23 ms·
Windows 10 is bringing ads to File Explorer – how to turn them off
- grawlinson 10y agoHere's a better idea - show Microsoft that you don't accept this type of behaviour by switching products/services. I'm aware that Windows 10 is a "free" OS, but trying to ram this type of behaviour down my throat is despicable unethical behaviour and I don't condone it. It is why I've switched to Linux for my daily computing needs.
- city41 10y agoWindows 10 is not free. The "free upgrade" period is over. MSRP for Windows 10 Home is $119.
- userbinator 10y agoThat's why the parent put "free" in quotes. Unlike all the previous versions of Windows, MSFT decided to make this upgrade "free" for a while, but AFAIK it's still ridiculously easy to pirate Win10, and the "accessibility technologies" free upgrade loophole, which was said to be closing "very soon" many months ago, is still open. In other words, if you really don't want to pay, Microsoft still seems desperate to get you to "upgrade" to Win10... precisely so they can monetise you with ads (and might make more from you eventually even if you never paid for their OS). As a mass-exodus to Linux and macOS curretly seems unlikely, their strategy appears to be winning so far.
- TAForObvReasons 10y ago> As a mass-exodus to Linux and macOS curretly seems unlikely, their strategy appears to be winning so far. ... or people just install windows 7 / avoid upgrading to 10. Hard to call that a "win" Take everything with a grain of salt, but metrics still point to Windows 7 dominance: http://gs.statcounter.com/os-version-market-share/windows/desktop/worldwide http://gs.statcounter.com/os-version-market-share/windows/de... https://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share.aspx?qprid=10&qpcustomd=0 https://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- criddell 10y agoIsn't Microsoft starting to block updates to Windows 7 on new hardware?
- clouddrover 10y agoYes: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4012982/discusses-an-issue-in-which-you-receive-a-your-pc-uses-a-processor-tha https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4012982/discusses-a...
- Mithaldu 10y agoThey're not "blocking" updates, they've stopped writing and compiling them with the backwards compatibility shims that made them work on older hardware. They probably do this because it drives updates AND because it's cheaper, but please try to describe it accurately.
- clouddrover 10y ago> they've stopped writing and compiling them with the backwards compatibility shims that made them work on older hardware That claim doesn't stack up. Windows 10, for example, works fine on older hardware. As Microsoft said, they're blocking updates to Windows 7 and 8 if you try to run those OSes on newer hardware.
- Pica_soO 10y agoHow hard would it be to replace the ads with instructions to do a parallel Ubuntu install?
- sova 10y agoI like the way you open source.
- calvano915 10y agoInstalling Windows 10 on activated Windows 7/8 installs still upgrade to digitally entitled license. Just did it the other day. I didn't believe it 'til I tried it, but it worked.
- jay-anderson 10y agoI'd argue that even the 'free' upgrade is not free. For example a windows 8 install which used the free windows 10 upgrade will require purchasing a full license to make any significant hardware changes. I'm liking lots of things microsoft is doing as of late, but I still don't like a lot of their business practices and they are ruining their operating systems infesting it with ads.
- EGreg 10y agoProbably less effective than showing a celebrity you're no longer a fan by unfollowing them on twitter. They won't care. They can get people using other means.
- coldtea 10y ago>I'm aware that Windows 10 is a "free" OS, but trying to ram this type of behaviour down my throat is despicable unethical behaviour and I don't condone it. It is why I've switched to Linux for my daily computing needs. That would make sense if the benefits were more than the costs. Which, for the average people, aren't. Just the hassle of using a new interface, much less one that needs more admin work like Linux, is enough. And let's not go with compatibility with the various tasks people do. (And no, most people don't just "browse and read email". They also want to be able to see all kinds of videos, they want to be able to do stuff with Office documents they receive, they want to transfer and/or edit their daughter's birthday videos, and so on...).
- cutler 10y agoLinux sometimes isn't even compatible with standard open source software. Recently I installed Lubuntu LTS on a 5-year-old Celeron laptop and was dismayed to see LibreOffice with clunky grey window borders looking like a 1998 Java applet. The menu bar was also blacked-out. The owner was not impressed.
- lutusp 10y agoYour basic point is legitimate, but in passing I want to say that in Linux distributions you can change the windows decorators/formats to suit yourself, often including a theme designed to resemble Windows. Not to detract from the point you're making, which is quite valid.
- dc3k 10y ago> trying to ram this type of behaviour down my throat is despicable unethical behaviour and I don't condone it. It is why I've switched to Linux for my daily computing needs. Last time I used Linux (well, Ubuntu specifically) every time I searched for anything in the file system I would see at least half a dozen ads for products on Amazon. Significantly worse than anything I've ever seen in Windows 10 personally. Uninstalled it and never using it again.
- pmiller2 10y agoReally? I've never seen that. Is it under GNOME in the default install?
- pikzen 10y agoIt was in one of Ubuntu's releases, 16.04 I believe? Unity included Amazon results in its search results. EDIT: 12.04. Time flies. Memory sucks.
- ericd 10y agoI'm using 16.04 right now, how does one trigger those? I've never seen them.
- pikzen 10y agoI was wrong, it was actually in the 12.04 days. Didn't remember it to be so long ago. I believe it's disabled by default in newer releases. http://www.pcworld.com/article/2840401/ubuntus-unity-8-desktop-removes-the-amazon-search-spyware.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2840401/ubuntus-unity-8-deskt...
- aban 10y agoIt was indeed 12.04 and only affecting Unity (Canonical's Desktop Environment), not other DE's like GNOME or KDE. You should check out https://fixubuntu.com https://fixubuntu.com nonetheless, which surfaced at that time, is still up and relevant.
- overcast 10y agoLet's just be realistic here, the general public is not ever going to switch a Linux desktop. I've been hearing about it for 25 years, how this year is going to be the year of Linux on the desktop. Not ever happening. Mac MAYBE, but Linux, never. And for the handful of us nerds that do switch, Microsoft doesn't care. The Enterprise is where they make their money, and they are DEFINITELY NOT switching away from Windows desktops.
- wildrhythms 10y agoI feel like there's a cyclical gridlock between businesses and business software vendors in which neither party can afford to be the "first" to move to a new platform. It's like a comical game of chicken because in less than a decade all of this software is going to be in a web browser anyway.
- SteveNuts 10y agoI think with the rise of cloud based productivity software (Google Docs, etc.) we'll see a rise in alternative OS's. I know one of the big issues with adopting Linux on the desktop in companies is the issue with access control (something like AD's Group Policy). It's amazing how you can control pretty much every permission/policy imaginable within your domain using AD, and until something like that comes out for Linux it won't get adopted.
- H4CK3RM4N 10y agoThe sad part here is that Linux is actually really good for that by design (if you take the time to understand Unix permissions).
- SteveNuts 10y agoThat's true, we use Red Hat's IDM and it's very nice.
- digi_owl 10y agoThe sad thing is that MS office is about more than editing documents these days. Thanks to embedded VB scripts etc the suite is more a RAD environment for office drones. There is an untold number of business processes that are effectively encoded into a excel spreadsheet sprinkled with scripts.
- ebbv 10y agoThis kind of shit is exactly why I retired my PC. Done with all Microsoft products.
- ReverseCold 10y agoI'll say it again on HN: I have never seen an ad on Windows 10 Pro except: - Candy Crush - Edge Homescreen (hardly counts)
- nu5500 10y agoI have Windows 10 Pro AND an Office 365 subscription and the damn thing showed up for me. While I use and enjoy quite a few Microsoft products, I feel like there are just some baffling, ill thought out, and ham-fisted mistakes going on there with how these ads are being pushed out. They look tacky and I can only imagine they're doing more harm than good. For example, the ads for Edge that now show up touting that you can stream longer with Edge. Really? I don't know anyone that that would convince to stop using Chrome. How about maybe something more basic like changing the logo, since every non-technical user that I know just thinks it's Internet Explorer and it's been pounded into their brains for years (and for good reason) to use Firefox or Chrome instead.
- sova 10y agoI know right?! How horrendously vile! "Hey, I know it wasn't clear that the consumer was actually the product before, so let's cut to the chase and let you know that you're really just an advertising-consuming-biological machine." How painfully and uncouthly reductive. Making your products skip the whole "getting infected by Malware before they show you advertisements all the time" is not the solution to making money, or growing your brand, or having long-term success. Rather, it looks more like the final hoo-rah of a sinking ship.
- Arizhel 10y agoSinking ship? Microsoft's financials are quite solid. And just look at the comments here in this thread, on "Hacker News", a site you think would be full of techies: they're mostly advocating sticking with Windows. How on Earth is Microsoft a "sinking ship"? Apple's laptops, by contrast, are the ones that seem to be going downhill, with that company concentrating on its mobile phones. Where are all the Windows users going to go? Not to Apple, and apparently not to Linux either judging by the marketshare numbers and comments here. Microsoft is doing exactly the right thing here, loading up their OS with spyware and adware to make money from their users. I see nothing at all wrong with them abusing users as much as they want, with forced reboots, forced ads, poorly-QAed driver updates causing system malfunctions, etc. Their customers have proven over and over and over that they will not abandon the Windows platform no matter what, so it's perfectly sensible for Microsoft to exploit this for monetary gain. And given that the techies on sites like this are generally libertarian, anyone who complains about MS's behavior is most likely a hypocrite.
- paulddraper 10y agoThat's great. Here's why most people don't: they like editing Word documents, using Bluetooth, playing AAA games, printing and scanning, connecting to external monitors, watching DVDs, and transferring files from their phones.
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y ago>they like editing Word documents LibreOffice supports this and it works quite well. I would guess most people prefer google drive these days, though. >using Bluetooth Do you actually know anyone non-technical who has used bluetooth at all in the past 5 years? Or technical for that matter, I've used bluetooth maybe 3 times in that time frame and always had no issues on Linux. >playing AAA games This is your only legitimate point, but it grows less legitimate every day. >printing and scanning Works fine OOTB for nearly all printers and scanners using only GUIs to configure and use the devices. >connecting to external monitors This has worked perfectly fine for at least 10 years... >watching DVDs Also works just fine. >transferring files from their phones I do this all the time. Works OOTB on popular distros. The real problem is that people are change averse and that people like you spread uninformed FUD. Cut it out.
- paulddraper 10y agoWhat you call "uninformed FUD" are unfortunately real problems I have had in the past 12 months on Lenovo Thinkpad W530 with Ubuntu 14.04. Perhaps I am missing the ever elusive combination of distro and machine.
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoLooks like there are a couple of minor issues that can be resolved with a trivial amount of research: http://www.linlap.com/lenovo_thinkpad_w530 http://www.linlap.com/lenovo_thinkpad_w530 If you hit other problems, did you do any research? Did you ask for support anywhere?
- Karunamon 10y ago
- alextooter 10y agoYes,I using macOS now.
- bradgessler 10y agoLinux isn't entirely immune to this. Ubuntu had Amazon search integration https://www.howtogeek.com/188589/5-things-you-need-to-know-about-ubuntu-14.04-lts/ https://www.howtogeek.com/188589/5-things-you-need-to-know-a... A while back. Not sure where that stands today. Firefox was paid by Google in the past and I believe Yahoo these days. macOS had a connection with Bing in Spotlight. The current incarnation is just a dog with different fleas.
- laumars 10y ago> Linux isn't entirely immune to this. Ubuntu had Amazon search integration https://www.howtogeek.com/188589/5-things-you-need-to-know-a.. https://www.howtogeek.com/188589/5-things-you-need-to-know-a.... A while back. Not sure where that stands today. This is the most relevant of your 3 examples and Canonical got heavily criticised for it. They ended up reversing their decision. Which makes it all the more important that people take this example not as "It's ok for Microsoft to do it as well" but rather "We also shouldn't allow Microsoft to get away with this". >Firefox was paid by Google In the last and I believe Yahoo these days. The thing here is that when you type something in the search bar you are actually wanting to search for something online - given that it's a "search" bar. It kind of made sense for Google to be the default search engine as that is the most popular search engine in the west (ie what most people would prefer to default to) so even without Google's investment I can see the logic of having a Google search bar. In fact I would go further and say that's a well received productivity tool. However It's also very easy to change which online service is used in the search bar - or even to remove it entirely. So the Google investment does not lock you into using Google services on Firefox. Thus I see no conflict of interest with regards to Google's donations to Firefox.
- bradgessler 10y agoRe: Ubuntu's decision to reverse ad integration, perhaps there's hope that with enough criticism Microsoft may re-evaluate integrating ads into explorer?
- laumars 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Markoff 10y agoyeah, if i used my laptop for personal use is no problem bit i doubt there is solid CAT software for Android or Linux which could compete with SDL Trados studio
- vetinari 10y agoDo you really use Studio? Most people I know seem to prefer the old Workbench. Big customers are also switching to web-based tools, where they can, among other thing, track the progress status easily.
- Markoff 10y agotried few others, they are inferior to SDL Trados Studio, web based tools are also pretty horrible, I currently work on project for major search engine and tool we use is just horrible, I mean the speed, I waste like 30% of my time waiting for response from their server (I have like 150Mb home internet), when it works fast then it's great and I can do a lot of work, but most of the time I have to wait same goes for another major Chinese phone producer, their virtual phones in browser are just horrible, something I would check even with screenshots and Excel in 30mins take with virtual phone 1.5hour, complete waste of time I am yet, to experience any web based tool which would be superior for my work compared to offline apps oh, now that I mentioned it, certain big Japanese phone brand have really nice web tool where you can work superfast no problem 150-200 screenshots per hour including editing and highlighting bugs, but that was only exception to my experience with all other companies
- vetinari 10y agoI'm already out of this business... The push for the web tools, I know only from talking to former colleagues. However, I did use the Studio few times and I didn't like it for the same reason you don't like web apps - it was big and slow like molasses. I did most of my work with (Trados) Workbench and TagEditor - these were lightning fast compared to Studio. So I guess, that it comes in cycles: fast forward few years and people will be complaining about the latest tools and how the previous web apps were quick and easy :).
- sgift 10y agoSure, give me a product which handles all of my use cases (that includes gaming) and I'll switch any minute.
- taf2 10y agoSucks to be a windows user
- amaks 10y agoInteresting. Chromebooks are cheaper and ChromeOS doesn't shove ads to users' faces. Who's scroogled now?
- brians 10y agoOf course not. It tracks your behavior, and adds the ads later. Why is that better, exactly?
- amaks 10y agoWhich is so much better, at least to me, to see targeted ads instead of some generic crap subscription for $7.99/mo.
- netsharc 10y agoPlaying today in theatres, Beauty and the Beast, a life-action version of the famous Disney cartoon. Starring Emma Watson, Ian McKellan, Ewan McGregor, and many more stars!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- csdreamer7 10y ago> how to turn them off Switch to Linux. Windows 10 Home is now $119 and tracks you. Microsoft is trying to sell you a product and monetize your behavior. They are pursuing a way to maintain their cash cow and have an avenue to push Google out.
- nobodyshere 10y agoI tried that quite a few times on a rarer pc setup (intel nuc 6i7kyk, 6i5syk). Doesn't usually end that well. What windows has that works great is the driver support, graphics drivers in particular. On ubuntu and mint especially. I'll try building a Ryzen pc this summer to see how well that works though.
- elcct 10y agoThis is not that easy - some software is Windows only and it doesn't work under WINE etc.
- chc 10y agoThis works well if your hobbies include manually editing obscure config files and replacing perfectly good hardware, and if your hobbies do not include playing games. I frequently explore the possibility of switching to Linux, and while it's not the garbage fire it was 15 years ago, it's still just not a peer to Windows for the way I use my computer.
- idobai 10y agoInteresting, gaming is one of my hobbies and I've switched to linux years ago. Most games I play are native and a few which aren't run on wine. The more people moving to linux = more games will be available on linux.
- booleandilemma 10y agoCompletely agree. I tried Ubuntu a few years ago because I heard that distro was comparably easier to use and my experience was frustrating. It took me 3 hours just to get the speakers to work, and the wifi connection would regularly drop off. Windows just works, and I'll happily pay money for a good product.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoThis is not acceptable
- youdontknowtho 10y agoI actually like windows 10, but this is really lame. * yes, I'm being pedantic, but the ad for one drive is in the file explorer, not the file system. Its doesn't appear in the command line.
- Arizhel 10y agoYou're right of course, but to most users, File Explorer is the normal window into the filesystem so to them the two terms are interchangeable in a colloquial sense.
- xkxx 10y agoIt was my first thought and after I checked the comments it seems like a general consensus of HN that the best way to turn them off is to switch to some other OS.
- idobai 10y agoDo you find it more comfortable to constantly fight with your malicious OS vendor about its greatly annoying and disrespectful decisions?
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe problem is that Microsoft doesn't really want you to turn them off, and is now on rolling releases, so there is no longer a one-time fix. You can turn it off now but next week they'll be back because they changed something and the old setting is no longer effective. The only permanent fix is to switch to a different OS.
- aphextron 10y agoI'm so divided on Microsoft these days. On the one hand they are doing all the right things in terms of supporting FOSS and making Windows into a truly great OS. But then they pull stuff like this and you remember it's Microsoft. I think this is just the price we are going to pay for "evergreen" operating systems. As a consumer, you now only buy Windows once. Microsoft has to make up for these lost sales so it makes sense. I don't agree with it, but having to toggle off advertising is not going to keep me from using what I consider to be the best operating system for my needs.
- jaxn 10y agoIt is like a bipolar company.
- lawpoop 10y agoIts always seemed to me like a company driven by committee. And that committee is strongly non-technical business types.
- jlgaddis 10y ago> As a consumer, you now only buy Windows once. Microsoft has to make up for these lost sales so it makes sense. Once per device. Consumers (with a few exceptions, of course) don't, in the standard sense, really "buy" Windows. They pay for it, sure, when they buy a new computer, phone, etc., but most consumers don't buy a shrink-wrapped copy of Windows 10 off the shelf. Microsoft is still making money off of Windows with every purchase of a new desktop or laptop. I'll grant that they may have lost some revenue by "giving away" Windows 10 upgrades and such but it doesn't seem to be affecting them too much. From a quick glance, it looks like $MSFT is currently at an all-time high. > ... having to toggle off advertising is not going to keep me from using [Windows] ... Out of curiosity, where will you draw the line? Will you change your mind when they remove the option to turn the OneDrive ads off? What about when the ads change -- from OneDrive ads to ads for other Microsoft products? Or ads for other, unrelated, third-party products? What about when the ads expand to other parts of the "Windows experience"? Right now, according to TFA, they're only shown in Windows Explorer. Will you change your mind when Microsoft starts injecting ads into other applications you use on a daily basis? What if they begin showing video advertisements before you can watch a home video of your kids in (the modern equivalent of) Windows Media Player? Or when a slideshow of your family vacation photos is interrupted by an advertisement being shown every tenth photo? It sounds absurd, I know, and these scenarios are a long way off from what's happening now -- showing OneDrive ads in Windows Explorer -- and I wouldn't really expect any of the above to ever actually happen. Then again, as recently as a couple years ago, we wouldn't have expected our operating system to ever show us any ads at all. If we had been asked a few years ago, most of us (in "the tech community") wouldn't have ever expected that Microsoft would someday implement the privacy-invading tracking features ("telemetry") that now exist in Windows 10. It would have seemed absolutely crazy that they'd do something like that -- but they did. If memory serves, it was -- at first -- relatively easy to disable. My understanding is, however, that they continued to implement more and more telemetry while at the same time making it even more difficult to completely turn off. Even today, I don't think there exists any way to reliably -- and with 100% certainty -- prevent a Windows 10 PC from sending any "telemetry" back to the mothership. If these ads make Microsoft money -- and I have no doubt that they will -- why wouldn't they expand on this idea and squeeze in more ads anywhere they can? We've already seen that customers will not move away from Windows as their desktop operating system (in any significant number) when Microsoft implements these new "features", so what do they have to lose? Rest assured that these ads will not be going away. To the contrary, they will almost certainly continue to exist and become even more widespread. We will, someday, reach a point where the average Windows desktop resembles a NASCAR race car -- covered with logos and advertisements -- and wonder "how did we get to this point?". --- Myself, the line that I drew was crossed by Microsoft many, many years ago. Looking back, I'm glad that it happened when it did. It saved me from dealing with a decade's worth of Microsoft's bullshit.
- randiantech 10y agoThe very same info was published just a couple of days ago.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoThis sucks, of course. Yet all the comments on this thread saying the solution is to simply switch platforms ignore something very fundamental. I like to say "Nobody goes to Home Depot to buy a drill bit; what they want to buy is a hole." I don't use Windows because I want to use Windows. I use it because there are things I need to do that can only be done with it. The "just switch to Linux" reaction is an understandable engineering reaction. And, frankly, if your world is limited to web development and some forms of embedded development it might make a ton of sense. Yet, from a business perspective it makes no sense outside of scenarios that fit Linux well. For others it isn't that simple. What would the Linux proponents suggest we do with hundreds of thousands of dollars invested in software not available on any other platform? Solidworks, Siemens NX, Altium Designer, FEA and other simulation tools, CAM and other manufacturing tools, an myriad other applications ranging from business to medicine to engineering that depend on this platform. The goal of a business is to deliver goods and services, not to play with operating systems. The operating system is irrelevant. It's all about the software that runs on it and the utility it provides to users. As an aside, this, I believe, is exactly where Apple has gone wrong. By insisting on having totalitarian control over everything on their platforms they have effectively limited the utility of their devices. At the same time, this is what makes them so good for a certain range of utilization scenarios. We use Windows because it is the only way to buy a hole. We could not care less what OS is under the hood. All we care about is the hole we need to drill. And, frankly, Microsoft has been making a better product with time. I've been using MS products since DOS on the original IBM PC (I bought one when they came out for $3,200). Save missteps here and there, MS software has always improved with time. What they need is our feedback in order to make it even better. The criticism is fair, of course.
- cm2187 10y agoI wonder how many of these industrial applications will want to remain on a platform that pushes unblockable updates that keep adding more telemetry and leakage of data. I am not even convinced windows 10 is usable in a sensitive environment like a law firm, a bank or in healthcare. Big companies will use enterprise versions and pay IT people full time to block all that shit. Smaller and medium companies just use the pro version and don't have the resources to configure it properly.
- unholiness 10y agoIn browsers, ad blockers are being used more and more commonly for even non-technical folks. In native apps mobile apps, there are some okay ad-blocking solutions. But when the ads are baked into the operating system itself... I have a hard time seeing Microsoft or Apple losing the ad blocking battle. So, instead of getting ads somewhat sandboxed inside a browser, in the future we may be getting ads inside the start menu, inside spotlight, on the toolbar... and instead of semi-directly funding content providers, the ad space will only ever be funneling money to the these same huge companies to spend as they see fit. Bleeech.
- cm2187 10y agoWhen companies think their business is to monetize their customers to the last penny instead of making a product people want, it is the beginning of the end. True for Microsoft, true for Apple. I think, long term, we will look back at 2016 as the turning point.
- givinguflac 10y agoSerious question, where do you see Apple monetizing customer data? I can't think of any way they monetize customers beyond hardware and app sales.
- cm2187 10y agoRemoving the audio jack to sell more dongles or proprietary devices. Shoving down our throat all their paying services: icloud, apple music, apple pay, etc. It used to be that I would be eager to buy a new iphone because I was keen to get the new features. Now I hold on to my older model because it has less of this nagging and new "features".
- omginternets 10y ago>I have a hard time seeing Microsoft or Apple losing the ad blocking battle At the risk of hijacking your comment, what's the present situation with regards to running Linux on Apple hardware? I quite like my Macbook and am generally tolerant of MacOS (mostly because it's POSIX-y enough to feel familiar), but would definitely consider installing a Linux distro depending on how well it worked.
- owebmaster 10y ago> how to turn them off If you feel the urge to turn it off, switch to GNU/Linux. Turn annoying things off is not a solution, it is an excuse.
- recursive 10y agoIt is a solution to that annoying thing happening. Switching to Linux isn't a solution either, even if it has GNU in the name, if your problem is "run this Windows software".
- alkonaut 10y agoI think many people would find at least as many annoyances in Linux within the first hours of use. Things like multi display with different dpi isn't great in windows but the story in Linux is worse. I think the difference is in what people find annoying. I find technical issues such as driver support, font rendering or dpi scaling 10x more annoying than an occasional ad or a fear of snooping. It's more an individual choice of what kind of annoyance you prefer. If there was an OS with great ivory tower polish and great attitude towards integrity and openness I'd be interested. Right now you just have to choose one or the other.
- cadecairos 10y agoI ditched File Explorer for Directory Opus a while back, no regrets, especially now that there are ads baked in.
- moogly 10y agoSame. I haven't even opened Explorer for several years.
- besselheim 10y agoDoesn't seem that big a deal, it's an upsell for Microsoft's own file synchronization services, not some third party ad. And you can easily disable it.
- ajmurmann 10y agoGood point! I only use Windows for Steam. So I haven't seen this in person. Is it that different from iOS constantly trying to get me to create a iCloud account? That also costs money if you need more space.
- Klathmon 10y agoIt's amazing how much this story has blown up, along with the "Google home has ads" story. In both cases they seem almost insane how many people are up in arms about this. It's them pushing a service of theirs in their os. Apple does it, Google does it, Ubuntu does it, everyone does it. And it's such a non issue. They are promoting a service that is very tied in to the OS that a lot of people want and don't know exist. Maybe I'm the weird one, but it just seems like a hit piece when so many websites started reporting on this so hard and it's not even a big deal to me...
- cyberpunk 10y agoYou think it's not a big deal that you pay microsoft $119 for an OS and they're injecting ads into the local file browser? How are those being targetted? Ads on sites and apps -- yeah okay. We got to pay the rent for the content we're viewing.. Ads baked into the OS, especially one you'be paid for, is disturbing.. For me anyway.. I've not used windows in a long time, but I'm kind of dissapointed in the way they've been going. They appeared to be going in a good direction with the new guy after balmer -- for a while I thought they'd buy github.. More OSS, some cool tech -- but they've been slowly getting into the data business and when that happens by degrees it's hard for people to be outraged enough to call them on it. Don't stand for this shit. Even if we don't, though, it won't make much of a difference since we're the minority who can even understand what's happening...
- 10y ago
- alistproducer2 10y agoSerious question: does MS sell a version of Window 10 outright that doesn't include all of the snooping? I've been a Windows user my whole life but I will NEVER use an OS that collects data on the OS level.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoThe LTSB edition is supposed to be this version, except it still includes the ads for OneDrive, so who knows what they're doing.
- criddell 10y agoConsumers can't buy that edition though.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoRight. For consumers, there is no version of Windows 10 where telemetry can be switched off. I use the "Shutup10" tool to disable everything can be disabled, but I don't use Windows 10 as my everyday OS.
- HeavenBanned 10y agoFor people who like dead comments: get the Windows (N) LTSB Enterprise edition. It's not _just_ the LTSB edition. Some perks to note of: * No bloatware * Updates every 60-90 days (as opposed to the oppressive every 5-7 days); choice to reboot auto or not. * No Windows Media Player * No MSFT Edge; Only Windows Explorer classic * Classic calculator * No Windows App Store * No background apps * No upselling shenanigans annoying my experience * No MSFT cloud * Cortana is removed completely not disabled * Mission-critical updates only...avoids needless flair in favor of stable security. * Never seen an ad ever. All in all, I would highly recommend it. For those that can see dead comments: you're welcome.
- drdaeman 10y agoI've noticed there's a "vouch" button for dead comments, and I believe your comment is informative. Although, problem is, this edition is just not available to mere mortals... well, legally. As far as I understand, it requires Volume Licensing, which may not be available for individuals (depends on reseller and jurisdiction, I guess - most probably won't bother to deal with non-companies at all) and, AFAIK, requires to purchase at least 5 licenses.
- AdeptusAquinas 10y agoSome irony in finding it hard to read the article through all its ad popups on the mobile version
- Keverw 10y agoAre the ads only for storage service? At first I was thinking we'd start seeing banner ads like we do on blogs. If it's only Microsoft pushing their own integrated services I don't really have much of a problem, but for software I paid for showing third party ads when I never ever had an expectation of such a thing then I do agree it is very horrible. The "Not now" button does seem like a anti-pattern instead of a simple no. Reminds me on how iOS apps bug you over and over again to rate them. I assume in X amount of time, it would show the banner again? I think it should be like "Learn More" or "Dismiss". Then have Dismiss never show it again on that device(unless they did like a reinstall of the OS). I'm sure it's useful to know it's available, especially to non tech people but you shouldn't have to jump into a long list of settings to stop it. Imagine some day your car dashboard updates and starts showing banner ads for deals at near by places when the car never did it in the first place. That'd be kinda creepy too.
- dboreham 10y agoThe only one I've seen was for their storage services. I admit it surprised me initially, but I suppose it could be worse. Hopefully it does not go the way of Skype which (for me) is almost entirely unusable on Windows these days due (I assume) to the ads locking up/hanging the process.
- skeletonjelly 10y agohttps://gist.github.com/joielechong/d0042338fd3132013aec4ee56045e558 https://gist.github.com/joielechong/d0042338fd3132013aec4ee5...
- froindt 10y agoMy mom already had OneDrive installed and it was pestering her. I don't know what they want me to do. I went in and turned the notification off, but 98% of people won't know to do that and will accept a shitty aspect of the user experience.
- nxc18 10y agoJust to clarify, this is basically the same exact thing that macOS does with regards to storage. Try running low on storage and see how long it takes to get spammed with notifications to buy more icloud storage.
- lutusp 10y agoThere's an opportunity here for a young, ambitious programmer -- create a PowerShell script that automatically goes through the Windows registry, creating/resetting options to disable all advertising (Start menu, File Explorer, OneDrive, Edge's annoying gripes when you launch a competing browser, and others). I suggest this because as time passes the manual approach to disabling the many sources of Windows advertising is becoming somewhat baroque. Such a script would be a great public service. I won't personally benefit -- I've run Linux exclusively for almost 20 years -- but when I visit Windows in connection with my work, I feel compassion for those who put up with it. I think, "Wait ... people pay to be abused this way?"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jlgaddis 10y agoYou can easily find an overwhelming number of projects similar to what you describe on Github and across the web. The problem is that Microsoft is constantly adding and/or changing the options, settings, registry keys, etc., and they don't exactly publish a nicely compiled, authoritative list of all of them. The folks writing these scripts (or even just documenting the settings) are working by trial and error, reverse engineering, and so on, to find the relevant knobs to tweak and switches to flip to get rid of these "features". If they do manage to get lucky and come up with a working solution, it's out-of-date as soon as the next update drops. Like you, this advertising isn't a problem for me. I was introduced to Linux in 1995 and it's been my primary operating system (along with a few OS X "phases") since then. I have friends and family, however, who can't switch (for various reasons), and so it still annoys me to no end that Microsoft does this kind of stuff.
- Arizhel 10y agoIt doesn't annoy me, it makes me laugh. As for friends and family, I've already switched two of them to Mint/KDE and they're both quite happy with it as it suits their limited needs extremely well (web browsing, simple document editing, watching DVDs) and is extremely reliable.
- 10y ago
- jaxn 10y agoThis is very disheartening. As a direct result, I am spending some time tonight researching running Linux on my Suface Book. I have been impressed with what seems like a new Microsoft. I even made the switch from OSX to a Surface Book as my primary laptop. I used OSX for a decade and ran Linux as my primary OS before that.
- bubblethink 10y ago>As a direct result, I am spending some time tonight researching running Linux on my Suface Book. Probably not the best hardware to run Linux on. There's an entire subreddit comprised of woes of people trying this https://www.reddit.com/r/SurfaceLinux/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SurfaceLinux/ . Try something very new like Fedora 25/upcoming 26 or the upcoming Ubuntu 17.04.
- exergy 10y agoI don't exactly have the surface book, I have the surface pro 3, but I'm able to dual boot with Xubuntu and Mint without too much trouble. Of course, it wouldn't be Linux if wifi wasn't tricky to set up, but touch works, Bluetooth works, the detachable keyboard also works.
- good_vibes 10y agoI guess have to stay with Mac and make it a Linux machine. Glad I saw this, I had a ZenBook in my Amazon 'save for later' cart.
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoYou may have done yourself a favor. I have a Zenbook Pro UX501VW, and getting Linux to run well on it has been unusually challenging. Although as time goes on and newer Linux kernels and nVidia drivers come along, a fresh install should get easier.
- good_vibes 10y agoWow, thanks. Already had a rough year with Apple. My MBP is about a year old and Apple already had to give me a new display and logic board for it! I wanted to ditch my iPhone and Macbook this year. I still may after I do some more research on an encrypted Linux setup.
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoYou're welcome. Just to be clear: The ZenBook Pro UX510VW is a nice Linux laptop, once properly configured. If you're okay with a investing several hours of setup, it could well be one of your better options. Here's a quick rundown of the issues I remember encountering, in case it matters. (I was setting it up a few months ago, so I would have been trying to install Ubuntu 16.10 and Mint 18.1.) (1) I can't remember all the details, but I was unable to install either Ubuntu 16.10 or Linux Mint 18.1 using the traditional BIOS-based installer. I had to use a UEFI-based one instead. (Which wasn't a big deal, but I had no past experience with UEFI, so I had to read up on it first.) (2) The trackpad jumped around a lot. I found an easy solution at [1]. IIRC, I had the problem initially with the 4.4 kernel that came with the Linux distros mentioned above. The problem might be fixed on its own with more recent kernels. (3) The laptop has both nVidia and (built-in) Intel graphics chips. The ability to switch between them is pretty seamless, except for the need to log out and back in again in order to go back and forth. However, this only worked well for me when using nVidia's proprietary driver, which in turn prevented me from (easily) using very recent Linux kernels (4.10+). Supposedly there are other ways to get this working (Bumblebee, et al), but making that work required more effort than I wanted to invest. (4) The laptop has two connectors for external monitors: a USB-C, and HDMI. My monitor accepts DVI and HDMI. IIRC, I tried three ways of connecting the laptop to my monitor (a Dell U2412M): (a) HDMI --> HDMI (b) HDMI --> (adapter) --> DVI (c) USB-C --> (adapter) --> HDMI Of those three, only (c) worked. Regarding (a) and (b), I can only guess as to where the blame lies. (5) The laptop has a high-DPI display, which many Linux apps have trouble with [2]. Those problem aren't peculiar to this laptop, but mention the issue because a lower-DPI laptop display wouldn't have this trouble. For one app I use (Intel VTune, which uses Gtk2), the only really workable solution was is to use an external monitor when using that app. Another consequence of the high-DPI display is that the virtual terminals (e.g., the terminal you get when you hit Ctrl-Alt-F1 ) have really small text. Which can make it a real hassle when you have to fix graphics-driver problems, etc. There may be an easy fix for this; I haven't checked. (6) When I'm fiddling with graphics drivers, sometimes the laptop's fan runs loud and stays on until the next time I reboot. When I've got the graphics drivers working right, this problem doesn't occur. [1] https://github.com/vlasenko/hid-asus-dkms.git https://github.com/vlasenko/hid-asus-dkms.git [2] http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/linux-hidpi-support-for-gnome-kde-xfce-cinnamon-and-firefox/ http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/linux-hidpi-support-for-gnome-k...
- Pica_soO 10y agoA funny game of whack the registry and group policy. Best of all its free.
- stevebmark 10y agoFeeling better every day about ignoring upgrade from 7 > 10 constant spam.
- NelsonMinar 10y agoNote there's ads in lots of other parts of Windows 10 too: the Start menu tiles, the preloaded programs, and the Notifications area. There are different ways to turn each of these off. They are multiplying. Fuck everything about this. My computer is my tool and my work environment.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoThe lock/login screen too.
- aptwebapps 10y agoWe've gotten quite attached to the random login screen pictures in our house. At some point they started adding textual explanations after you clicked so you could read a little about what you were looking at. I was surprised how disappointed I was yesterday when instead of the usual explanations it was an ad for some Adobe product. I'm used to ads in the browser but this was personal somehow.
- bubblethink 10y agoIs it possible to run Windows Server on desktop/laptop in order to avoid all the windows 10 nonsense (cortana, telemetry, ads etc.) ?
- jlgaddis 10y agoIt should be. It's been several years ago and I don't keep up-to-date on Windows server tech anymore but, at the time, I knew many people (devs, mostly) who chose to run Windows Server 2008 on their desktop instead of Windows 7. It was quite easy to do because 7 & 2008 shared so much of the underlying code. I'm not sure if the same is still true (e.g., with 10 and 2012/2016).
- motyar 10y agoSwitch to Linux. Its easier than you think. or Switch to Mac if you can.
- askvictor 10y ago'Sync provider notifications' sounds like a useful API for cloud file services such as Dropbox or Drive to be able to communicate with the user. If that's what is actually for, and some other part of ms thought it might be a good place to push OneDrive, it will probably have the unfortunate effect of people turning off an otherwise useful part of windows.
- mherrmann 10y agoIf you're fed up with Explorer, you might also look into alternative file managers. I'm developing one: https://fman.io https://fman.io
- lessclue 10y agoNice, but it'd be better if the homepage mentioned that its not a free product. Also, it's unclear how long the evaluation version lasts.
- ksk 10y agoWith everyone salivating at shoving ads in peoples faces at every opportunity, not doing so is probably 'leaving money on the table' for MS. It sucks that digital advertising is a moneymaker. IMHO it would be beneficial for the tech world if Google/FB become unprofitable.
- shmerl 10y agoSwitch to Linux. Problem solved ;)
- kabdib 10y agoWe're doing some qualification of Windows Server 2016, which we use to run some business logic [insert history here]. Imagine my surprise when I found some Cortana-related processes running on one of the test boxes. Cortana. On an OS that's supposed to be a server. I can tell that I'm going to have a ton of fun locking this stupid thing down. Also, seeing a process named "NetworkSpy" got fun, fast; whoever named that thing sure knew how to get my attention. I like the core Windows OS; it's a nice kernel. But there's a lot of crap on top of it, and their testing is getting worse. Ask me about Remote Desktop regressions... well, don't. It's the weekend and I want to forget.
- morrbo 10y agoThe forced restarts on a server are funny too. As is the feedback information to Microsoft (which iirc can not be turned off completely, only to basic, maybe there is a registry/gpo hack but i havent played with this yet). Can't set the "active hours" to more than 12 hours to prevent restarting when it dictates, so end up disabling the update service entirely which is a complete anti-pattern to what they were trying to "achieve". I mean, the active hours stuff is a good idea, but for the love of god in a server environment it should be easy to disable automatic restarts.
- Mithaldu 10y ago> The forced restarts on a server are funny too. If you're already using Windows Server, have it serviced by someone trained in it, and you won't see forced restarts. If i can have 100% control of it on my pro system with only out-of-the-box tools, including selection of which updates i want to install and which not, then so can you on the server version.
- morrbo 10y agoAs i said below i am more on about MS even considering this as a default option for a server environment, not about the lack of control.
- 10y ago
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoNo, we're talking about an OS shipping with ads (that you can turn off) and an OS shipping with a theme that some people don't like (that you can change). One of these is a gross breach of trust on the part of the OS. You know the difference, cut the crap.
- dang 10y ago> You know the difference, cut the crap. This kind of incivility isn't allowed here, regardless of how strongly you feel or how wrong the other person is. Same with "Don't be an ass" elsewhere in the thread. Your comments would have been fine with such bits edited out. Please do that in the future. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13905313 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13905313 and marked it off-topic.
- perfectstorm 10y agoNot sure why this is a big deal. you can turn it off. HBO subscribers are shown ads (for other HBO shows) at the beginning of the play. I believe that happens with Amazon Prime Videos as well. Google shows ads for Chrome browser when you google from a different browser. how is this any different ?
- jolux 10y agoBecause you pay Microsoft to use Windows, and you pay them a lot. With HBO streaming you can always skip past those ads, and I've never seen them on Prime videos (if you could again you can skip past them). With Google, they're giving you the service for free, so ads are expected. If I'm going to shell out $120 for a Windows license, I don't want to see goddamn ads built into the fucking operating system.
- perfectstorm 10y agoGoogle started playing ads on their $129 Google Home just the other day (http://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/3/16/14948696/google-home-assistant-advertising-beauty-and-the-beast http://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/3/16/14948696/go...). Apple shows ads to older iPhone users (https://9to5mac.com/2015/12/11/apple-advertising-iphone-6s-to-older-iphone-owners-through-app-store-popups/ https://9to5mac.com/2015/12/11/apple-advertising-iphone-6s-t...). how is this any different ? Actually Windows can at least be turned off.
- jolux 10y agoGoogle is a goddamn ad company, I expect that kind of bullshit from them. Does that Apple ad come up more than once? If it does, yeah that's pretty annoying and disappointing too.
- megablast 10y agoAre you serious? So you will not mind if your phone suddenly starts putting ads on the lock screen? Or your watch?
- asadlionpk 10y agoEveryone panicking should know that macOS has this too.
- tempodox 10y agoThis is plainly wrong. You are disseminating misinformation.
- asadlionpk 10y agoIt gives me an annoying 'disk is full' message every day even when I have plenty of it left. And clicking it opens up Storage Management utility which simply upsells me iCloud upgrade as the top 'Recommendation'.
- frik 10y agoWhen will Microsoft stop with this shit, and do a 180 degree U-turn? What does it need? It's unbelievable how MSFT turned Windows from the great Win7 to the worst spyware operating system in human history aka Win10 in just 5 years. Is it just greed? Is it that they failed with Mobile (WinPhone is dead and has 0.1% world wide market share) and Android amd iOS have a bigger market share than Windows 7? (Win10 has way smaller market share). On desktop Windows 7 has like 50% market share, where as Win10 is around 20%. Is it that they failed with XBoxOne, now Sony and Nintendo eat MSFT former console market share as breakfast. I bought two highend notebooks one a MacBookPro, the other with Win7 Pro preinstalled. The will last for the next five years. I stay with Office 2010 and additionally installed LibreOffice. I skip Win8 and Win10, and I am running Linux in VMs. What's really disgusting is that in future many smaller companies like law firms, doctors will leak your private confidential data to Microsoft - as Windows 10 collects audio from connected microphones, collect keystrokes from connected keyboards, and indexes all files on local drives and sends a lot of data home to many different domains (some are owned by Microsoft, some have very dubious names and owners).
- Ace17 10y agoThe GNU/Linux systems get to be in the VMs hosted by Windows? That's the other way around, man!
- cube2222 10y agoWell, I think we should calm down from the paranoia a little bit. Nobody has ever proven any actual spying on windows 10 (it's actually a very secure system) What everybody's talking about are metrics. Anonymous usage metrics. And trust me, as a user and programmer I know of no company that doesn't collect metrics like that. It's totally common. Between, as far as I know, from the next update "creators" (this or next month) you can actually turn them off too.
- frik 10y agoAs a MSFT employee: Provide a proof that Win10 is not sending home the data I mentioned. Oh wait, it has been documented by third parties. Win10 has a whitelist in the signed 64bit kernel mode network driver, so you can't stop it except by putting a hardware firewall in front of your Win10 box - good luck with your Win10 notebook. If an app sends home metrics, it can be stopped with a software firewall. If you can't trust your operating system any more, it's a whole different ballpark. Adware and spyware companies with their unwanted toolbars and what not got problems with the US law since 2004. Win10 is an adware and spyware per definition, see news article of this HN thread.
- mankash666 10y agoTo be honest, I don't mind a plug or two about relevant Microsoft products within the OS. However, tracking usage and serving customized ads at the OS layer is unpleasant. So, I'm OK with how things are. I'm not disabling anything and giving MS the benefit of doubt that they won't turn my OS into an advertising and tracking channel
- alephu5 10y agoWhen I get a new computer with Windows preinstalled, the first thing I do is split the hard disk and put a nice Linux distro on. On the odd occasion I need to use Windows it's really no big deal having to navigate the ocean of bloat and whatever else. I don't even mind being tracked on these disparate occasions.
- smcl 10y agoIs this on Pro as well? I was tempted to get a dedicated windows laptop but if even Windows 10 Pro contains this nonsense then I may have to reconsider. Also - I know an OS is different from a webpage, but slamming a company for having "shitty" ads when you've got some obnoxious full-screen ads of your own is pretty funny: http://imgur.com/a/3eJ4H http://imgur.com/a/3eJ4H
- ForFreedom 10y agoBut then would they be reading any content on the computer itself if the adverts are targeted?
- ap46 10y agoAll the more necessitates the need to create a light-weight VM on top of which 7 + macOS can run. With better hardware we could abstract the hardware underneath the OS for legacy apps & switch to *nix at a click/shortcut.
- AsyncAwait 10y agoI again see a lot of outdated comments about Linux here. Not saying there aren't problems, but as somebody who uses macOS every day, it's nothing I haven't experienced on other OSes as well. Give it a shot yourself and make up your own mind. If you're thinking about switching, I'd recommend you looking past stock Ubuntu, it is no longer the premiere distro in the community, instead consider: First off, pick supported hardware - you'll do that for Windows and macOS as well. Use known hardware, like Intel, use DELL XPS or system76, it will save you a lot of frustration. Ubuntu MATE - https://ubuntu-mate.org https://ubuntu-mate.org - If you need the Ubuntu ecosystem, UM offers a more polished experience, if not as much eye candy. Arch Linux - https://www.archlinux.org https://www.archlinux.org - Before you skip this, no it's not unstable, at all, I clock one of my systems at 3+ years without an issue, the rolling release is great and the AUR makes any software just a command away. No fuss, just works. The ArchWiki is the best resource on all things Linux, it' great. Fedora - https://getfedora.org https://getfedora.org - If you want stock GNOME. KDE - https://neon.kde.org https://neon.kde.org - If you want upstream KDE.
- funkyy 10y agoFunny that Satya Nadella is praised on HN for his business sense and revolutionary thinking, yet when something like this happens, no one seems to remember about him. He is a CEO, it's his signature that allows this. Think about all Windows 10 spying, stupid updates policy etc. next time you praise him.
- Arizhel 10y agoI don't understand your problem: the Windows 10 spying, "stupid" updates policy, etc., are all good examples of Nadella's excellent business sense and revolutionary thinking. He's finally cast off this obsolete, idiotic thinking about not pissing off your customers, and realizes that Windows users aren't going to switch to another OS no matter what, so it makes perfect business sense to milk them for every penny they're worth with ads, spying, forced updates, etc. He's doing an excellent job, though personally I think he could do even better (though it'll make Windows users even more unhappy, but that's their problem).
- PleaseHelpMe 10y agoWhen some articles bashing Edge or some other Windows features appear on Hackernews, there is always someone in the comment stating "I work for Microsoft". "Microsoft employee here"... then protect the product. I am dying to see one that protects this.