11 ms·
Molten Salt Reactor Claims Melt Down Under Scrutiny
- FireBeyond 10y agoTheranos 2.0...
- kbar13 10y agono, theranos actively lied about their product, this crew got their stuff reviewed and has since revised their claims (which seems to still be pretty good improvements)
- jobu 10y agoThe Powermag.com site seems to be melting down as well. After giving up on loading the page I was able to google a bit and found this article: "Nuclear Energy Startup Transatomic Backtracks on Key Promises" https://www.technologyreview.com/s/603731/nuclear-energy-startup-transatomic-backtracks-on-key-promises/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/603731/nuclear-energy-sta... 2x the energy per ton of uranium is decent, but I wonder how they ever thought they could get 75x.
- dredmorbius 10y agohttps://archive.fo/YoYEu https://archive.fo/YoYEu
- acidburnNSA 10y agoThey thought they had a breeder reactor I guess. Typical reactors burn mostly U235 and a bit of bred-up Pu239 for an average burnup of the mined uranium of roughly 10 MWd/kg. Breeder reactors, on the other hand (both Thorium thermal MSR breeders and Uranium-Plutonium fast breeders) can get up very near the theoretical maximum of ~930 MWd/kg. The latter figure really demonstrates the sheer magnitude of the nuclear force in atoms. What a wonder to behold!
- cjslep 10y agoNuclear engineering undergrad at NC State from 2009-2013. It's very easy to get overhyped about molten salt anything. Our groups senior design project presented at the ANS student conference at MIT was on a novel way to pyroprocess SNF to get only Uranium out one end and Plutonium & Radioactive Crap out the other, so it would be proliferation resistant. And continuous. The theory and simulations all lined up. But we still were cautious about claiming any sort of breakthrough, because we needed empirical experiments to prove the theory. And the government doesn't just hand out SNF (as my Navy Nuke classmate learned when he asked the Pentagon). The most exciting thing at the ANS student conference at the time was a presentation by a German Graduate student and her work on ceramic cladding of fuel rods. So, its an industry that doesn't naturally lend itself to hype.
- M_Grey 10y agoWhat do you think of Pb-Bi eutectic?
- acidburnNSA 10y agoIt's good in that it gives you a very hard neutron spectrum (good for efficient breeding) without being chemically reactive. It still has potentially unsolved problems in corrosion, required pumping power (i.e. power density limits) and erosion. There's been some recent work on oxygen control that really helps with the corrosion issue.
- M_Grey 10y agoThanks, I was wondering the issues around corrosion and servicing were being addressed. It always seemed like the best hope for a balance between a good breeder reactor, and non-proliferation concerns to me.
- WatchDog 10y agoANS : American Nuclear Society SNF : Spent Nuclear Fuel
- leeoniya 10y agoeven 2x is pretty damn good, though not being able to consume spent fuel is a huge bummer. what of the claimed safety benefits? and how completely can it use up new fuel (thus reducing its own waste)?
- tjohns 10y agoMisleading title. The way this is phrased, it sounds like a reactor meltdown occurred (!) and is now under scrutiny. In reality, it's just an energy startup's exaggerated performance claims that "melted down" (were proven incorrect) when examined by the community.
- astrodust 10y agoIf your reactor normally runs in a molten state, melt-down becomes a whole other thing, doesn't it?
- nordsieck 10y ago"Melt down" has traditionally meant that the fuel has overheated and breached the primary containment vessel. I don't see how that definition would not apply here. Just because the primary coolant loop uses molten salt instead of water shouldn't much matter.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- astrodust 10y agoIt also implied that the fuel that should be solid is now molten and, as these things tend to go, well on its way into the ground. A molten salt engine is going to be molten when everything's fine!
- vacri 10y agoAre you a native speaker of English? If so, how would a Molten Salt Reactor make any claims?
- tgb 10y agoThe title is a garden path sentence trying to be too clever with using "melt down" in the context of nuclear reactors. I had to read the first few sentences to have any idea what it was talking about. You don't need to question people's language skills for this. Regardless, it's easy to take "Molten Salt Reactor" as the name of a company, just as if you saw a title saying "Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant claims meltdown".
- geodel 10y agoI was reading like 'Morton Salt Reactor' and thinking do we really have one of those.
- leeoniya 10y agodrove past there today; Geiger counter didnt budge, so i guess not :/
- jxramos 10y ago"technology journalists all too credulous." ha, I guess so.
- tinco 10y agoOh that's awkward. Worse than not being 75 times as efficient, and instead only twice, is this other quote: In addition, it now specifies that the design “does not reduce existing stockpiles of spent nuclear fuel” or use them as its fuel source. To me that was the most inspiring aspect of this idea. I'd still one day hope to have a nuclear reactor in my back yard, but to realise that dream we've got to keep the science as well as the engineering on point. If nuclear scientists goof like this, it does not inspire confidence to the public and all we will end up is projects like Shoreham.
- bmh_ca 10y ago> If nuclear scientists goof like this, it does not inspire confidence to the public and all we will end up is projects like Shoreham. To be fair, the claims were made by grad students. Good on them for experimenting, hoping, testing, and failing. The true calamity would have never been to test. Their failure is not a reflection of their character, ambition, or talent. Well perhaps a little bit their talent. But they could've done like many (most, arguably) grad students and worked on some fundamentally useless but "safe" path to ongoing work in the Ivory tower. So let's hope they keep trying to identify and test the hard problems whose resolution would improve life for humans, and do better next time.
- noobermin 10y ago>Smith thought the claims for the technology were bogus, based on the physics, notified the MIT hierarchy, and launched an inquiry. The magazine quoted him, “I said this is obviously incorrect based on basic physics.” Grad students should know the basic physics of their respective subfields.
- huxley 10y agoAt the very least, if it doesn't match up with the basic physics, to do the legwork to show why they are right and the apparent contradictions with basic physics are incorrect.
- hapless 10y ago
- fixxer 10y agoAre we close to peak bullshit for this cycle? I've about had enough.
- astrodust 10y agoThank you for your deeply insightful contributions.
- imaginenore 10y agoWhile doubling the efficiency is still great, I'm not sure we should trust people who make errors in such basic calculations to build a freaking nuclear reactor. 75x should have been the red flag from the first mention, it's such a huge figure. It's not like they are switching from fission to fusion.
- DennisP 10y agoIt's actually feasible with fast reactors. Conventional reactors fission U235 and a little plutonium which gets bred from U238, but most of the U238 and plutonium just ends up as waste. Fast reactors fission the plutonium just fine, and ultimately can use up virtually all the U238. So they produce very little waste, most of that is short-lived, and they get up to 100x more power out of the same amount of uranium ore. But Transatomic isn't a fast reactor.
- djsumdog 10y agoFrom what I've read on other threads about Thorium and Molten-Salt reactors is that they are highly corrosive. I found the experimental Oak Ridge one that's talked about in the article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten-Salt_Reactor_Experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten-Salt_Reactor_Experiment ..but I thought there was one fully operational and connected to the grid for years before it was shut down. I can't seem to find that one though.
- wersplectior 10y agoPossible corrosion issues aside, does the article have any negative implications for the much sought-for development of molten-salt thorium reactors?
- sandGorgon 10y agoThis. India and China need thorium power. It is non-proliferation fuel and is abundant in these two countries. It could be the biggest factor bringing down pollution in the world's two fastest growing economies with massive demand for power.
- neutronicus 10y agoYour zeroth-order mental model of a Thorium reactor should be "exactly like a Uranium reactor". It's a different radioisotope; it ain't magic.
- DennisP 10y agoYour first-order mental model should be that (1) thorium requires breeding and that works in a thermal spectrum, (2) uranium doesn't require breeding if you're content with fissioning U235, and (3) you can have a breeding uranium reactor but that requires a fast spectrum.
- DennisP 10y agoIt doesn't really have negative implications for MSRs in general. It's just one design out of many. The debunked claim is just that they could get uranium fuel utilization comparable to a fast reactor, using a reactor operating mainly in the thermal spectrum. None of the other projects make that claim; either they actually are fast reactors (Moltex, Terrapower), they claim much lower fuel utilization (Terrestrial Energy), or they plan to run on thorium.
- comicjk 10y agoThis whole discussion is misplaced. Economically, the cost of fuel for a nuclear plant is almost negligible, about half a cent per kWh! Up-front capital costs are the vast majority of the total. That's where research and venture capital should be focused, not on squeezing down the half-cent.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hocuspocus 10y agoPWRs are inherently expensive to build, that's also a huge argument for molten salts reactors, that were initially designed to fit an airplane.
- justatdotin 10y agotoo cheap to meter!
- fnordfnordfnord 10y agoIt might be if we hadn't frozen the tech at circa 1970.
- kemiller 10y agoI don't think it's about the price of fuel per kWh it's about the waste generated per kWh.
- Gibbon1 10y agoI don't think waste is the biggest cost with nuclear power. At least over the short run of 50 years. I remember some figure that coal fired plants cost about half as much to build as nuclear plants. I could be wrong. But if true there might not be that much fat to cut out of nuke designs in general.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ajarmst 10y agoSigh. Claims made by a few people about a particular molten salt reactor design do not stand up to scrutiny. Molten salt reactors, on the other hand, are proven technology.
- pjc50 10y agoHow many of them are in commercial use today? Where?
- ajarmst 10y ago"Proven Technology" != "Many are currently in commercial use". Had I meant the latter, that's what I would have said. The initial theory behind MSRs was well-defined prior to the 1960s, and experimental reactors (notably the ARE and MSRE) demonstrated the viability of the concept 50 years ago. THE LFTR is one of the most interesting modern reactor concepts and is being explored by several countries (I'm personally more of a fan of the LMBR--if only because it's closer to full commercial viability (and would already be there had Clinton and Gore not murdered the project)---but that's another story). The failure of Gen IV reactors to gain widespread commercial usage (especially in the age of global warming) is about fear, politics and economic interests, not the viability of the technology.
- m389571 10y agoБН-600 & БН-800, Russia.
- acidburnNSA 10y agoThose are both liquid-metal cooled solid-fueled reactors (sodium-cooled fast reactors). Sodium in elemental form is a metal, not a salt like sodium-chloride. There has never been a commercial molten-salt reactor.
- shaunrussell 10y agoAlarmist misleading title. Downvote. There are other companies (FLIBE, Lightbridge) researching LFTR MSR that have promise. Just because some grad students made ridiculous claims, it shouldn't throw shade on the whole industry.
- phkahler 10y agoLast paragraph: inally, who cares about reprocessing fuel? At this time naturally abundant U235 prices are so low and projected to continue to be low for this century that all this effort to recycle fuel and burn longer seems completely unwarranted on market principles, despite how cool and hip it sounds to "close the fuel cycle" or produce "100 times" less waste. Last I checked, fuel and disposal was a tiny fraction of the real costs of nuclear electricity, and certainly far smaller of an engineering problem than the public likes to believe. I wasn't aware that anyone had solved the problem of spent fuel. last I knew there were thousands of tons of the stuff sitting around in swimming pools next to reactors all over the country/world. I don't recall the status of the project to bury the stuff under mountain in Nevada either, but I don't think that plan is approved. WTF is wrong with breeder reactors that consume the otherwise spent fuel? Yeah, yeah, proliferation risk. If the stuff is that hard to contain then why all the waste sitting around?
- robotresearcher 10y ago> Yeah, yeah, proliferation risk. If the stuff is that hard to contain then why all the waste sitting around? It's harder to contain than to process from waste. You need advanced expensive tech to turn the waste into weapons-grade material. If we don't create it, the nasty material doesn't exist and has lower security risk.
- caf 10y agoWTF is wrong with breeder reactors that consume the otherwise spent fuel? They turned out to be uneconomic, is all. Perhaps that will change at some point.
- wahern 10y agoYeah, yeah, proliferation risk. If the stuff is that hard to contain then why all the waste sitting around? I think the concern about breeder reactors isn't so much the proliferation risk of the fuel and waste itself, but that a commercial market in breeder reactor technology will proliferate the knowledge and equipment necessary such that state actors will find it easier to build breeder reactors quickly and secretly. But maybe that's just a misperception on my part. Before Beowulf clusters, building supercomputers required tremendous expertise. The U.S. thought it could keep China from building supercomputers by controlling the export of supercomputers and supercomputing-enabling technology. But once supercomputing moved to clusters of commodity hardware, most of those export controls became useless almost overnight. China didn't spontaneously develop an expertise in chip design and fabrication; rather, because of the technological shift in the West, supercomputing know-how and equipment simply became impossible to contain.
- kalaracey 10y agoThis title is extremely misleading. Makes it sounds like there has been a nuclear accident, and subtly stokes fears of nuclear technology.
- aetherson 10y agoGuys. It's a pun. This how article titles work. Welcome to the last 50 years of American journalism.
- castis 10y agoHN has been on an extreme title pedantry kick for a bit now. Hoping it cools off a little.
- stock_toaster 10y agoWhat is the expected half-life of the cooling period?
- exabrial 10y agoI thought the pun was obvious; after all, that would be a waste of unspent material.....
- jefurii 10y ago"Extreme pedantry"! I like the sound of that! Makes me want to listen to some MC Frontalot https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7sKhHPKqAc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7sKhHPKqAc
- vacri 10y agoThese kinds of puns have been around nearly as long as newspapers themselves.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThe pun is fine. The noun/verb confusion on 'claims' is an issue.
- burntrelish1273 10y agoAlso interesting: http://www.ted.com/talks/taylor_wilson_my_radical_plan_for_small_nuclear_fission_reactors http://www.ted.com/talks/taylor_wilson_my_radical_plan_for_s...
- bronz 10y agopeople need to end this ridiculous obsession with fission for energy. solar and wind. thats all we need. all the nuclear stuff should be limited to research. when fusion is ready then we can do that. solar, wind and batteries are here and ready to go. they are already rolling out. anything else is a complete distraction and waste of time. im so fucking tired of this.
- debacle 10y agoNuclear has many benefits over solar and wind. I'm not a nuclear proponent, but in certain scenarios (especially ones outside our atmosphere), nuclear makes sense.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWind and solar are many times more destructive to the environment that safe nuclear reactors. And many times less cost-effective. That's why nuclear keeps getting revisited - it works so well.
- bronz 10y agono, actually they arent. and they dont produce radioactive waste that has be be stored for generations either. and the reactors are sometimes safe. and it only takes on bad one to do huge amounts of damage and kill tons of people. panels have never hurt or killed anyone.
- chiph 10y agoNot a nuke guy -- if you slow/stop the reaction, and the salt solidifies in all the piping, how do you get it started again? Sure, the salt near the reactor becomes liquid again, but there's no flow through the pipes to the pumps & heat exchanger and all you have is convection flow in/near the vessel itself, and maybe the heat eventually works its way through the plumbing. Do you wrap all the pipes & pumps in heat tape?
- ars 10y agoThey use salts that melt at low temperature, and don't boil easily. So they are unlikely to ever get cold enough to solidify, and if they do, can be melted with external energy. And yes, they do insulate the pipes. So heat from the reactor would eventually flow and melt all the salt.
- acidburnNSA 10y agoThey also do run heater wires along the pipes. Same with liquid metal cooled reactors.
- gumby 10y agoI enjoyed the bit about "in MIT’s highly regarded magazine, Technology Review". I don't know anybody from MIT who doesn't think it's worthless (except for the alumni news bound into the back of the alumni editions they send out free. It's only connection to MIT is that they pay the alumni association for the right to use the name (and agree to send alumni notes out). A friend of mine (also an alum) refers to it as "the magazine of things that will never happen".
- gpawl 10y agoWhy does the alumni continue to agree to license their name to a publication that drags down MIT's reputation?
- gumby 10y agoIt funds the alumni association. And it would take more than one dumb magazine to put a dent in the institute's reputation.
- jholman 10y agoYeah, I LOLed at that line, and then came here to wonder if anyone had a contrary opinion. I have yet to read something in that, uh, "publication" that was worth my time.
- nilstycho 10y agoI am from MIT. I don't think it's worthless. I don't read it often, but I've liked some of the articles I have read. I found A Tale of Two Drugs (https://www.technologyreview.com/s/520441/a-tale-of-two-drugs/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/520441/a-tale-of-two-drug...) to be unusually evenhanded, for example.
- seesomesense 10y agoSounds like another would-be Theranos.