6 ms·
The only business model for fiber that will work to produce the competition, low prices, and world-class data transport we need — certainly in urban areas — is
by mindcrime 10y ago
The only business model for fiber that will work to produce the competition, low prices, and world-class data transport we need — certainly in urban areas — is to get local governments involved in overseeing basic, street grid-like “dark” (passive, unlit with electronics) fiber available at a set, wholesale price to a zillion retail providers of access and services
That's an interesting assertion, but not supported by any evidence that I can see. And OTOH, there is direct contradictory evidence suggesting that there is another viable business model for building this kind of infrastructure: non-profit member-owned cooperatives. The same kind that provide telephone, cable and electric service all over the country[1].
Note that I'm not saying that cooperatives are a panacea, but their existence is evidence that other options are available. And before somebody screams "but aren't they all subsidized by the government", I would argue that if the kind long-term stable returns that the author of TFA speaks of are really available, then there's no reason to think that a coop couldn't get a loan (or equity investment) from private institutions.
My guess is that the biggest thing preventing this kind of thing from happening more often is exactly the amount of red-tape and government regulation involved.
[1]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_cooperative
- LogicX 10y agoYes, we have Horry Telephone Cooperative here in Myrtle Beach, SC. They've been laying fiber in the ground for 20 years, and I've been petitioning them for the last few years to offer faster speeds. They just started offering gigabit fiber a few weeks ago for $134.99/mo. I'm thankful to have an alternative to national cable companies, the only disadvantage is that local cooperatives can move slow!
- mindcrime 10y agoYes, we have Horry Telephone Cooperative here in Myrtle Beach, SC. Hah, what an interesting bit of synchronicity. I'm originally from Brunswick County, NC, just a hair north of you. We are served by Atlantic Telephone Membership Cooperative and Brunswick Electric Membership Corporation.
- robk 10y agoAtmc is lovely. My parents live in ocean Isle and I've found atmc so pleasant to deal with.
- jackmott 10y ago>non-profit member-owned cooperatives some might call that government
- VMG 10y agotrue, there are forms of government where your vote is correlated to your contribution
- mindcrime 10y agoMaybe the differences are subtle, but there are differences. That said, I've long been a proponent of shifting more and more services from "the state" per-se to these kinds of cooperatives. But I'm a government hating libertarian, so...
- jackmott 10y agoonce all your services are shifted to the cooperatives, the red tape of all the different cooperatives will annoy you and you will hate those =)
- adrianN 10y agoThen you just use Gubernetes(tm) to organize your micro governments and all your troubles go away.
- tracker1 10y agoIt can be argued, that communications, in particular internet connectivity is considered essential infrastructure, like roads and is the responsibility of the government to deliver. This doesn't really stray from my pragmatic libertarian view, but is just an argument of what is or isn't "essential infrastructure" or how it should be delivered and paid for. A backed cooperative is fine, so long as other providers are allowed to continue to operate (should they choose to), so as to establish baselines and competition.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago
- mmanfrin 10y agoThe same kind that provide telephone, cable and electric service Telephone: deeply regulated. Cable: deeply unregulated. Electric: deeply regulated. There's an odd-man-out here.
- mjevans 10y agoI think you've got your categories wrong and very selectively chosen. * Water / Sewer: Regulated OR 'off grid' (EG: well + septic field) * Roads: Local roads always regulated (taxpayer provided) * Hospital: Many areas only have one, denser areas may have a small handful; in an emergency you don't choose. * Electricity: Regulated (Possibly a choice of generation providers, usually never a choice of 'line transmission' providers.) * Natural Gas: Regulated, one provider. * Schools: Regulated, there's a basic default option. * Police: Regulated, there's a basic default option. * Fire: Regulated, there's a basic default option. * 'Emergency': Your 911 call goes to one place* (for a source area) * Data: Many municipalities have //regulated// a monopoly (sometimes a duopoly) Yet they don't regulate the performance of that monopoly sufficiently.
- 13871292throwaw 10y ago> My guess is that the biggest thing preventing this kind of thing from happening more often is exactly the amount of red-tape and government regulation involved. I was briefly and directly involved with the Google Fiber rollout here in Austin. Here's the thing: anyone with firsthand information is unlikely to drop in to set things straight in a way that gives away any amount of detail, purely because in the professional world it would be unbecoming to say the kinds of things that would necessarily come out. I don't expect that local government intervention and red-tape could be called the major contributing factor here. From someone involved at the end I was working from, dbg31415's comments are exactly what I would expect the other end to feel like. The thing you have to understand is this: generally speaking, the people involved with the labor on this kind of project inhabit a completely different world than the one that you or I or the rest of a site like HN lives in. That applies to the boys in the field doing the work, to the boys in the office shuffling paperwork and signing off on their checks. It's unsurprising to me to hear that the labor costs are out of control, and to hear that Google was halting expansion to other cities this past fall was like hearing someone say that they smashed their fingers in the door and it hurt. 6d11e0a226cb3b6b24dc05bd96ebb7b176c29b587512fae370d5c825ff5a08bf742152134a1e75c9104b8944fbae2b4640757e2533b41f44ceefbb04be602103
- jackmott 10y agoI don't know if I was lucky, or dbg was unlucky, or if Google streamlined things by the time they got to my hood, but the fiber install was great for me here in Austin.
- SlipperySlope 10y agoOMG And where I live in South Austin I get between 500 megabits and 1 million megabit download and upload speeds. The most amazing thing is that Google TV with 200 channels is mostly and totally uncompressed. Equal in quality to the over-the-air UHF HD from my local broadcast stations well lit studio news shows. Go to the Google Fiber headquarters in downtown Austin and you can see the quality on an upscaled 4K TV - awesome so very awesome! Time Warner and AT&T - never going back! So sorry, so really very sorry rest of the country doesn't have this Choice - yay for Google.
- jsemrau 10y agoThere are many areas, and we can see that in many parts of the world, where the government will do a better (cheaper to the citizens) job compared to private businesses. Among them are public transportation, Internet connectivity, Phone/Gas/Electricity. Google moving out of Fiber or proving that it is not economically viable to them is a disappointment but not a surprise
- tracker1 10y agoI think that tends to be the case the more localized the cooperative/utility is... at the City level, more than the state, more than the federal govt. That's because a city-level org can make pragmatic decisions that become harder the higher you get.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"non-profit member-owned cooperative" That was my plan, too. It's already proven out by one rural ISP doing something like that. You also have the angle of people willing to pay extra or sacrifice some features for a good the community owns. There's also a pride aspect that can happen.
- specialist 10y agobefore somebody screams "but aren't they all subsidized by the government" Government is the source of all wealth. So says Reagan's conservative economist, Kevin Phillips. Wealth and Democracy: A Political History of the American Rich http://amzn.to/2ntP4eW http://amzn.to/2ntP4eW Belief in Freedom Markets™ is faith-, not reality-based.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoIt's intellectually dishonest to call out Kevin Phillips as "Reagan's conservative economist." He never worked for Reagan, never worked in the Whitehouse, opposed Reagan's tax cuts, and wrote a book criticizing Reagan's trade policies in 1984. He has written several additional attacks since. By all means bring up Phillip's ideas, I agree with some of Phillips' critiques, but it is wrong to portray him as some sort of conservative insider. This is how Jacob Weisberg described him: Phillips long ago left behind both obscurity and conservatism, becoming one of our most ubiquitous political commentators and one of the most left-wing. His biennial books have become illogical, dizzying screeds. And his diagnoses, predictions, and advice to Democrats have been consistently, embarrassingly wrong.
- specialist 10y agoForgive me; I misremembered. He was Nixon's man. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Phillips_(political_commentator) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Phillips_(political_comm...
- jmspring 10y agoI recently moved to an area where the local coop did step up and is bringing Fiber to one of the least populace continues in California -- Plumas County -- and the spinoff of the coop is Plumas Sierra Telecom. They've been providing some form of internet to the area for 11-12 years (maybe more). They've been bringing fiber slowly up from Reno to communities along Highways 70 and 89. The condo I just bought, PSREC installed fiber to the unit. I hope to help find ways to invigorate the adoption in the community and maybe some more tech up here. Reno is about an hour away. Coops and small rural companies are the ones investing in infrastructure (in the town I am in, the cable company folded and the telecom stepped up) rather than the big telecoms which are trying to disinvest from things. Interesting local article: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/01/today-a-california-ghost-town-can-have-fiber-to-the-doorstep-but-its-not-easy/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/01/today...