4 ms·
Most folks on HN are part of the startup crowd, and what that crowd misses is that while GCP is technically superior in every way, they have no idea how to sell
by jedberg 10y ago
Most folks on HN are part of the startup crowd, and what that crowd misses is that while GCP is technically superior in every way, they have no idea how to sell to an enterprise.
Google's sales method is, "There's the docs, good luck". Enterprises don't like that. They like to be hand held, they like lots of humans taking them out for lunches and dinners.
So far Google has not shown any inclination that they know how to enterprise, and in fact it's fairly counter-cultural for them.
If they learn to sell to the enterprise, I agree with you.
But right now, almost all the money in cloud is with the enterprise, and right now Google has no idea how to address that market.
- nodesocket 10y ago> So far Google has not shown any inclination that they know how to enterprise, and in fact it's fairly counter-cultural for them. While traditionally true with Google Products, I disagree with Cloud. Did you attend Google Cloud Next? Trust me, they are focusing on enterprises. Their support has improved significantly and they are focusing on business cases (costs, management, audit, security). I am certain the Google Cloud Next conference in a few years will look just as enterprise as AWS re:Invent.
- jedberg 10y agoI did attend briefly, and I got a run down from some enterprise folks. They said Google appears to be thinking about making an effort towards enterprise, but they aren't there yet. Also, they don't have a sales force like Amazon. A bunch of non-engineer humans who do nothing but convince other people to buy their product. They are still trying to solve human problems with engineering, and sales is a tough nut to crack for a computer, even a really strong AI. :)
- ma2rten 10y agoAt my last job I actually talked to a sales person from Google who tried really hard to get us to move to GCP.
- nodesocket 10y ago> Also, they don't have a sales force like Amazon. A bunch of non-engineer humans who do nothing but convince other people to buy their product. Here's the catch, the "bunch of non-engineer humans" as you called them are not stupid though. All around these people are watching the landscape and market. They are aware that GCP has a superior pricing structure and can be up to 50% cheaper[1]. Therefore my theory is that GCP can continue to offer lower prices, greater governance, superior performance, and solid support, and their (sales+engineering) force can be in-bound driven instead of out-bound like AWS. [1] - https://thehftguy.com/2016/11/18/google-cloud-is-50-cheaper-than-aws/ https://thehftguy.com/2016/11/18/google-cloud-is-50-cheaper-...
- Guest98123 10y ago"The numbers given in this article do not account for any AWS reservation. However, they all account for Google sustained use discount (30% automatic discount on instances that ran for the entire month)." I'll never understand why people keep referencing that 50% cheaper article. They take into account the 30% monthly discount from Google, but ignore the 47% discount I currently get from Amazon by reserving my instances for a year. Why? Well, because the author thinks "Reserved Instances are bullshit!". Now, I agree reserved instances are not ideal, but if you're trying to write an article about pricing, it's absurd to exclude such a discount. It's obvious the author was just going for click-bait.
- manigandham 10y agoWhy? RI's require upfront purchasing, sustained use doesn't. So the comparison is valid because it's comparing on-demand instances from both providers, and Google comes out cheaper. Otherwise you can say anything has better pricing because you signed a big volume discount upfront, whether you're buying cloud VMs or tires.
- sokoloff 10y agoAWS RIs don't require upfront purchasing (payment). They offer full-upfront; they offer half-upfront; they also offer no-upfront. Source: https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/pricing/reserved-instances/pricing/ https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/pricing/reserved-instances/pricin...
- mattzito 10y agoGCP has a sales force - one can debate their relative sophistication or effectiveness compared to Amazon, but Diane Greene has brought in a bunch of ex-VMware leadership to run the sales, presales, and consulting organizations, and they definitely understand enterprise sales. Amazon just has some additional experience from doing it for longer.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Most folks on HN are part of the startup crowd, and what that crowd misses is that while GCP is technically superior in every way, they have no idea how to sell to an enterprise. They seem to be doing the build technology and sell to and partner with forms that specialize in enterprise sales thing, while building their own enterprise sales capacity. Lots of players now dominant in enterprise and very big on direct enterprise sales (including Microsoft) got to that position largely by the same route, unseating predecessors who had much more expertise in direct enterprise sales.
- jedberg 10y agoThis is a fair assessment. It will be interesting to see how it plays out now that they have a semi-complete enterprise offering.
- bitmapbrother 10y ago>So far Google has not shown any inclination that they know how to enterprise, and in fact it's fairly counter-cultural for them. They have over 3 million businesses that use G Suite and their other enterprise offerings. To imply that they no inclination on "how to enterprise" or that "it's fairly counter-cultural for them" is disingenuous to say the least. >But right now, almost all the money in cloud is with the enterprise, and right now Google has no idea how to address that market. That's amusing considering all of the enterprise customers that are using GCP. Perhaps you should watch their cloud conference.
- jedberg 10y agoSelling GSuite is very different than selling compute. Besides being SaaS vs. infrastructure, the GSuite contracts are tiny compared to enterprise infrastructure. If a company with 100,000 employees paid list price for GSuite monthly, that would only be $1,000,000/mo, which is peanuts for an enterprise contract. Especially since they would probably get a huge bulk discount. What I mean by counter-cultural is that at Google, they try to solve problems with computers instead of humans. It's worked really well for them so far, but it won't work for selling huge enterprise contracts. Yes, they have spun up a small support and sales team, but they will need to grow it a lot to support lots of large enterprises. Also, in companies that cater to enterprises, the sales team drives the engineering roadmap, or it is at least a collaboration. From talking to folks in Google, it seems that they don't really allow the sales team any input in to product cycles or technology. And I attended their cloud conference and I'm very aware of their customer base vs. AWS. Their customers would all be considered fairly small to AWS, with the exception of a few big players. Edit: An additional anecdote, I saw firsthand how they support an enterprise install of thousands of GSuite users. For the most part, it was "there's the docs, good luck". Sometimes they would assign an engineer, who would never come on site, to tell us that what we want is impossible.
- manigandham 10y agoThis is why they brought on Diane Greene who was the founder/CEO of VMWare. She clearly understands enterprise sales, has staffed up and merged departments appropriately and it's starting to show in everything from marketing to the support interactions.
- MrBuddyCasino 10y agoThere was an event recently at Google Munich where they offered a whole day of free Google Cloud training. I couldn't attend, so I can't comment on the quality.
- tw04 10y agoThey're well aware and have a plan for that as well.
- mabbo 10y agoIt's cultural. Amazon's culture is all about "customer obsession". That's their thing. When they have breakthrough tech products (Kindle, Alexa, etc) it's because they try to focus on the customers needs (and actually get it right, unlike the fire phone). AWS has an enterprise sales team, many of whom have strong engineering backgrounds, because that's what customer obsession looks like in the cloud world.
- 013a 10y agoDid you even watch GCPNext? The entire event was enterprise-focused. They brought a half-dozen companies on stage to basically say the same thing over and over again: "We moved to Google cloud, its so much better, Google helped us every step of the way." Its possible these companies were lying, but I think that conference should be evidence enough for any prospective customers that Google is ready.
- signal11 10y ago> The entire event was enterprise-focused Some very old-school enterprises are working with Google to onboard GCP in their organisations. A few of them even spoke at the event. I'm assuming they've done due diligence to ensure that Google will devote time and attention span to GCP and not treat it like a "side project". Also, looking at this logically, whether Google offers GCP or not, you can't deny that that they'll continue to refine their internal infrastructure. Their internal platform is one of their crown jewels. It just makes sense to offer that to businesses willing to pay for it.
- manigandham 10y agoYes. Sales is easy to staff up but technology is very hard to build. Google is going in the right order and can easily hire the enterprise handlers it needs to close large contracts.
- jedberg 10y agoI'm not saying Google can't do it, and I agree that they did it right (build the technology first). What I'm saying is that there isn't strong evidence that they are getting good at enterprise sales yet. If they can do it, then they will be very successful. I'm starting to see signs that they might be doing it right, but the jury is still out.
- jedberg 10y agoI did, yes. They are starting to show signs of learning how to sell to an enterprise. If they get it right, they will do well. I'm just saying the jury is still out.
- SEJeff 10y agoI'm guessing you didn't watch any of the videos of Google Next and haven't been paying attention to their moves for at least a year or two? Their new Customer Reliability Engineering team is no flipping joke. They helped scale out Pokemon Go (among other things). https://cloudplatform.googleblog.com/2016/09/bringing-Pokemon-GO-to-life-on-Google-Cloud.html https://cloudplatform.googleblog.com/2016/09/bringing-Pokemo... Seems like an awful lot of handholding to me, so I suspect your argument is simply invalid.
- jedberg 10y agoI've been paying very close attention to what they are doing and attended Google Next. I know what they are doing. They seem to be doing the right thing, but the jury is still out. They still haven't proven they are good at the enterprise.