5 ms·
He mentions it in the article: It's a failure of feedback that makes this happen. If people can't get reliable information about quality, quality will not det
by lordnacho 10y ago
He mentions it in the article:
It's a failure of feedback that makes this happen.
If people can't get reliable information about quality, quality will not determine what they buy. Price will, and price is readily available. To get price down, you need costs down. To do that, you replace the parts with crappy parts.
If feedback worked, people would know they were paying less for a less good appliance that will have more downtime, and they would act accordingly.
Part of it is statistical noise: you only get to use so many washing machines in your life, and you may or may not have big problems with them. Your only direct evidence on quality then depends on this roll of the dice.
Part of it is lack of competition: only 4 competitors. You only need to be in the ballpark of "OK" to sell. You're not scratching around for every customer, there's definitely going to be some. So why spend a lot of money making your machine more reliable?
Part of it is cost of information: how much time are you going to spend finding this information? You'll need to learn a bunch of technical terms. And how do you find trustworthy reviews? Most likely reviews are another source of noise, for the same reason as mentioned. So information is expensive to get and anyway if you're right about the manufacturers being the same it's also worthless!
- throwawaysbdi 10y agoAlong the same lines, probably the easiest way to get quality in almost every type of product is to buy the commercial version. The people using these products are very familiar with them, so nobody sells garbage. Businesses are also generally more conservative in future projections and less price sensitive than consumers. I personally started doing this a few years ago. I even have a throwaway LLC that sounds nebulously like a contractor so I can sign up for "industry only" marketplaces. Since I can usually get wholesale prices doing this, I pay only maybe 30% more than for crap consumer level throwaway stuff. The major downside is the time it takes, but the upside is that none of my stuff ever breaks.
- j3097736 10y ago>more conservative in future projections and less price sensitive than consumers. Which means that if you need some replacement part in the future it's going to cost even more.
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoPerhaps, but they'll be available at all, and the device will be repairable. I don't even mind that modern appliances break so often; it's the fiddly plastic bits and lack of parts that are the problem. Give us something made of metal with some screws and the damn thing can probably be fixed. (re: the article topic, this is another thing that's kept me away from automobiles for the past twenty years)
- emodendroket 10y agoNeat idea.
- grogenaut 10y agoWhat's a good one of these marketplaces?
- Nition 10y agoI'd love to see a store that sells buy-it-for-life style products that are probably more expensive up front but also built to last, all with robust warranties so you know the claims are backed up. A place you could go into and know everything in there was good. If you wanted the cheapest you'd go somewhere else but man, I'd shop there. They could do appliances (stuff like SpeedQueen washers), hand and garden tools, kitchen stuff like pots and pans and knives... just anything that's solid and lasts and doesn't require ridiculous maintenance to make it so. Sometimes now I'd be willing pay more but either I can't even find the stuff that isn't cheap junk, or I just can't tell what's going to break and what isn't.
- cardamomo 10y agoYes! I absolutely agree. The store could also offer repair services. (Gasp!) I wonder where a market for such a store would exist, though.
- dbg31415 10y agoYou're describing Sears, no? Sarcasm doesn't read so well on the internet but yeah my parents still have a washing machine from probably 1970 in their house. The matching dryer finally gave up on them about 5 years back... that thing was still to this day the best dryer I ever used. Run it 30 minutes, even the heaviest towels were crispy dry and almost too hot to handle when you took them out. I think having high quality appliances is partially why Sears tanked... First they didn't sell as many (due to having to compete on price with lower quality / cheaper products), then when they found a way to compete (having Samsung make Kenmore appliances, for example), they lost the quality and the last reason anyone would opt to go there over Costco or Amazon or Home Depot. I bought a matching Washer / Dryer set from Costco. Then the next year I bought a Fridge and Dishwasher from LG there too. For the first three years or so it was fine, but about 5 years in I think they all have issues. My house is about 20 years old, and the Dishwasher I replaced was the original... so it lasted 15 years. I can say that the new (and fairly top of the line) Dishwasher has more issues at 5 than the old builder-grade one had at 15. I really regret not getting a Bosch... But even up into the 80s and 90s Sears / Maytag were known for selling top quality goods that didn't break. Here's a cute commercial. * 1988 Maytag Repairman Commercial - YouTube || https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZHsxPEAUOI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZHsxPEAUOI
- valuearb 10y agoWhen appliances are out of date in ten years because new electronics provide better features, why should customers or makers spend extra to get them to last longer?
- foxylad 10y agoDepends on the device. Both our fridge and washing machine are 20 years old, and still going strong. New models offer nothing that we value - I don't want to attach either of them to the internet.
- pnathan 10y agoAnytime I do anything around appliance shopping, the ability to get information about what is actually quality is near zero. It's SEO'd, spammed, paid-reviewed, and marketed into the ground. Mattresses are similar, but fortunately, there is https://www.themattressunderground.com/ https://www.themattressunderground.com/ , which is a high quality site. I bought a Tuft and Needle mattress based on my learning there and it has been spectacular. Similar needs to happen for appliances.
- computator 10y ago> appliance shopping, the ability to get information about what is actually quality is near zero Do you know about Consumer Reports?[1] It's a non-profit organization which puts out a magazine (and website) which does unbiased product testing, has zero advertising, pays for all the products they test, never takes sample products, buys all their products anonymously (so they can't be given better samples for testing purposes), and has extensive laboratories, procedures, scientist/technicians for testing (a private track for testing cars, for example). I never heard of anyone saying that Consumer Reports was fraudulent or paid-reviewed. Appliances are things that they definitely review all the time. The downsides of Consumer Reports are as follows: - it's U.S. based, so it's focused on products available in the U.S. - for appliances, say a washing machine, they are going to pick only 10-20 models to review, even though there may be hundreds of models on the market - there are a million things they'll never review because they are not an ordinary, common, consumer purchases; you'll never see reviews of oscilloscopes :-) [1] http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/index.htm http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/index.htm
- defined 10y ago> The downsides of Consumer Reports are as follows: Another downside, as the article pointed out, is the intentional smokescreen of multiple product names and slightly differing versions that make comparison shopping and meaningful reviews virtually impossible, and why I don't get as much value from my Consumer Reports subscription as I used to. This is particularly prevalent in the mattress industry.
- mark-r 10y agoPart of it is brand reputation stripping. If a brand gets a good reputation, some big conglomerate buys it and starts using it to make trash, and it takes time for consumers to learn it through the grapevine. This happens far too often to be mere coincidence.
- shuntress 10y agoIt's not a coincidence. But that doesn't mean it's a global conspiracy. You stated the entire cause->effect very succinctly yourself: "If a brand gets a good reputation, some big conglomerate buys it and starts using it to make trash, and it takes time for consumers to learn it through the grapevine" It is an extremely straightforward way for a company to make quick money.
- perlgeek 10y agoCompanies could offer a 20 year warranty to signal that their products are intended to last a long time.
- e40 10y agoquality will not determine what they buy BS. It's my #1 criteria when buying something.