3 ms·
Philosophy is the obsolete precursor to science. I think scientists should be embarrassed to admit to any mind-body dualist belief. But if this guy is coming
by ilaksh 10y ago
Philosophy is the obsolete precursor to science.
I think scientists should be embarrassed to admit to any mind-body dualist belief.
But if this guy is coming from the ancient Buddhist philosopher Dharmakirti’s dualism, that may overlap a little bit with the actual scientific property of emergence. But emergence just means larger more complex systems get properties that their constituent parts don't have.
We don't need fuzzy philosophical interpretations of quantum mechanics to explain consciousness any more than we need them to explaining flocking behavior in birds.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dualism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dualism (see Buddhist philosophy section)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Philosophy is the obsolete precursor to science No, philosophy is more general than and includes science (hence, the Ph. in Ph.D.) Now, some historical philosophies seem to lack current utility given the existence of science and it's manifest utilitt, but that's a different issue.
- M_Grey 10y agoPhilosophers won't be going anywhere as long as they can safely pontificate from within gaps in our scientific knowledge, or at least, the gaps in the knowledge of so many people. It's even more tragic when old physicists turn into philosophers, but don't realize it. In the end, people with degrees need to justify those degrees, and in Philosophy that pretty much means... teaching philosophy. Unless you're writing books that do quite well... you're teaching (or not working in "philosophy"). When you pair that with the natural curiosity people have, and the fact that plenty of people lack the desire or capacity to seek those answers in something like QM, they will never die.
- Koshkin 10y ago> Philosophy is the obsolete precursor to science. To be fair rather than dismissive, philosophy (usually of something concrete, such as mathematics, mind, etc.) may be seen as a science that does not have a name yet. True, it may begin with an analysis of the subject that is very preliminary and that can be not very accurate and may even contain mistakes, but there is no limit to how complete and precise such philosophical analysis may become later on.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoPhilosophy also covers topics that aren't scientific. (Eg, ethics.) Similarly, gluing mathematics to science is a philosophical framework. Most meta- fields are philosophical because they define the framework in which you can apply science to the field. Most of the criticisms are people who work in a narrow, high part of the intellectual stack misunderstanding how the framework they use every day is constructed (or ignoring that such a framework even exists). And then they rant about early versions having bugs or some of the "failed" experiments or quirky side-projects. The people making snide comments here are no better than Javascript developers wondering why anyone would use a pointer, completely ignorant of the underlying technology (such as the fact processors need a way to address in to memory).
- pizza 10y agoScience - experimentation and observation - and philosophy - inquiry into reality - are both ways to employ the principle of maximum relative entropy: > The principle of maximum entropy states that, subject to precisely stated prior data (such as a proposition that expresses testable information), the probability distribution which best represents the current state of knowledge is the one with largest entropy. I think philosophy will only be obsolete when it stops choosing which aspects of reality people use science to investigate. At least, this is the rosy belief I have that hopefully approximates what actually occurs in science. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_maximum_entropy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_maximum_entropy
- xelxebar 10y agoHey now, hey now. There are all sorts of questions that we don't even know how to postulate rigorously, the question of consciousness being but one example. Others smarter than I have commented on the symbiosis between science and philosophy, that once we learn how to precisely formulate a question it becomes science. Before then, it's philosophy. In my experience, a huge part of the battle in truth seeking is simply folding the right questions to ask.