4 ms·
In other industries, the the wisdom of experienced workers is the only thing that keeps capital from completely fucking over labor. Why don't experienced worker
by jessaustin 10y ago
In other industries, the the wisdom of experienced workers is the only thing that keeps capital from completely fucking over labor. Why don't experienced workers play the same role here? When I read stuff like this by experienced workers, I sometimes hope to see that question answered...
- muglug 10y agoBecause capital keeps telling the young developers that they’re smarter/quicker/more adaptable than the older ones. It's a seductive lie.
- cwyers 10y agoAll the other industries have capital. Why doesn't capital tell the younger workers in all those other industries the same seductive lie?
- shiven 10y agoMaturity. Not every industry can sustain a "move fast and break things" mentality. Software is fairly young in terms of capital investment growth. Wait till it becomes as boring and grave as manufacturing.
- majormajor 10y agoShort time frames and code quality being less visible to customers than construction or build quality of physical goods. It's a lot easier to build a (really shitty underneath the hood) app without experience than to design or build an airplane without experience. In most cases you can dump a good chunk of your stake for a massive profit before the poor infrastructure and maintenance costs become an issue (the Twitter "fail whale" and rewrites are the outlier here, I think, where the scale came much faster than the payoffs).
- Frondo 10y agoYeah, no kidding. Think of how every time unionization comes up here, you'll see dozens of people chiming in with "but we're really well-paid already!" or "I can negotiate for myself!" or whatever. Never even thinking about how much better they could be paid if they worked together to demand a larger slice of that sweet, sweet tech pie. It's crab bucket is what it is.
- analognoise 10y agoIt isn't just a lie - they're more impressionable. Tell them they're smart, they're critical! and then work them to the bone until you can replace them with the next batch of the bright-eyed and bushy tailed.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoWhich is why technology churn and cultivating ageism are so useful. It's a fabulous cover for the con. That person didn't get death marched into burning out in his closet sized apartment. He turned 30 and couldn't hack React. Hey, check out this Ayn Rand novel...
- lacampbell 10y agoWhat does anything you have written have to do with Ayn Rand novels?
- pnathan 10y agoA big part of it is that what we do is literal magic to the uninitiated. We wave incantations with our hands upon the keyboards, and the uninitiated do not understand how this turns into the world we have. It's invisible, untouchable, and and the expert wizards have collectively refused to provide a meaningful system for determining what is good vs what is bad. In other industries there are things like certifications that mean something or guilds/unions/associations where membership means something, in the software world, the gurus have refused to build an association/certification system of meaning, citing libertarian ideas against it. Since this helps the forces against labor, our management likes that idea too.
- Sunset 10y agoI would eat my own hat before I let a "guild council" dictate anything that could impact my code style or the way I do things. The lack of centralized control is a good thing. In other industries you can be barred from even working in the field if the "council" doesn't like you. Things like the lawyers' bar are complete bullshit as a concept in themselves.
- mdpopescu 10y agoPeople who "made it" are always trying to restrict the field. The excuses are many - protecting the poor, the quality, the children... but the reality is always "we are afraid of the competition".
- pnathan 10y ago> I would eat my own hat before I let a "guild council" dictate anything that could impact my code style or the way I do things. That attitude is exactly why we have quality and fad problems. ::shrug::
- WkndTriathlete 10y agoThat attitude is also why we have nice things like Linux and AWS.
- watwut 10y agoAssuming that being old makes you wise is as much trap as assuming it makes you stupid.