5 ms·
I know this light personally. I live there. It is no problem for the casual driver, as Dresden is one of those rare german towns with US "Rechtsabbieger" rules.
by rurban 10y ago
I know this light personally. I live there. It is no problem for the casual driver, as Dresden is one of those rare german towns with US "Rechtsabbieger" rules. You may turn right even with red lights.
And the german law clearly states if one entries to a crossing has lights, all others have to get lights also. This is the only case in Germany where this law makes no sense.
But the best is the last sentence: They do change all the green and yellow light bulbs also in their regular maintenance schedule. The justification goes like this: Bulbs mostly wear due to hours in usage, yes. Red and Yellow are not used, so should not wear, and thus should not be replaced. But hours can not be the only cause for problems, and while we are there and there's a budget for replacement, we'll do it all together. Not really a just technical justification, just a practical one.
We do the same in software also all the time. There are two principles:
1. Make minimal changes to cause only minimal effect.
2. Harmonize your changes to avoid unnecessary asymmetries.
They went with 2.
You can fight the system, or you can live with it. In this case there is no reason to rock the boat.
[Update:]
The lawful alternative would have been to close this crossing for the Ziegelstraße into the Güntzstraße. People would have protested over this sillyness. And Dresden has enough budget surplus to do such things. In fact Dresden was very lucky in its real-estate deals, where they sold all of their old residential apartment complexes to a US company Fortress for billions:
http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/milliardendeal-dresden-verkauft-wohnungsbestand-und-wird-schuldenfrei-a-405194.html http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/milliardendeal-dresden-verk...
Normally such deals turn out bad and unprofitable, but in this case not. Both parties are happy.
- pluma 10y ago> Dresden is one of those rare german towns with US "Rechtsabbieger" rules If it's anything like the picture, the reason right turns are allowed is the green arrow (it roughly translates to "when red, right turns are allowed if you don't interfere with other traffic"). I strongly doubt random towns in Germany can bypass the StVO (the laws which govern public roads). EDIT: To clarify, I was born in Cologne, which is on the opposite of Germany, and green right arrows exist here as well and they are part of the material you learn for taking a driving exam.
- rurban 10y agoDresden is not allowed to bypass the StVO, so they had to put up this crazy light, yes. But the Rechtsabbieger "Grünpfeil" is also in the StVO § 37 Abs. 2 Nr. 1 Satz 8 bis 10 https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gr%C3%BCnpfeil https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gr%C3%BCnpfeil History: The old DDR came up with this Grünpfeil (turn on red) law. During the Wiedervereinigung it was "agreed on", that this law can persist for max. one more year, 1991. But based on huge civil protests on silly law reforms (same for abortion and women rights which where more advances in the east), Germany kept this exception, and even some old ex-BRD towns introduced it since. I believe Dresden had most of the existing 2.500 Grünpfeil signs in Germany, but in the meantime the west has caught up, and there are now 5.000 such signs.
- majewsky 10y agoGrünpfeile were really new in West Germany after the reunification. My brother told an anecdote from when he once drove through Hamburg and saw a Grünpfeil there, which had a sign below it explaining how it worked (something like: "Grüner Pfeil = Stoppschild für Rechtsabbieger", "green arrow = stop sign for right-turning drivers"). He quipped that this was probably the only traffic sign ever to come with its own manual.
- snaily 10y agoUnlike in France, where for some reason a lot of symbolic signs come with text instructions on a separate sign: http://s3.freefoto.com/images/41/03/41_03_88_web.jpg http://s3.freefoto.com/images/41/03/41_03_88_web.jpg (English: "Give way")
- Declanomous 10y agoThe same is true in the United States to a certain extent, though the instructions are a bit more complicated usually. The Yield sign and the Stop sign will have the relevant text within them, but below those signs you will have instructions for the given intersection, especially with stop signs: "4 Way" or "All Way" -- Indicates that every entrance to the intersection has a stop sign. I understand all way stops are either uncommon or unheard of in Europe. "Cross Traffic Does Not Stop" - often used with "Two Way" stop "Traffic from the left/right does not stop" -- often used when one direction is coming off a signaled light or crossing railroad tracks, or other cases when traffic from one direction needs to continue to flow to prevent a backup that could be dangerous.
- timthelion 10y agoAn aquantance of mine wrote a peice of software that looks at satelite pictures of Prague at night and tells the city which street lights are out, so they don't have to use a "regular replacement schedual" but only replace the bulbs that need it. Could the same thing not be done using red-light cameras and stop lights?
- mattygee 10y agoHey, that's a good idea - exception catching for traffic lights
- germanier 10y agoReplacing a traffic light after it already failed is too late.
- londons_explore 10y agoNot in London. Nearly every day I see a new failed one. There is usually redundancy tho
- lsaferite 10y agoThat seems like the right approach. The traffic light has a backup bulb and alerts when one burns out. I mean, cars can tell when a bulb is out, right? Why shouldn't traffic lights.
- Klathmon 10y agoActually it's even simpler than that, just have a minimum of 2 lights per direction of travel. So if one fails, a bulb burns out, one gets destroyed in a storm, or anything else happens, there will be at least one full backup.
- lsaferite 10y agoHaving automated outage reporting still makes sense though. It keeps you from having a guy that's paid to check every light in the city manually. And since your lights are on a city-wide network (they are, right?), then adding outage reporting should be a feasible thing.
- iopq 10y ago> But hours can not be the only cause for problems, and while we are there and there's a budget for replacement, we'll do it all together. what does it matter if the green and yellow bulbs are broken? They'll never be turned on.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoI think the point is the bulbs are cheaper than the (a) cost of developing, deploying and tracking a one-off maintenance protocol change and (b) risk the instructions are applied to the wrong intersection.
- rurban 10y agoThis. And they rules may change, and someone might decide to turn them on someday. They are prepared then :)
- iopq 10y agoIt should be obvious if the light doesn't have ANY yellow or green bulb that they shouldn't be changed.
- germanier 10y agoUsually we teach people to not try to be clever when applying checklists. More often than not the "obvious" thing to do can have fatal consequences.
- icebraining 10y agoOr maybe the last person forgot, or they were stolen, or whatever. You'd probably have to report that and waste the time of a bunch of people.
- dwighttk 10y agosurely it is illegal to put up a traffic signal without working bulbs.
- ygra 10y ago
- lordnacho 10y agoWhat happens when someone from somewhere else comes to this light? Do you see tourists stuck here?
- gpvos 10y agoI think for most tourists the green arrow next to the red light should be suggestive enough.
- rurban 10y agoTourists don't come that way. It's very small residential street, turning into a big street with lots of confusing signs and disallowed directions. For me the much worse problem is the other way, coming down the Güntzstraße to the Elbe. The whole crossing is a real city planning nightmare, and I worked in city planning for some years.
- mhandley 10y agoThe streetview image posted by advisedwang shows there's also a white-on-blue "must turn right" sign at that junction. This ought to make it clear that you shouldn't wait there to go straight.
- ygra 10y agoExcept that the traffic light takes precedence over the sign and thus the sign has no effect whatsoever as long as the traffic light is active.
- Asooka 10y agoNo, it would take precedence if it had an arrow painted on it, but as it's just a traffic sign, it only controls entry into the intersection, not where you can go.
- svckr 10y agoHey, so just to clear things up, because nobody seems to have mentioned it: Is there a sign indicating that there are only right turns allowed? (White angled arrow pointing right on blue background) As a driver approaching this particular crossing while seeing I'm only allowed to turn right I'm not sure I'd ever notice the light staying red indefinitely.
- ygra 10y agoThere is such a sign, but it's irrelevant as long as the traffic light is active so you can just ignore it. The whole intersection is also built in a way that you can really only go right as there is nowhere to go straight ahead or even left. And you surely would notice the green arrow sign next to the red light and act accordingly.
- nevex 10y ago> This is the only case in Germany where this law makes no sense. Actually, there are two more permanently red lights in Dresden alone. They are mentioned at the end of this Video: https://www.ndr.de/fernsehen/sendungen/extra_3/Realer-Irrsinn-Dauerrote-Ampel-in-Dresden,extra9516.html https://www.ndr.de/fernsehen/sendungen/extra_3/Realer-Irrsin...
- rurban 10y agoGeil
- mcv 10y agoIs there a more complete overview of this traffic situation somewhere? I still find the reasoning a bit hard to understand. I understand that from this road, you can only ever turn right, and can do so at all times, so there's no need for a traffic light, except that it legally needs to have one because other roads at the junction need traffic lights for other reasons. So what are the other roads here? Clearly it has to be more than just the Ziegelstraße and the Güntzstraße.
- woodpanel 10y agoI think this is it: https://goo.gl/maps/uLpY8kjjJFw https://goo.gl/maps/uLpY8kjjJFw
- shmageggy 10y agoAh this makes the whole thing so much clearer. Thank you. (Why couldn't the article have this?)
- herpdorplarp 10y agohttps://www.google.no/maps/@51.0539102,13.7575856,3a,75y,78.56h,87.49t/data=!3m9!1e1!3m7!1scW7PqWjukB-tqiTFHHMidA!2e0!7i13312!8i6656!9m2!1b1!2i33!6m1!1e1 https://www.google.no/maps/@51.0539102,13.7575856,3a,75y,78....
- qachaos 10y agoso could someone just sit at the stop light to just annoy the other german drivers and police?
- uf 10y agoI also do remember somewhat fondly when Dresden still had actual police officers regulating traffic by hand. It's been some time since I left Dresden and I don't remember the crossings. Oh, and the frequent power outages..
- rabboRubble 10y agoOkay, the law requires a signal light at that intersection. Okay, the light is always red because reasons. What I don't understand is why the 3 light red/yellow/green signal unit has never been changed to a 1 light red-only unit.
- rsfinn 10y agoPerhaps because it wouldn't "look like" a traffic light and so would be potentially confusing ("Wait, do I have to stop for that, or can I just turn?").
- rabboRubble 10y agoI know I've seen single lamp traffic lights before. Like this one.... https://c1.staticflickr.com/3/2041/2234314943_bdcd95d800_b.jpg https://c1.staticflickr.com/3/2041/2234314943_bdcd95d800_b.j...
- brewdad 10y agoThose come with a "stop" sign as well and are usually seen on high speed highways as a way to get drivers' attention long before the sign comes into view. This intersection has a yield sign. A blinking red "stop" and a yield can't go together can they?
- rabboRubble 10y agoA blinking single bulb red light is the same as a regular 3 bulb traffic light red light, with the exception the 1 bulb red light on/off is programmed with a shorter periodicity. Take a blinking red and make it a solid red. Obviously, they took a 3 bulb traffic light where the red light should be turned off periodically and programmed it to show continuous red. A continuous red light on a 3 bulb red/green/yellow traffic light is abnormal behavior for that type of traffic sign.
- amai 10y agoYou could have mentioned, that the traffic light doesn't exist anymore: http://www.faz.net/aktuell/gesellschaft/ewiges-rot-an-dresdner-ampel-hat-ein-ende-genommen-14435741.html http://www.faz.net/aktuell/gesellschaft/ewiges-rot-an-dresdn...