6 ms·
Buffett's own writing on selling him your business is quite interesting. "Appendix B" at the end of the 1990 letter http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/199
by tim333 10y ago
Buffett's own writing on selling him your business is quite interesting. "Appendix B" at the end of the 1990 letter http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1990.html http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1990.html
- ruleabidinguser 10y agoI wonder what the good reason to sell is that he described. Like he pointed out, when you sell youre moving your safe assets to risky assets. Odd.
- aeden 10y agoDiversification perhaps? WEB clearly believes in the power of owning multiple businesses, perhaps he is just extrapolating from his own success that others are interested in following his lead?
- ruleabidinguser 10y agoYea that does make sense actually.
- hxta98596 10y ago> when you sell youre moving your safe assets to risky assets That's not exactly what he is saying nor what he means. Both are risky assets. A 100% owned business you deeply understand is still a very risky asset. On its own. I agree with aeden's comment that diversification is one of the main reasons to sell. The other good reason to sell...you get cash! Sure some of the cash will "probably" go to a diversified stock portfolio but some of it will be spent on cool stuff. You can't use stocks to buy your dream vacation home or donate money to charity for it to be spent on medical research. Cash is also the reason to sell. Lastly, people die. A business founder must sell the business or give it to someone else at some point in one way or another or it will be done for him or her.
- ChefDenominator 10y agoThat last part, death, is important, especially to Buffet. He supports the death tax because it strongly encourages business owners to sell to some outside investor. My understanding is that many businesses cannot support providing the Government with amount of cash necessary pay the tax, or the net reduction in income makes running the business not worthwhile. Note how the letter is worded to carefully state that the family members will still have some ownership and management will be maintained. While this is certainly wise acquisition tactic, it is also very appealing to a seller who is on the margin and primarily selling to avoid the death tax. (If you are thinking, "but the inheritor will still have to pay the tax on the cash," you are correct, but paying tax on cash still provides immediate payback with what is left over, whereas running or even just owning a business or any investment asset for 10+ years and getting zero or close to zero is not going to be desirable to a great many people.)
- valuearb 10y agoBuffett doesn't support estate taxes because of self interest, that would be silly as it's just a tiny factor in Berkshire Hathaway's business. He just doesn't believe the concentration of wealth and power is healthy for a democracy. That's a big reason why 99% of his wealth is going to charity instead of his kids. Now I think he's wrong about this. Rockefeller had a roughly ten times greater share of our nations wealth as Gates or Buffett ever had. And somehow our democracy survived and flourished, because inheritances typically get split up among children, grand-children and eventually hundreds of great-grand kids and great-great grand kids, and predominantly those descendants dissipate the wealth because they don't have the same drive or abilities as the wealth creator. And lots of that money ends up in charities before it's all gone.
- ChefDenominator 10y agoNon-profit entity is not the same as "charity". Most of the large non-profits operate on a percentage of the interest earned on a large endowment. It's essentially a scam for the very rich and the banks. If the purpose of the entity were truly to benefit the needy, then they would operate directly on donations and not withhold so much funding from those in need. I specifically discussed sellers who are on the margin. While it can be difficult to know exactly how many of these are, I'm willing to bet this would result in a very real and measurable reduction in investment opportunity for Berkshire. If it were 10 businesses in a year at Buffet's stated minimum of $10 million annual net profit, then that would represent $80 million in annual revenue for Berkshire. In the world of big business, famous personalities, and politics, my position is to assume the worst case scenario, which is that the only reason someone like Buffet supports the death tax is because he profits from it. In this case, it is not a coincidence.
- georgeecollins 10y agoLiquidity and diversification.
- ruleabidinguser 10y agoWhen you put it this way selling seems so unattractive
- tim333 10y agoCommon reasons to sell - The person running it is getting to retirement and the kids aren't that in to taking over, or some of the kids would rather have the cash - often the case in Buffett's purchases You want to cash in and do something else eg. Paul Graham selling Viaweb and ending up with this YC stuff Maybe diversification Maybe you have VC like investors who want/need to monetize
- aeden 10y agoThanks for linking this, it was quite an interesting lead.
- AVTizzle 10y agoThis was fascinating Tim - big thanks for sharing. I imagine you know your way around Buffett's annual letters well. Any other favorite portions you might particularly recommend?
- sudshekhar 10y ago+1 on this .. I have always wanted to read his letters but never found the time. Would love a curated set of ideas/articles to read
- jacques_chester 10y agoYou can buy the first 50 annual reports as a book; there are also books of collected essays. They're worth taking your time with, especially once the thing gathers pace.
- tim333 10y agoThey are also online Partnership letters 1959 - 1975 https://www.rbcpa.com/WEB_letters/WEB_Letters_pre_berkshire.html https://www.rbcpa.com/WEB_letters/WEB_Letters_pre_berkshire.... Berkshire letters http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/letters.html http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/letters.html
- tim333 10y agoLawrence Cunningham's book as mentioned by sumedh is a curated set.
- sumedh 10y agoJust read the actual letters or read https://www.amazon.com/Essays-Warren-Buffett-Lessons-Corporate/dp/1611637589 https://www.amazon.com/Essays-Warren-Buffett-Lessons-Corpora... There are little nuggets of wisdom everywhere.
- tim333 10y agoDunno - depends a bit what you are interested in. For some reason "Shutdown of Textile Business" http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1985.html http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1985.html sticks in my mind.
- ductionist 10y agoThis really resonated with me: > There is often a sound reason to sell but, if the transaction is a fair one, the reason is not so that the seller can become wealthier. It's a challenging statement in a world where pre-revenue startups can sell for $xM, and instructive about how the rest of the world works.
- wayn3 10y agoAssuming that your business has to make money to be of value is no different from assuming that your car has to make money to be of value.
- barrkel 10y agoSelling is a route to liquidity. Capital value is usually based on discounted (net present value) future income. To spend that future income you need to wait (& work) for it to arrive; or you can sell the future income stream today. To the degree that wealth means being able to spend money, selling capital can make you wealthy, but it just materialises something that was probabilistic. So I don't really see the challenge. Pre-revenue just means higher risk and a bigger discount.
- sandworm101 10y agoIt is more complicated these days. The asset is more than future revenue. The value of an asset is, at least partially, detached from the rights it embodies. A stock's present value is also based on it's likely future value, which is in turn based on market forces and geopolitic. A stock's price can go up only because another's goes down. An asset can increase in value because regs change or banks decide it can be more leveraged. Such forces are needed to explain why many invest in apparantly negative interest/growth, something that seem irrational if capital assets are valued purely on future earnings.
- sverige 10y ago>A stock's price can go up only because another's goes down. Ah, the zero-sum game deception. That only works in the short term, else the world economies wouldn't be able to support a population that is double what it was 30 or 40 years ago. That doesn't mean I disagree with the statement that capital assets are not valued purely on future earnings.
- htk 10y agoIf you should decide to do business with Berkshire [...] There would be no brokers involved. Seems to contradict the first rule of the article.