4 ms·
"Facebook was for several first years just a set of PHP crud pages and heaps of servers to run them well." Personally, I think we've all got a piece of the ele
by jerf 10y ago
"Facebook was for several first years just a set of PHP crud pages and heaps of servers to run them well."
Personally, I think we've all got a piece of the elephant here. It is true that there are no known methodologies that could build Facebook at the speed it has been built without producing a globally-incoherent design. Anything that could produce a globally-coherent design would have slowed them down so much that they wouldn't have been such big winners in the first place. (So "globally incoherent" isn't much of a criticism here, really.)
On the other hand, there are options other than "a big set of PHP CRUD pages and heaps of servers" available to us now, too, and I expect those options to continue to advance in usability. Even the various projects that improve on PHP would bring more benefit if you could use them from day one instead of a retrofit.
- chii 10y agoFacebook didn't win because of the software, but because of marketing. At its inception, it felt exclusive. You were special of you got an invite. The other social networks were open season. Facebook made some good design choices with the simple looking UI, and didn't offer the customisations MySpace had. But that's a design choice, not software engineering choice.
- phil21 10y agoNo one wins because of the software (code quality). They win on marketing and that software (UIx) doing a needed task people are willing to "pay" for. HN tends to be rather myopic in that programmers exist to program. Nope. Programmers exist to use a tool to solve a real world problem. The best way to do that is with the minimal amount of design and time required to accomplish the task at the desired level of reliability. Very few projects require anything resembling the "code quality" talked about on HN - in most cases I would say trying to enforce such principles generally result in worse outcomes and folks would have been better off spending 1/10th the money on a 16 year old off elance.com and simply fixed problems as they came up. Typically the thing that is done the quickest wins, even if the implementation would make you cry. The fact is from a business standpoint - it truly rarely matters. Very little is as critical as people think. I've noticed the industry becoming vastly disconnected with this fact recently.
- eh78ssxv2f 10y ago> Facebook didn't win because of the software. Probably true, but it's also important that they did not lose because of the software. There are lot of great ideas that have gone in the drain because of sloppy software.
- tluyben2 10y agoMany successful companies run the worst software you will ever seen. Yesterday there was a post about MUMPS which got me flashbacks of clients that showed me software that ran their entire 100m+ euro / year factory mostly written in MS Access / Excel on a shared drive (with the lovely locking Windows does!) mostly (this particular client had some CRM and an ERP from Dutch companies 'laying on the shelf' but 'never got around to it'). One of the biggest EU factories that creates the belts for conveyor belts runs on the worst PHP code as ERP I have ever seen. Many sites that are not Google or Facebook etc run on hacked together crap in whatever language and tech and do fine. Twitter was crap at the start, most software in electronics was beyond unusable until recently (in some systems) etc. You can of course lose because of sloppy software, but if your marketing is done well, I don't see why that would happen. There is an enormous overestimation how much people care about that kind of thing here on HN. From the first decade of the Windows versions to tons of Twitter outages after the launch to getting their computers hacked, passwords stolen, CCs stolen, privacy taken, slow as molasses systems, forced reboots, many crashes, bodged updates, forced updates, virus/malware scanners taking up 50%+ of your /still too expensive/ resources too much of the time, really bad iteration of the Facebook app at the moment (at least on Android), broken airplane booking forms, 404 support pages etc etc etc and yet no-one goes away because most people curse and move on to whatever. Unless your marketing is bad aka no-one uses it, it usually won't fail because of sloppy software.