15 ms·
> One reason for film's superiority as an archival medium is that you can hold a piece of film up to the light and see what it contains, whereas to see a digita
by cm2187 10y ago
> One reason for film's superiority as an archival medium is that you can hold a piece of film up to the light and see what it contains, whereas to see a digital archive you need to invent all the technology that leads up to decoding that particular file type.
Realistically, unless these nukes are put to intensive use, we are not going to disinvent computers. But your point is certainly valid for codecs. The videos will require to be transcoded multiple times as old codecs become obsolete (who can read real media's .rm files today?)
- adventured 10y agoOn the flip side, it wouldn't be extremely hard to create something to deal with .rm files either, which was demonstrated back then on several occasions. Seeing as the files are digital, and assuming proper storage, you have vast amounts of time to resolve the issue of reading .rm files, including directly requesting support from the engineers responsible for building out RealMedia's technology. The transcoding is trivial as far as problems go. We've been dealing with that non-problem for decades persistently and will continue to. The engineering skills needed will continue to exist to deal with it.
- cm2187 10y agoWell, for .rm files, you might already have to pull engineers out of retirement. But what about in 30 years?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 10y agoIf there is reasonably common non-DRMed software that can play it today (e.g. VLC), running on a operating system common today, you probably won't have too many issues just emulating said OS and using said software. DOS 5.0 was released in 1991, over 25 years ago. There is a rather astonishing number of JavaScript based emulators that will let you run it in a browser. Even if the next 5 years of browser development break all of those emulators, getting a 5 year old portable version of Firefox that will run on current hardware isn't difficult. I don't think decoding video that can be played with VLC today will be a problem in 30 years, and I also think that 30 years after that, all you might need to do is another level of nested virtualization. If we assume that there will be sufficiently well working emulators capable of emulating a 2017 machine in 2047, just like there are such emulators for 1987 machines in 2017, and that at least the most common binaries will somehow be preserved, you should be able to recover most reasonably popular video formats in perpetuity. Compare that to analog material that rots and requires incredibly delicate handling by experts, while with digital media, you can let anyone try since they can't break anything. And finding a copy of a popular OS and player binary might prove easier than finding a projector/VCR that can handle the ancient format. Even if you were to recompress every 30 years, the loss will likely be less than from physical degradation of physical media. However, if you have a lot of video in one canonical format (down to using the same encoder and settings, so you don't have to worry about weird edge cases), you can just preserve a copy of the player and every 30 years, you make sure you can either port it to a current OS, or virtualize it efficiently.
- lb1lf 10y ago>The videos will require to be transcoded multiple times as old codecs become obsolete (...) -My chief worry in that regard would be DRM; I have next to no idea how digital content is distributed to theatres, but presumably it is locked down all over. The transcoding itself is trivial. Decrypting the source material may not be.
- grkvlt 10y agoI don't think DRM is that big of a problem for future archive access. I assume that in 50-100 years, we would simply brute-force the DRM keys in milliseconds. EDIT - Note that this assumes knowledge of the DRM algorithm. I admit the brute force approach might fail if the algorithm was secret and no players existed any more.
- flukus 10y agoYou can't extrapolate future computing improvements based on the past, we are hitting physical limits now and in 50 years may not have computers dramatically faster than today.
- cm2187 10y agoWhich is what makes me reasonably skeptical about the future of AI.
- grkvlt 10y agoI don't believe we are anywhere near the physical limits of computing at all; the laws of mathematics, physics and information theory give us an enormous upper bound on capacity. There are technologies like quantum computing we haven't even started to scratch the surface of, and our knowledge of nano-scale engineering is still very much in its infancy. I would be very surprised if in only five years computers were not dramatically faster, let alone 50.
- jwarren 10y agoIt's a bit of a glib argument but it does hold water. The main points are that a timeframe of 30 years is actually quite short. While the moving image on film has only been around for about 120 years, ideally archivists would have film copies that would last far longer than that. Our idea of a computer in 120 years may be very different from what we currently use. More mundanely, what about when the last optical drive is manufactured? We'll suddenly have a finite number of reads left in the world. Or the hard drive connector breaks and it hasn't been manufactured for 30 years. Sure, a special one-off manufacturing run is certainly possible, but could a struggling and under-staffed archive afford to do that for every one of it's thousand hard drives, especially when it may not know exactly what's on every one of them? I'm know I'm being a devil's advocate here, but I did want to illustrate that every unknown part of this equation is exactly what scares working archivists.
- eslaught 10y ago> what about when the last optical drive is manufactured? [...] There are two types of digital archiving. One, which you're describing in this line of reasoning, is keeping a digital storage device in cold storage, booting up later, and trying to read the data. I agree that this has significant issues, as digital devices are physical devices, in addition to being digital ones, and not necessarily that reliable at that. There is also digital archiving in the sense of understanding what the bits represent. I would argue that this sense of the phrase is actually more compelling, because fundamentally digital data is just a bag of bits. While this would be more effort than I'd go to personally, I'd expect any competent digital archivist to store their data in a ZFS-based disk array, SAN, or cloud service like S3, or ideally multiple of the above. (Or futures equivalents of these techniques.) Yes, any given service, technology, or device may come and go. But this is missing the point. The way you achieve continuity is by periodically refreshing the storage so that at any given point in time the data is stored in a modern (for the time) storage device. There are still important issues to be solved, but the important ones are no longer questions of maintain physical devices, which is key. (E.g. the codec problem.) The main situation in which this approach does not work out is if you're trying to do archeological-type recovery of a digital storage device that has not been actively maintained. Then you're back in scenario #1. But if we're asking about a situation where someone actively cares about preserving their own data, the situation is not nearly as bad as these arguments make out.