt it for you... reduce or stop eating: * meat/dairy/eggs (bad fats, bad protein, toxin build-up) * processed foods, like oils & sugar (they have been separated from their original form thus lacking fibers and nutrients) * non foods, like chemicals (sugar replacements, preservatives, colorants, etc.)
- Toine 10y agoNot sure about eggs. I get a lot of contradicting opinions. My conclusion is that 4-5 eggs a week is good for us.
- cies 10y agoI contains a lot of cholesterol and "bad" protein (the protein that has lots of sulfur-based amino acids); besides that very little nutrients. If you want you can have a ton of nutrients for the same cholesterol/calories by choosing whole plant-based foods. So in the absence of choice, eggs are great. But most of us have so much choice nowadays, that eggs are clearly an inferior option.
- 10y ago
- kev009 10y agoI'm curious what people think of diet-hackers.. this forum is probably more sympathetic than most. It seems like there's a bi-modal distribution where either you don't care about diet, or you ascribe metaphysical properties to food and how it was obtained and prepared. The later seems like ho-hum, nutrition is much more complicated than the FDA labels, but I have to believe it's possible to synthesize boring goop that gives you everything you need. I really don't care that much about eating.. as in, if I could flip a switch and never eat again, I would unhesitatingly do so. I tried Soylent for a while, which I liked well enough, but they are optimizing for things I don't particularly care about like vegan ingredients and sedentary nutrition profile. Lately I've been using 100%FOOD which I like quite a bit in the triple protein profile, and is helpful for my activity level.
- stagbeetle 10y ago> but I have to believe it's possible to synthesize boring goop that gives you everything you need It is, but to make it as bioavailable and "healthy" as regular food is a challenge (and extremely expensive). Contemporary goop uses synthetic micronutrients (as opposed to more bioavailable organic) and extracts (as opposed to full-profile concentrates). This is also ignoring that Soylent's ingredient profile is likely incompatible with a large part of the public.
- good_vibes 10y agoA plant-based diet has been proven to prevent many of the leading causes of death and is also what is best for the planet. Our modern diet has way too much animal flesh and animal byproducts, all kinds of evidence in our anatomy, genetics, and biochemistry. The amount of land and water use for animal agriculture is insane, the greenhouse emissions and life-killing pollution are another set of externalities. A lot can change for the individual organism and the whole biosphere with a simple diet change. I think a plant-based society is the only kind that could live harmoniously with our home planet and expand successfully onto other planets.
- rimliu 10y agoI fail to see how switching from meat to plants will decrease the usage of land and water. Also, planet could not care less what we eat or what we do.
- good_vibes 10y ago"Worldwide, an estimated 2 billion people live primarily on a meat-based diet, while an estimated 4 billion live primarily on a plant-based diet. The US food production system uses about 50% of the total US land area, 80% of the fresh water, and 17% of the fossil energy used in the country. The heavy dependence on fossil energy suggests that the US food system, whether meat-based or plant-based, is not sustainable. The use of land and energy resources devoted to an average meat-based diet compared with a lactoovovegetarian (plant-based) diet is analyzed in this report. In both diets, the daily quantity of calories consumed are kept constant at about 3533 kcal per person. The meat-based food system requires more energy, land, and water resources than the lactoovovegetarian diet. In this limited sense, the lactoovovegetarian diet is more sustainable than the average American meat-based diet. The major threat to future survival and to US natural resources is rapid population growth. The US population of 285 million is projected to double to 570 million in the next 70 y, which will place greater stress on the already-limited supply of energy, land, and water resources. These vital resources will have to be divided among ever greater numbers of people." http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/78/3/660S.full http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/78/3/660S.full
- 10y ago
- hashmal 10y agono kidding.
- bsharitt 10y agoWhile I'm not "old" yet, I'm not as young as I used to be and I can feel my life time of poor diet is starting to catch up with me. So I've become very mindful of my diet very recently. I've switched to a mostly plant based diet and avoid most processed food combined with some intermittent fasting. I'm feeling much better, I'm losing weight at a healthy pace and I'm sleeping much better, though that might be more related also dropping caffeine and alcohol. The rest of my family is also eating more healthy, though not with the same strictness as me. I went cold turkey and it's a bit more of a gradual process for them.
- jordanb 10y agoThe best thing you can do is avoid sugar. I started doing it about a year ago for similar reasons. I lost 30 pounds and feel great. I also cut way back on caffeine and alcohol. That probably played a part in my feeling better but perhaps not losing weight.
- Jtsummers 10y agoCutting out alcohol will have a significant effect on weight loss (positive effect). Alcohol gets consumed, for calories, more easily than sugars and other calorie sources. So your body will process your alcohol intake quickly. Once sated, calorically, your body has to do something with the rest of what you've eaten/drunk. This means it's expelled from the body, or stored (as fat) and your weight goes up (or stays high). It's a bit like sodas, here. It's easy to get many or most of the calories you need from alcohol (especially beers) and sugary sodas. You don't feel sated so you still eat, now you've exceeded your calorie goals and you end up gaining weight (or maintaining a higher than desired weight). Eliminating sodas and alcohol moves your caloric intake to be, predominantly, food stuffs. Now you'll feel sated when you're full from your meal, and, with a bit of planning and practice, before consuming too many calories.
- bsharitt 10y agoI've found that eliminating processed foods has cut down on my sugar intake dramatically without specifically focusing on it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Taylor_OD 10y agoI've lost over 25 pounds in the last couple months by changing my diet slightly. I essentially eat a nice sized lunch and no other real meals. I drink a protein shake with some peanut butter and a banana for breakfast and a soylent drink for dinner. Sometimes I substitute the soylent for booze if I've got an event to go to. I fast, skip the lunch, on Mondays. It's incredible how different my body feels without that extra weight and barring a couple nights of thinking about the gelato in my freezer it hasnt been that difficult. I'm not sure if I'm just now gaining the will power to stick to a diet or if I got to a weight I was truly uncomfortable with but I wish I could get my family on the same plan to avoid stuff like this.
- dopamean 10y agoI work with a guy who eats a single large meal a day for dinner and nothing else. He has water and the occasional handful of nuts during the day but that's it. Other than that he doesn't work out a ton and appears to be one of the healthiest people I know.
- nervousvarun 10y agoInteresting. What about eating with your wife/husband/SO? Are they on the same diet? Kids?
- Taylor_OD 10y agoI'm 24 and single currently. When in relationships this tends to fluctuate a bit but mostly its just a dinner a couple times a week. I could imagine with kids this would be difficult.
- ThrowawayR2 10y ago> ...a soylent drink for dinner... Careful, you don't really know what, if anything, that's doing to your health without periodic blood testing. For example, my triglyceride levels shot off the scale and my doctor directed me to discontinue using Soylent immediately.
- antisthenes 10y ago
- VLM 10y agoThere's a substantial hole in the logical argument of the article "a substantial portion of these deaths could be prevented". Obviously everyone studied will die despite the articles implication that giving up steak results in eternal life. They'll just die of something else. It is also not intuitive that merely not dying from a cardio problem will result in a longer life. Surely you can eat less meat and be less fat merely by skipping some meals and smoking a pack or two of cigs or dipping tobacco, and it seems like cardio death rates would drop, but overall death rate due to lung cancer would probably increase to a net systemic higher level. It doesn't have to be that extreme. Maybe something as simple as replacing a bloodthirsty steak with a nice glass of vegan corn syrup soda could cause a net increase in death rates while slightly dropping cardio death rates. There are also peculiar side issues such as declaring fish to be healthy not-meat means mercury intake would explode and the fisheries will be wiped out sooner than if we didn't. The net long term effect of wiping out the fisheries for all time might be worse than merely eating land based meat for that time interval. Finally there are peculiar geographic problems where urban vegans absolutely refuse to admit there is some land suitable solely for beef production, or the hipster quinoa fad which for a grain isn't as bad as most but the fad primarily resulted in starvation in south america.
- good_vibes 10y agoI think there is a substantial hole in your train of thought as well. Don't miss the forest for the trees. I think this guide will help you understand the bigger picture: https://zenhabits.net/plants/ https://zenhabits.net/plants/
- 746F7475 10y agoOn our next breaking news: Gun deaths linked to bullets
- jdhzzz 10y agoDog bites man!