4 ms·
One of my friends commented today that the US Gov't is now taking measures to shore up the economy - however he remarked that they did very little to control th
by wallflower 19y ago
One of my friends commented today that the US Gov't is now taking measures to shore up the economy - however he remarked that they did very little to control the economy during the boom period. For example, if the stock market falls 500 or whatever points, there are built-in circuit breakers to halt trading. However, in the roaring NASDAQ/Dow days, there were no circuit breakers to prevent crazy, gambling-style appreciation..
The best analogy I've read likens the economy to California Wildfires. One of the reasons the California wildfires were so intense was the policy of fire prevention. Forests in the natural cycle of burn and regeneration seem to require a healthy burn once in a while. Obviating the natural wildfires leads us to bigger conflagrations. One can liken the economic impacts of lowering interest rates to fuel the housing bubble to putting out natural wildfires, building up fuel for a bigger economic problem (recession, millions of upside-down mortgages)
- Prrometheus 19y agoAn interesting facet of this fiasco is that the poison of artificially low credit is also being touted as the antidote. I for one believe that we would have been better off if we let the economy slip into a recession in 2001 and coped with 7% or 8% unemployment, rather than causing a massive asset bubble and a gigantic financial mess.
- jdavid 19y agoi doubt we would have seen 7-8% unemployment. the US wines when unemployment reaches 4%. Typically in recessions large companies lay people off to protect share price and free up cash. It's just an excuse to shareholders to let go some of the spending. If companies were to cut spending in a boom time shareholders would speculate that something bad was going to happen. in recessions labor prices return to market value, and entrepreneurs like us can afford to hire talent. the best indicator of an economic down turn is a cut in R&D, and from what I can tell engineering salaries are still increasing right now. I think the thing to do, instead of bailing out homeowners with low interest rates is to provide a free education. we are in a full blown knowledge economy and EVERYONE will have to make the transition sooner or later.
- trevelyan 19y agoYou already have 7-8 precent unemployment and probably had it back in 2002. The reason you don't know this is because of the very specific US way of counting unemployment: someone who has not "actively" looked for work in the last 4 weeks is not counted. This is the reason countries in Europe tend to report higher unemployment than the United States does. Look to payrolls reports and the percentage of the population "working" for a better sense of the job market.
- kingkongrevenge 19y ago> they did very little to control the economy Huh? They explicitly controlled the economy. They pumped cheap credit and deliberately passed various legislation to further inflate the housing and derivatives markets. You have to understand the government at all levels is in on the action when it comes to these bubbles. They profit both in terms of tax revenues and by straight-up payola. Government milks the scam just like the perps, and then when it falls apart they release a "lessoned learned" study and prosecute a few scapegoats they parade on TV. You'd have to be pretty naive to think the key regulators and legislators are genuinely surprised by these crises that roll around every 8 years. They're really involved in making them happen.
- caudicus 19y agoHe's saying they should have tried to slow the economy down when it was raging upward...which I think you know, but you were just being overly cynical. In terms of the Fed wanting to promote the economy and "make money" for the government...not so much. The Fed as an organization is set up to operate independently, and in the long run the government is going to lose more money due to economic fluctuations. The whole point of a central bank is to smooth out the business cycles (to everyone's benefit).
- kingkongrevenge 19y ago> The whole point of a central bank is to smooth out the business cycles That's the cover story. A few centuries of data from source around the world clearly show that central banking destabilizes prices and economies and aggravates the business cycle. The purpose of central banks is to allow a connected elite to rip off the population at large through seigniorage. This is NOT conspiracy theory garbage. This has been popularly understood at various times in US history. Tom Paine wrote about it extensively as a best selling author. Andrew Jackson got a mandate to dismantle the national bank.
- caudicus 19y agoWell, modern day central banks operate through Keynesian principles of economics which were not developed until the mid 20th century - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keynesian_economics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keynesian_economics - so I find it hard to apply the writings of Thomas Paine to them. I do realize the US Federal Reserve was founded before that (1913), but modern fiscal policy decisions are based on Kaynes' work. Related to that, the historical US National Bank (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Bank_of_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Bank_of_the_United_States) and Central Bank (Federal Reserve) have very different objectives. Do not confuse the two.